Fantasy Football Today - fantasy football rankings, cheatsheets, and information
A Fantasy Football Community!




Create An Account  |  Advertise  |  Contact      







Staff Writer
Email Joe

Joe's Articles

Building A Dynasty
Tight Ends
7/8/09
QBs | RBs | WRs | TEs

The rankings below are meant to be used as a guide rather than a list to follow in exact fashion. Many factors an owner has in regards to their own roster can influence the value they should place among certain players. In a dynasty league, age becomes one such factor. You need to use logic between balancing your roster with aging veterans and younger players you can afford to take risks on.

In regards to the scoring format these rankings are based upon, 10 yards receiving equals one point. Each touchdown catch is worth 6 points. Every reception is worth half a point, so adjust accordingly dependant upon whether or not your league gives points for receptions. Their position rank in 2008 is based upon FFToday’s default scoring when looking at the players stats.

Also of note, the number in parenthesis following a players name and team is the age he will be at the start of the 2009 season (September 10th). If a “UR” appears in the ‘Position Rank ‘08’ column it means the player failed to place among the Top 35 last year. An “*” in any column simply means the player is a rookie and therefore has no input to be listed.

Tight End Rankings - Dynasty
Rk Player Seasons Position
Rank '08
Yrs in Top 12
(Since 2000)
Yrs in Top 24
(Since 2000)
Projected Top 12
Seasons
(Next 3 Yrs)
1 Jason Witten, DAL (27) 6 3 5 6 3
Witten’s been among the better tight ends to own since his second year in the league. His value has risen even further though with Romo under center. The loss of Owens should allow for just as many looks, if not more, to continue coming his way.
2 Antonio Gates, SD (29) 6 4 5 6 3
Like Witten, Gates continues to impress year after year. His numbers dropped a bit last season, but were impressive enough to squash any concerns stemming from an injured toe suffered during the 2007 playoffs. His touchdown production is among the best in league at tight end along with his yardage and receptions.
3 Chris Cooley, WAS (27) 5 8 4 5 3
Cooley’s touchdown production slipped last season, but he set career highs for himself in both yardage and receptions. Look for him to find the end zone more often in ’09 while he improves upon his fantasy rank from a year ago.
4 Greg Olsen CHI (24) 2 10 1 2 3
Olsen’s only entering his third season, but his progression suggests he’ll quickly be among the best tight ends in the league. With Jay Cutler’s arrival in Chicago, look for his numbers to continue rising in the years ahead.
5 Tony Gonzalez, ATL (33) 12 1 9 9 3
There’s nothing not to like about Gonzalez, accept for his age. At 33 he is nearing retirement, but he continues to rank among the best at his position year in and year out. He likely has another 2-3 seasons left in him with Atlanta.
6 Dallas Clark, IND (30) 6 2 3 5 2
Clark’s last two seasons are his best in the league. Prior to that he was a known talent, but injuries always derailed his outings. With the injury bug behind him, he’s now become a significant part of the Colts passing attack.
7 Owen Daniels, HOU (26) 3 6 2 3 2
Owens has quickly made himself known as one of the better pass catching tight ends in the league. His touchdown count could use some improvement, but nonetheless his production is hard to overlook.
8 Kellen Winslow, TB (26) 5 21 2 3 2
Based on talent alone, Winslow is one of the best receiving tight ends in the NFL. Injuries cost him a fair bit of playing time in ’08 however, and his change of address doesn’t help his value any. He’s produced with less than stellar QBs in Cleveland, but it’s doubtful he’ll match his career highs anytime soon in Tampa Bay.
9 John Carlson, SEA (25) 1 7 1 1 2
Injuries to the Seahawks receiving core last season forced Carlson to become a primary target for QB Matt Hasselbeck. He responded with 5 touchdowns and 627 yards on 55 receptions. The addition of Houshmandzadeh should help open things up more for him this year.
10 Zach Miller, OAK (23) 2 11 1 2 2
Oakland doesn’t have much of a passing game, but Zach Miller tends to be JaMarcus Russell’s favorite target. He’ll post good yardage and reception totals, but his touchdowns aren’t likely to climb very high.
11 Dustin Keller, NYJ (24) 1 14 0 1 2
Keller’s production as a rookie last season wasn’t much of a surprise. The only question surrounding his productivity this year is how he’ll perform with an inexperienced QB under center. With Coles no longer a Jet however, Kelly should get more looks this season.
12 Jeremy Shockey, NO (29) 7 26 6 6 1
Shockey’s style of play leaves him vulnerable to injuries, and he’s had his fair share throughout the years. His value is on the decline, but if he can stay healthy with the Saints in the years ahead he may have a few surprise outings left in him.
13 Heath Miller, PIT (26) 4 15 2 4 1
Miller’s been productive for the Steelers since being drafted. Playing on a run first offense though makes it hard for his numbers to rise any higher than he’s already posted. He’s become a familiar red zone target for Ben Roethlisberger, and that’s what makes Miller a worthwhile option in fantasy leagues. When he fails to reach the end zone frequently though, like last season, it really drops his value.
14 Bo Scaife, TEN (28) 4 16 0 2 1
Scaife has been talked about in fantasy circles for a few years now, but he never really had a breakout performance as expected. With Kerry Collins under center in Tennessee his value is on the rise a bit. The concern is what will happen once Collins is no longer taking snaps for the Titans.
15 Tony Scheffler, DEN (26) 3 12 2 3 1
Scheffler’s been a nice receiving option from the tight end position for the Broncos since they drafted him. His main issue has been dealing with injuries on a regular basis. The loss of Cutler however, along with the coaching change in Denver, may cause his numbers to drop a bit though even if he remains healthy throughout the year.
16 Brent Celek, PHI (24) 2 32 0 0 1
Celek’s made the most of his opportunities in Philadelphia whenever he’s been placed on the field. He now has the chance to start for the team following the departure of L.J. Smith this offseason. Expect him to post some pretty solid numbers, although he’ll have to fend of Cornelius Ingram in the years ahead.
17 Todd Heap, BAL (29) 8 22 4 6 0
Heap’s value took a steep dive last season and it would appear his most productive outings are now behind him. Injuries are always an issue with the veteran tight end as well. He’ll need to bounce back in a big way if he’s to ever reclaim the elite status he once held.
18 Visanthe Shiancoe, MIN (29) 6 5 1 1 1
Shiancoe had a career year for himself last season, but I wouldn’t get too carried away with raising his value in dynasty formats. He may have another productive outing in ’09, but it’s doubtful he’ll make for a long-term solution at the position in fantasy leagues.
19 Kevin Boss, NYG (25) 2 13 0 1 1
Boss is still young and working on establishing himself as a fixture at tight end for the Giants. With the loss of Burress and Toomer in recent years for the G-men, he may become a more frequent option for QB Eli Manning. He tends to snag a fair share of passes in the end zone as well.
20 Anthony Fasano, MIA (25) 3 9 1 1 0
Fasano was a productive fantasy option last season, but it was mainly due to his seven touchdown receptions. It’s hard to predict he’ll accomplish that feat again, and with David Martin still getting looks from the tight end position it’s doubtful Fasano’s receptions and yardage will be on the rise anytime soon.
21 Marcedes Lewis, JAC (25) 3 20 0 2 0
Lewis had a decent season last year, but in terms of fantasy value he didn’t accomplish much. If he doesn’t begin catching passes in the end zone he won’t be much of an option for owners.
22 Vernon Davis, SF (25) 3 27 0 2 0
Fantasy owner’s patience with Vernon Davis has got to be wearing thin at this point. He remains a tremendously talented athlete, but until he transfers his abilities into production on the field it won’t matter any. Maybe new head coach Mike Singletary can get into his head, but its nearing put up or shut up time for Davis in San Francisco.
23 Brad Cottam, KC (24) 1 UR 0 0 1
Many felt Cottam could be the best all around tight end to come out of last year’s draft. Few knew he would be getting the opportunity to start this soon however. With the trade of Tony Gonzalez to Atlanta this offseason, the second year product out of Tennessee will have to learn on the field quicker than expected. He’s worth keeping an eye on.
24 Chase Coffman, CIN (22) R * * * 1
The Bengals tight end position hasn’t produced for fantasy owners in recent years, but if it’s going to anytime soon it will be via Chase Coffman. He’ll need to acclimate himself to playing at the NFL level early on, but he should get the chance to start within the next 2-3 years.
25 Donald Lee, GB (29) 6 23 1 3 0
Donald Lee was a somewhat productive option for the Packers last season, but he didn’t come close to matching his 2007 output. His numbers may rise a bit this year, but sooner or later he’ll get pushed for playing time by Jermichael Finley.
26 Randy McMichael, STL (30) 7 UR 5 6 0
McMichael was a solid fantasy option during his days with the Dolphins, but his two seasons in St. Louis haven’t been impressive. His outing last year was cut short after four games due to injury. He’s a vet that may get you by if you need him, but he shouldn’t be a fixture on any fantasy rosters.
27 Jermichael Finley, GB (22) 1 UR 0 0 0
Finley is still stuck behind Donald Lee at the moment, but within the next few seasons he’ll likely get the chance to start in Green Bay. His skill set suggests he’d make for a great receiver at the tight end position in the NFL once he gets the opportunity.
28 Brandon Pettigrew, DET (24) R * * * 0
Pettigrew was the top tight end taken in this year’s draft, but it had as much to do with his blocking capabilities as it did with anything related to his skills as a receiver. I wouldn’t expect too much from him in fantasy leagues right away, though he could prove to be a solid target in the end zone.
29 Martin Rucker, CLE (24) 1 UR 0 0 0
With the offseason trade of Kellen Winslow, Rucker’s opportunity to start in Cleveland has come quicker than expected. He’s still stuck behind Steve Heiden on the depth chart, but if any Browns tight ends prove to be useful in fantasy leagues it will be Rucker.
30 Cornelius Ingram, PHI (24) R * * * 0
Injury caused Ingram’s value to drop in the draft this offseason, but the Eagles were happy to snag him in the fifth round. If he can make a full recovery from a torn ACL that cost him his senior year in college he may push Brent Celek for the starting job in years ahead.
31 David Martin, MIA (30) 8 19 0 1 0
Martin isn’t going to help any owners win a championship, but he still has a role in the Miami offense even with Anthony Fasano around. Use him if you must, but don’t expect much.
32 Martellus Bennett, DAL (22) 1 24 0 1 0
Bennett’s considered a very talented tight end to come out of last year’s draft. Playing behind Jason Witten leaves him with little chance to showcase himself though. He did haul in 20 receptions for 283 yards and 4 touchdowns as a rookie however.
33 Fred Davis, WAS (23) 1 UR 0 0 0
Davis is another talented player at the position from the 2008 draft. Like Bennett though, he is also stuck playing behind one of the better tight ends in the league. It remains to be scene when, or if he’ll ever get a chance to start in the NFL.
34 Richard Quinn, DEN (23) R * * * 0
Quinn didn’t produce much in college, but his pre-draft workouts encouraged the Broncos to select him in the second round this year. He’s known to be a good blocker, and if he proves he can catch the ball as well he may someday replace Scheffler as the starter in Denver.
35 Desmond Clark, CHI (32) 10 30 3 4 0
Clark’s nearing retirement and has fallen behind Greg Olsen on the Bears depth chart, but he still has a little bit of punch left in him. You may be able to get another year or two of back-up productivity out of him in fantasy leagues.

More: Quarterbacks