THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF FANTASY ANALYSTS DO NOT CONSIDER
DEFENSIVE MATCHUPS WHEN CREATING PROJECTIONS.
Sometime between the end of the preseason and the first week
of the season, fantasy managers and analysts alike shift gears
from not caring one iota about their players' matchups to making
it their primary consideration when setting about 70 percent of
their lineup. A tough three- or four-game stretch for a player
at the beginning or end of the season should not surprise anyone
that is paying attention to matchups, yet many are shocked to
learn some of their players open the season with three of their
first five or six games against likely top 10 pass defenses and/or
stud cornerbacks.
Defense may not matter as much as it used to, but it is a mistake
to not account for it at all. Doing so suggests a belief that
NFL games are like seven-on-seven drills. I realized as early
as 2004 that I did not like the idea of my players having to face
the Ravens or the Steelers, especially during the fantasy playoffs.
Certainly, my approach has evolved significantly from that initial
premise, but I think my track record of success speaks for itself
(finishing in the black in each of the 20-plus seasons I've played
fantasy football) and suggests there is substantial value in putting
a fair amount of weight into "the matchup." The key
is giving potential matchups the proper amount of weight to a
player's evaluation. By itself, a matchup will not transform an
every-week RB3 into an RB1 or turn a perennial WR1 into a bench
option, but it is helpful for fantasy managers trying to find
weekly and even season-long values and avoid potential busts.
That brings us to our focus for the next two weeks. With defenses
operating out of sub-packages (nickel, dime, quarter, etc.) almost
70 percent of the time in today's game, it makes sense to use
their likely sub-package personnel as the basis for our matchup
analysis. Furthermore, it helps to have an understanding of how
each veteran defensive player who will be playing in those packages
graded out and/or performed last year. With the help of sites
like Pro Football Focus and Pro Football Reference, we can do
that.
Defense is a team endeavor, so the process is never as easy as
spotting a player with a weakness and having an offense exploit
that matchup repeatedly. An important part of coaching in any
sport is the ability to maximize players' strengths and mask their
weaknesses; players either will get help from the scheme or be
benched if they continue to struggle. Nevertheless, the goal of
any good offense is to isolate the weak link in the passing defense
as often as possible or take advantage of what may be a "soft"
run defense (assuming that matches up with the run-blocking ability
of the offensive line). It is also important to understand that
no defender lines up across any offensive player on every play,
so we are playing odds here as opposed to dealing with virtual
certainties (i.e. shadow cornerbacks usually only "shadow"
about 50-60 percent of the time).
The color-coding in this two-part series is based on last year
only because we have no information about this season. Last year's
color codes help set the stage for this year. Film analysis and
advanced analytics help us predict what may happen.
Each team table below will contain more than 11 players. The
players in italics are likely rotational players or ones that
will be replaced on certain downs for any number of reasons. Most
of the players have projected grades next to their ages, but some
of them will not because I want the final team projected scores
(coverage, pass rush and run defense) to reflect the defenders
logging the most snaps. Much as I did for the offensive line at
the end of last week's column, next week's column will rank each
team in terms of projected coverage, pass rush and run defense
scores.
The purpose of this article is simple, even if the execution
of it is not: attempting to identify what defenders present fantasy
owners with an opportunity for success. There is a heavy amount
of subjectivity that goes into my color-coding matchups in advance
of the Big Board. It is my hope this process reduces most of that
and gives readers a look under the hood, so to speak.
Key:
Green box - Player graded 80 or higher in that
particular discipline per PFF (100-point scale) Blue box - Player graded between 70 or 79.9 in
that particular discipline Yellow box - Player graded between 60 or 69.9
in that particular discipline Red box - Player graded 59.9 or lower in that
particular discipline Black box - Player did not log a snap in the
NFL snap or the discipline does not apply to his position
Italic (player name) - Likely (but potentially
important) rotational player Red text - Player is returning from a major injury # - Rookie 23 Cov - Projected 2023 coverage grade 23 Run - Projected 2023 run defense grade Grades - Coverage (Cov) and run defense (Run
D)
Baltimore
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Tyus Bowser
ED
28
6
60.5
51.4
Michael Pierce
DI
30
7
76.5
74.3
Justin Madubuike
DI
25
6
54.5
64.5
Odafe Oweh
ED
24
41.8
53.9
Broderick
Washington Jr.
DI
26
6
69.8
63.1
David Ojabo
ED
23
60.0
63.7
Roquan Smith
LB
26
7
7
62.8
78.0
Patrick Queen
LB
23
7
6
65.5
64.6
Marlon Humphrey
CB
26
8
6
75.6
64.0
Rock Ya-Sin
CB
27
6
5
65.8
59.3
Brandon Stephens
CB
25
5
6
50.2
65.3
Marcus Williams
S
26
8
7
72.0
72.8
Kyle Hamilton
S
22
8
8
83.0
87.7
DC: Mike Macdonald (second year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Marlon Humphrey (will shadow on
occasion, even in the slot), S Marcus Williams, S Kyle Hamilton
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LCB Rock Ya-Sin, SCB Brandon Stephens
Summary: The Ravens have long possessed a stout
run defense, and there is little reason to believe that will change
in 2023. Venerable run-stuffer Pierce missed most of last season
and Baltimore did not miss a beat, finishing as one of three teams
to hold opponents below 4.0 yards per carry. Travis Jones may
end up being better than Pierce at some point but may not crack
the top three interior defensive linemen this season, so Baltimore
is set where it matters up front. Smith and Queen figure to benefit
from having those enormous men in front of them.
Ojabo is in his first full year back from an Achilles tear and
could push Oweh for a starting job if he regains the pre-injury
form he showed at Michigan. Like Ojabo, Oweh could be a future
pass-rushing stud. All of this matters because the Ravens have
built a very talented secondary (specifically Humphrey, Williams
and Hamilton) that will probably continue to look very good if
Ojabo and Oweh take the next step. The concerns here are Ya-Sin
and Stephens. Ya-Sin was reportedly considering retirement before
signing a one-year deal with Baltimore this spring. Stephens finished
last season strong, but he has not graded out particularly well
through two NFL seasons. With Humphrey in his prime and the safeties
playing at a high level, opponents figure to test Ya-Sin and Stephens
early and often in 2023.
Buffalo
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Von
Miller
ED
34
7
78.8
DaQuan Jones
DI
31
6
66.2
Ed Oliver
DI
25
6
65.0
Gregory Rousseau
ED
23
6
64.6
Poona Ford
DI
27
52.9
Leonard Floyd
ED
30
58.3
Matt Milano
LB
28
7
6
83.2
59.3
Terrel Bernard
LB
24
5
7
53.2
75.5
Tre'Davious
White
CB
28
7
5
56.7
67.1
Kaiir Elam
CB
22
7
5
66.0
51.7
Taron Johnson
CB
26
7
4
73.2
51.4
Micah Hyde
S
32
7
5
69.1
52.5
Jordan Poyer
S
32
7
7
62.7
70.0
DC: HC Sean McDermott (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Tre'Davious White (will shadow on occasion), LB Matt
Milano, S Micah Hyde, S Jordan Poyer
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LB Terrel Bernard
Summary: DC Leslie Frazier is taking a year off from coaching,
so McDermott is expected to return to a familiar role, as he ran
defenses in Philadelphia (2009-10) and Carolina (2011-16) for
several years before taking the Bills' head coaching job in 2017.
As has typically been the case since the emergence of Josh Allen,
run defense is taking a bit of a backseat - although the addition
of Ford should help that part of the defense. If we exclude the
return of Miller (ACL), the only notable addition up front is
Floyd, who was added as insurance for Miller and rotate with Miller
and Rousseau if all of them stay healthy.
Third-round draft choice LB Dorian Williams is expected to upgrade
the quality of coverage from the linebacker unit, which already
boasts a good coverage linebacker in Milano. Buffalo's secondary
took a step back in 2022, although it was to be expected with
White slow to recover from his ACL surgery and Elam absorbing
the bumps rookies are expected to take. What was not expected
was Hyde missing all but two games and Poyer failing to play a
handful himself. Age (32) is starting to become a concern for
both safeties. The return of Damar Hamlin from his scary cardiac
issue and the addition of Taylor Rapp gives Buffalo great depth
at the position, however. It could also allow the Bills to use
more "big nickel."
Cincinnati
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Trey Hendrickson
ED
28
6
58.8
D.J. Reader
DI
28
8
70.8
B.J. Hill
DI
28
6
65.2
Sam Hubbard
ED
27
7
74.0
Myles Murphy#
ED
21
Germaine Pratt
LB
27
7
6
87.2
64.3
Logan Wilson
LB
26
7
6
74.0
70.6
Chidobe
Awuzie
CB
28
8
5
73.1
48.7
Cam Taylor-Britt
CB
23
7
5
69.2
46.7
Mike Hilton
CB
29
6
7
64.3
76.2
DJ Turner#
CB
22
Daxton Hill
S
22
6
6
56.6
71.4
Nick Scott
S
28
5
6
43.4
77.0
DC: Lou Anarumo (fifth year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Chidobe Awuzie (will shadow on occasion), LCB Cam Taylor-Britt,
LBs Germaine Pratt and Logan Wilson
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: S Nick Scott, S Dax Hill
Summary: Reader may be the most important player on the Bengals'
defense. How important? Cincinnati gave up at least 155 rushing
totals three times in the six games he missed in 2022. (The Bengals
held seven of their other 13 opponents - including playoffs -
to 76 yards rushing or fewer.) Cincinnati lacks a proven pass-rush
threat opposite Hendrickson at the moment, but first-round pick
Murphy has a chance to change that. So does highly athletic third-year
pro Joseph Ossai.
By virtue of how well Awuzie has played for the Bengals when
he is healthy (played only eight games in 2022 before tearing
his ACL), every other player in the secondary is going to get
targeted more than they probably should. Taylor-Britt performed
admirably during the playoffs and may already be better than Eli
Apple ever was in the orange and black. Hilton is one of the best
all-around slot corners in the league and has been for a while,
but he is the one weak link among the top three corners if this
group has such a thing. While Scott and Hill should prove to be
just fine at safety, the drop-off from Jessie Bates and Vonn Bell
is a significant one. Luckily for the Bengals, Anarumo is about
as good as it gets in scheming up defenses.
Cleveland
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Myles Garrett
ED
27
7
68.6
Dalvin Tomlinson
DI
29
7
65.0
Jordan Elliott
DI
25
4
33.0
Za'Darius Smith
ED
30
7
72.5
Ogbonnia Okoronkwo
ED
28
61.5
Anthony Walker
LB
27
8
6
90.0
56.2
Jeremiah
Owusu-Koramoah
LB
23
7
7
73.4
58.8
Sione Takitaki
LB
28
7
64.3
65.0
Denzel Ward
CB
26
8
5
60.4
46.6
Greg Newsome II
CB
23
7
5
72.3
55.1
Martin Emerson
CB
22
7
5
75.1
51.3
Grant Delpit
S
24
7
6
62.5
69.3
Juan Thornhill
S
27
7
8
75.2
65.4
DC: Jim Schwartz (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: LCB Denzel Ward (will shadow on occasion),
S Juan Thornhill, LBs Anthony Walker and Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LB Sione Takitaki
Summary: This may be Schwartz's first season calling the shots
for Cleveland's defense, but 2023 marks his 15th season as a NFL
defensive boss. Schwartz is known for favoring a "wide nine"
front and should have the personnel to run it effectively with
Garrett, Smith and Okoronkwo expected to handle most of the reps
at defensive end. Tomlinson is a huge addition to a run defense
that lacked an interior force and/or could command a double team
last season. The ex-Viking should rectify that. The Browns could
not keep their linebackers clean or healthy last year, as Walker,
Takitaki and Owusu-Koramoah combined to play 26 games. Walker
and Owusu-Koramoah, in particular, should be among the better
cover 'backers in the game.
The Browns are on the verge of having a very good secondary.
Ward is probably a top-15 corner in the league at worst, and the
only reason he is not a top-10 lock is that he has struggled to
stay healthy. Newsome is a very solid corner with room to grow
entering his third professional season, while Emerson showed enough
as a third-round rookie last year for Cleveland to trust him opposite
Ward and use Newsome inside. Delpit showed well in his first full
season in 2022, while Thornhill should represent a considerable
upgrade - in his second year removed from ACL surgery - over John
Johnson III.
Denver
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Randy Gregory
ED
30
6
64.5
Zach Allen
DI
25
7
67.4
D.J. Jones
DI
28
5
57.4
Frank Clark
ED
30
6
59.2
Mike Purcell
DI
32
69.9
Alex Singleton
LB
29
6
8
73.0
82.6
Josey Jewell
LB
28
6
6
62.2
79.6
Drew Sanders#
LB
21
Patrick Surtain
II
CB
23
8
8
86.7
76.9
Damarri Mathis
CB
24
7
6
65.3
61.9
K'Waun Williams
CB
31
6
7
66.5
69.9
Kareem Jackson
S
35
6
6
60.9
71.3
Justin Simmons
S
29
8
7
74.3
61.1
DC: Vance Joseph (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Patrick Surtain II (will shadow on occasion), S Justin
Simmons, LB Alex Singleton
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LCB Damarri Mathis, SCB K'Waun Williams, LB Josey Jewell
Summary: With Joseph serving as his play-caller over that same
time in Arizona, the Broncos know what they are getting in Allen.
He may not be a game-changer yet, but he may be on the verge of
becoming one after playing alongside J.J. Watt over the last two
seasons. Along with Purcell and Jones, Denver should be able to
stop the run most weeks. After trading away the likes of Von Miller
and Bradley Chubb in recent seasons, the Broncos will turn to
30-year-olds in Clark and Gregory to serve as their top pass-rush
threats. A wild-card is third-round rookie Sanders, who showed
an incredible proclivity to hunt the quarterback as an inside
linebacker at Arkansas. That skill will be utilized heavily under
Joseph.
The Broncos should be the essence of what fantasy managers are
looking for in a fantasy defense in 2023. Joseph has blitzed well
over 30 percent of the time in each of his last five seasons and
it could be argued he never had a cornerback as good as Surtain.
Mathis still has plenty of time to develop as he enters his second
pro season, but he and Williams will be targeted almost regardless
of how well they play in 2023 because Surtain has emerged as arguably
the league's premier cover corner. Joseph's blitz-happy attack
should also benefit Simmons, whose play has leveled off in recent
years as the defense around him has lost some of its top players
and the overall aggressiveness of the defense fell off.
Houston
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Will Anderson#
ED
21
5
Maliek Collins
DI
28
6
54.1
Sheldon Rankins
DI
29
6
67.5
Jonathan Greenard
ED
26
6
76.6
Jerry Hughes
ED
34
59.7
Christian Harris
LB
22
5
5
29.6
29.1
Denzel Perryman
LB
30
6
7
61.4
80.5
Cory Littleton
LB
29
6
6
67.8
70.0
Derek Stingley Jr.
CB
22
7
5
49.9
43.4
Steven Nelson
CB
30
7
6
72.0
39.2
Desmond King II
CB
28
6
7
71.8
69.8
Jalen Pitre
S
24
7
5
65.8
38.5
Jimmie Ward
S
31
7
8
76.9
91.4
DC: Matt Burke (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: S Jalen Pitre, S Jimmie Ward
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: SCB Desmond King II
Summary: While the Texans did yeoman's work adding talent to
their roster this spring, perhaps no new face will mean more to
Houston's season than new HC DeMeco Ryans. The first-time head
coach has seemingly maximized the talent of every unit he has
coached since joining the 49ers as a defensive quality control
coach in 2017 following a long NFL playing career. Although not
exactly known as a premier run-stopper, Rankins is a huge upgrade
inside. He joins Collins at defensive tackle and should give Houston
some credibility in the interior of its defense. Perryman and
Harris stand to benefit the most from that tag team up front.
Do not be surprised if Ryans' presence leads to Harris taking
a huge step forward following an injury-plagued rookie campaign
as well.
Only time will tell if Houston made a good call in buying into
Stingley's freshman tape at LSU, but he is another player that
seems poised to excel under Ryans. Avoiding injuries would be
a good start to that end. If he can stay on the field, he will
be a matchup to avoid soon enough. The bold move to move up and
draft Anderson may be as important to Stingley's development as
anything, as it will be critical for Anderson to emerge as the
Texans' version of Nick Bosa in this San Francisco-inspired defense.
King had a good year under former HC Lovie Smith, but his recent
track record suggests he will be an easy target for quarterbacks.
Fortunately, Ward can replace him in the slot if necessary. If
King can put together another solid season, then Ward and Pitre
should be able to erase - or at least limit - the mistakes of
the aforementioned cornerbacks. The Texans also added Shaquill
Griffin, giving them yet another veteran corner capable of starting.
Indianapolis
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Kwity Paye
ED
24
6
76.6
DeForest Buckner
DI
29
7
71.4
Grover Stewart
DI
29
7
68.9
Samson Ebukam
ED
28
6
57.4
Shaquille Leonard
LB
27
6
7
35.9
59.9
Zaire Franklin
LB
26
6
6
50.2
65.0
E.J. Speed
LB
28
5
6
62.7
82.8
Isaiah Rodgers
CB
25
7
6
81.5
75.5
Julius Brents#
CB
23
5
5
Kenny Moore II
CB
27
5
7
46.3
80.5
Darius Rush#
CB
23
Julian Blackmon
S
24
6
7
57.4
77.0
Rodney Thomas II
S
25
6
6
54.8
55.4
DC: Gus Bradley (second year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Isaiah Rodgers (assuming he plays at all this season),
LB Shaquille Leonard
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LCB Julius Brents, S Julian Blackmon, S Rodney Thomas II
Summary: Buckner and Leonard are about the only proven playmakers
that remain from a defense that one year ago appeared to be much
closer to one of the league's best than where it is today. Just
getting Leonard (back) completely healthy again would be a nice
development after he was limited to three games one season ago.
Stewart and Paye are plus-run defenders as well for a team that
finished in a tie for fourth in run defense (4.1 YPC).
The Colts likely felt as if they needed to trade the 32-year-old
Stephon Gilmore while he could fetch a draft pick (2023 fifth-rounder),
but the deal that sent him to Dallas leaves Indy with virtually
nothing on the back end. The one player that did show something
in 2022 was Rodgers, who is likely now facing an indefinite ban
from the NFL for "pervasive" betting on the NFL. Moore
has long been a solid slot corner for the Colts, but one must
wonder if he is a fit in Bradley's defense after enduring easily
his worst season as a pro last year. Brents should be a fine corner
one day, but he is nowhere close to being ready to be a NFL team's
top corner. As such, Indy's defense should be expected to struggle
mightily against the pass in 2023.
Jacksonville
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Josh Allen
ED
25
7
83.0
Roy Robertson-Harris
DI
29
6
63.5
Davon Hamilton
DI
26
6
67.5
Travon Walker
ED
22
6
59.6
Folorunso Fatukasi
DI
28
39.0
Foyesade Oluokun
LB
27
6
6
66.3
69.8
Devin Lloyd
LB
24
5
7
32.4
69.0
Tyson Campbell
CB
23
7
7
80.7
71.7
Darious Williams
CB
30
6
6
64.6
56.1
Tre Herndon
CB
27
5
5
57.2
40.2
Rayshawn Jenkins
S
29
5
6
45.8
62.4
Andre Cisco
S
23
7
6
69.4
61.4
DC: Mike Caldwell (second year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: RCB Tyson Campbell, S Andre Cisco, LB Foyesade Oluokun
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: SCB Tre Herndon, S Rayshawn Jenkins, LB Devin Lloyd
Summary: One look at the individual run defense grades for Jacksonville
is a reminder that Pro Football Focus' player grades do not always
reflect reality. The Jaguars finished last season in a tie for
seventh in run defense (4.2 YPC allowed) despite having only one
front-seven player (Allen) truly standing out as a run defender.
Jacksonville's front four remains mostly intact and is anchored
by 335-pound Hamilton. Fatukasi is coming off a down year in his
first season with the Jaguars, but he built a strong reputation
as a quality run defender in his previous three years with the
Jets. Assuming Hamilton and Fatukasi meet expectations, they should
allow Oluokun and Lloyd to flow quickly and keep Jacksonville
among the top half of run defenses in the league.
As long as Walker, last year's No. 1 pick, takes the next step
in his development, he and Allen should make the secondary look
good more often than not. Not that Campbell needs much help; he
has quickly emerged as the team's top corner and essentially made
Shaquill Griffin expendable. Williams may not reach the heights
he once enjoyed with the Rams and will probably always struggle
against bigger receivers at 5-9 and 187 pounds, but he should
not have to look over his shoulder anytime soon either. The Jaguars'
biggest liability in the secondary right now figures to be projected
slot corner Herndon. It is likely a problem the team cannot fix
this season or cover up with safety play. Neither Jenkins nor
Cisco has established themselves as ball hawks yet.
Kansas City
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
George Karlaftis
ED
22
6
41.2
Chris Jones
DI
28
7
80.7
Derrick Nnadi
DI
27
5
37.0
Charles Omenihu
ED
25
5
51.5
Felix
Anudike-Uzomah#
ED
21
Willie Gay Jr.
LB
25
7
6
74.1
54.5
Nick Bolton
LB
23
7
8
73.8
81.4
Trent McDuffie
CB
22
8
6
75.1
61.7
L'Jarius Sneed
CB
26
7
7
75.7
70.9
Jaylen Watson
CB
24
6
5
59.9
58.6
Justin Reid
S
26
7
6
70.7
64.3
Bryan Cook
S
23
6
7
57.6
69.7
DC: Steve Spagnuolo (fifth year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: LCB L'Jarius Sneed, RCB/SCB Trent McDuffie, S Justin Reid,
LBs Willie Gay and Nick Bolton
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: RCB Jaylen Watson, S Bryan Cook
Summary: It would be unfair to suggest that the Chiefs do not
care about stopping the run. It would be more accurate to say
they do not have to care about it. As the run defense grades above
suggest, Jones and Bolton are about the only two players from
this defense that consistently get it done on early downs. Perhaps
adding a massive human being like 332-pound sixth-round draft
pick DT Keondre Coburn changes things a bit for Kansas City, but
this defense remains one that can be run so long as the opponent's
defense can keep Patrick Mahomes & Co. out of the end zone
for any length of time.
Losing Frank Clark will hurt the pass rush, but the team should
be able to replace what he leaves behind - either because Karlaftis
took the next step in this development or first-round draft pick
Anudike-Uzomah ends up being a quick study. The biggest revelation
for the Chiefs during their Super Bowl push last year may have
been the play of their pass defense, specifically from their young
secondary. A trio of 2022 draft picks - first-rounder McDuffie,
second-rounder Cook and seventh-rounder Watson - took turns making
plays and are all expected to start in 2023. While the numbers
will likely not reinforce it at season's end, Kansas City should
have a solid pass defense - albeit one that will likely be fantasy-friendly
for backs, receivers and tight ends because they should see more
pass attempts than most defenses.
Las Vegas
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Maxx Crosby
ED
25
8
82.5
Bilal Nichols
DI
26
5
48.9
Jerry Tillery
DI
26
44.2
Tyree Wilson#
ED
23
5
Chandler Jones
ED
33
6
65.5
Divine Deablo
LB
24
5
7
50.7
71.1
Robert Spillane
LB
27
4
6
39.5
77.3
Nate Hobbs
CB
24
6
7
57.1
75.1
Duke Shelley
CB
26
5
5
86.4
53.4
David Long Jr.
CB
25
6
5
54.2
46.2
Trevon Moehrig
S
24
6
6
49.0
64.6
Marcus Epps
S
27
5
7
47.5
81.0
DC: Patrick Graham (second year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: N/A
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: All of them except for maybe likely SCB Nate Hobbs and S
Trevon Moehrig
Summary: The Raiders are one stout defensive tackle away from
having an upper-tier defensive line. Tillery and Nichols are fine
rotational pieces, but they are not the kind of massive space-eaters
defenses usually need to attract double teams. Jones has been
too good for far too long to believe he lost it in 2022. With
that said, he turned 33 this winter and may need to be considered
more of a sub-package player at this point. Las Vegas may have
that luxury after selecting Wilson at No. 7 overall this spring,
as it should only be a matter of time before he and Crosby are
terrorizing defenses against the run and the pass. It may be too
much to ask for that to happen this year, however. In case it
was not already obvious, Crosby is a stud.
Neither of the Raiders' projected primary linebackers in their
nickel package graded out well in 2022, but Deablo is a highly
athletic former college safety who should be a solid coverage
player before long. Las Vegas needs him to be that because Hobbs
is the only defensive back expected to see a lot of playing time
that has enjoyed any recent prolonged success in coverage. He
played exceptionally well as a rookie out of the slot in 2021
but struggled a bit more in 2022. Shelley enjoyed his finest year
as a pro playing half of last season with the Vikings but has
never logged more than 470 snaps in four NFL seasons. Long's last
good season came with the Rams in 2019. Shelley and Long are projected
to be the Raiders' primary perimeter corners, so it would be in
Graham's best interest to find out if Hobbs can hold things down
in the slot in hopes that the team only has to protect Shelley
and Long.
LA Chargers
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Joey Bosa
ED
27
7
74.2
Morgan Fox
DI
28
5
50.9
Sebastian
Joseph-Day
DI
28
5
48.2
Khalil Mack
ED
32
6
61.7
Kenneth Murray
LB
24
6
5
68.9
28.2
Eric Kendricks
LB
31
6
6
45.0
79.5
Tuli Tuipulotu#
ED
20
J.C.
Jackson
CB
27
7
6
28.1
53.4
Asante Samuel Jr.
CB
23
7
5
76.1
49.2
Michael Davis
CB
28
7
6
74.7
61.8
Ja'Sir Taylor
CB
24
6
5
61.5
52.7
Alohi Gilman
S
25
6
6
57.2
60.1
Derwin James
S
26
8
8
74.5
75.3
DC: Derrick Ansley (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: CB Asante Samuel Jr., (plays both left and right side almost
equally), S Derwin James
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: SCB Ja'Sir Taylor, S Alohi Gilman and LB Eric Kendricks
Summary: The hope is that Ansley reaches this talented defense
in a way previous DC Renaldo Hill could not. While HC Brandon
Staley's philosophy lends itself to a defense giving up a bit
more in the run game, it is hard to understand how a defense with
Mack, Bosa, Murray and James is capable of allowing a league-worst
5.4 YPC. That kind of incompetence undermines the talent the Chargers
possess in their secondary. Los Angeles added Kendricks to bolster
a solid linebacking corps, but it will be up Joseph-Day to be
the interior force he was with Staley during their time together
with the Rams if this unit has any hope of becoming even an average
run-stopping defense.
Losing Jackson (ruptured patellar tendon) so early in the season
contributed to the disappointing overall performance of this defense,
although he played poorly in the short time he was healthy. While
there is no guarantee he returns to his previous form in 2023,
he appears on track to play in the opener. In the unlikely event
he can be fully healthy by October, the Chargers may finally have
the ability to pair him with rising star Samuel. The team undoubtedly
suffered a blow when Nasir Adderley announced his retirement this
spring, but James' presence is exponentially more important. James
is a force against the run and pass and probably only needs the
front seven to play up to its talent level to be recognized more
consistently for being the impact player he is.
Miami
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Bradley Chubb
ED
27
6
69.3
Christian Wilkins
DI
27
8
78.9
Zach Sieler
DI
27
7
77.9
Jaelan Phillips
ED
24
6
74.8
Raekwon Davis
DI
25
37.3
Jerome Baker
LB
26
7
5
67.8
69.6
David Long
LB
26
6
7
62.9
89.0
Xavien Howard
CB
29
7
7
56.0
84.2
Jalen Ramsey
CB
28
8
8
77.8
91.8
Kader Kohou
CB
24
7
5
68.6
65.1
Brandon Jones
S
25
5
6
52.4
73.3
Jevon Holland
S
23
8
6
65.7
67.6
DC: Vic Fangio (first year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: LCB Xavien Howard, RCB Jalen Ramsey, S Jevon Holland, LB
Jerome Baker
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: S Brandon Jones
Summary: As a coach who has been in the NFL in some fashion for
all but one year since 1986 - most of which he has served as a
defensive coordinator - Fangio has seen about everything a coach
can see. Fangio's defenses do not blitz so much as they force
offenses to be patient drive after drive. He may have just the
kind of personnel he needs with this edition of the Dolphins,
however. Most of his front seven graded out exceptionally well
against the run in 2022. Fangio's defenses tend to give a little
more ground to rushing attacks, but that may not be much of an
issue for Miami this year given how explosive the offense should
be. Positive game scripts play right into the hands of Fangio's
philosophy and this team in particular because the Dolphins' secondary
should be among the best in the league. Chubb and Phillips should
just now reaching their prime, further complicating matters for
opposing quarterbacks.
Assuming both players stay healthy in 2023, Howard and Ramsey
should rank among the league's best cornerback duos - if not the
best. If both players are at their best, slot corner Kohou could
be among the most targeted cornerbacks in the league. Jones and
Holland round out what could (and probably should) be one of the
stingiest secondaries in the NFL. When offenses are not targeting
Kohou, they will likely be trying their luck against LBs Baker
and/or Long. Both players are more than capable in coverage, but
it should come as little surprise if Miami ends up being a favorable
fantasy matchup for running backs and tight ends. A check-down
to a running back or chain-moving tight end will be a much more
appealing option than testing Howard or Ramsey for most teams.
New England
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Matthew Judon
ED
30
6
67.0
Davon Godchaux
DI
28
6
52.9
Christian Barmore
DI
23
5
46.9
Deatrich Wise Jr.
ED
28
6
59.7
Keion White#
ED
24
Ja'Whaun Bentley
LB
26
6
7
72.6
83.8
Jahlani Tavai
LB
26
6
7
73.3
69.2
Marte Mapu#
LB
23
Christian Gonzalez#
CB
20
Jonathan Jones
CB
29
7
7
67.9
70.0
Marcus Jones
CB
24
7
6
66.8
65.6
Adrian Phillips
S
31
7
7
71.6
70.6
Kyle Dugger
S
27
8
7
78.3
76.7
DC: Steve Belichick and Jerod Mayo (fourth year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: S Kyle Dugger, LBs Ja'Whaun Bentley and Jahlani Tavai
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: N/A
Summary: Judon is about the only player most casual fans will
be somewhat familiar with from the Patriots' front seven, but
the group tends to hold up well against the run as most Bill Belichick
defenses do - despite what the grades above suggest. It should
also only be a matter of time before Barmore takes the next step
in his development and begins to command double teams. While it
is obviously far too early to compare the two players, second-round
draft pick White could end up being one of the better five-technique
fits to play for Belichick since Richard Seymour. Only time will
tell if he comes anywhere close to that level of play.
Bentley has essentially taken over the mantle of on-field leadership
that once belonged to Dont'a Hightower and is equally adept at
stopping the run and the pass. The wild-card this year is third-round
rookie Mapu, who was a 216-pound safety at Sacramento State but
could end up seeing the same kind of linebacker/safety usage as
Dugger. First-round pick CB Gonzalez was arguably the draft's
top cornerback prospect and should emerge as the team's top cover
man no later than the end of this season. It should come as no
surprise if his rookie season rivals that of Trevon Diggs or Sauce
Gardner. Jonathan and Marcus Jones held up exceptionally well
given the relatively dire situation they were thrown into last
season. Assuming Gonzalez quickly lives up to his reputation,
New England should be one of the tougher teams to throw against
at some point in 2023.
N.Y. Jets
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Carl Lawson
ED
27
5
48.8
Quinnen Williams
DI
25
8
77.7
Quinton Jefferson
DI
25
4
39.0
John Franklin
ED
26
7
76.8
Will McDonald
IV#
ED
24
C.J. Mosley
LB
31
7
7
65.9
73.8
Quincy Williams
LB
26
5
5
50.0
60.8
Sauce Gardner
CB
22
9
7
90.0
69.2
D.J. Reed Jr.
CB
26
8
7
77.5
47.2
Michael Carter II
CB
24
7
7
72.2
78.4
Jordan Whitehead
S
26
7
6
70.6
59.4
Adrian Amos
S
30
6
7
45.6
69.7
DC: Jeff Ulbrich (third year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: LCB Sauce Gardner, RCB D.J. Reed
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: S Adrian Amos, LB Quincy Williams
Summary: The most important player in the front seven for New
York is Quinnen Williams, who broke out in a big way in his fourth
season in 2022. His presence is as critical to the front four
as anyone's because he allows the Jets to collapse the pocket
consistently despite blitzing a league-low 14.9 percent of the
time. Perhaps even more impressively with that low blitz rate,
no team knocked down the quarterback more often than New York
did last year (13.7 percent). Franklin-Myers does not get near
the recognition he deserves, but he has also transformed himself
into a vital cog of the run and pass defense. First-round draft
choice DE McDonald may not be an immediate impact player, but
his freakish ability to bend around the edge (not unlike Dwight
Freeney) is going to cause offensive tackles fits. If there is
another player up front that rivals Williams' importance, it is
probably Mosley. Despite turning 31 in June, he appears to be
recapturing the form that made him such an attractive free agent
for the Jets in 2019.
Perhaps no other cornerback duo was as stingy as Gardner and
Reed one season ago. With the pass rush that has only enhanced
the level of talent it has, the Jets should easily be one of the
five stingiest pass defenses again in 2023. Carter should remain
locked into slot duties. Although he might be the player opponents
pick on the most, it does not mean he is an easy target. Whitehead
was a good addition last offseason and should be free to do even
more next season after adding Amos. The latter spot was supposed
to be filled by Chuck Clark, but he tore his ACL during a June
practice and is out for the year. Amos is not quite as good in
coverage as a healthy Clark, but he has been a plus-defender in
the run game for most of his eight-year pro career.
Pittsburgh
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
T.J. Watt
ED
28
8
77.1
Cameron Heyward
DI
34
8
78.2
Larry Ogunjobi
DI
29
7
62.8
Alex Highsmith
ED
25
7
73.3
Keeanu Benton#
DI
21
Elandon Roberts
LB
29
5
5
46.2
61.4
Cole Holcomb
LB
26
7
7
67.0
69.4
Patrick Peterson
CB
32
6
5
79.7
63.9
Joey Porter Jr.#
CB
22
5
5
Levi Wallace
CB
28
6
6
59.3
76.3
Damontae Kazee
S
30
7
7
78.6
79.6
Minkah Fitzpatrick
S
26
8
8
83.3
82.2
Keanu Neal
S
27
63.1
52.5
DC: Teryl Austin (second year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: S Minkah Fitzpatrick, S Damontae Kazee, LB Cole Holcomb
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LCB Patrick Peterson, RCB Joey Porter Jr., LB Elandon Roberts
Summary: The addition of second-round draft choice Benton should
be just what the doctor ordered in terms of getting the Steelers
back to their usual run-stuffing ways, mostly because it means
the team will not have to rely so heavily on Montravius Adams
and Breiden Fehoko in the middle. Heyward remains a standout,
while Pittsburgh liked what it saw from Ogunjobi so much in 2022
that it handed him a three-year contract worth $28.75 million
this offseason. Watt and Highsmith also graded out exceptionally
well versus the run last season, likely leaving it up to free-agent
signing Holcomb to repeat what he did a year ago for the Commanders.
He should at least be an upgrade over Robert Spillane in coverage.
There is also a chance that Neal plays a relatively big role in
the front seven on likely running downs.
The pass rush that Watt and Highsmith provide will be critical
to this year's defense because of the unusual situation the Steelers
have at cornerback. Peterson has put together an impressive NFL
resume over the years, but he will turn 33 in July. Porter is
an imposing (6-3) likely future stud with great bloodlines, but
it is hard to expect any rookie to become his team's top corner
in his first year. Fortunately for the Steelers, Fitzpatrick can
erase mistakes on the back end. Pittsburgh does possess decent
cornerback depth, however, in veterans James Pierre and Wallace.
Tennessee
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Denico Autry
ED
32
6
74.3
Jeffery Simmons
DI
25
7
73.0
Teair Tart
DI
26
6
67.0
Harold Landry III
ED
27
6
Arden Key
ED
27
75.1
Monty Rice
LB
24
5
7
53.6
73.8
Azeez Al-Shaair
LB
25
7
7
61.0
82.1
Roger McCreary
CB
23
7
7
60.4
73.2
Sean Bunting
CB
26
7
6
74.5
64.7
Caleb Farley
CB
24
34.7
84.7
Kristian Fulton
CB
24
6
6
58.5
88.6
Kevin Byard
S
29
8
8
81.0
78.0
Amani Hooker
S
25
7
5
71.5
43.8
DC: Shane Bowen (third year)
Prominent second- and third-level players to avoid in
the passing game: LCB/SCB Roger McCreary, S Kevin Byard, S Amani Hooker
Prominent second- and third-level players to target in
the passing game: LCB Kristian Fulton, LB Monty Rice
Summary: Everything begins and ends up front with Simmons, who
may be one of the top five defensive players in the league. Although
he is a slightly better pass-rusher than a run defender, he regularly
commands double teams. Autry enjoyed the finest season of his
nine-year career in 2022, grading better than or almost equal
to Simmons across the board. Tart's emergence inside may have
been the one thing that pushed this run defense over the top last
season as it finished in a tie for first with the 49ers (3.4 YPC).
Al-Shaair may not be able to top David Long's 89.0 run defense
grade in 2022, but the falloff should be minimal and he could
end up being a small upgrade in coverage.
While Tennessee's front seven figures to be about as stout as
it was last season, it has questions in the secondary. Both Fulton
and McCreary are former second-rounders with a ton of ability.
McCreary appears to be well on his way to being a very good corner,
but Fulton has struggled to stay on the field. While the Titans
were wise to land versatile Murphy-Bunting in free agency, McCreary
may not be able to play the slot as much as Tennessee wants if
Fulton and 2021 first-round pick Farley keep struggling with injuries.
Farley has logged a mere 12 games in two seasons. If healthy,
he has No. 1 cornerback ability. The Titans are in great shape
at safety with Hooker and Byard, although the former has struggled
to stay on the field himself over the last two seasons.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and has appeared as a guest analyst on several national sports radio shows and podcasts, including Sirius XM's Fantasy Drive, FantasyPros and RealTime Fantasy Sports. He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.