In the words of the great philosopher (and former heavyweight boxing
champ) Mike Tyson, "Everybody has a plan until they get punched
in the mouth."
In short, the "plan" going into a game changes anywhere
from a third to roughly a half of most football games change as
the game moves along. When a team falls more than one score behind,
they will inevitably throw the ball more than they expected. When
a team consistently plays with a lead, they will run the ball
more often. This should not come as mind-blowing information.
Nevertheless, there is plenty to be learned from studying play-caller
tendencies and, more specifically, how much they rely on certain
players to carry the offense. While the situation a team finds
itself in during the course of the game will generally affect
volume, coaches don't typically go away from their best players
whether they are down by 10 or ahead by 14. And even though play-callers
don't deliver the ball to the intended target on every play, they
do draw up the plays designed to get the ball to their playmakers.
That alone make studying their tendencies - especially over multiple
seasons when possible - a good idea.
This two-part series is my latest attempt to provide each of
you - as well as myself - a better grasp of the way players are
able to reach the statistical heights they do (or don't), focusing
primarily on the recent history of the men who will call the shots.
Given the injury rate of players and turnover rate of coaches,
be advised this will be far from a perfect exercise. With that
said, I think you will find some of the information below to be
fascinating and perhaps even helpful. Last week, I
covered the AFC. This week, we take a look at the NFC:
Most of the setup below should be fairly self-explanatory,
but I'll break it down anyway. The RB1/WR1/TE1 designations are
based on carry share (the percentage of a team's carries by a
player) and target share (the percentage of a team's targets by
a player). I limited the play-callers' histories to three seasons
in order to conserve space and keep the information somewhat relevant.
The bolded numbers right below the headings of "carry share"
and "target share" are the team totals in those respective
columns to give you some sense of the actual workload. Last but
not least, the coaches listed below the team name are the men
responsible for calling plays this year.
Instead of the methodical, run-it-up-the-gut football that Mike
McCoy drove fantasy owners crazy with for half of a season in
2018, the Cardinals can expect tempo and a lot of open field under
Kingsbury. A few numbers to consider: Arizona averaged 56.4 offensive
snaps last season (only Miami was worse), down from 66.2 in Bruce
Arians' final season. Kingsbury's offenses at Texas Tech led FBS
in snaps per game during his six years in Lubbock. (Last year
was 82.6, up from 79.3 in 2017.) No one is expecting Arizona to
fire off almost 1,300 offensive plays (just over 80 per game).
After all, New England is usually near the top of the league with
an average somewhere in the high 60s. But there's no question
Kingsbury's squad will move the ball, do so with much more urgency
and sustain drives much better than last year's Cardinals.
Only one player during Kingsbury's reign with the Red Raiders
exceeded 132 carries. Unsurprisingly, that players was also the
only Texas Tech running back over that time to make the pros:
DeAndre Washington. Contrary to popular belief, Kingsbury's Red
Raider offenses actually did run the ball a fair amount (410 or
more attempts in four of six seasons). Kingsbury is also no fool,
he
has a good idea what David Johnson brings to the table. Given
the kind of pace Arizona is expected to play with, Johnson might
cede a few more carries to Chase Edmonds than fantasy owners want
(and, in turn, he may have a lower carry share than expected).
But make no mistake about it: if the Cardinals can get to 400
rushing attempts this season, Johnson's floor should be 250 (62.5
percent). The slot was usually the featured receiver in the passing
game for Kingsbury, although that player took on different body
types over the years. Jace Amaro tallied 106 catches as a 6-5,
260-pound "F" tight end. Then we had two years of 5-7,
168-pound Jakeem Grant. Then, 6-1, 186-pound Jonathan Giles and
5-11, 180-pound Keke Coutee. Last but not least, 6-5, 185-pound
Antoine Wesley. None of those players lined up exclusively in
the slot, but most of them spent the bulk of their time there.
And while there was generally a clear No. 1 in his offenses, a
lot of his offenses got contributions from several players. In
five of his six years in charge, Kingsbury had at least seven
players finish with at least 20 catches.
Atlanta OC Dirk Koetter
Koetter (TB) 2018
Koetter (TB) 2014
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
389
619
372
624
RB1
Peyton Barber
60.2%
4.7%
RB1
Steven Jackson
51.1%
4.3%
RB2
Jacquizz Rodgers
8.5%
7.3%
RB2
Devonta Freeman
17.5%
5.9%
RB3
Ronald Jones
5.9%
1.5%
RB3
Jacquizz Rodgers
15.6%
6.4%
WR1
Mike Evans
0.0%
22.3%
WR1
Julio Jones
0.3%
26.1%
WR2
Adam Humphries
0.5%
17.0%
WR2
Roddy White
0.0%
20.0%
WR3
Chris Godwin
0.0%
15.3%
WR3
Harry Douglas
0.0%
11.9%
WR4
DeSean Jackson
1.5%
12.0%
TE1
Cameron Brate
0.0%
7.9%
TE1
Levine Toilolo
0.0%
8.7%
TE1
O.J. Howard
0.0%
7.8%
It is difficult to put much stock into Koetter's overall percentages
with Tampa Bay last season because there were periods in which
former OC Todd Monken was calling the shots and times he was.
Unfortunately, outside of Doug Martin's resurgent 2015 season,
Koetter's offenses have ranked no better than 24th in rushing
yards since he signed on to be the Falcons' offensive coordinator
the first time around in 2012. His departure to take the head-coaching
job with the Bucs in 2015 led to the arrival of Kyle Shanahan,
who obviously oversaw Freeman's breakout campaign in 2015. For
what it's worth, Koetter's offenses have tended to lean on one
back in the rare instance they've been productive (or at least
significantly more productive than their teammates). Barber, Martin
and Jackson are all examples of that. It would seem with only
Ito Smith in reserve, Freeman will have his opportunity to handle
at least 50 percent of the carries for the first time since 2016.
Koetter has been blessed with having a freak at wideout since
joining Atlanta in 2012 and hasn't been shy about making sure
he gets fed well. Evans' 22.3 percent target share last year is
the lowest for one of his lead receivers dating back to 2014.
Given how dominant Jones still is, it's hard to imagine his share
dipping much from 28.1 last year. White's 20 percent share in
2014 and Humphries' 17 percent share last season is proof a capable
second receiver like Calvin Ridley can push for 20 percent in
Koetter's offense. He may not quite there this fall, but he should
be close. Some of his targets figure to come at the expense of
Mohamed Sanu, who saw 15.6 percent of the looks from Matt Ryan
in 2018. That seems reasonable for a capable No. 3 receiver in
this offense, especially considering Koetter hasn't utilized his
running backs much in the passing game since Charles Sims in 2015.
As far as Austin Hooper is concerned, it's hard to tell how much
the tight ends were a priority for Koetter in Tampa Bay. Jameis
Winston relied on that position long before he became a pro. Whether
it was a Winston thing or not, the usage of Bucs' tight ends under
Koetter is encouraging. Last year was the first time in three
seasons tight ends didn't account for at least 20 percent of the
target share (17.8); given the injury to Howard and all the talent
Tampa Bay has at receiver, it's not hard to understand why.
Carolina OC Norv Turner
Turner (CAR) 2018
Turner (MIN) 2015
Turner (MIN) 2014
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
416
544
473
443
413
510
QB1
Cam Newton
24.3%
0.0%
RB1
Christian McCaffrey
52.6%
22.8%
RB1
Adrian Peterson
69.1%
8.1%
RB1
Matt Asiata
39.7%
12.4%
RB2
C.J. Anderson
5.8%
0.6%
RB2
Jerick McKinnon
11.0%
6.5%
RB2
Jerick McKinnon
27.4%
8.0%
WR1
D.J. Moore
3.1%
15.1%
WR1
Stefon Diggs
0.6%
19.0%
WR1
Greg Jennings
0.0%
18.0%
WR2
Devin Funchess
0.0%
14.5%
WR2
Mike Wallace
0.2%
16.3%
WR2
C. Patterson
2.4%
13.1%
WR3
Curtis Samuel
1.9%
11.9%
WR3
Jarius Wright
0.2%
11.3%
WR3
Jarius Wright
1.2%
12.2%
WR4
Jarius Wright
0.5%
10.8%
WR4
Charles Johnson
0.2%
11.6%
TE1
Ian Thomas
0.0%
9.0%
TE1
Kyle Rudolph
0.0%
16.5%
TE1
Kyle Rudolph
0.0%
6.7%
McCaffrey's early carry totals last season under Turner didn't exactly
inspire confidence: 10, 8, 28, 17, 8 and 7. Neither did the fact
he didn't score a rushing touchdown until Week 8 (which was also
the last time Newton scored on the ground). In the end, Turner lived
up to his reputation as an offensive play-caller comfortable riding
his top back. And ride McCaffrey he did. From Week 8 to Week 16,
McCaffrey handled 137 of the 152 carries that came from Panthers'
running backs (90.1 percent). At the very least, the Stanford product
proved beyond a shadow of a doubt he is capable of carrying the
load. Whether that remains the case this season is another story.
The additions of pounders Jordan Scarlett and Elijah Holyfield make
me wonder if Carolina won't back off a bit on McCaffrey on early
downs this year, at least early in the season.
It becomes quite clear right away last year's target share isn't
going to help us much, as Moore didn't play more than 33 snaps
in a game until Week 8 and Samuel didn't see more than 26 snaps
until Week 12. There was little question they were the team's
best receivers by the end of the season. If Greg Olsen can manage
to stay healthy this season (admittedly, a big if), then he's
probably not going to lose the target battle to Thomas either.
With Funchess' 79 targets now in Indianapolis, Moore (82 targets
in 2018) and Samuel (65) could both easily move over 100 targets,
and I don't think that's an overly ambitious goal. McCaffrey likely
won't exceed last year's 124 targets for obvious reasons, although
I don't think it's too much to ask for him and Moore to see 20
percent of the looks in this offense. Samuel shouldn't be too
far behind at around 15 or 16 percent. Turner's offenses have
typically kept tight ends busy, but I'm not sure owners should
expect much more than the 16.9 percent share they saw last season
given the weapons the Panthers have everywhere else.
Chicago OC Matt Nagy
Nagy (CHI) 2018
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Target
Share
468
503
QB1
Mitchell Trubisky
14.5%
0.0%
RB1
Jordan Howard
53.4%
5.2%
RB2
Tarik Cohen
21.2%
18.1%
WR1
Allen Robinson
0.2%
18.7%
WR2
Taylor Gabriel
1.9%
18.5%
WR3
Anthony Miller
1.3%
10.7%
TE1
Trey Burton
0.2%
15.1%
It's still a relatively small sample size, but when we combine Nagy's
five games as the Chiefs' play-caller in 2017 with last year's Bears,
it would appear he wants one back to take charge. Kareem Hunt handled
77.8 percent of the carry share at the end of the 2017 campaign,
while Howard was at 53.4 despite obviously not being Nagy's preferred
back. Even with the addition of Mike Davis, it's one of several
reasons I'm bullish on David Montgomery this year. In Nagy's perfect
world, I'm sure he would like last year's run-pass balance without
feeling the need to see Trubisky on the move 14 percent of the time.
Even if Trubisky's share drops to around 10 percent and Cohen settles
in around 15, it means Davis could handle 15-20 percent of the carries
and still leave Montgomery with about 50 percent.
Nagy is from
the Andy Reid coaching tree, and that background showed up in
the balance exhibited by the passing game last season. Robinson
battled hip and groin issues for most of the second half of the
season after spending the first half of it getting used to his
surgically repaired knee. It's positive for potential upside he
managed almost 19 percent of the targets despite missing three
games. He's a good bet for a low-20 percent share in 2019. Miller
was slowed by a shoulder injury for the better part of the season,
so his 10.7 percent share is certainly not indicative of what
could have been. Normal skill development and slightly better
injury luck - plus the fact he will be the team's primary slot
receiver again - should allow him to push for a 16-17 percent
share as a sophomore. Gabriel had a nice surge against two very
exploitable defenses early in the season, but his 18.5 percent
target share last season was more a product of Robinson and Miller's
injuries than a breakout. He is primarily a deep threat and should
be used that way. Although the addition of Cordarrelle Patterson
will interest some folks, he'll likely play in a hybrid role;
he's unlikely to see more than 7-8 percent of the carry or target
share. After a strong start to the season, it was nearly impossible
to get a handle on Burton. Assuming Miller is healthy this season,
I would expect Burton's looks to drop into the 12-13 percent area.
Dallas OC Kellen Moore
Linehan 2018
Linehan 2017
Linehan 2016
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
439
517
480
485
498
479
QB1
Dak Prescott
17.1%
0.2%
QB1
Dak Prescott
11.9%
0.0%
QB1
Dak Prescott
11.4%
0.0%
RB1
Ezekiel Elliott
50.4%
7.8%
RB1
Ezekiel Elliott
50.4%
7.8%
RB1
Ezekiel Elliott
64.7%
8.1%
RB2
Rod Smith
11.5%
4.7%
RB2
Rod Smith
11.5%
4.7%
RB2
Alfred Morris
13.9%
1.3%
WR1
Dez Bryant
0.2%
27.2%
WR1
Dez Bryant
0.2%
27.2%
WR1
Cole Beasley
0.2%
20.5%
WR2
Terrance Williams
0.4%
16.1%
WR2
Terrance Williams
0.4%
16.1%
WR2
Dez Bryant
0.0%
20.0%
WR3
Cole Beasley
0.0%
13.0%
WR3
Cole Beasley
0.0%
13.0%
WR3
Terrance Williams
0.0%
12.7%
TE1
Jason Witten
0.0%
17.9%
TE1
Jason Witten
0.0%
17.9%
TE1
Jason Witten
0.0%
19.8%
Using another man's play-calling tendencies to open for a first-time
offensive coordinator can be a recipe for disaster, so I'm only
going to post Scott Linehan's last three seasons as a reference
point for what Dallas has done in the Prescott-Elliott era. The
only reason Elliott hasn't finished well above a 60 percent carry
share in each of his first three seasons is because of his six-game
suspension in 2017. Little else really needs to be said. The addition
of Tony Pollard may give Dallas what it hoped Tavon Austin was
going to provide last year, but Zeke is about as much of a lock
to handle another heavy workload as there is in fantasy football
- barring injury or some poor decision-making off the field (again).
The most interesting thing in terms of the running game figures
to be whether or not Moore (a former quarterback himself) will
expose Prescott to the same kind of carry share again that typically
is reserved for a change-of-pace back.
If we merely take Cooper's 14.7 percent target share from his
nine games with Dallas and extrapolate it over a full season,
he would have amassed 26.1 percent of the looks in the passing
game. The Cowboys have upgraded their personnel from last season,
however, so maybe something in the 22-23 percent neighborhood
is more likely for Cooper in 2019. Gallup became much more of
a factor as the season came to a close, finishing with at least
six targets in six of his final seven contests. It's going to
be hard to get him too many more looks with trusty veterans like
Randall Cobb and Witten around, but he'll likely benefit the most
if Cobb struggles to stay healthy yet again. There's almost no
chance the former Packer reaches Beasley's 16.8 percent target
share, in part due to his lack of durability and in part because
he'll be sharing short-range targets with Witten. The 37-year-old
tight end also is a poor candidate to reach his former heights
of 17.9 and 19.8 percent target share; 12-14 percent seems like
it should be his ceiling now. Last but certainly not least, will
Dallas target Zeke 18.4 percent of the time again? If he drops
down into the 10-12 percent area, he'll need to find the end zone
with more regularity in order to be a solid overall No. 1 pick
in fantasy drafts.
Detroit OC Darrell Bevell
Bevell (SEA) 2017
Bevell (SEA) 2016
Bevell (SEA) 2015
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
409
526
401
548
500
472
QB1
Russell Wilson
23.2%
0.0%
QB1
Russell Wilson
18.0%
0.4%
QB1
Russell Wilson
20.6%
0.0%
RB1
Eddie Lacy
16.9%
1.1%
RB1
Christine Michael
29.2%
4.7%
RB1
Thomas Rawls
29.4%
2.3%
RB2
Mike Davis
16.6%
3.4%
RB2
Thomas Rawls
27.2%
3.1%
RB2
Marshawn Lynch
22.2%
4.4%
RB3
Thomas Rawls
14.2%
2.5%
RB4
Chris Carson
12.0%
1.5%
RB5
J.D. McKissic
11.2%
8.7%
WR1
Doug Baldwin
0.5%
22.1%
WR1
Doug Baldwin
0.7%
22.8%
WR1
Doug Baldwin
0.0%
21.8%
WR2
Paul Richardson
0.0%
15.2%
WR2
Jermaine Kearse
0.0%
16.2%
WR2
Tyler Lockett
1.0%
14.6%
WR3
Tyler Lockett
2.4%
13.5%
WR3
Tyler Lockett
1.5%
12.0%
WR3
Jermaine Kearse
0.0%
14.4%
TE1
Jimmy Graham
0.0%
18.3%
TE1
Jimmy Graham
0.2%
17.3%
TE1
Jimmy Graham
0.0%
15.7%
We can pretty much dismiss 2017 Seahawks as an example for the
running game, as Seattle suffered a ridiculous amount of injuries
to the backfield. Nevertheless, the last time Bevell gave one
running back more than 30 percent of the carries was Marshawn
Lynch (53.3) in 2014. That's probably going to have to change
in Detroit since Matthew Stafford isn't going to augment the running
game like Wilson did. Still, it's probably going to take Kerryon
Johnson making the rest of the depth chart look ridiculous for
him to get much more than 40 percent of the rushing attempts.
C.J. Anderson was added in part to make sure Johnson doesn't get
overworked, and we can bet Theo Riddick will find a way to get
a 10-15 percent of the carries if he makes the team.
In the rare instance or two the Seahawks employed a back capable
of being a weapon in the passing game under Bevell, he didn’t
see much work as a receiver. There is talk earlier in the offseason
about Johnson potentially catching 60 passes, but it appears there
will have to be a serious shift in philosophy for that to happen.
Bevell's squads in Seattle don't really resemble the talent he
has now, as these Lions seemingly have their outside receivers
figured out. His Seahawks had their slot receiver and tight end
secured. Danny Amendola is a familiar face to HC Matt Patricia
and figures to be good for the culture he wants to build in Detroit,
but he's obviously no Baldwin. He'll likely top out around 10-12
percent of the target share. If there is one thing is clear from
Bevell's days with the Seahawks, it is that he might be able to
keep four pass-catchers involved. Baldwin's low-20s usage is a
good sign for Golladay, who should build on his 21.3 target share
from 2018. Marvin Jones was actually averaging seven targets -
one less than Golladay - through nine games before he was lost
for the season, so a 16-18 percent share seems doable. Where both
players can pick up some extra targets is at tight end. While
T.J. Hockenson should one day become a Pro Bowl tight end, there's
almost zero chance he'll see more than 10-12 percent of the looks
from Stafford as a rookie.
Green Bay HC Matt LaFleur
LaFleur (TEN)
2018
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Target
Share
456
425
QB1
Marcus Mariota
14.0%
0.2%
RB1
Derrick Henry
47.1%
4.2%
RB2
Dion Lewis
34.0%
15.8%
WR1
Corey Davis
1.3%
26.4%
WR2
Taywan Taylor
0.0%
13.2%
WR3
Tajae Sharpe
0.2%
11.1%
TE1
Jonnu Smith
0.0%
7.1%
One of the first things LaFleur mentioned publicly after his
hiring was that he believed a "committee approach" is
the most effective solution regarding Aaron Jones and Jamaal Williams.
If there is hope for fantasy owners with Jones, it is that Tennessee
turned things over to Henry late last season when it became obvious
the Titans were embracing his physical running style. With that
said, we simply don't have enough of a sample size with LaFleur
as the offensive coordinator to figure out if he is just promoting
competition at the position this summer or trying to play mind
games with Green Bay's early opponents. It is telling, however,
that Jones used the offseason to get down to 5.3 percent body
fat. Perhaps he feels he can change LaFleur's mind about a committee?
On one hand, the 26.4 percent target share Davis enjoyed last
season has to be encouraging for fantasy owners of Davante Adams,
who saw 27.5 percent of the looks in 2018; it's a number set to
decline if Geronimo Allison stays healthy this year. On the other
hand, it's slightly discouraging Davis didn't do more with those
opportunities than he did. Owners will naturally (and probably
rightfully) ignore such an observation because Aaron Rodgers and
Adams > Mariota and Davis, but it could also speak to a potential
inability for LaFleur to figure out how to best use his most dynamic
receiver. (I think LaFleur deserves the benefit of the doubt,
however.) It's reasonable for Allison (4.9 percent after four-plus
games) and Marquez Valdes-Scantling (11.9) to both exceed Taylor's
13.2 percent share from 2018. Jonnu Smith was only a factor late
last season, so his 7.1 percent share was obviously not indicative
of what Jimmy Graham might mean in this offense. However, if Jace
Sternberger shows much of anything during camp, Graham could struggle
to reach 10 percent target share after going for 14.5 in 2018.
LaFleur talked earlier this offseason about getting his running
backs more involved in the passing game as well. One would hope;
Jones (5.7), Williams (6.7) and Ty Montgomery (3.7) combined for
a 16.1 percent target share last year.
Los Angeles
Rams HC Sean McVay
McVay (LAR) 2018
McVay (LAR) 2017
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
459
545
454
510
QB1
Jared Goff
9.4%
0.0%
QB1
Jared Goff
6.2%
0.0%
RB1
Todd Gurley
55.8%
14.9%
RB1
Todd Gurley
61.5%
17.1%
RB2
Malcolm Brown
9.4%
1.3%
RB2
Malcolm Brown
13.9%
2.2%
RB3
C.J. Anderson
9.4%
1.1%
OW
Tavon Austin
13.0%
4.3%
WR1
Robert Woods
4.1%
23.9%
WR1
Cooper Kupp
0.0%
18.4%
WR2
Brandin Cooks
2.2%
21.5%
WR2
Robert Woods
0.4%
16.7%
WR3
Cooper Kupp
0.9%
10.1%
WR3
Sammy Watkins
0.0%
13.7%
WR4
Josh Reynolds
0.4%
9.7%
TE1
Gerald Everett
0.4%
9.2%
TE1
Tyler Higbee
0.0%
8.8%
TE1
Tyler Higbee
0.0%
6.2%
TE2
Gerald Everett
0.2%
6.3%
There's no question it's going to be difficult to trust Gurley's
knee this year. Had he not missed the final two regular-season
games, his carry share would have been over 60 percent yet again.
Those days MIGHT be over, but I don't think he's close to being
done yet. As far as I'm concerned, this will be similar to when
owners had to play it week-to-week with Brian Westbrook late in
his career. I think there will be surprising and inconvenient
inactive announcements, but I also think the Rams would have done
more to address the position if they were overly concerned about
him not being able to handle 200-250 carries. Yes, Brown and Darrell
Henderson are candidates to steal roughly 80 carries apiece even
with a healthy Gurley, but Los Angeles has it to spare (with 450-plus
carries each of the last two years). For what it's worth, I think
the handcuff to own this year will be Brown, not Henderson, at
least in regards to carrying the load if/when Gurley sits. Henderson
will obviously the more valuable standalone option of the two
backups when Gurley plays.
As noted earlier, a hallmark of McVay's passing games has been
balance among his top three receivers. Had Kupp been able to play
more than half of the season, he probably would have joined Woods
and Cooks with target shares right around 20 percent. It's anyone's
guess how ready he'll be coming off ACL surgery (he got hurt in
early November), so a slow start should probably be expected.
Considering his game is built on quickness, I'd expect him to
struggle to match his rookie year target share of 18.4. Woods
and Cooks will probably be 1A and 1B early this season (and not
necessarily in that order). Both will push - and probably exceed
- 20 percent again this season. The major difference in this offense
figures to be how much Gurley's target share drops after being
in the mid-to-high teens in both seasons under McVay. Henderson
could push for 10 percent even if Gurley plays all 16 games. Everett
will probably climb over 10 percent for the first time in his
career as well, but there are simply too many weapons (assuming
Kupp is ready sooner than later) on this offense for him to become
a fantasy star, at least until he is able to improve his blocking
enough to make Higbee an afterthought.
Minnesota OC Kevin Stefanski
Stefanski only called plays for the last three games of the season
following the firing of former OC John DeFilippo, so it doesn't
make a ton of sense to post those numbers. For what it's worth,
Minnesota recorded one more rushing attempt in those three contests
(83), although 40 of the runs came in a blowout win against the
run-defense challenged Dolphins in Week 15. Dalvin Cook hasn't
been healthy enough in either of his first two seasons for owners
to get a good read on whether the Vikings want to use him as a
workhorse, but it's worth noting he has yet to record double-digit
carries in five straight games two years into his career. Still,
it's a good bet Minnesota will try to get him to handle at least
50 percent of the rushing attempts in 2019 and make Cook prove
he can't handle it. Rookie Alexander Mattison doesn't figure to
come anywhere close to matching Latavius Murray's 39.2 percent
carry share if Cook lasts the season, but the mid-20s should be
his floor if the Vikings at least try to preserve their starter.
Last week, I said I can't remember any team having two receivers
with a target share over 24 percent. Minnesota had two over 25:
Adam Thielen (25.8) and Stefon Diggs (25.2). In addition to trying
to run a more balanced offense, the Vikings probably don't want
a repeat of two players accounting for more than 300 targets.
Neither player figures to take that big of a hit (low 20s is probably
their floor), but it's going to be on the shoulders of players
Laquon Treadwell, Chad Beebe and Jordan Taylor to force the action.
At the moment, the Vikings don't have a third receiver they trust
enough to take some of the attention away from Thielen and Diggs.
However, a healthy season from Cook alone may be enough to boost
his target share around 15 percent and knock Minnesota's dynamic
duo down a peg. Kyle Rudolph seems unlikely to match last year's
13.9 percent target share, if only because rookie Irv Smith is
a lot like an oversized slot receiver at this point of his career.
Perhaps Minnesota will turn to him as a regular option in the
slot if Treadwell, Beebe and Taylor fail to live up to expectations.
Nevertheless, he's still unlikely to push 10 percent of the target
share.
New Orleans HC Sean Payton
Payton 2018
Payton 2017
Payton 2016
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
471
511
444
528
404
664
RB1
Alvin Kamara
41.2%
20.5%
RB1
Mark Ingram
51.8%
13.4%
RB1
Mark Ingram
50.7%
8.7%
RB2
Mark Ingram
29.3%
5.3%
RB2
Alvin Kamara
27.0%
18.9%
RB2
Tim Hightower
32.9%
3.9%
OW
Taysom Hill
7.9%
1.4%
RB3
Adrian Peterson
6.1%
0.6%
RB3
Travaris Cadet
1.0%
8.1%
WR1
Michael Thomas
0.0%
28.8%
WR1
Michael Thomas
0.0%
28.2%
WR1
Michael Thomas
0.0%
18.2%
WR2
Tre'Quan Smith
0.0%
8.6%
WR2
Ted Ginn
2.3%
13.3%
WR2
Brandin Cooks
1.5%
17.6%
WR3
Ted Ginn
0.6%
5.9%
WR3
Brandon Coleman
0.0%
7.0%
WR3
Willie Snead
0.0%
15.7%
TE1
Ben Watson
0.0%
9.0%
TE1
Coby Fleener
0.0%
5.7%
TE1
Coby Fleener
0.2%
12.2%
The Saints are a great example of why this kind of analysis can
be useful, in part because it highlights how much more balanced
they have become in recent years. Even with Ingram suspended for
the first four games of last season, New Orleans threw the ball
155 fewer times and ran the ball 67 more times than it did just
two seasons ago. With the Saints going all-in on trying to make
sure they keep Drew Brees upright, don't look for last year's
balance to go away. The big question when it comes to Payton's
running game is this: does he use (or talk himself into using)
Latavius Murray the same way he did Ingram last year? Ingram averaged
just over 11 rushing attempts last year for a team that ran the
ball an average of 29.4 times. Over that same 12-game stretch
following Ingram's return from suspension, Kamara averaged 12.5
(which would put him on pace for 200 in a full season). If Payton
can talk himself into giving two more carries per game to one
of the NFL's 10 most efficient backs of all-time through his first
two seasons, Kamara will come close to a 50 percent carry share
and would be the odds-on favorite to be the most valuable player
in fantasy football (especially given the frequency in which he
has scored touchdowns throughout his first two seasons). Don't
be surprised if UDFA Devine Ozigbo works his way into the equation
at some point; his emergence would obviously damage Murray's potential
fantasy impact.
Besides Kamara, the obvious star of the show in this passing
game is Thomas. It's pretty clear he'll remain heavily involved
no matter what his supporting cast looks like, but it seems reasonable
Payton would probably like to see the offense not rely on him
quite so heavily. It would not be overly surprising if he dropped
to around 25-26 percent of the target share (admittedly not a
big decline) and had those looks redirected toward Jared Cook,
who seems like a good bet for target share of at least 15 percent.
Because Kamara is the consummate mismatch in the passing game
for this offense, he's likely to remain right around 20 percent.
The Saints probably wouldn't mind having Smith and Ginn combine
for about 20 percent, presumably with the hope the younger Smith
shows he is ready to handle something close to Ginn's 13.3 percent
target share from 2017. Brees doesn't mind spreading the love
around, so it's a good bet that will happen again this season
after Payton makes sure Thomas, Kamara and Cook account for 60
percent of the target pie.
New York
Giants HC Pat Shurmur
Shurmur (NYG)
2018
Shurmur (MIN) 2017
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
354
574
501
520
RB1
Saquon Barkley
73.7%
21.1%
RB1
Latavius Murray
43.1%
3.3%
RB2
Wayne Gallman
14.4%
3.8%
RB2
Jerick McKinnon
29.9%
13.1%
RB3
Dalvin Cook
14.8%
3.1%
WR1
Odell Beckham
1.4%
21.6%
WR1
Adam Thielen
0.2%
27.3%
WR2
Sterling Shepard
0.8%
18.6%
WR2
Stefon Diggs
1.6%
18.3%
TE1
Evan Engram
0.8%
11.1%
TE1
Kyle Rudolph
0.0%
15.6%
TE2
Rhett Ellison
0.0%
5.9%
Only two Giants handled more than Eli Manning's 15 rushing attempts
(4.2 percent carry share) last season. If Daniel Jones takes over
around midseason, there's a fair chance he might get 10 percent.
Otherwise, expect another massive workload for Barkley behind
what should be an improved offensive line. Given the fact New
York seems uncertain about who is backup running back is (Paul
Perkins reportedly worked ahead of Gallman during offseason workouts),
it is possible - albeit unlikely - Barkley handles closer to 80
percent of the rushing attempts. Either way, it would be a mild
surprise if he doesn’t lead the league in carries, touches
or both.
The plan for the Giants in 2019 is to have more balance on offense
and let Barkley do as much of the heavy lifting as possible. Another
20 percent target share is not only possible for him, but likely.
If we can only say for certain whether or not Shepard will be
the primary slot receiver, then perhaps we could put him down
for 22 percent of the targets. The same goes for Golden Tate if
he operates as the primary slot receiver. At the moment, however,
the lack of certainty makes both a bit difficult to project for
target share and fantasy purposes. The likelihood is the duo will
probably account for 40 percent of the targets one way or the
other. A fourth potential player who could push 20 percent is
Engram, who attracted 19.1 percent of the looks as a rookie under
the previous regime in 2017. The reason the Giants could have
as many as four players each accounting for about 18-22 percent
target share is there's not much reason to believe either Corey
Coleman or Cody Latimer will do much with their opportunity to
take the third receiver job. The wild-card for that role is Darius
Slayton. Unfortunately for the rookie, his game is speed. As most
fantasy owners already know, Manning isn't throwing many downfield
dimes at this stage of his career.
Philadelphia HC Doug Pederson
Pederson (PHI)
2018
Pederson (PHI)
2017
Pederson (PHI)
2016
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
398
592
473
555
437
604
RB1
Josh Adams
30.2%
2.2%
RB1
LeGarrette Blount
36.6%
1.4%
RB1
Ryan Mathews
35.5%
2.3%
RB2
W. Smallwood
21.9%
5.9%
RB2
Corey Clement
15.6%
2.7%
RB2
Darren Sproles
21.5%
11.8%
RB3
Corey Clement
17.1%
4.2%
RB3
Jay Ajayi
14.8%
2.5%
RB3
W. Smallwood
17.6%
2.2%
WR1
Nelson Agholor
0.8%
16.4%
WR1
Alshon Jeffery
0.0%
21.6%
WR1
Jordan Matthews
0.0%
19.4%
WR2
Alshon Jeffery
0.0%
15.5%
WR2
Nelson Agholor
0.2%
17.1%
WR2
Green-Beckham
0.0%
12.3%
WR3
Golden Tate
0.3%
7.4%
WR3
Torrey Smith
0.2%
12.1%
WR3
Nelson Agholor
1.1%
11.4%
TE1
Zach Ertz
0.0%
26.4%
TE1
Zach Ertz
0.0%
19.8%
TE1
Zach Ertz
0.0%
17.5%
TE2
Dallas Goedert
0.0%
7.4%
TE2
Trey Burton
0.0%
9.9%
There have been times during the Pederson regime that the Eagles
have been tempted (or at least contemplated) relying more heavily
on one back. (One such instance was at the beginning of last season
with Ajayi.) However, in three years under Pederson, Philadelphia
has very much been a committee backfield. The addition of Miles
Sanders may change that eventually, but don't count on it happening
in 2019 - especially considering how much time he missed this
spring. The Eagles appear to be very comfortable with a 35-20-15
(percent) type of setup when it comes to distributing carries
and the addition of an early-down pounder like Jordan Howard only
reinforces the likelihood they will spread the wealth again this
year.
Andy Reid disciples tend to emphasize a relatively equal target
distribution, making last year a bit of a departure. Of course,
it didn't help matters that Jeffrey missed three games, Tate was
acquired midseason and Carson Wentz played in only 11 contests.
The Eagles will almost certainly want to turn back the clock a
bit to 2016 and 2017 if the trio of Jeffery, DeSean Jackson and
Ertz can stay healthy. The Wentz-to-Ertz connection is undeniable,
meaning owners of the tight end can probably bank on target share
of at least 22-23 percent. Jeffrey has only played one full season
in the last four years (2017), so it seems reasonable that a lack
of durability will probably keep him just shy of reaching 20 percent.
Jackson is an interesting case. Per Pro Football Focus, Jackson's
best routes throughout his career have been the go, hitch and
out. Incidentally, those are the same routes Wentz has enjoyed
the most success with throughout his career, again per PFF. Due
in part to his lack of durability over the years, Jackson's highest
target share (at least since 2014) is 17.6 percent. If he can
suit up for at least 14 games in 2019, I think he has a realistic
shot of matching that. With the addition of a capable receiver
like Jackson and the emergence of Goedert, expect Agholor to take
a significant hit - maybe in the 10-12 percent area. That's roughly
the same area I expect Goedert to end up, as I expect the Eagles
to use two-tight formations on a more regular basis this season.
San Francisco HC Kyle Shanahan
Shanahan (SF)
2018
Shanahan (ATL)
2017
Shanahan (ATL)
2016
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
423
514
408
599
421
530
RB1
Matt Breida
36.2%
6.0%
RB1
Carlos Hyde
58.8%
14.7%
RB1
Devonta Freeman
53.9%
12.3%
RB2
Alfred Morris
26.2%
2.5%
RB2
Matt Breida
25.7%
6.0%
RB2
Tevin Coleman
28.0%
7.5%
RB3
Jeff Wilson
15.6%
2.9%
RB3
Kyle Juszczyk
1.7%
7.0%
WR1
Kendrick Bourne
0.0%
12.8%
WR1
M. Goodwin
1.0%
17.5%
WR1
Julio Jones
0.0%
24.3%
WR2
Pierre Garcon
0.0%
8.9%
WR2
Pierre Garcon
0.0%
11.2%
WR2
Mohamed Sanu
0.2%
15.3%
WR3
Dante Pettis
0.2%
8.8%
WR3
Trent Taylor
0.0%
10.0%
WR3
Taylor Gabriel
1.0%
9.4%
WR4
Marquise Goodwin
0.9%
8.4%
TE1
George Kittle
0.2%
26.5%
TE1
George Kittle
0.0%
10.5%
TE1
Jacob Tamme
0.0%
5.8%
The 2018 season was a unique one to say the least for the 49ers,
who only saw three skill-position players play more than 14 games
(Kittle, Bourne and FB Kyle Jusczyk). Shanahan hasn't been opposed
to using committee backfields, although he also has plenty of
history of riding one back if the situation calls for it. He and
GM John Lynch might have forced themselves into the former this
spring, however, when they added Coleman. Shanahan himself dropped
several hints during the spring that Breida, Coleman and Jerick
McKinnon will earn their roles and that all of them could be active
on game day. This offense will produce a fantasy-relevant rusher
more weeks than not even if it is a three-headed monster, but
it will be difficult to project which one will step up on a game-by-game
basis - especially early in the season.
Much like the running back, there was far too much chaos last
year to use it to help us project 2019. For example, Bourne played
159 more snaps than any other wideout after starting out the season
No. 4 on the depth chart. He didn't exactly earn his promotion
as a result of stellar play on the field. Pettis began to assert
himself as the leader of the pack after the Week 11 bye and enjoyed
a 15.3 percent target share over his final five games, which seems
like a reasonable starting point for this year. After that, it's
nearly impossible to predict. Goodwin was billed as the No. 1
leading into last season and will probably pace the complementary
wideouts for as long as he can stay healthy - unfortunately, he's
played 16 games only once in six NFL seasons - but the 2017 campaign
proved he is capable of being a productive starting receiver in
the NFL. Deebo Samuel should eventually start, although it's anyone's
guess when that might happen. Samuel's physical style is certain
to appeal to Shanahan, but he's bound to struggle for 10 percent
of the looks if Pettis and Goodwin stay on the field. McKinnon
was initially expected to handle the Devonta Freeman role in this
offense before his ACL tear, and Shanahan couldn't stop talking
last year about the mismatches he thought the former Viking could
create. If he can stay healthy, McKinnon also seems like a lock
for 10-12 percent of the target share. Last but not least, Kittle
saw monster usage after the bye week, handling 32 percent of the
targets over that span. There's no real reason for San Francisco
to bring it down lower than last year's 26.5.
Seattle OC Brian Schottenheimer
Schottenheimer
(SEA) 2018
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
534
400
QB1
Russell Wilson
12.5%
0.3%
RB1
Chris Carson
46.3%
6.0%
RB2
Mike Davis
21.0%
10.5%
RB3
Rashaad Penny
15.9%
3.0%
WR1
Doug Baldwin
0.0%
18.3%
WR2
Tyler Lockett
2.4%
17.5%
WR3
David Moore
0.2%
13.3%
TE1
Nick Vannett
0.0%
10.8%
The message since the beginning of last season has been clear:
run the ball as much possible. The Seahawks obviously didn't count
on Davis seeing more work than Penny, but they undoubtedly had
every intention on trying to run 500-plus times last year. That's
unlikely to change just because Wilson is now the highest-paid
quarterback in the league. What should be different this year
is that Carson and Penny becoming more of a 1A/1B tandem instead
of what happened in 2018 when Carson simply refused to give up
the lead role. Penny has worked hard this offseason to get in
better shape, and since Seattle will likely want to see some return
on last year's first-round pick, expect both backs to push for
200 carries if both of them can avoid injury. Unlike last season
when Davis was still around, there doesn't figure to be a committee
if/when Carson gets hurt. If either Carson or Penny goes down
this year, I expect the Seahawks to feature the other.
Each of Schottenheimer's last four offenses - dating back to
2012 with the Rams - has featured a lot of balance in terms of
target share, as only Jared Cook (19.6) came close to topping
20 percent. Lockett is the best candidate to change that with
Baldwin retired, but don't look for it to happen in 2019 either.
The Seahawks added enough receivers this spring (most notably
D.K. Metcalf) and have talked up Jaron Brown enough to the point
where it is feasible Lockett remains in the high teens, while
a handful of others hover around 10-12 percent. Moore, Brown and
Metcalf figure to have the best shot of finishing on the high
end of that. John Ursua has a realistic shot of taking over the
slot job at some point, which would give Schottenheimer the option
to keep Lockett outside more often. It's unlikely the seventh-rounder
will see enough opportunities to be even a low-end bench option
in deeper PPR leagues as a rookie, but he's got a better shot
than most think. Owners only need to go back to early September
last season to remember that Will Dissly quickly became a thing
in fantasy. With Dissly recovering from a torn patella tendon,
there's an opportunity for someone else playing for a coordinator
with a history of keeping his tight end involved. As of now, Jacob
Hollister appears as if he has the inside track. Consider him
a dark-horse candidate for 10 percent of the targets.
Tampa Bay OC Byron Leftwich
Arians (ARI) 2017
Arians (ARI) 2016
Arians (ARI) 2015
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
410
592
398
636
452
549
RB1
Adrian Peterson
31.5%
2.7%
RB1
David Johnson
73.6%
18.9%
RB1
Chris Johnson
43.4%
2.4%
RB2
Kerwynn Williams
29.3%
2.5%
RB2
Andre Ellington
8.5%
3.0%
RB2
David Johnson
27.7%
10.4%
RB3
Chris Johnson
11.0%
1.0%
RB3
Andre Ellington
10.0%
4.4%
WR1
Larry Fitzgerald
0.0%
27.2%
WR1
Larry Fitzgerald
0.5%
23.6%
WR1
Larry Fitzgerald
0.0%
26.4%
WR2
Jaron Brown
0.0%
11.7%
WR2
John Brown
0.3%
11.5%
WR2
John Brown
0.7%
18.4%
WR3
J.J. Nelson
0.7%
10.3%
WR3
J.J. Nelson
100.0%
11.6%
WR3
Michael Floyd
0.0%
16.2%
WR4
Michael Floyd
0.0%
11.0%
TE1
J. Gresham
0.0%
7.8%
TE1
J. Gresham
0.0%
9.6%
TE1
J. Gresham
0.0%
5.8%
Even though HC Bruce Arians has entrusted Leftwich to be the
play-caller, I will detail Arians' history instead. Why? The bulk
of Leftwich's coaching career has come learning at the knee of
Arians, who hired him in 2017. Also, it would be unfair to pin
the disaster that was Arizona's offense on him after he was asked
to take over for Mike McCoy in the middle of October last year
(meaning he was mostly bound by McCoy's playbook). It's fair to
say that Arians has shown a willingness to lean on one back throughout
his career (Vick Ballard in 2012, Rashard Mendenhall in 2013 and
Ellington in 2014 are non-David Johnson examples over the last
decade). It suggests that if the hype surrounding Ronald Jones'
spring practices carries over into the preseason, there's potential
200-carry upside with him on a team that will run the ball more
effectively and more often than it did last year under former
HC Dirk Koetter and OC Todd Monken. Undrafted rookie free agent
Bruce Anderson also needs to be on owners' radar.
Led by players as Hines Ward and Fitzgerald, the slot receiver
has received a ton of attention in Arians' offenses over the years.
It's probably not realistic to expect Chris Godwin to join that
group or command roughly a quarter of the targets as Fitzgerald
did in each of the three seasons above, but Arians definitely
turned some heads this spring when he said Godwin "is never
coming off the field" and could be "close to a 100-catch
guy." Only twice in Arians' coaching career as the No. 2
receiver finished with more than 120 targets, which sets the ceiling
at about 80 receptions if he catches two-thirds of his targets
(a fairly high mark). At any rate, it would seem as though Arians
very much wants Godwin to see at least 20 percent of the targets,
which would be a cool 4.7 percent increase from 2018. Evans commanded
a career-low 22.3 percent of the looks last season; it's unlikely
he'll take another hit in that area when his game matches up so
well with Arians' "no risk it, no biscuit" offense.
Arians routinely had a third receiver play a substantial role
in his offenses in Arizona, so don't discount the possibility
of someone like Breshad Perriman, Justin Watson or even rookie
Scott Miller working his way in a double-digit percentage target
share. There was an early narrative that O.J. Howard and Cameron
Brate were doomed following Arians' hire because he so rarely
ever uses tight ends. That myth seems to have lost steam in recent
months; one reason might be that people discovered Heath Miller's
career-high reception total came in 2009 under Arians. Tight ends
will be a big part of the offense because Howard's talents will
dictate it. If he stays healthy, a 15 percent target share should
be his floor.
Washington HC Jay Gruden
Gruden (WAS) 2018
Gruden (WAS) 2017
Gruden (WAS) 2014
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
Pos
Player
Carry
Share
Tgt
Share
414
489
401
534
401
541
RB1
Adrian Peterson
60.6%
5.3%
RB1
Samaje Perine
43.6%
4.5%
RB1
Alfred Morris
66.1%
4.8%
RB2
Chris Thompson
10.4%
11.2%
RB2
Chris Thompson
16.0%
10.1%
RB2
Roy Helu
10.0%
8.7%
RB3
Robert Kelley
15.5%
1.3%
WR1
Josh Doctson
0.0%
16.0%
WR1
Jamison Crowder
1.7%
19.3%
WR1
Pierre Garcon
0.0%
19.4%
WR2
Jamison Crowder
1.0%
10.0%
WR2
Josh Doctson
0.2%
14.6%
WR2
DeSean Jackson
1.0%
17.6%
WR3
Maurice Harris
0.5%
9.6%
WR3
Ryan Grant
0.0%
12.2%
WR3
Andre Roberts
0.5%
13.5%
TE1
Jordan Reed
0.0%
17.2%
TE1
Vernon Davis
0.0%
12.9%
TE1
Jordan Reed
0.0%
12.0%
TE2
Vernon Davis
0.0%
7.4%
TE2
Jordan Reed
0.0%
6.6%
Gruden has typically preferred to trust one back to handle the
majority of the workload throughout his NFL coaching career, dating
as far back as BenJarvus Green-Ellis with Cincinnati in 2012.
Derrius Guice's preseason ACL tear obviously changed the plan
last year or Washington, which quickly shifted years and allowed
Peterson to take on a workhorse role. Peterson signed a two-year
contract in the offseason, suggesting he will remain fairly involved
at the very least and perhaps start all season again if Guice's
injury woes continue (he injured his hamstring while rehabbing
his ACL tear and may miss the start of camp). Assuming both backs
enter the season healthy, a reasonable expectation would be the
two each finishing with a carry share in the mid-30s. It's a strong
possibility Gruden wants Thompson to be as involved as he was
in 2017, so it is realistic he ends up in the high teens in terms
of carry share.
In each of the last two years, Crowder finished or was on pace
for almost 20 percent. While that may partly be a function of
the receiving talent in Washington since Garcon and Jackson left,
the fact of the matter is the team isn't in much better shape
in 2019. Enter Trey Quinn, who is going to be a player owners
need to get familiar with over the next two months. It's entirely
possible he pushes for 20 percent of the targets in 2019, especially
if Case Keenum ends up starting the majority of games. If the
offense to function at its highest level, Thompson and Reed need
to be right alongside Quinn in terms of target share. Durability
issues continue to haunt Thompson, who has been on roughly a 60-catch
pace in each of the last two years before suffering a season-ending
injury. Reed's health woes have been well-documented; if he could
ever play all 16 games (he's never done so in six pro seasons),
he will almost certainly lead the team in receptions and targets
- as he did last season despite playing only 13 contests. Doctson
has posted two remarkably unimpressive seasons since missing most
of his rookie season in 2016 due to injury. Even with a solid
16 percent target share last year, he still only managed 44 catches.
It's hard to be optimistic about him improving much on that. If
Paul Richardson could ever stay healthy, he might have some low-end
appeal. He'll likely need Dwayne Haskins to start in order to
reach his ceiling, however low that may be.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and been featured in USA TODAY's Fantasy Football Preview magazine since 2010. He is also a high-stakes player who often appears as a guest analyst on a number of national sports radio shows, such as Sirius XM's "Fantasy Drive." Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.