Preseason Schedule Analysis
7/25/11
A head start. An advantage over the competition. A leg-up on your
league-mates. Whatever expression you want to use, fantasy owners
want it. In some cases, it doesn’t matter if they get it one
minute before everyone else does, so long as they do.
Most fantasy analysts that are considered industry “experts”
make their living – however modest – by identifying
trends, interpreting information and reaching conclusions more
quickly than “average” people do. Quite often, “experts”
are counted upon to set the fantasy table – if you will
– with projections, analysis and rankings that allow those
who do not have the time or expertise to do all the legwork themselves.
Whether I am considered an “expert” or not is inconsequential,
I believe it is my responsibility as a trusted fantasy football
analyst to provide detailed analysis whenever possible. Sometimes,
that means making observations based on trends and, other times,
it means doing my best at predicting the future based on somewhat
limited information. This offseason is one of those times for
the latter. Never before have we entered late July with so much
player movement yet to be determined. While the draft proceedings
went off without a hitch in April, there are roughly 400-500 free
agents that either need to find different teams or re-sign with
their old employer. Then, there are the countless undrafted free
agents that will have limited time in training camp to make an
impression on their new team. And finally, there are several players
who are likely to be traded that need to find a new landing spot
as well.
This week, I will try to help each of you get a small head start
on your competition by attempting to handicap the potential free
agent and trade market from a fantasy perspective. While this
exercise will probably lead to more wrong predictions than right
ones, I believe it serves a very worthwhile purpose: helping readers
formulate opinions on players before they actually move. This
offseason is going to be unlike any one fantasy owners have ever
known since we will have no OTAs or mini-camp to collect information
from nor will we have the benefit of an entire summer to reach
conclusions on an old face in a new place. In
short, the 2011 season figures to reward the prepared owner and
punish the unprepared owners even more than usual.
Because restricted free agents are a slippery slope and often
do not change teams, I will stick to unrestricted free agents
and players that can reasonably expect to be traded once transactions
are allowed. It should be noted that in the “teams that
should be interested” portions of this article, I am attempting
to be somewhat realistic in the teams that a free agent would
actually consider. For example, Carolina has a desperate need
for a WR like Santonio Holmes, but the likelihood that he will
choose to sign with the Panthers is pretty small. Something else
to keep in mind as you read this article: it is being widely reported
that each team will be required to hit a salary “floor”
at roughly 99% of the projected cap of $123 M (actual $120 M cap
with $3 M of credits as reported by NFL Network). That means some
teams that are projected to have a lot of cap room – Cincinnati
and Tampa Bay are two of several – will be required to spend
up to somewhere between $118.8-121.7 M and be major players in
the free agent market. One final note: late Sunday night (July
24), Drew Brees sent an
e-mail to his teammates that stated the reported three-day
window each team was supposed to have to sign its own free agents
does not exist. If that happens, free agency will be a true feeding
frenzy unlike anything we have ever seen.
From most impact to least, players are listed in order of projected
fantasy impact in 2011, assuming my prediction for where they
sign is correct. “Interested” teams are listed in
alphabetical order.
Ahmad
Bradshaw, RB
Teams that should be interested:
Cincinnati, Denver, Indianapolis, Miami, NY Giants
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Giants.
Bradshaw should be the second domino to fall on the RB market
– assuming the Giants don’t re-sign him during the now-in-question
three-day window that teams will have to negotiate with their
own free agents – but if he somehow is allowed on the market,
expect the Giants to match any offer. With that said, the Broncos
could definitely be in play should DeAngelo Williams elect to
stay with Carolina. Three years younger than the 28-year-old Williams,
Bradshaw may actually be a more coveted option for Denver. The
Dolphins could scrap their plan to add a scatback like Darren
Sproles and instead find a big-play complement for Daniel Thomas;
however, I tend to believe that will not happen. Admittedly, two
of the teams above (Colts, Bengals) are extreme longshots (neither
team has much history spending big dollars early in free agency)
but it isn’t out of the realm of possibility that Indianapolis
passes on re-signing Joseph Addai and decides to bring a young
big-play element into its backfield alongside rookie Delone Carter
– the RB the team hopes will help address its short-yardage woes.
The Bengals are a slightly lesser longshot, but with Cedric Benson’s
most recent arrest, one would hope Cincinnati considers other
backfield options (although if it does, I expect a cheaper talent
like Jason Snelling or restricted free agent Michael Bush). Because
it has been so long since the Bengals possessed a big-play threat
in the backfield, perhaps they would trust a player like Bradshaw
– someone who has produced while playing in pain. If Bradshaw
does remain in New York as many expect – and it will be tough
with the Giants’
salary cap situation – he should start coming off the board
in the early part of the third round at the latest in 12-team
leagues.
Williams: It will be a two-horse race between
the Broncos and Panthers.
DeAngelo
Williams, RB
Teams that should be interested:
Carolina, Denver, Miami
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Denver.
Ultimately, this should end up being a two-horse race between
the Broncos and Panthers, unless a darkhorse candidate like Cincinnati
(highly doubtful) or Washington (intriguing but still doubtful)
wants to drive up the price. Prior to the draft, there appeared
to be some mutual interest with the Dolphins, but after their
selection of Daniel Thomas, it seems unlikely the team will pursue
anything more than a third-down scatback type who can return kicks.
Therefore, it should come down to D-Will returning to Carolina
– which has Jonathan Stewart and Mike Goodson, two younger and
slightly more durable options – and Denver – which would mean
Williams would play for the only NFL head coach he has ever known
in John Fox. Despite a fine second-half showing in 2010, Knowshon
Moreno isn’t considered a workhorse-type RB and wouldn’t be able
to handle all the carries in the run-heavy offense Fox wants to
run anyway. (It should be noted that Fox’s teams have never run
the ball less than 422 times in a season in his nine seasons as
a HC. And over the last six seasons, Carolina’s lead back averaged
225 carries per season while the “complementary” RB received an
average of 158 per season – an average percentage split of roughly
59:41 between his team’s top two RBs. What this all means is that
Moreno’s stock doesn’t plummet – even if it does drop a bit –
while Williams moves from a dominant run-blocking line in Carolina
(when healthy) to a rebuilding one in Denver. Thus, the net result
in fantasy is that both Williams and Moreno would see their draft
stock fall, with Williams’ durability and lesser offensive line
probably making him more of a third-round selection in 12-team
leagues while Moreno’s own injury issues and fewer touches should
make him more of a consideration in the sixth-round area.
Santonio
Holmes, WR
Teams that should be interested: Chicago, NY Jets, St. Louis,
Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Jets.
As the youngest proven WR in this class, it would come as little
surprise if Holmes ends up as the highest-paid one of the bunch.
As much as Chicago and St. Louis could use someone of Holmes’
talents, one would think the only way either team will land him
is if Holmes prefers to take his time in signing, which is doubtful
since the dollars will be flying fast in the first few days of
free agency. This leaves with the Jets and Redskins, two deep-pocketed
teams with a history of spending money on free agents. Because
the Jets have repeatedly stated that Holmes is their top priority,
expect them to match any offer Washington can come up with, even
if that means New York has to let WRs Braylon Edwards and Brad
Smith sign elsewhere. And even if the Redskins do outbid the Jets,
it’s doubtful that it will be by such a significant margin that
Holmes will leave a Super Bowl-contending team for one that is
still finding itself in Year Two of the Mike Shanahan-Bruce Allen
regime. Holmes would represent a rock-solid choice in the fourth
round of fantasy drafts if he remains in New York.
Steve
Smith, WR (Carolina)
Teams that should be interested: Chicago, New England, San
Diego, St. Louis
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Chicago.
While much of the talk during the offseason has Smith linked to
the Chargers, he doesn’t strike me as their kind of receiver.
Don’t get me wrong, his explosiveness would be a welcome addition
in San Diego and help make Antonio Gates’ job even easier. But
San Diego has favored bigger receivers of late and I can’t foresee
A.J. Smith dealing a second-day pick for a 32-year-old wideout
with a fairly big salary number. St. Louis represents an interesting
possibility as the need and chance to play for a better team are
both present with the Rams, but something tells me St. Louis is
going in a different direction (more on that later). I included
New England among the list of interested teams simply because
the Pats always seems to have more than enough second-day draft
picks to make a move. Acquiring Smith shouldn’t require much more
than a third-round selection and his presence in Foxboro would
make Tom Brady that much more dangerous. The best fit in my mind,
however, is Chicago. OC Mike Martz’s offense is based on deep-in
routes, explosiveness and precise route-running ability with enough
toughness to take the hit over the middle from the safety. Few
receivers fit that description much better than Smith, who would
move Johnny Knox into a more comfortable WR2 role on the team
while allowing Earl Bennett to serve as the third receiver. Wherever
Smith does end up, he is unlikely to return to rekindle his 80-catch
days of yesteryear, but another 1,000 yard, eight-TD season in
a Martz offense is entirely possible. Landing in Chicago would
probably revitalize Smith’s draft stock and make him a bargain
in the early-to-mid part of Round 5.
Jason
Snelling, RB
Teams that should be interested: Atlanta, Cincinnati, Miami,
St. Louis
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Cincinnati.
In limited duty with the Falcons, Snelling has essentially done
what Michael Turner did in San Diego before he landed in Atlanta
– produce in a big way. It probably comes as little surprise then
that Snelling wants a bigger role as he enters his age-28 season.
Unfortunately, it is doubtful the Falcons can offer him that after
selecting Jacquizz Rodgers in April’s draft to protect themselves
for Snelling’s possible departure. So, despite his love for his
current employer, he may have a better shot for more playing time
somewhere else. Fortunately, one team has a need for someone with
his size and talents – the Bengals. With Cincinnati wanting to
run the ball with a big, physical RB in new OC Jay Gruden’s West
Coast offense, I see Snelling as more of a complete back than
Cedric Benson with none of the headaches. Consider for a minute
that Snelling’s 44 receptions as a third-down back from a season
ago are 16 more than Benson has caught in any season, including
the last two-plus as the Bengals’ featured back. To me, this is
an easy choice for Cincinnati; the question is will they see it
the same way? On one hand, Snelling presents a pass-catching option
with a lot of tread left on his tires in a short-passing offense
that requires its running backs to be good receivers. On the other
hand is Benson, a limited power back with significant off-field
concerns that is about the same age as Snelling and has 1,008
more touches in the NFL. Snelling is no superstar, but he is steady
and versatile – qualities the Bengals need in the worst way. Because
Cincinnati has a tendency to lean on one runner, Snelling could
emerge as one of the biggest winners in free agency and fantasy
if this happens. If this all comes to fruition (and I know it
is a lot to ask the Bengals to turn the page from Benson), then
Snelling becomes a very solid RB2 in fantasy who could easily
command an early-fifth round selection at worst in 12-team leagues.
Santana
Moss, WR
Teams that should be interested: Chicago, Jacksonville, Minnesota,
St. Louis, Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Washington.
It probably seems odd that I would suggest Chicago would chase
a 32-year-old receiver in Smith who would require draft-pick compensation
as opposed to another 32-year-old receiver who does not requires
one in Moss. But I think the very reason the Bears will try to
land Smith before Moss is that Smith has two years remaining on
his contract at $7 M and $7.75 M in 2011 and 2012, respectively.
There’s no way Chicago (or any other team) will land Moss with
a two-year offer, so Smith really should be the hotter commodity
because there is less risk he will get “old” before the end of
his contract. Since neither Jacksonville or St. Louis strike me
as a team willing to take a chance on Smith, that leaves us with
Minnesota – which seems like a poor bet right now to retain Rice
– and a return to the Redskins. CSN Washington reported in early
July the Redskins could end up with somewhere between $10-28
M of salary cap room, assuming they can find trading partners
for Donovan McNabb and Albert Haynesworth and release a few other
veterans. GM Bruce Allen and HC Mike Shanahan restrained themselves
in free agency last season, but have given every indication they
have been preparing for an aggressive offseason this time around.
That aggressiveness will likely manifest itself at receiver and
on the offensive line first, with additional free-agent help coming
on the defensive line. The team is also likely to add a veteran
QB to come closer to the aforementioned $28 M of cap room than
the $10 M figure. If Moss returns to Washington as I believe he
will, he should continue to be the PPR dynamo he has been for
most of his career. And with rookie Leonard Hankerson joining
Chris Cooley and Anthony Armstrong, Moss may not be asked to carry
the passing game each and every week anymore. Even with John Beck
under center, Moss should be considered a low-end fantasy WR2
and should come off the board in the late-fifth or early-sixth
round.
Joseph
Addai, RB
Teams that should be interested: Cincinnati, Indianapolis,
Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Indianapolis.
In all honesty, there are very few teams that have a need for
a running back with Addai’s talents. That’s really not a knock
on his ability as much as it is a realistic assessment of what
he is – a wonderful RB in all facets of the passing game with
decent ability as a runner when he is healthy. And to say that
his skill set is valued more in Indy than it is anywhere else
is a definite understatement, particularly with Peyton Manning
coming off his second neck surgery in as many years. The Bengals
should really be in the market for a RB not named Cedric Benson
and the Redskins may have some interest as they head into the
2011 season with rookie Roy Helu and injury-prone Ryan Torain.
In the end, though, a return to the Colts makes the most sense
for both parties. In Indy, Addai may see his fantasy appeal drop
a bit from where it has been in previous years since the Colts
added a rookie RB in Delone Carter who they hope will be their
answer to their short-yardage woes. But even if Addai’s new ceiling
is around six TDs, he is too involved in the passing game to drop
lower than a very serviceable RB2 in fantasy. He’s well worth
a sixth-round selection in 12-team leagues should he last that
long in PPR drafts this summer.
Zach
Miller, TE
Teams that should be interested: Oakland
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Oakland.
If Miller escapes Oakland, it will be a huge upset. The Raiders
placed a first- and third-round tender on him in March before
the lockout became official – a clear sign that Al Davis has no
intention to let him get away. With Miller the focal point of
the passing game, the Raiders showing some signs of life in 2010
and the team’s history of overpaying to keep its own players,
staying in Oakland may not be a bad option for the TE. Miller
should be considered a strong sixth-round choice in 12-team PPR
leagues this summer.
Kevin
Kolb, QB
Teams that should be interested: Arizona, Seattle, Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Arizona.
For months, the only “near-guarantee” once the lockout was lifted
has been the identity of Kolb’s new team, the Cardinals. In fact,
the only debate for months has been if Arizona would sacrifice
multiple draft picks or a player and draft pick in order to secure
the player the Cardinals must feel is their long-term successor
to Kurt Warner. The problem is that while Kolb is the youngest
QB (26) with a decent track record that is rumored to be available,
he’s not the youngest QB with the best track record that can be
had. (That distinction, in my mind, belongs to 28-year-old Kyle
Orton, who just happens to be good friends with Arizona institution
Larry Fitzgerald and is supposedly available for a third-round
pick whereas Kolb is likely to require a second-round pick and
a veteran player in return.) Be that as it may, I’m not in the
business of telling or convincing team owners and GM’s what they
do with their resources or franchises (yet). In Arizona, Kolb
would not see much of a drop-off in offensive skill-position talent,
but the Cardinals need to add some quality offensive linemen if
they plan on keeping Kolb around for the long term. (In three
of his five starts last season, Kolb was sacked three, four and
six times – with the three-sack game happening in about a half
of football before the Packers knocked him out for good.) As for
the other teams that should be interested, I can only see the
Seahawks staying in the race long enough to drive up the price
on their division rivals while the Redskins showed in April’s
draft they plan on being more judicious with their draft picks
than in years past. As a Cardinal, Kolb’s fantasy status would
be a difficult one to call, due mostly the offensive line woes.
His upside isn’t as great as another injury-risk QB like Detroit’s
Matthew Stafford, but he should be one of the better fantasy QB2
options available assuming Arizona takes some steps to improve
its line.
Kyle
Orton, QB
Teams that should be interested: Arizona, Miami, Seattle,
Tennessee, Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Miami.
Of the QBs expected to be available (and thus, on this list) I
feel Orton is probably the best bet to succeed long-term. In four
full years as a NFL starter, one could argue that a single year
each with Brandon Marshall and a late-blooming Brandon Lloyd are
the best receivers Orton has played with, so it is possible that
we only caught a glimpse of what he can do in a wide-open passing
offense with any kind of threat at receiver. With that said, it
is only a matter of time before Denver decides to hand the starting
job to Tim Tebow permanently. According to a
recent Denver Post article, the Broncos are going to be roughly
$9 M over the cap at the start of free agency. It just so happens
that Orton’s “cap hit” is $8.879 M, so it seems like a logical
place to start for a team that wants to be active in free agency.
Therefore, the question isn’t if Orton will get traded or released,
but when and where he will end up. As I stated above with Kolb,
I believe he is the better choice for Arizona. However, if the
Cards do what just about no one expects them to do and use Kolb
and Orton as leverage against each other (and ultimately taking
the cheaper option in Orton), then Denver may be forced to accept
a third- or fourth-round pick in return. One team that may just
pay that price could be Miami - a team that has a player Orton
is already familiar with in Marshall. Many of the Dolphins’ personnel
people who have supported Chad Henne are no longer with the team,
so the Dolphins would be wise to bring in a proven QB to push
Henne, if not overtake him. And if Orton does join Miami, his
fantasy stock would remain fairly high with a supporting cast
that includes Marshall, Davone Bess, rookie RB Daniel Thomas and
a scatback RB like Reggie Bush or Darren Sproles. Therefore, in
such a situation, Orton would be a solid QB2 choice in fantasy
this season.
Sidney
Rice, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Chicago, Jacksonville,
Minnesota, Oakland, San Diego, Seattle, St. Louis, Tennessee,
Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Carolina.
From the time Rice reportedly last spoke to Vikings HC Leslie
Frazier back in April, it became clear he wanted to test the open
market and was willing to go to the highest bidder. As a player
entering his age-25 season, Rice will have no shortage of suitors
looking for a big receiver (6-4, 202) that can create at least
one big play per game, so it’s a good bet Rice will attempt to
break the bank with this contract – a description that would seem
to eliminate teams like the Jags, Rams and Titans. Seattle makes
some sense since Rice could fit in well opposite Mike Williams
(not to mention HC Pete Carroll likes big receivers), but the
feel just isn’t quite right there either. I also wonder about
the fit in Chicago since the one big receiver the Bears just had
who could get downfield (Devin Aromashodu) did not appeal to OC
Mike Martz and is the same kind of player Rice is, albeit less
talented. I could also see a scenario in which San Diego and Minnesota
brokered a sign-and-trade deal, swapping Vincent Jackson for Rice
in a deal that would get the former away from GM A.J. Smith while
the latter would fit the Chargers’ profile of supersized WRs who
can create big plays (admittedly a longshot). In the end, I expect
Washington, Minnesota and Carolina – which according to one estimate
may be as much as $70
M under the new proposed salary cap – to drive up the price
on each other to land the youngest impact free-agent receiver
on the market. And if that ends up happening, I suspect Rice will
chase the money – not to mention the team that has the most-talented
QB with the highest ceiling– and replace Steve Smith as the big-play
receiver in Carolina. Yes, his injury history may lead to a slightly
smaller contract than some expect, but the Panthers will have
the room to offer Rice the most guaranteed money if they choose
to do so. With a rookie QB in Minnesota (Christian Ponder) and
Carolina (Cam Newton) as well as an unproven veteran (John Beck)
in Washington, Rice’s fantasy value will take a hit regardless,
at least from its 2009 zenith. He has a shot at low-end WR2 status
in all three locales, assuming good health, although his best
shot at reaching that status would be as a Redskin. However, if
he signs with the Panthers, fantasy owners should view him as
a top-end WR3 at best, considering his new supporting cast and
lack of durability.
Randy
Moss, WR
Teams that should be interested: NY Jets
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Jets.
As it was made quite clear during the middle of the 2010 season,
teams were leery of adding Moss back then. And he justified those
fears by producing next to nothing as a Titan. So despite the
fact that Moss should be a relative bargain on the free agent
market, Moss and his agent may be waiting by the phone for a while
despite the latter’s claim that his client is in “freakish shape”.
Perhaps the only team that will kick his tires will be “the other
New York team” since it is highly probable the Jets will be looking
for someone with big-play ability that should come relatively
cheap to replace Braylon Edwards. (And what fun would that be,
Moss playing for the archrival of the team he professed his love
for just last season?) For fantasy purposes, Moss would have pretty
decent upside and could be a steal as a late-round pick, at least
until we find out whether or not his agent was lying to us about
Moss’ conditioning. But in the instance that Moss is re-committed,
his fantasy floor would be Edwards’ production in 2010 and his
ceiling is, well, as high as Moss wants it to be.
Reggie
Bush, RB
Teams that should be interested: Miami, New Orleans, St. Louis
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: St.
Louis. There is little doubt that Bush and his $11.8 M
salary in 2011 will not both return to the Saints. But could he
return at half that price? Considering the Saints have nearly
30 free agents, there’s a pretty good chance the answer is no.
It hasn’t helped this projection that Bush has both confirmed
he wants to return to New Orleans and told the national media
(on NFL Network) that he will not accept a paycut to return to
the Saints. So which is it? The smart money is that if Bush isn’t
amenable to a quick restructure, so he will be set free in hopes
they can bring him back. But one has to wonder if a reduced role
will appeal enough to the 26-year-old when teams like the Dolphins
and Rams should be able to guarantee him at least 10-12 touches
per game and should have the cap room to pay him more than New
Orleans. St. Louis makes the most sense of the two because it
isn’t a stretch to see OC Josh McDaniels use Bush in a Kevin Faulk-
or Correll Buckhalter-type of role to reduce Steven Jackson’s
workload. Furthermore, adding Bush to the passing game would make
the absence of a true WR1 less of an issue since he would command
most of the defense’s attention while he is on the field. Bush
could also see that Jackson is nearing that magical 2,000-carry
career mark when RBs tend to start trending downward and smell
an opportunity to carve out a 50-50 split by 2012. That likelihood
doesn’t figure to happen in Miami, New Orleans or Philadelphia
(another rumored destination), so I’ll send Bush to the Rams after
believing he would agree to a restructured deal with the Saints
initially. In St. Louis, Bush would have some RB4 value in PPR
leagues, although his non-PPR stock would probably plummet to
later-round status in most regular-sized leagues.
Cedric
Benson, RB
Teams that should be interested: Cincinnati, Denver, St. Louis,
Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Washington.
I’ll admit it; it would be a pretty big upset if the Bengals don’t
take back their lovable criminal. But in the off-chance they do
come to their senses and sign Snelling instead, there is going
to be a pretty limited market for a RB going into his age-29 season
that sports a career 3.7 YPC. The most likely suitor would probably
be the Broncos – if they miss out on both DeAngelo Williams and
Ahmad Bradshaw – so they could have a veteran NFL runner that
could share the load with Knowshon Moreno. However, I do expect
Denver to land one of the best RBs in this free agent class, meaning
it could go down to the Rams (who I expect will land a well-rounded
third-down back instead of a limited power back) and the Redskins.
Despite the fact Washington should enter camp with rookie Roy
Helu and Ryan Torain fighting for the top spot, neither player
is a great bet to stay healthy all season long. However, the best
reason for Benson to end up in Washington is because he has already
proven his ability to adequately run behind a zone-blocking line.
Cincinnati is by far the best place for Benson’s fantasy stock,
but if there is another place that could give him a chance to
prove me wrong, it might be Washington since he would definitely
be in line for a good chunk of the backfield work. As a Bengal,
Benson warrants late-fourth to early-fifth round consideration
in both PPR and non-PPR leagues while his stock drops roughly
2-3 rounds should he be forced to share touches with Helu and
Torain in the nation’s capital.
Chad
Ochocinco, WR
Teams that should be interested: Chicago, New England
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: New
England. In team owner Mike Brown’s world, it is pretty
cut and dried: a player is not going to force his way out of town
and if a player has “invisible” value to the common man, it doesn’t
mean he still can’t be useful to Brown. The first part of that
statement applies to both Carson Palmer and Ochocinco while the
second part impacts only “85”. Try as he might over the years,
Ocho hasn’t been able to talk or act his way out of town, even
when trading him would have been the best thing for the team.
Now, with the emergence of Jerome Simpson and the selection of
A.J. Green in April’s draft, Ocho’s career as a Bengal is almost
certainly coming to a close. No team will likely trade for him,
but Brown isn’t going to release him right away either since keeping
him around for a while should enhance the team’s position in contract
negotiations with Green. In short, expect most of the potential
market for Ocho’s services to be dried up by the time he becomes
an ex-Bengal. As luck would have it, that last part makes him
a good fit for the Patriots as HC Bill Belichick has long had
an odd fascination with him. The one team I can see competing
with New England is Chicago since Ochocinco’s speed and explosion
at 33 years of age can still play in a Mike Martz offense, but
I tend to believe the Bears will not wait until his release to
fill their need for a WR1. In fantasy, Ocho would probably merit
high-upside WR4 consideration initially with the Pats, with a
possibility for WR2 value should he beat out Deion Branch for
a starting job.
Malcom
Floyd, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Miami, Jacksonville,
St. Louis, San Diego
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: San
Diego. Floyd is just the kind of mid-priced, big-play receiver
that teams like the Jags and Rams could be interested in. And
if the Panthers and Dolphins each want to take a dip into a more
reasonably-priced option than the bigger names I have listed for
them above, Floyd could be headed there as well. But I highly
doubt the Chargers will let it go that far since Floyd is a pretty
good bet to re-sign with the team. Not only does Floyd already
play a prominent role in a great offense, he may also get a chance
to move up the proverbial food chain should the acrimony between
GM A.J. Smith and Vincent Jackson continue through next season.
With Jackson likely to return under the franchise tag, however,
Floyd should be considered a WR3 again for fantasy purposes since
he will be third in the pecking order behind Antonio Gates and
Jackson.
James
Jones, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Cleveland, Minnesota,
San Diego, Seattle
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Minnesota.
San Diego could test the waters if it cannot re-sign Malcom Floyd
and Seattle may be interested in Jones as a complement to Mike
Williams, but both teams figure to be longshots at best. The Panthers
are a good bet to land one top free agent receiver and maybe two
with their projected cap room and the likely departure of Steve
Smith, so Carolina could be a player in the Jones’ sweepstakes
if it wants to be. (And how much better would the Panthers be
already in 2011 if they were able to start Rice and Jones at WR
instead of Brandon LaFell and David Gettis?) But in the end, I
think Jones stays in the NFC North. If a division rival can kill
two birds with one stone in free agency, they will take the opportunity
to do so more times than not. While the whole “team steals player
from division rival” angle is a bit overrated in my mind – especially
in this case since Green Bay doesn’t mind letting Jones go – he
could serve as an instant upgrade to Bernard Berrian in Minnesota.
As just about any Green Bay fan can attest, Jones’ proclivity
to dropping passes is troublesome and is the main reason he isn’t
likely to return to the Packers. But his big-play ability is undeniable
and his experience in HC Mike McCarthy’s West Coast offense should
carry over fairly well to Bill Musgrave’s offense in Minnesota
if the Vikes are unable to hold on to Sidney Rice. As a Viking,
Jones would make a decent WR4 option in fantasy that could be
drafted in the later rounds.
Braylon
Edwards, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Chicago, Miami,
Minnesota, San Diego, Seattle
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Miami.
In finding a logical landing spot for Edwards, a few things need
to be considered. At 28, Edwards is likely seeking his final big
NFL payday, so a team with some cap room is a prerequisite. Secondly,
if he is to leave the Jets, Edwards will want to play for a team
that is perhaps one or two players away from making a deep playoff
run. Last but not least, his new team needs to be in the market
for a deep threat receiver. I’ll admit, this is one fit I have
my doubts about and things could really get dicey on South Beach
with Brandon Marshall and Edwards together, but Miami should have
the cap room and talent necessary to recruit him. It also bears
mentioning that new Dolphins OC Brian Daboll has a bit of experience
with Edwards from their short time together in Cleveland, although
that connection could also be the very reason the receiver would
have no interest in Miami. (Edwards was traded early in Daboll’s
first year with Cleveland.) Either way, the No. 3 overall pick
in the 2005 draft would also represent a significant upgrade over
Brian Hartline and give Chad Henne (or Kyle Orton, as I have projected
above) a multitude of weapons for the first time in either quarterback’s
career. A move to Miami would not be the greatest thing for Edwards’
fantasy stock in all likelihood since Marshall would be the clear
top option and Davone Bess is one of the best short-yardage and
third-down options in the league. Thus, Edwards would start out
the season as little more than a fantasy WR4 on a team that will
look to establish the run game in and game out.
Ronnie
Brown, RB
Teams that should be interested: Baltimore, Cincinnati, Denver,
Miami, Philadelphia, Tampa Bay
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Baltimore.
Despite the number of teams listed above, Brown is quite likely
to receive interest on the secondary market, that is, the wave
of free agents that sign after most of the money has been spent.
Miami is included since it is possible he could return to the
Dolphins, but the team would have to miss out on every one of
the younger, more explosive options first. Cincinnati could be
appealing to Brown since the Bengals would have an opening for
a bellcow RB if they cut the cord on Cedric Benson while Denver
could offer significant touches in its backfield alongside Knowshon
Moreno. Philadelphia may also have moderate interest later on
in free agency since Brown would offer the Eagles a physical runner
in short-yardage situations, similar to what Leonard Weaver provided
in 2009. Tampa Bay would meet Brown’s requirements of playing
in a warm-weather city and occupying a role in which he would
get to show off his receiving talents more than he has in recent
years. However, the team I would expect to emerge from this pack
would probably be considered a darkhorse pick – the Ravens. In
an offseason in which I expect many players to sign deals in which
they are reunited with familiar faces, Brown may see Baltimore
as an opportunity to play the Willis McGahee role for a Super
Bowl-contending team. It would also give him a chance to work
with OC Cam Cameron, the same play-caller that helped Brown turn
into a fantasy beast for the first half of the 2007 season before
he was lost for the final nine games due to injury. If he does
bolt for the Ravens, Brown would warrant low-end RB4 or high-end
RB5 consideration in the later rounds as an inconsistent fantasy
player who could explode for multi-TD games 2-3 times a season.
Matt
Hasselbeck, QB
Teams that should be interested: Arizona, Seattle, Tennessee,
Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Tennessee.
Very few teams are ever in the market for a free-agent QB who
knows he is headed toward retirement in a year or two. With that
said, there is always some interest in a player – no matter his
age – that can still produce. It sounds funny to say, but Hasselbeck
is probably the perfect fit for the Titans in that he is good
enough to “tutor” rookie Jake Locker yet possesses just the right
combination of age (will turn 36 during the season) and brittleness
(hasn’t play 16 games in a season since 2007) that the Titans
will likely have the opportunity to turn things over to its rookie
multiple times in 2011. Hasselbeck is also a good fit in Washington
because he is mobile enough and has plenty of experience in a
West Coast offense like the Redskins run. Arizona is also a reasonable
destination, but at this point, I believe Philadelphia (Kolb)
and Denver (Orton) would have to be unreasonable in their trade
discussions with the Cardinals, so Hasselbeck is probably Arizona’s
third choice. A return to Seattle is still possible, but he has
already turned down a one-year, $7 M offer from the team, perhaps
believing he can land a two-year deal with Tennessee instead.
And there is plenty of reason to believe the Titans are Hasselbeck’s
first choice – three members of the team’s front office (GM Mike
Reinfeldt, Vice President of Player Personnel Ruston Webster and
Director of Pro Personnel Lake Dawson) all have ties to Hasselbeck
as does new OC Chris Palmer. And let’s not forget that Locker
– a University of Washington graduate – worked out with the longtime
Seattle QB prior to the draft and has a “working relationship”
with the rookie, according to NFL Network’s Jason LaConfora. With
Tennessee, Hasselbeck has the look of a solid QB2 in 12-team leagues,
especially considering he’ll be working in the same backfield
as Chris Johnson and two other players (Kenny Britt and Jared
Cook) who possess more game-breaking talent than anyone Seattle
has employed in recent years.
Darren
Sproles, RB
Teams that should be interested: Miami, St. Louis
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Miami.
All offseason, there has been one consistent theme in regards
to their backfield situation: get a pass-catching RB who can break
the big play at any point of the game. When the team traded up
for Kansas State’s Daniel Thomas in April, it increased the likelihood
that Miami would pursue a scatback in free agency as opposed to
hoping for DeAngelo Williams or Ahmad Bradshaw. Fortunately for
the Dolphins, no team fits all the aforementioned prerequisites
better than Sproles – who is likely done in San Diego following
the emergence of Mike Tolbert, the presence of second-year runner
Ryan Mathews and selection of Jordan Todman in the draft. Certainly,
I expect the Rams to show a high degree of interest, but they
don’t strike me as a team that will nab Sproles when the player
they need is a capable three-down reserve. In Miami, Sproles’
PPR value would make him worthy of a late-round pick. In leagues
that reward kick and punt returns, he would enjoy the same kind
of value he possessed in San Diego. However, in non-PPR, he may
go undrafted in most regular-sized leagues.
Mike
Sims-Walker, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Cleveland, Miami,
Seattle, Tennessee
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Seattle.
If there is one sure way for a player with an injury history to
ensure he will receive lukewarm interest on the free agent market,
it is to talk his way out of town. While few will question the
talent that allowed MSW to come out of nowhere to produce a 63-869-7
line in 2009, he may find it difficult to generate heavy interest
from receiver-needy teams since he is basically seen around the
league as an inconsistent me-first player who isn’t the greatest
bet to stay healthy. Thus, I doubt a first-year coach will want
to deal with Sims-Walker, so eliminate the Browns, Panthers and
Titans from the mix. MSW has publicly campaigned to join his college
teammate Brandon Marshall in Miami, but one has to wonder about
such a reunion when there have been reports that some Dolphins’
executives are already questioning the decision to trade for Marshall.
Therefore, the one remaining landing spot is in the Pacific Northwest
where Sims-Walker may see a chance to rebuild his image in much
the same way HC Pete Carroll restored Mike Williams’ reputation
last season. MSW possesses good enough size (6-2, 214) to fit
in OC Darrell Bevell’s offense and the Seahawks probably can offer
him the best opportunity to be a team’s top receiver in 2011.
As for his fantasy value, one would think that Williams and Sims-Walker
would cancel each other out in fantasy, thereby hurting each other’s
big-game potential. In such a situation, owners should view him
both as high-end reserves in three-WR leagues in the later rounds.
Plaxico
Burress, WR
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Miami, Philadelphia,
St. Louis
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: St.
Louis. Burress’ free agency should be focused on one team
– the Rams. With his selection of Demaryius Thomas in the 2010
NFL draft as the Broncos’ HC, new OC Josh McDaniels proved his
offense isn’t just for “average-sized” receivers. While the Rams
boosted their WR corps with Austin Pettis and Greg Salas in April’s
draft, they still lack a potential WR1 who commands attention
in the red zone. Burress also figures to come cheaper than most
of the receivers that should be available and is a known quantity
to HC Steve Spagnuolo, who was the Giants’ DC for two of the four
seasons the former was in New York. Carolina could have scant
interest, but I tend to believe the Panthers will try to focus
on playmakers who are about to hit their prime, not a player entering
his age-34 season that may or may not have a year or two of decent
productivity left. Philly has been rumored as a possible Burress
landing spot all offseason and makes some sense as a red-zone
specialist, but the Eagles are four-deep at WR with DeSean Jackson,
Jeremy Maclin, Jason Avant and Riley Cooper. Miami is a reasonable
destination as well since as he could potentially serve as a bigger
big-play threat than Brian Hartline. But for all the reasons discussed
earlier, St. Louis should be where he signs. Burress’ fantasy
potential with the Rams in 2011 is fair, but expectations need
to be kept low for any player who has been away from the field
as long as he has. Thus, he warrants a late-round fantasy pick
at best in most regular-sized leagues.
Steve
Breaston, WR
Teams that should be interested: Arizona, Carolina, Kansas
City
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Arizona.
First things first, any team that makes a run at Breaston will
need to be convinced his right knee can hold up for the long haul
since it’s entirely possible that injury contributed greatly to
Andre Roberts’ rise in playing time down the stretch. No team
would likely have a better feel for Breaston’s knee than the Cardinals,
who owe it to their new QB and Larry Fitzgerald to provide them
with as many weapons as possible. Kansas City makes a ton of sense
since the Chiefs could use another capable WR in the event that
rookie Jonathan Baldwin is not ready to contribute right away.
Even if Baldwin hits the ground running, putting Breaston in the
slot with Dwayne Bowe and Baldwin on the outside would make for
a talented receiver trio for QB Matt Cassel. Considering the injury
risk, his best bet would likely be to sign a short-term deal with
Arizona and prove himself all over again this season, something
that should be much easier to do with a capable QB under center
in 2011. Breaston has WR3 potential, but he ranks low on this
list because his knee sounds as if it is still an issue as we
stand here in late July. Whether he is a Chief or a Cardinal this
season, he should probably be considered a WR4 at best in fantasy.
Vince
Young, QB
Teams that should be interested:
Miami, Oakland, Seattle, Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Washington.
One of the more interesting players that will be available at
some point is Young, who remains property of the Titans despite
the fact just about everyone knows they are moving on at the QB
position. Make no mistake, Tennessee will release him. From Young’s
perspective, he is a proven winner in this league (career 30-17
record) who was showing signs of developing into a capable passer
in Tennessee. But his warts are well-known: he hasn’t dealt with
adversity well since becoming a pro and his lack of work ethic
is reportedly “legendary”. However, we have seen time and again
that coaches will almost always give superior talents with character
red flags more chances than they probably deserve. Two of the
teams on the list above have reputations for bringing such players
onto their rosters (Oakland, Washington) while the two other teams
(Miami, Seattle) almost have to be interested in someone to challenge
their likely starters. Be that as it may, I expect the Raiders
to show their support for Jason Campbell by not pursuing starting-caliber
options at QB while I doubt Seattle views Young as a great fit
for new OC Darrell Bevell’s offense. This process of elimination
leaves us with Miami and Washington. Certainly, Miami is a good
fit in that the Dolphins will be a run-heavy team again this season,
but one has to wonder how long Young will keep his nose clean
down by South Beach. While Young would probably win a camp competition
with Chad Henne, the former Michigan QB is talented enough to
threaten Young should he struggle at any point during the season.
Conversely, I don’t think many folks outside of Mike Shanahan
believe John Beck is the answer in Washington. Young is hardly
a prototypical West Coast QB, but the Shanahans (Mike and Kyle)
like to roll their QB out much more than most coaches do. As we
know, few QBs run as well as Young. VY has always viewed himself
as a starter and will very likely choose a team that will give
him the easiest path to the top of the depth chart. Washington
is probably the best fit for Young for fantasy purposes as well
since any QB that starts for Shanahan deserves our attention.
Therefore, he deserves mid-to-low QB2 consideration in the late
rounds.
Donovan
McNabb, QB
Teams that should be interested: Cincinnati, Cleveland, Minnesota,
Miami, Seattle
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Cleveland.
It has been a swift fall from grace for a QB who, just two seasons
ago, was leading one of the more explosive offensive attacks in
the NFL. But as a QB heading into his age-35 season that is due
a $10 M offseason bonus, McNabb will soon be looking for another
team. Several teams could make compelling cases to extend an offer
to McNabb once he is a free agent – which may not be until late
August or September – because they each run a version of the West
Coast offense now (all of the aforementioned teams except Miami).
McNabb has been heavily rumored to be a Viking for most of this
offseason, but Minnesota appears more interested in throwing rookie
Christian Ponder into the fire rather than having him holding
a clipboard. And, perhaps more importantly, the Vikes probably
don’t want an accomplished veteran delaying Ponder’s rise into
the starting lineup, which makes a low-upside QB like Bruce Gradkowski
a better fit. Seattle makes a ton of sense in that McNabb should
have an easy enough time beating out Charlie Whitehurst, but the
Seahawks will not wait until a week or two before the season for
him. Likewise, Cincinnati could make a strong argument to start
him Week 1 ahead of Andy Dalton, lending experience to what is
an incredibly talented but very young set of QBs, WRs and TEs
in the Queen City. However, I expect the Bengals to go another
way and pursue Gradkowski as well. Therefore, in a theme I expect
to play out quite often this offseason because of the time lost
due to the lockout, a player will sign with a team that has a
familiar face or two on the sideline. In Cleveland, HC Pat Shurmur
was McNabb’s QB coach from 1999-2008. Jake Delhomme is almost
guaranteed to leave and join HC John Fox in Denver, Seneca Wallace
is no better than a career backup and Colt
McCoy has yet to prove he can stay healthy. The fit in Cleveland
would be an interesting one to be sure, but McNabb’s fantasy prospects
in such a scenario would be as a low-end QB2 at best in 12-team
league.
Cadillac
Williams, RB
Teams that should be interested: St. Louis, Tampa Bay
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Tampa
Bay. Williams should be a good test case for the new “salary
floor” that is being instituted in the new CBA this season, at
least from the Bucs’ perspective. Why? Tampa Bay is projected
to have nearly $60 M to spend in signing its own and other teams’
free agents this season, so since it will be forced to spend most
of that money, the team may decide to pay the players it already
knows. Bringing Williams back also makes sense because LeGarrette
Blount isn’t exactly trusted in the different aspects of the passing
game quite yet. It also doesn’t hurt that Caddy is a noted team
leader and was considered the
most efficient third-down RB in the league, according to Football
Outsiders’ DVOA (Defense-adjusted Value Over Average) metric.
So, after sending him to St. Louis initially in my projections,
the Bucs may just end up deciding to stay with the familiar at
RB and spending their wealth under the cap on the back seven of
their defense instead. Returning to Tampa would mean Williams
should keep the same kind of fantasy value he enjoyed during the
second half of last season, with the biggest feather in his hat
being that he would be a mandatory handcuff for Blount and be
in line for more touches if the young stud is forced to miss time
at any point.
Steve
Smith, WR (Giants)
Teams that should be interested: Carolina, Kansas City, NY
Giants
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Giants.
Without going into a great deal of detail, Smith is a good bet
to start the season on the PUP list, which makes it extremely
likely that he will sign a short-term, incentive-laden deal with
his current team. If there is one team that will make it interesting,
though, it could be the Panthers, who may see signing Smith as
a risk worth taking. Combining Smith with another talented free
agent (such as Sidney Rice) would go a long way in correcting
one of the worst receiving situations in the league right now
in Carolina. But, in the end, I would say there is a 95% chance
Smith returns to New York, where he will make an interesting late-round
sleeper.
Tarvaris
Jackson, QB
Teams that should be interested: Miami, Seattle, Washington
Predicted
final destination and fantasy impact: Seattle.
Jackson should be able to rest easy for the first few days of
the free-agent frenzy. That comment is not really meant to be
a knock on Jackson’s ability; it’s more that he will be lower
on the list than most of the aforementioned signal-callers on
just about every QB-needy team’s list. In other words, I suspect
he will be the fallback option for a team who doesn’t want to
trade a pick or a player and missed out on their first few choices
at the position. Jackson, who owns a 10-10 record as a starter,
believes in his ability to regain QB1 status with his new team,
so it is a smart bet that he will choose a team that gives him
a realistic shot at doing so. I believe each of the three teams
listed above make some degree of sense for him, but I can’t imagine
Jackson beating out Chad Henne or even John Beck with virtually
no offseason to learn a new playbook. Fortunately, his former
OC in Minnesota (Bevell) is the new play-caller for the Seahawks,
meaning he would actually have a leg up on his competition with
Charlie Whitehurst to be the starter. If it plays out that way,
the fantasy impact would be negligible. Jackson’s running ability
would make him a decent spot start in highly favorable matchups,
but assuming he beats out Whitehurst, he’s probably best left
undrafted in all but the deepest of fantasy leagues.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article or fantasy football
in general? E-mail me.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared
in USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each
of the last two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football
analyst for 106.7 The Fan in Washington, D.C. this past season.
He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.
You can also follow him
on Twitter.
|