| A Fantasy Perspective
 7/23/07
 
 Wide receivers are a necessary evil in fantasy football and in the 
              lives of football fans. They seemingly create the most news but, 
              outside of a few exceptions, do not bring it consistently every 
              week in fantasy. They would have the novice football fan believe 
              they the main reason that his team wins, but he is all too often 
              the first player to throw his QB under the bus when his team loses. 
              That said, the above is not meant to be a blanket statement and 
              certainly does not apply to the position as a whole; it merely suggests 
              that some of the more notable receivers suffer from an inferiority 
              complex.
 What receivers do, however, is create big plays that change games 
                and create headaches for the defenses that are built to stop that 
                big play from happening. And it is for that reason that we love 
                watching them at their craft. In terms of receivers that swap 
                teams in the offseason, the prevailing thought as to drafting 
                them is to remain cool on their prospects until we get a chance 
                to see them a handful of times with their new employer. Most of 
                the time in fantasy football, though, we don’t get that 
                chance.  So, for our purposes in fantasy football drafting, it makes a 
                lot of sense to take the gamble on WRs that fall under one or 
                more of the following guidelines:
 
                Those are some of the factors I look at when assessing the WR crop 
              from year to year anyway and, in most seasons, I downgrade the same 
              faces in different places enough where I am unable to draft them. 
              However, this offseason saw a handful of possible elite options 
              switch teams, meaning a rewrite to the above statements may be needed 
              and once again proving that nothing is ever guaranteed in fantasy 
              football. Transitioning from a run-heavy to a pass-heavy offense.
 Going from a team that spreads it around to one that has 
                  shown a proclivity to target their #1 option.
 Receiving a serious upgrade in surrounding talent, especially 
                  at the QB position. 
               At just about every position, a below-the-radar (and sometimes 
                undrafted) player gets “it” for a season and goes from waiver 
                wire hopeful to the final piece in your run for a fantasy title. 
                This position is no different. Last season was a pretty fair season 
                for the position in that regard, as Lee 
                Evans, Reggie 
                Brown, Mike 
                Furrey and Marques 
                Colston all emerged from mid-to-late round or undrafted obscurity 
                to second-half starters on just about any fantasy team, especially 
                the ones that were unfortunate enough to land the likes of Randy 
                Moss, Joe Horn or Derrick Mason. In 2005, Santana Moss, Terry 
                Glenn and Chris Chambers were good WR options that appeared as 
                fantasy top 20 WRs that could be had late in fantasy drafts.  All that being said, there are a few WRs making the move this 
                season who fall under the guidelines just mentioned in the preceding 
                paragraphs. In order of projected fantasy impact, let’s 
                take a look the WRs who switched teams this offseason and their 
                chances for fantasy success… Randy Moss(From OAK to NE)
 Let’s get this out right away…Tom Brady + Moss does not equal 
                Daunte Culpepper + Moss from a few seasons ago. However, there 
                may have been no more intriguing move in the offseason than the 
                one made by the Patriots on the second day of the 2007 NFL Draft 
                when they picked up Moss for a fourth-round pick. Much like Corey 
                Dillon before him, I do expect Moss to push aside the public perception 
                of being a ball-and-chain on his employer whose potential and 
                consistency almost always teases. Also, like Dillon, I expect 
                Moss to have 1-2 solid years in New England before fading. In 
                New England, it’s a no-brainer that Moss will be part of a better 
                supporting cast and since he is going from a poor passing team 
                to a very good one, it should mean Moss’ prospects to become fantasy-relevant 
                once again are very good.
 Here’s what I do expect…a lot of scores. No way will he rack 
                up the 1632 receiving yards or the 111 catches he did in his last 
                healthy season as a Viking. I expect something resembling his 
                2005 season in Oakland (60 catches, 1005 yards) with an uptick 
                of scoring grabs, somewhere in the 10-12 TD neighborhood. I also 
                expect defenses to pay more attention to him than QB Tom Brady 
                will, as he will opt for Ben Watson, Donte Stallworth and Wes 
                Welker underneath more often than hitting the big play on a regular 
                basis. I will be more than just a little surprised if Moss makes 
                a living on the quick slant and drag patterns, as that is not 
                what he likes nor is it what he does best. Another area Moss will 
                excel in will be the red zone, where he will be the prime option 
                (yes, ahead of the ground game). The Patriots have long hung their 
                hat on specialization and molding their attack around the talents 
                of their players. What does Moss do best? Hit the big play and 
                make an inviting target on jump balls. Expect to see a lot of 
                that in Gillette Stadium this season. By the projections I set 
                forth earlier, that makes him a fair target for a low-end #1 WR, 
                although I would feel much better drafting him as my #2. While 
                his final numbers may look pretty nice, I don’t see the Patriots 
                dropping their spread-the-wealth attack – even for a talent like 
                Moss – meaning his weekly consistency will be hard to predict. Donte Stallworth(From PHI to NE)
 Meet the real beneficiary, besides Tom Brady, of the signing of 
                Randy Moss. Now, if he could just stay healthy!!! Looking at the 
                names, it is hard not to like the way New England attacked the 
                offseason, as the reputations of the players the Patriots brought 
                in turned the WR position from a definite weakness into a definite 
                strength. However, as great as I think a healthy Stallworth would 
                mesh with Tom Brady, we are talking about New England. That fact 
                alone means, as any experienced fantasy player knows, that Stallworth 
                is game-by-game decision from about Week 2 until the end of the 
                season. Why? Stallworth’s penchant for injury and HC Bill 
                Belichick’s ability to keep his intentions about who he 
                will play in the “Patriots’ vault”, information 
                not to be discovered until about 10 minutes after kickoff or about 
                an hour after most of us NEED to know if he is active.
 If I knew he could be counted on for a full slate, I would rank 
                Stallworth ahead of Moss in terms of fantasy impact this season. 
                Since I don’t know that and I’m certainly not going 
                to bet on it – not to mention how the Patriots share the 
                wealth in the passing game – I would push the former Volunteer 
                down to one of the last #2 fantasy WRs spots, making him about 
                a sixth-round pick in 12-team, two-starting WR leagues. I would 
                feel even better if he was my third option at the position. I’ll 
                go out on a limb and say that Stallworth does a pretty good imitation 
                of 2005, his last year as a Saint – 70 catches, 945 yards 
                and seven TDs – in 13 starts.  Kevin Curtis(From STL to PHI)
 Curtis to the Detroit Lions seemed like a no-brainer to me. Somewhere 
                along the way, signing with a proven winner and knowing he had 
                a starting gig won out over a team that hasn’t won in a 
                while and familiarity with the play caller. (It could have been 
                that he didn’t want to play third fiddle for Detroit either 
                when he could have a chance at a starring role in Philly…) 
                Whatever the reason, the Eagles let Stallworth leave and replaced 
                him with the slightly less injury-prone version of himself. Assuming 
                McNabb is good to go Week 1 – a big if – I expect 
                Curtis to pick right up from where Stallworth left off. Now, if 
                AJ Feeley needs to take snaps for the first month or so, then 
                I expect Reggie Brown to be the bigger beneficiary.
 So, what this boils down to is how soon McNabb is ready to play 
                and how long he will last. If you want to bet on a full season, 
                Curtis will look like a savvy #2 WR pick for the price of a #3. 
                If you think McNabb will start Week 1 but only play half the season 
                and you would like a guy who you could potentially sell high on, 
                Curtis is your guy as well. Lastly, if you think McNabb will not 
                play the first month but play the final 12 games and you would 
                like a buy-low candidate, again, the ex-Ram is a solid choice. 
               Allow me to conclude on Curtis by talking about McNabb, as he 
                will be the biggest reason Curtis will either be a fantasy boon 
                or bust. While the comparison of McNabb’s knee injury to Daunte 
                Culpepper’s is similar as far as they both tore their ACL’s, McNabb 
                did not blow out each of his other knee ligaments, so a comparison 
                to Carson Palmer is much more spot on. As such, expect a slow 
                start from McNabb, much like the one Palmer experienced last season. 
                In McNabb’s favor is the fact that his injury happened two months 
                earlier than Palmer’s, so a quick start is not impossible by any 
                means. Either way, there’s enough injury risk between McNabb and 
                Curtis that you should draft him as a high-reward #3 fantasy WR. 
                I like Curtis’ ability to log 65-70 catches and notch his first 
                1000-yard receiving season and 7-8 TDs if he can make all 16 starts. Darrell Jackson(From SEA to SFO)
 In my mind, the acquisition of Jackson was the best use of a fourth-round 
                pick to acquire a receiver. And, in all honesty, I still can’t 
                quite comprehend why the Seahawks willingly did this deal, even 
                with his injury history or contract status. At 28, Jackson should 
                still be in his prime for a few more years. Either way, Seattle’s 
                loss is San Francisco’s gain, in this instance. As such, I expect 
                less drop-off than most in the fantasy industry. Even though I 
                expect the Niners to be a run-heavy team this season, Jackson 
                should still be the #1 option in the passing game. The scenario 
                isn’t all that different from what he had become accustomed to 
                in Seattle, benefiting from all the attention paid to RB Shaun 
                Alexander. The difference is that Alex Smith is not Matt Hasselbeck, 
                so a slight reduction in numbers is likely.
 I will be very interested to see how well first-time OC Jim Hostler 
                works Jackson in with TE Vernon Davis. For fantasy purposes, there 
                is little doubt in my mind that if you are able to get Jackson 
                as your #2 WR, you are well on your way to building a team capable 
                of winning a fantasy championship. He will be intimately familiar 
                with the best CB he will face twice in the division (Seahawks 
                CB Marcus Trufant), meaning I expect six stellar games from Jackson 
                against the NFC West. Games against Cincinnati and Cleveland in 
                Weeks 15 and 17 also shape up as opponents that Jackson owners 
                can point to and believe that he will post equitable numbers in 
                at least half the games and especially when they count the most 
                for his owners. If he somehow lasts past the fifth round in 12-team, 
                two-starting WR leagues, scoop him up as he should be good for 
                13-14 games once again, with 65-70 catches, 1000+ yards and 6-7 
                touchdowns a fair expectation. Drew Bennett(From TEN to STL)
 At first, it struck me a bit odd that the Rams put out such a 
                big carrot for Bennett to take a bite on. However, I like this 
                signing the more I think about it. HC Scott Linehan is probably 
                figuring on having the services of 13-(soon to be 14) year vet 
                WR Isaac Bruce for one more season. In the meantime, the Rams 
                can essentially be the NFC’s answer to the Cincinnati Bengals 
                in which Torry Holt plays the role of Chad Johnson, Bruce serves 
                as the precision route runner to Cincy’s Doug Houshmandzadeh and 
                Bennett the hard-to-guard tall deep threat who is nearly impossible 
                to guard on jump balls, just like Chris Henry.
 In all honesty, I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if Bennett had 
                the best season of any #3 WR the Rams have had since Az Hakim 
                was making waves for The Greatest Show on Turf. It is not hard 
                to imagine the 6-6 college quarterback-turned-receiver will be 
                worthy of a roster spot in two-starting WR leagues and a starting 
                spot in three-WR leagues. The only things to be aware of with 
                Bennett are his tendency to get nicked up as well as his role. 
                Only Brandon Stokley from a couple years ago jumps to mind in 
                regards of a #3 WR who offered any kind of weekly consistency 
                from a fantasy standpoint. So, even though he will be dropping 
                two spots on the depth chart when he straps on a Rams uniform, 
                I would expect similar total numbers to what he had last season 
                (46 catches, 737 yards), with a high probability that he will 
                score 5-6 times and maybe even sprinkle in a TD throw. Joe Horn(From NO to ATL)
 Long a #1 WR staple in most fantasy leagues, Horn will be picked 
                lower in this summer’s drafts than he has since the year he joined 
                the Saints in 2000. At 35, he cannot be expected to carry the 
                #1 fantasy WR mantle anymore but he is the most dependable option 
                – outside of TE Alge Crumpler – that QB Michael Vick has. That 
                said, Vick will need to clear his name with the authorities and 
                the courts before we can see what Horn still has left. I dread 
                the thought of counting on Horn if backup QB Joey Harrington needs 
                to play more than a few games this fall.
 Assuming Vick avoids the legal mess he is currently involved 
                in regarding the federal dog-fighting charges he is facing, the 
                focus then turns on his ability to stay healthy all season long. 
                I believe new HC Bobby Petrino will give Vick the best play-calling 
                he’s had since he became a Falcon. However, I’m not 
                sure Vick will consistently survive behind his offensive line, 
                as I’m not sure relative green OL coach Tom Cable will be 
                able to command an overwhelming performance from his troops. Pair 
                Vick’s issues together with Horn’s recent injury-shortened 
                seasons and you have enough reason to push Horn back into mid-#3 
                fantasy WR status. I tend to believe that Petrino will employ 
                a spread-the-wealth mentality to his passing game with regular 
                three-and-four WR sets. All in all, I expect Horn to be the best 
                WR pick fantasy-wise from the Falcons’ roster, posting 50-55 
                catches for 750-800 yards and five scores. I do believe his reputation 
                will push him up higher in the draft than he should go, though, 
                which would between rounds 8-10 in 12-team, two-starting WRs leagues. Wes Welker(From MIA to NE)
 At what point did the Patriots’ splurge on other teams’ 
                WRs become ridiculous? Well, you can’t point to Welker, 
                who was the first of seven receivers who were ether traded for, 
                signed or re-signed by the team. Now one does have to question 
                why Welker was worth a second and a seventh-round pick when luminaries 
                like Randy Moss and Darrell Jackson were worth just a fourth-rounder. 
                No matter, as Welker is one of the best return men in the business 
                right now. He also works out of the slot very well, meaning if 
                all else fails with Stallworth and Moss, QB Tom Brady will still 
                have more talent at the WR position to work with than he did last 
                season.
 Welker will likely be one of many players that will help his 
                real team more than any fantasy team, as he will provide the Patriots 
                with good field position and a player that will regularly move 
                the chains on third down. All this means is he will get consistent 
                looks, but will not be a consistent fantasy WR as they will be 
                too many other New England players that will be higher in the 
                TD pecking order than Welker. A fair estimate for his final numbers 
                would be 40-45 catches, 550 yards and 1-2 scores. However, a Pro 
                Bowl-caliber season as a returner may be in the offing. Brandon 
                Stokley(From IND to DEN)
 For the nine games that Stokley averages each season, he can serve 
                as a viable threat. However, he goes from the mountaintop of fantasy 
                production to a unit that is somewhat less proficient from a fantasy 
                standpoint, but every bit as effective in the real game. What 
                is going to be tough for Stokley will be overcoming history: his 
                own and the Broncos. Staying healthy is always a concern with 
                him but one literally has to go back to 1988 and the days of the 
                Three Amigos (Ricky Nattiel, Mark Jackson, Vance Johnson) to find 
                the last time Denver had three fantasy-worthy WRs in the same 
                season.
 
 And it's not just that. While Rod Smith appears to be winding 
                down after a stellar career, he will still be the starter until 
                further notice. Stokley will also need to prove his wares over 
                second-year future stud Brandon Marshall. In fact, a dream scenario 
                for HC Mike Shanahan would be that Marshall shows enough this 
                season that he passes - or at least splits time with - Smith on 
                the depth chart. This would allow Stokley to stay in the #3 role 
                that he fits in the best. For fantasy purposes, Stokley is too 
                injury-prone and QB Jay Cutler - while very talented - is probably 
                too green yet to make three WRs fantasy relevant. As a result, 
                let Stokley go undrafted in all but the deepest of fantasy leagues, 
                as he is unlikely to do any better than 40 receptions for 500 
                yards and a couple of scores.
 Bobby Wade(From TEN to MIN)
 No, seeing this name does not mean you should stop reading. Wade 
                is a relatively unknown and underappreciated talent. And all things 
                being equal, the former University of Arizona standout will be 
                nothing more than a #3 or #4 WR on the Vikings, who will have 
                one of the worst passing attacks in the league as they wait for 
                raw second-year QB Tavaris Jackson to develop. That said, it’s 
                hard to say he isn’t the most proven wideout in the collection 
                of Minnesota WRs, so he may someone to keep an eye on for sporadic 
                production. The thing that will be most intriguing to me will 
                be the development of the other WRs on the roster. Will Troy Williamson’s 
                eye surgery be all it takes for him to realize his potential this 
                season, in this, his third year of the league? Will rookies Sidney 
                Rice and Aundrae Allison be the main cogs in the passing attack 
                by the end of 2007? Will Billy McMullen be able to match the production 
                of the man he was traded for last summer, Philly’s Hank Baskett?
 For these reasons, Wade’s quickness and experience may be the 
                reasons he ends up being the best Viking WR this fall. He had 
                just four fantasy-relevant games this season with the Titans and 
                he shouldn’t be expected to top that in Minnesota. His production 
                should remain fairly similar to his 2006 numbers (33 catches, 
                461 yards, 2 TDs) with his biggest impact being made in the return 
                game. All told, Jackson will need receivers in the passing game 
                whose routes he can trust. I expect RB Chester Taylor to be one 
                of those players. I expect Wade to be the other until Williamson’s 
                hands can be trusted.
 |