When it occurred to me last week I should write a two-part column
based on receiver-cornerback matchups, it never crossed my mind
that I would consider a title that played into the content and pay
homage to Thanksgiving Day at the same time. Sometimes, it just
all works out…
Speaking of having it all work out, fantasy
owners often want/need/crave information as it relates to the
best and worst matchups at this time of the season. After 12 weeks,
it often feels our emotions are hanging by a thread just as much
as the playing status of some of the players on our rosters.
Thanks to the FF
Points Allowed tool on FF Today, it isn’t all that difficult
to identify which defenses perform well against certain positions.
After all, if a defense performs well against Cam Newton, it is
logical to believe it will also perform well against Colin Kaepernick.
That’s not to suggest Newton and Kaepernick are the same,
but they are similar – as are their teams’ offensive
philosophies. Running backs aren’t all that much different,
because the position relies on 10 other players on his side of
the ball to do their jobs and stopping the run for a defense is
often an 11-man chore.
While the FF Today points allowed tool is helpful in determining
if a team’s receivers or tight ends are likely to have success
in a given week, it cannot account for likely individual matchups.
However, given the dearth of game-changing tight ends, owners
can almost treat that position like quarterback and running back
when it comes to estimating their impact in a given week. Furthermore,
it is almost a complete waste of time to predicting how often
a tight end will be in safety coverage, linebacker coverage or
trying to find a hole in zone coverage. Players like Jimmy Graham
and Rob Gronkowski are essentially oversized receivers that have
very few defenders that can guard them and play-callers scheming
to get them open – which cannot be said for most tight ends
– so owners shouldn’t be shocked when an upper-echelon
tight end has his way with a good fantasy defense against the
position. Why? Because there is a good chance that defense hasn’t
seen more than one or two players at the position that can emulate
what Graham or Gronkowski can do on the field nor is it all that
likely that same defense has faced an offense that makes the tight
end a featured position.
In a team game, the receiver vs. cornerback battle is often as
individual as it gets at the skill positions. Without getting
into too much of a philosophical discussion about how individual
it is, we can generally assume that a defense will remain either
a team that uses a “shadow” cornerback or opts to
“play sides” and not change its method during the
course of a game. Receivers tend to move all around the formation
and many of the top receivers nowadays spend time in the slot,
so the most any analyst can say with any certainty is that a certain
receiver should see a lot of a certain receiver in coverage based
on where he has lined up to this point.
I have often said owners make the most lineup mistakes at receiver
because there is more mystery surrounding the receiver vs. cornerback
battle than any other fantasy position. In an effort to eliminate
some of that mystery, last week’s “Dirty
Dozen” took a look at the 12 cornerbacks we don’t
want our receivers to meet at any point of the season, especially
now. This week, it is time to turn the spotlight on the juiciest
matchups available to our receivers, just in time for what we
all hope is a long playoff run.
While the receiver position will probably always remain the most
difficult fantasy position to predict from week to week, we do
have some tools at our disposal to evaluate just how difficult
their upcoming matchups are. Although Pro Football Focus has many
stats that can help us to make informed decisions about what receiver
vs. cornerback matchups we should target, I prefer to use the
NFL QB rating against a defender (in this case, a cornerback)
as a tool to help discern what receivers could be in for a big
day. Below is a list of the 12 cornerbacks that have played at
least 60% of their team’s snaps and struggled for most of
2013.
Note: In most
cases, the projected wide receiver-cornerback matchups are based
on the side where each player has lined up the most this season
and are obviously variable (as noted above) since offenses tend
to move their receivers around the formation, send them in motion
or use them in bunch sets in order to get help them gain early
separation or avoid jams at the line of scrimmage. Identifying
possible wide receiver-cornerback matchups will be more difficult
this week than last because offenses often try to “scheme”
their best receiver so he can get singled up against the opponent’s
worst corner. Not surprisingly, defenses often try to “hide”
their struggling defensive backs.
1. Josh
Wilson, Washington (NFL QB Rating – 126.0, mostly in the slot)
Analysis: Minnesota rookie Josh
Robinson actually has the worst QB Rating Against at 127.0, but
he might miss the rest of the season with a fractured sternum,
so it doesn’t make a lot of sense to begin this list with him.
Wilson was picked on relentlessly on Monday Night Football against
San Francisco, almost to the point where it got to be ridiculous
(11 targets while teammate DeAngelo Hall was only targeted twice).
For the season, Wilson has been targeted 66 times and given up
55 catches for 716 yards and three touchdowns without recording
an interception.
Week 13: Victor Cruz, (slot), Rueben Randle (outside); New York
Giants
Week 14: Dwayne Bowe, Kansas City
Week 15: Harry Douglas, (slot), Roddy White (outside); Atlanta
Week 16: Miles Austin, Dallas
2. Janoris
Jenkins, St. Louis (119.8)
Analysis: Jenkins was considered something of a rookie revelation
because he was opportunistic, but the numbers (66 catches for
715 yards on 107 targets in 2012) show that he gave up his fair
share of plays as well. This year, the interceptions have decreased
(four to one) while the touchdowns allowed (five to six) and success
rate of receivers in his coverage (61.7 to 66.7 percent) has increased.
Jenkins’ rookie success is a reminder that just because
a cornerback makes splashy plays, it doesn’t mean he is
ready to evolve into the next shutdown corner. There’s plenty
of time (and talent) still there for Jenkins to become one of
the league’s better cover men, but it probably won’t
happen this year.
Week 13: Anquan Boldin, St. Louis (based on Week 4 matchup)
Week 14: Larry Fitzgerald, Arizona (based on Week 1 matchup)
Week 15: Marques Colston, New Orleans
Week 16: Vincent Jackson, Tampa Bay
3. Shareece
Wright, San Diego (118.8)
Analysis: To put it kindly, one of the main reasons Wright doesn’t
top this list is because he has plenty of teammates in the secondary
that are giving up big plays about as often as he is. Wright has
graded out poorly in three straight games. He has surrendered
19 catches on 26 targets over that time to Demaryius Thomas, Mike
Wallace, Charles Clay and a whole host of Kansas Chiefs (most
notably Dexter McCluster). In particular, Thomas scorched him
for seven receptions, 108 yards and three touchdowns, meaning
Denver saw him as the most exploitable option in a secondary full
of weak links.
Week 13: A.J. Green, Cincinnati
Week 14: Victor Cruz/Rueben Randle (outside); New York Giants
Week 15: Demaryius Thomas, Denver (based on Week 10 matchup)
Week 16: Rod Streater, Oakland
4. Ike
Taylor, Pittsburgh (116.5)
Analysis: Known for sticky coverage and stone hands throughout
most of his career, Taylor’s presence on this list is bit
of a surprise for a “shadow” corner. His high ranking
appears to be more of a function of facing Calvin Johnson and
Josh Gordon in consecutive weeks (during which time he has surrendered
three of his four touchdowns and 328 of his 807 yards allowed)
than anything else. With that said, his play has declined in 2013
after he closed out last season on such a high note.
Week 13: Torrey Smith, Baltimore (based on Week 7 matchup)
Week 14: Mike Wallace, Miami
Week 15: A.J. Green, Cincinnati (based on Week 2 matchup)
Week 16: Jordy Nelson, Green Bay
5. Vontae
Davis, Indianapolis (111.0)
Analysis: Davis – like many of his defensive teammates
– enjoyed their best performance against Denver back in
Week 7. The fourth-year corner has also been good enough in keeping
receivers in check on occasion (34 catches on 62 targets in his
coverage), but has given up an alarming five touchdowns over the
last three weeks – including two each to Andre Johnson and
Tavon Austin as well as one to Larry Fitzgerald. Davis is dealing
with a groin injury and his status is in some doubt for Week 13.
Week 13: Kendall Wright, Tennessee (based on Week 11 matchup)
Week 14: Marvin Jones/Mohamed Sanu, Cincinnati
Week 15: Andre Johnson, Houston (based on Week 9 matchup)
Week 16: Jordy Nelson, Green Bay
6. Chris
Houston, Detroit (108.7)
Analysis: Owners may not get a shot to target Houston this week
as he is listed as doubtful with a foot injury for the Lions’
Thanksgiving Day game against Green Bay, but they might get an
upgrade (at least from a fantasy perspective) since rookie Darius
Slay will likely be asked to replace him. Slay (134.0 QB rating
allowed) has been benched a handful of times already, so he’ll
have a bulls-eye on his back for as long as he is in the lineup.
In the off-chance Houston does suit up, it is worth noting that
he has given up long touchdowns (34 yards to Antonio Brown and
85 yards to Tiquan Underwood) over the last two weeks.
Week 13: James Jones, Green Bay (based on Week 5 matchup)
Week 14: DeSean Jackson, Philadelphia
Week 15: Marlon Brown/Jacoby Jones, Baltimore
Week 16: Victor Cruz/Rueben Randle (outside); New York Giants
7. Derek
Cox, San Diego (106.4)
Analysis: There’s a pretty good
chance Cox will not make it more than one year into the four-year,
$20 M deal he signed in the offseason. The former Jacksonville
Jaguar has been benched in three of the last four games and graded
out poorly in coverage in seven of the Chargers’ previous eight
contests. To illustrate how bad the situation is for Cox and San
Diego right now, when Shareece Wright was injured last week, the
Chargers called upon journeyman Crezdon Butler – and not Cox –
to replace him. It’s a long fall for a player who was considered
a better cornerback that Rashean Mathis when Mathis’ star was
still fairly bright in Jacksonville.
Week 13: Marvin Jones/Mohamed Sanu, Cincinnati
Week 14: Hakeem Nicks, New York Giants
Week 15: Eric Decker, Denver (based on Week 10 matchup)
Week 16: Denarius Moore, Oakland (based on Week 5 matchup)
8. Mike
Jenkins, Oakland (102.7)
Analysis: Jenkins has a few things working against him as we
speak. Although he hasn’t yielded a touchdown in his coverage
over the last two games, he has still permitted 14 receptions
on 19 targets for 151 yards over that span. Making matters worse,
he suffered a concussion in the Week 12 loss to Tennessee, but
Oakland is still expected to make him active for its Thanksgiving
Day game against Dallas. For the season, he has allowed 43 catches
on 63 targets for 521 yards and three touchdowns.
Week 13: Miles Austin/Terrance Williams, Dallas
Week 14: Stephen Hill/David Nelson, New York Jets
Week 15: Dwayne Bowe, Kansas City (based on Week 6 matchup)
Week 16: Keenan Allen, San Diego (based on Week 5 matchup)
9. Johnthan
Banks, Tampa Bay (101.9)
Analysis: It’s hard to come down
too hard on any rookie, especially one that knows he will be targeted
just about every week Darrelle Revis is healthy and shadowing
the other team’s best receiver (which oddly started happening
about the same time the Bucs started winning). Revis’ status appears
to be in some doubt with a groin injury, so perhaps Tampa Bay
will go back to the zone-heavy scheme it utilized during its losing
streak. As a result, I’ll settle for predicting his likely matchup
with Revis in the lineup below because it is almost pointless
to project his primary matchup if the Bucs play a lot of zone.
Week 13: Brandon LaFell, Carolina
Week 14: Robert Woods, Buffalo
Week 15: Mario Manningham/Michael Crabtree, San Francisco
Week 16: Austin Pettis, St. Louis
T-10. Antonio
Cromartie, New York Jets (100.4)
Analysis: After a brilliant 2012 that made parting with Revis
a little easier, Cromartie has struggled mightily in 2013 –
thanks in large part to an old hip injury that really hasn’t
received a lot of press. He was burned on Torrey Smith’s
60-yard catch last week, Marquise Goodwin’s 43-yard TD catch
a week earlier, Robert Meachem’s 60-yarder the week before
that and A.J. Green’s 53-yard reception in Week 8. Suffice
it to say that someone like Mike Wallace may get a deep target
or two if he had the good fortune of facing him. As luck would
have it, that matchup should happen this week. Josh Gordon owners
that are still around for fantasy championship week should rejoice.
Week 13: Mike Wallace, Miami
Week 14: Denarius Moore, Oakland
(If Moore is still not healthy in two weeks, Rod Streater becomes
the likely opponent.)
Week 15: Steve Smith, Carolina
Week 16: Josh Gordon, Cleveland
T-10. Brandon
Flowers, Kansas City (100.4, mostly in the slot)
Analysis: This one is a stunner and likely a bit of an anomaly.
Although the success rate (49 catches on 71 targets) against him
suggests his play may not be matching his reputation as one of
the top corners in the league, the two touchdowns he has allowed
this season were to Dez Bryant in Week 2 and TE Ladarius Green
last week. As a result, I’m not exactly sure opponents (and
thus, fantasy owners) should target Flowers as a plus-matchup
just because the 5-9 Virginia Tech product surrendered TDs to
two of the bigger and most-gifted athletes at their respective
positions.
Week 13: Wes Welker, Denver (based on Week 11 matchup)
Week 14: Santana Moss, Washington
Week 15: Brice Butler, Oakland
Week 16: T.Y. Hilton, Indianapolis
12. Kyle
Arrington, New England (99.0)
Analysis: Like Johnthan Banks above, Arrington operates opposite
one of the league’s top “shadow” corners in
Aqib Talib, so it is only natural he is going to see his fair
share of targets. (Arrington has seen plenty of playing time since
Talib and Alfonzo Dennard have each dealt with injuries.) Arrington
often finds himself in the slot when everyone is healthy and has
graded out pretty well according to PFF in most games. However,
while he has yielded a respectable 38 catches on 65 targets, Arrington
has been charged with five touchdowns – including the game-winner
to Ted Ginn against Carolina in Week 11 on Monday Night Football.
Week 13: Keshawn Martin, Houston
Week 14: Davone Bess, Cleveland
Week 15: Rishard Matthews, Miami
Week 16: Marlon Brown, Baltimore
Suggestions, comments, about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and appeared in
USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in 2010 and
2011. He is also the host of USA Today’s hour-long, pre-kickoff
fantasy football internet chat every Sunday. Doug regularly appears
as a fantasy football analyst on Sirius XM’s “Fantasy
Drive” and for 106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C).
He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |