9/9/02
Change, the only true constant in life, is what every fantasy owners
is trying to be in tune with regarding the NFL. Many of the changes
in the world of professional football are predictable, injury, free
agency, salary cap reductions, trades, retirement and the ever-emerging
rookies and players stepping up. Most of these changes provide a ripple
effect upon the league and the organization. At best they may be a
wave worthy of ten seconds of surf time. They are nothing compared
to the tsunami of an ownership change. Outside of changing owners,
the biggest waves created in the NFL are those made by coaching changes.
These are waves big enough to challenge the best fantasy surfer with
their impacts possibly being long lasting. This season there have
been six coaching changes in the league. Three of them are retread
coaches getting another chance at the helm, while the other three
represent either fresh blood to the league or their first chance at
being in charge of a professional team.
Outside of the owner, no single person stamps their personal philosophy
on a team like the head coach. It eclipses concerns over who can recover
from last year's knee injury or who is due for a break out year. A
coach can determine who will be having the chance to recover or breakout.
The coach is the man who sets the tone for a team on both the practice
and playing field like no owner or player can. It is their system,
their assistants, their coordinators and their philosophy on the line
every day. The coach of any team is the direct instrument of change.
(Unless you work for Al Davis, more later.) This year of coaching
changes has been the most controversial and high profile. The waves
emitted by these changes will affect the league for years.
For the third time in three years, the Washington Redskins have a
new head coach. Daniel Snyder maintained his good record of changing
coaches like underwear when he rid himself of Marty Schottenheimer
hiring instead, Steve Spurrier. Although Marty may have had his entire
family on the payroll along with many of his friends, he did have
a respectable 8 and 8 record with the Redskins. Even more respectable
when one considers the Redskins started the regular season at 0 and
five.
During training camp veterans were complaining the drills were too
tough, the coach did not care, and they were on the verge of mutiny.
To his credit, Marty turned the team around. They team began to win.
They finished the season hungry, looking like a real NFL team having
the potential to make the 2002 play-offs. Not satisfied, Daniel Snyder
let him go. Still seen as a viable commodity by Alex Spanos, he was
hired by the San Diego Chargers.
Marty is charged with turning around a team with a single digit
winning record over the last two years. The man who loved running
back by committee in Kansas City, barely has a back up to LaDainian
Tomlinson. Seeming to always love a quarterback who does not make
mistakes, he is saddled with second year quarterback Drew Breeze
who will be a first year starter. At least he has one aspect of
the team to make him feel comfortable, an aging yet competent defense
led by one of the best line backers of all time. The Chargers will
be better this year with Marty in charge, but they will fall short
of the play-offs. Outside of Tomlinson, there is really nothing
to claim as a fantasy owner this year. The future could be brighter.
Steve Spurrier has an NCAA pedigree the envy of many. As a Heisman
Trophy winner at quarterback in 1966, he was drafted number one
by the San Francisco 49ers. He spent 10 years in the pros, but never
rose to the level of the hype preceding him. He ended his career
with the hapless Buccaneers in 1976 to begin coaching at the college
ranks. He spent a brief stint with the defunct Tampa Bay Bandits
in the USFL, before taking a downtrodden Duke team to the level
of respectability, before taking over the University of Florida
program. He stayed with the university for 12 seasons earning one
NCAA title in 1996. Despite a record of 127-27-1, the best of any
twelve-year coach, his team spent much of their time in the shadows
as the third best college team in Florida. With the departure of
Shottenheimer at Washington, Spurrier became a Redskin.
Spurrier brings with him the reputation of having an aerial attack
second to few. He inherits a team with a strong defense only made
stronger with the addition of Marvin Lewis from Baltimore. During
the preseason the Redskins set a new record for points scored, averaging
thirty per game. He has incurred the wrath of opposing coaches for
running up the score. Although he has no real star at the quarterback
position, the team has shown passing to be their strength. It will
only be complimented with the running of Stephen Davis who saw few
touches during the preseason onslaught. Receiver Rod Gardner has
made the sleeper list of virtually every fantasy publication. The
team seems poised for success in the regular season and should improve
over their 8 and 8 record from last season. The glaring problem
is at the QB position and Spurrier's philosophy regarding it. He
was never known to stick with one player. If starter Shane Matthews
falls short, he may be inclined to revert to one of his other U
of F grads. Quarterback by committee has never truly been successful
in the NFL and is a disaster for any fantasy owner. Unlike many
diverse offensive attacks, there is no value at the quarterback
position; the fantasy value lies in the defense and skill positions.
The play-offs are possible this year, but there is only one bowl
game in the NFL. This team may come close, but it is still out of
reach.
Aside from out and out changes in the organization, there are
two assistant coaches who have received their promotion to head
coach from within. For both coaches it is their first time being
in charge of a professional team. Both of them replace coaches who
had fair to great success with their teams, but were unable to put
the organization on top. One will be asked to turn his team around
after a five win season the other will be dedicated to a "Commitment
to Excellence."
Mike Tice came to the Vikings in 1992 as a tight end. He played
for two seasons at the position before moving on to the coaching
level in 94. In 1997 he was promoted to offensive line coach. With
the departure of Dennis Green at the end of the 2002 season he became
the head coach of the Minnesota Vikings. He has always been described
as unspectacular if not "blue collar' in his approach to the
game.
Last year, after a disastrous summer camp, the Vikings fell apart
during the regular season. Randy Moss and Chris Carter were seen
fighting with each other as well as fellow teammates. After coming
close to the big game a couple of times, Green was seen as not being
able to discipline his team. Owner Billy Joe fired him "Red"
McCombs at the end of the season.
On the surface, the changes seem to have been for the better. Players
are reported as being happy. Randy Moss has said he wants to be
a leader on the team. Daunte Culpepper has stated Randy will be
90% of the offense. It appears Michael Bennett has matured as a
person and a runner, while their non-existent defense has shown
some backbone. This team should have more focus than the past, but
there should be few changes on offense. Why mess with a good thing?
With a solid, if not spectacular defense, the Vikings should be
headed back to the play-offs. The addition Biekert, a veteran from
the Oakland Raiders, should assist in this process. (Like Marcus
Allen, another Davis casualty.) Their offensive triangle of Culpepper,
Moss and Bennett should be in the top five rounds of any draft.
Despite another death in the Viking family, the team appears to
have a great attitude, which should translate well into the regular
season. Given their performance last season, and subsequent easier
schedule outside of their division; the Vikings have a shot at the
play offs. The "Big Game" looms in the future if they
can adhere to the work ethic of their head coach.
Bill Callahan takes over a Raider team aging, yet still on the
brink of making it to the Super Bowl. Callahan was the offensive
coordinator/line coach under John "Chuckie" Gruden. He
may not have called the plays last season, but he has been a crucial
part of the Oakland offensive scheme. With Gruden taking the job
at Tampa Bay, Callahan has been hailed as a player's coach and the
change has been welcome. Although the Raiders were in double digits
in their first two games in penalties, most of them being of the
way stupid variety. Against the 49ers the Raiders looked to be more
focused, against the Cardinals they looked to be in control. Once
again they will challenge for the final showdown, once again they
have few fantasy players worth taking in the top four rounds of
any draft. The problem, they have too many weapons and their offensive
success is built around role players like Crockett, Rice and Wheatley
Outside of Rich Gannon, none of the Raider offensive players are
consistently good enough to be anything but a secondary player or
substitute. (As much as I love Tim Brown, he would not be my first
choice as a wide receiver.) Part of the Raider scheme is to spread
the touches of the ball between many players, this, unfortunately
for fantasy players, will not change. Another element unchanging
in the Raider organization is the megalomaniac personality of Al
Davis. Greg Biekert is gone, I have a strong feeling it is the reason
"Chuckie" wanted out. The more things change, the more
they stay the same.
One of the most high profile coaching changes of the season occurred
between Tampa Bay and Oakland Raiders. After several years of solid
success, Tony Dungy was asked to leave the Bucs. It seemed he could
not win the big game in the playoffs and get the team over the hump
to real respectability. To replace him the organization went after
John Gruden of the Raiders. The romance was one of the biggest soap
operas of the off-season.
Gruden comes to a Tampa Bay team in search of a savior. Even the
messiah "Chuckie" may not be able to lift this team to
the very top level. Their defense has always been amongst the league's
best; their offense let them down. Brad Johnson will be the starter.
He makes few mistakes, but seems to lack the leadership skills of
John's last quarterback project in Oakland. . Although Michael Pittman
is listed as the starter at running back, Mike Alstott will still
be the goal line guy making Pittman nothing better than a middle
round fantasy draft selection. Between McCardell and Keyshawn Johnson
they will have two solid receivers sharing the catches with neither
one being a constant scoring threat. It will be ball control offense
and just don't lose as the motto. The team may improve their record,
but will fall short of Super Bowl rings. Even with Keyshawn Johnson
and more freedom, none of their offensive fantasy players deserve
anything above a fourth round pick. This is not the case in the
new home of Tony Dungy.
Last season the Colts had an offense with the ability to score
from anywhere on the field. They better had because their defense
gave up points like a broken slot machine. Last year the Colt defense
was every fantasy player's dream. Even your average guy could have
a great day against a defense who could not get out of their own
way. Tony has been hired to change it.
Controversy surrounded the dismissal of Dungy in Tampa Bay. Many
people felt he had gotten the dirty end of the stick. Tony had brought
them out of the cellar giving them, a glimpse of the light, but
he could not take them to the "Promised Land." He has
the job of changing the attitude of every fantasy owner's whipping
boy, the Colt defense. He seems to have addressed the problem through
free agency and the college draft. Look for the Colts to be better,
but not great. At least defensive stats should not be on the bottom.
It would not take much of a defense to allow the Colt offense to
turn up the heat making the other team play catch up for a change,
allowing them to make more mistakes.
He has stated he will not overhaul the offense of the team. There
is really no need. Peyton Manning may have had his worst year for
interceptions, but it is understandable. When your team is constantly
down by two or more touchdowns you have to throw the ball more.
They should not be in the position this season. For the last four
years Peyton Manning has worked with Tom Moore Offensive Coordinator.
For the last four years the Colts have had one of the hottest offenses
in team history. To his credit, Tony Dungy has allowed Moore to
stay on showing both his faith and commitment to the offense as
is. After all, if it aint broken, why fix it?
The only broken thing on the Colts offense, outside of Manning's
nose, is their starting running back Edgerrin James. He went down
about mid-season last year with a knee injury. Pundits have cast
doubt regarding his return in full strength. They say he has not
worked out with the team during the off-season. They also say he
has seen little action during this preseason. It should be remembered;
James did not work out with the team last season either. Up until
the time of his injury it appeared he was on his way to his third
Pro Bowl. Few of the major starters play huge roles during the preseason.
It is a time to evaluate talent; James has already passed the test.
With James once again in the offense, the Colts should have very
productive fantasy players. Their defense may not be strong enough
to put them in the Super Bowl, but with Dungy at the helm, it could
come in the near future.
Of course coaching changes are not the only concerns facing fantasy
players on the eve of the first game of the season, but these are
player concerns whose impacts will be short lived in the history
of the game or organization. There are always replacements out there.
There is always going to be the rookie surprise on a team or the
veteran who finally has to hang them up. With the exception of Washington,
few teams change their coaches on a regular basis, especially if
the team has been successful under their regime. Coaching changes
are more permanent, with a larger impact than any player could ever
expect to have.
Sure Marshall Faulk has had tremendous success with the Rams.
Their system of wide-open offense, with a diverse back, lends itself
to his kind of play. Still, it was only a few years ago fantasy
owners were writing off Marshal as the latest in a long line of
busts at the position. Did Marshal get faster? Become a better receiver?
A more elusive runner? probably yes, but not far from his pre-injury
collegiate days. What happened was he went to a system where a player
of his diverse talent was not only appreciated, it was required.
The coach is the system. Follow the system to success. Good luck
to all this fantasy season.
|