THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF FANTASY ANALYSTS DO NOT CONSIDER
DEFENSIVE MATCHUPS WHEN CREATING PROJECTIONS.
Sometime between the end of the preseason and the first week
of the season, fantasy managers and analysts alike shift gears
from not caring one iota about their players' matchups to making
it their primary consideration when setting about 70 percent of
their lineup. A tough three- or four-game stretch for a player
at the beginning or end of the season should not surprise anyone
that is paying attention to matchups, yet many are shocked to
learn some of their players open the season with three of their
first five or six games against likely top 10 pass defenses and/or
stud cornerbacks.
Defense may not matter as much as it used to, but it is a mistake
to not account for it at all. Doing so suggests a belief that
NFL games are like seven-on-seven drills. I realized as early
as 2004 that I did not like the idea of my players having to face
the Ravens or the Steelers, especially during the fantasy playoffs.
Certainly, my approach has evolved significantly from that initial
premise, but I think my track record of success speaks for itself
(finishing in the black in each of the 20-plus seasons I've played
fantasy football) and suggests there is substantial value in putting
a fair amount of weight into "the matchup." The key
is giving potential matchups the proper amount of weight to a
player's evaluation. By itself, a matchup will not transform an
every-week RB3 into an RB1 or turn a perennial WR1 into a bench
option, but it is helpful for fantasy managers trying to find
weekly and even season-long values and avoid potential busts.
That brings us to our focus for the next two weeks. With defenses
operating out of sub-packages (nickel, dime, quarter, etc.) almost
70 percent of the time in today's game, it makes sense to use
their likely sub-package personnel as the basis for our matchup
analysis. Furthermore, it helps to have an understanding of how
each veteran defensive player who will be playing in those packages
graded out and/or performed last year. With the help of sites
like Pro Football Focus and Pro Football Reference, we can do
that.
Defense is a team endeavor, so the process is never as easy as
spotting a player with a weakness and having an offense exploit
that matchup repeatedly. An important part of coaching in any
sport is the ability to maximize players' strengths and mask their
weaknesses; players either will get help from the scheme or be
benched if they continue to struggle. Nevertheless, the goal of
any good offense is to isolate the weak link in the passing defense
as often as possible or take advantage of what may be a "soft"
run defense (assuming that matches up with the run-blocking ability
of the offensive line). It is also important to understand that
no defender lines up across any offensive player on every play,
so we are playing odds here as opposed to dealing with virtual
certainties (i.e. shadow cornerbacks usually only "shadow"
about 50-60 percent of the time).
The color-coding in this two-part series is based on last year
only because we have no information about this season. Last year's
color codes help set the stage for this year. Film analysis and
advanced analytics help us predict what may happen.
Each team table below will contain more than 11 players. The
players in italics are likely rotational players or ones that
will be replaced on certain downs for any number of reasons. Most
of the players have projected grades next to their ages, but some
of them will not because I want the final team projected scores
(coverage, pass rush and run defense) to reflect the defenders
logging the most snaps. Much as I did for the offensive line at
the end of the two-part
Big Uglies series, this week's column will rank each team
in terms of projected coverage, pass rush and run defense scores.
The purpose of this article is simple, even if the execution
of it is not: attempting to identify what defenders present fantasy
owners with an opportunity for success. There is a heavy amount
of subjectivity that goes into my color-coding matchups in advance
of the Big Board. It is my hope this process reduces most of that
and gives readers a look under the hood, so to speak.
Key:
Green box - Player graded 80 or higher in that
particular discipline per PFF (100-point scale) Blue box - Player graded between 70 or 79.9 in
that particular discipline Yellow box - Player graded between 60 or 69.9
in that particular discipline Red box - Player graded 59.9 or lower in that
particular discipline Black box - Player did not log a snap in the
NFL snap or the discipline does not apply to his position
Italic (player name) - Likely (but potentially
important) rotational player Red text - Player is returning from a major injury # - Rookie 23 Cov - Projected 2023 coverage grade 23 Run - Projected 2023 run defense grade Grades - Coverage (Cov) and run defense (Run
D)
Arizona
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Cameron Thomas
ED
23
6
39.3
63.8
Rashard Lawrence
DI
24
6
60.0
63.8
Carlos Watkins
DI
29
5
66.7
54.0
BJ Ojulari#
ED
21
L.J. Collier
DI
27
4
60.0
34.4
Myjai Sanders
ED
24
46.8
46.9
Zaven Collins
LB
24
6
5
70.1
45.2
Kyzir White
LB
27
6
6
66.4
64.9
Antonio Hamilton
CB
30
6
5
69.4
59.7
Marco Wilson
CB
24
5
4
61.2
28.9
Garrett Williams#
CB
22
Rashad Fenton
CB
26
56.2
59.1
Isaiah Simmons
S
24
7
5
69.9
47.0
Budda Baker
S
27
7
7
69.1
80.2
Jalen Thompson
S
24
6
6
59.7
77.4
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: S Isaiah Simmons,
S Budda Baker
Prominent players to target in the passing game: Any cornerback
not named Marco Wilson.
Summary: Rallis is a 29-year-old assistant who is running a defense
for the first time in his coaching career. He joins the Cardinals
after coaching linebackers for the Eagles over the last two seasons.
Rallis figures to be less aggressive than his predecessor, Vance
Joseph, in part because of his personnel and in part because few
defensive play-callers dial up the blitz as often as Joseph (34.5
percent blitz rate in 2022). Other contributing factors: Arizona
will very likely run significantly fewer plays per game under
new HC Jonathan Gannon than it did under former HC Kliff Kingsbury
and will also likely try to limit possessions, at least as long
as QB Kyler Murray (knee) is sidelined.
The Cardinals are clearly in a rebuilding phase right now and
unlikely to perform very well offensively in 2023, so it would
be an upset if their defense does not finish among the league
leaders in terms of most rushing attempts and rushing yards allowed.
Further complicating matters is that Arizona lacks a significant
presence on its defensive line - one that can command a double
team and let its athletic linebackers flow to the ball in the
running game.
Atlanta
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Lorenzo Carter
ED
27
6
56.8
67.7
Grady Jarrett
DI
30
7
63.3
61.4
Calais Campbell
DI
36
7
57.1
74.1
Bud Dupree
ED
30
47.1
61.8
David Onyemata
DI
30
7
72.8
53.0
Arnold Ebiketie
ED
24
76.3
70.0
Troy Andersen
LB
24
5
5
34.0
49.0
Kaden Elliss
LB
27
6
7
67.5
81.1
A.J. Terrell
CB
24
7
6
61.8
67.3
Jeffrey Okudah
CB
24
6
6
54.4
74.0
Mike Hughes
CB
26
5
6
51.4
81.1
Clark Phillips#
CB
21
Jessie Bates III
S
26
7
8
64.9
88.3
Richie Grant
S
25
7
6
69.0
57.1
DC: Ryan Nielsen (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB A.J. Terrell,
S Jessie Bates
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Mike Hughes,
LB Troy Andersen
Summary: Nielsen is also a first-time coordinator, although (unlike
Rallis) he is a 44-year-old with significant NFL experience -
most of which has come coaching the Saints' defensive line. The
major concern with the Falcons is the age of their key defensive
stalwarts up front (Campbell, Onyemata, Jarrett and Dupree are
all in their 30s), but there is no question Atlanta upgraded its
defensive talent this offseason. Adding Bates further shores up
the run defense and should also enable Terrell and Okudah to be
as aggressive as they want to be on the outside on likely passing
downs. Andersen is a highly athletic linebacker who should perform
much better in coverage in his second season. Until that happens,
receiving backs should feast against Atlanta.
Assuming most of the other key players such as Terrell continue
on their current path, the additions of Bates and Okudah could
(should?) take this defense to the next level. Bates should remain
a top-five safety in the league, but the Falcons could enjoy some
of the New Orleans-caliber of defense Nielsen is used to if Okudah
can regain his confidence. Atlanta should put more pressure on
the quarterback than Detroit ever did during Okudah's time in
the Motor City. The former No. 3 overall pick did flash that kind
of upside on occasion last year. The Falcons could emerge as a
dark-horse top-10 pass defense if Okudah thrives with his change
of scenery and rookie Phillips overtakes Hughes - as he should
- as the team's primary slot corner.
Carolina
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Brian Burns
ED
25
5
78.3
50.9
Derrick Brown
DI
25
7
53.1
80.6
DeShawn Williams
DI
30
5
69.0
51.6
Yetur Gross-Matos
ED
25
5
59.3
58.9
Shy Tuttle
DI
27
7
56.0
67.1
Marquis Haynes
ED
29
78.0
37.2
Shaq Thompson
LB
29
5
7
56.0
90.3
Frankie Luvu
LB
26
6
7
51.5
90.1
Jaycee Horn
CB
23
8
5
73.2
54.2
Donte Jackson
CB
27
5
5
55.2
51.1
C.J. Henderson
CB
24
48.9
69.7
Jeremy Chinn
S
25
7
6
58.0
43.2
Vonn Bell
S
28
7
7
68.4
66.1
Xavier Woods
S
27
6
7
64.0
67.9
DC: Ejiro Evero (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Jaycee Horn
(will shadow on occasion), S Jeremy Chinn
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB C.J. Henderson
Summary: Evero may only be going into his second season as a
defensive coordinator, but he did well enough in his one year
with the Broncos to generate head-coaching interest around the
league. It remains to be seen whether the Panthers already have
the personnel to run Evero's favored 3-4 defense, although lining
up Williams, Tuttle and Brown next to each other is a great start
to freeing up the linebackers. Tuttle (305 pounds) and Brown (320)
are both well-equipped to handle the rigors of occupying multiple
blockers. Less congestion up front should allow Thompson to focus
more on being the strong coverage 'backer he was in 2021. As evidenced
by the two first-round picks the Rams were willing to give up
for him, Burns is a stud and figures to be the main reason the
switch to the 3-4 works for Carolina - assuming it does.
Perhaps even more important than Burns' presence is Horn's ability
to stay healthy. Horn has proven to be an elite cover corner when
he has been on the field, but playing 16 of a possible 33 games
through two seasons is not close to enough. (He played in 13 last
season.) Jackson and Henderson should be better than they have
been to this point, and it is worth wondering if the likely increase
of quarterback pressures up front in 2023 leads to either one
or both having career years. Carolina is legitimately four-deep
at safety, although a healthy Chinn (11 games last season) may
be as important as any Carolina defender. Keeping Horn and Chinn
on the field will also allow Jackson and Henderson the luxury
of playing against No. 2 and No. 3 receivers most weeks.
Chicago
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Justin Jones
DI
26
5
55.9
43.4
Andrew Billings
DI
28
7
69.3
72.3
DeMarcus Walker
DI
28
6
58.8
68.7
Gervon Dexter#
DI
21
Trevis Gipson
ED
26
5
54.3
39.7
Tremaine Edmunds
LB
25
7
6
90.0
60.1
T.J. Edwards
LB
26
7
7
78.4
79.0
Jack Sanborn
LB
22
6
6
67.8
53.6
Jaylon Johnson
CB
24
7
6
65.2
58.5
Tyrique Stevenson#
CB
23
5
5
Kyler Gordon
CB
23
6
5
46.4
65.8
Eddie Jackson
S
28
7
7
74.3
73.5
Jaquan Brisker
S
24
6
6
65.0
64.2
DC: Alan Williams (second year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Jaylon Johnson,
S Eddie Jackson
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Kyler Gordon,
CB Tyrique Stevenson
Summary: With the exceptions of trading away Robert Quinn and
Roquan Smith last season, the Bears may have upgraded at each
of the other five front-seven spots - either via experience in
Williams' defense or because of a talent boost. Billings can eat
up blockers, while Walker has flashed at times with Denver and
Tennessee. Edmunds may not be an upgrade on Smith, but he is a
good enough athlete to handle the Shaq Leonard role in this defense
at a high level. Edwards was also a huge addition for this defense
- both for the run and pass defense - following consecutive seasons
with at least 130 tackles with the Eagles. After three seasons
as a part-time player in Philly, he graded out at career-high
levels in his first full year as a starter in 2022.
The Bears were not expected to have a great defense last season
as it was, but it did not help matters for Johnson (six games),
Gordon (three), Jackson (five) and Brisker (two) to combine to
miss 15 games. There still is not enough pass rush to believe
Chicago will be even average defending the pass in 2023, but the
aforementioned quartet in the secondary at least gives the Bears'
front seven a fighting chance - assuming better injury luck -
to top last season's pathetic season sack total of 20 by mid-November.
Dallas
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Micah Parsons
ED
24
8
84.9
73.8
Mazi Smith#
DI
22
6
Osa Odighizuwa
DI
24
6
66.4
58.6
Demarcus Lawrence
ED
31
6
66.5
65.9
Dorance Armstrong
ED
26
73.5
57.3
Dante Fowler Jr.
ED
28
76.3
43.0
Leighton Vander Esch
LB
27
6
6
76.7
63.7
Damone Clark
LB
23
7
6
64.8
64.3
Stephon Gilmore
CB
32
8
6
81.1
65.6
Trevon Diggs
CB
24
7
6
67.0
66.2
Jourdan Lewis
CB
27
5
5
55.9
66.0
Malik Hooker
S
27
7
7
74.8
76.0
Donovan Wilson
S
28
6
6
65.9
74.6
Jayron Kearse
S
29
68.4
75.2
DC: Dan Quinn (third year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Stephon Gilmore
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Jourdan Lewis
Summary: Except for adding a 337-pound fire hydrant in rookie
first-rounder Smith, very little is changing up front for the
Cowboys. While the selection of Smith can be attributed at least
in part to helping Dallas defend the Eagles' rugby scrum quarterback
sneak play better, the truth of the matter is Dallas was a middling
run defense again last season. Having the ability to pair Smith
with fellow run-stuffer Jonathan Hankins should go a long way
in correcting that issue. Better run defense should only increase
the number of pass-rush opportunities for a deep and talented
defensive end group led by Parsons, Lawrence, Sam Williams and
Fowler.
Vander Esch and Clark are not elite in coverage, but the majority
of NFL running backs and tight ends will find it difficult to
shake them very often. The acquisition of Gilmore was a bit of
a risk given his age (turns 33 in mid-September), but one worth
taking if he still has another year of high-end play in his tank.
If Gilmore remains as sticky in coverage as he has been for the
better part of the last six years, it should give Diggs even more
opportunities to jump routes, which may be the role he is most
suited for - and not as the team's top corner. With Lewis and
DaRon Bland behind them, Dallas has some quality cornerback depth
if it should need it. The Cowboys also go three-deep at safety
with Kearse, Hooker and Wilson.
Detroit
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Aidan Hutchinson
ED
22
7
84.7
68.4
Isaiah Buggs
DI
26
60.2
47.0
Alim McNeill
DI
23
6
66.6
59.8
John Cominsky
ED
27
6
79.4
62.8
James Houston IV
ED
24
6
51.5
56.6
Alex Anzalone
LB
28
6
6
58.9
58.5
Malcolm Rodriguez
LB
24
55.1
66.4
Jack Campbell#
LB
22
7
6
Cameron Sutton
CB
28
6
6
70.4
73.6
Emmanuel Moseley
CB
27
6
6
73.5
58.6
Brian Branch#
CB
21
Chauncey Gardner-Johnson
S
25
6
5
66.2
54.7
Tracy Walker
S
28
6
6
75.4
58.5
Kerby Joseph
S
22
7
6
65.0
58.0
DC: Aaron Glenn (third year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: N/A
Prominent players to target in the passing game: LB Malcolm Rodriguez
Summary: It is hard to get a good read on just how bad the Lions'
run defense was last season (5.2 YPC allowed) in part because
they had the misfortune of facing Justin Fields twice (combined
279 yards rushing in two games against Detroit). With that said,
most of the team's improvement against the run during the second-half
surge appears to have been the product of jumping out on opponents
early. Make no mistake about it: the Lions did not do a lot to
address their front seven this spring other than parting with
DT Michael Brockers and adding a first-round linebacker in Campbell.
Detroit likely needs either McNeill to take another huge step
forward or 330-pound third-round pick Brodric Martin to fill Brocker's
shoes at the very least if it hopes to avoid getting pummeled
again on the ground in neutral game scripts.
The Lions' pass defense may have been the most pleasant surprise
down the stretch, as only two opponents topped 300 yards passing
during their 8-2 finish. The emergence of Houston - coupled with
the development of Hutchinson - played a huge role in this development.
Detroit spent a ton of resources trying to build on its progress,
including adding the freakishly athletic Campbell to a very capable
cover 'backer in Anzalone. The Lions overhauled their cornerback
room and will likely start Sutton and Moseley (replacing Jeff
Okudah and Amani Oruwariye). The surprise development of the offseason
may have been adding two highly capable cornerback/safety types
in Gardner-Johnson and Branch, each of whom can handle slot duties.
Green Bay
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Kenny Clark
DI
27
5
64.0
53.0
Tedarrell Slaton
DI
25
60.0
61.9
Devonte Wyatt
DI
25
6
60.6
60.9
Preston Smith
ED
30
6
61.4
64.1
Rashan Gary
ED
25
6
90.1
67.1
Lukas Van Ness#
ED
21
De'Vondre Campbell
LB
30
7
6
78.8
60.3
Quay Walker
LB
23
8
5
70.8
34.9
Jaire Alexander
CB
26
9
6
82.1
71.2
Rasul Douglas
CB
27
7
6
71.5
71.5
Keisean Nixon
CB
26
6
6
63.6
71.8
Eric Stokes
CB
24
60.3
33.8
Darnell Savage
S
25
6
5
43.8
56.2
Rudy Ford
S
28
6
5
77.8
58.9
DC: Joe Barry (third year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Jaire Alexander
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Keisean Nixon
Summary: Barry is likely on his last leg in Green Bay, as the
Packers have generally underperformed during his time in charge
despite having an abundance of highly drafted talent on that side
of the ball (seven first-round picks if we include 2023 first-round
pick Van Ness). Working against Barry is his apparent refusal
to be aggressive when the situation calls for it. The run defense
has been abysmal under Barry (4.7 YPC in 2021 - third-worst -
and 5.0 YPC in 2022 - fifth-worst) and little has been done to
address it through personnel. Considering Barry's defenses have
never finished higher than 23rd against the run (YPC), another
long year appears to be on the horizon for Green Bay's run defense.
Perhaps the only hope for the Packers is 2022 first-round selection
Wyatt approaches the level Clark played at during the early part
of his career.
Gary (ACL), Van Ness and Smith make for an exciting pass-rush
trio assuming Gary is good to go for Week 1. Unfortunately, Barry's
conservative play-calling vastly undermines Alexander's sticky
coverage skills. Douglas has come into his own with the Packers,
but he would likely benefit more from a more aggressive play-caller
too. Barry's play-calling also affects the play-making ability
of Savage.
LA Rams
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Byron Young#
ED
25
Aaron Donald
DI
32
8
61.4
75.6
Marquise Copeland
DI
26
6
60.3
73.5
Michael Hoecht
ED
25
6
58.6
66.3
Bobby Brown III
DI
22
6
60.0
62.1
Kobie Turner#
DI
24
Ernest Jones
LB
23
6
5
51.2
78.8
Christian Rozeboom
LB
26
5
70.0
Ahkello Witherspoon
CB
28
42.8
61.5
Derion Kendrick
CB
22
5
4
44.8
38.0
Cobie Durant
CB
25
6
6
74.3
58.3
Tre'Vius Hodges-Tomlinson#
CB
23
Jordan Fuller
S
25
6
7
55.4
76.2
Russ Yeast
S
24
5
7
47.1
85.9
DC: Raheem Morris (third year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: N/A
Prominent players to target in the passing game: Virtually every
back-seven defender is fair game, although Hodges-Tomlinson should
be a good slot corner sooner than later.
Summary: The fate of this defense rests largely on the shoulders
of 32-year-old Donald, as is typically the case. In the 10 full
games he played, the Rams yielded 100 yards rushing only three
times (95.3-yard average). In the other seven games (including
the Nov. 28 game against the Chiefs when he injured his ankle),
six opponents crossed the century mark (143.2 average). After
Donald, it gets dicey fast. Then again, injuries wreaked so much
havoc on this team in 2022 that many of the players above probably
deserve a pass for their grades. Second-round draft choice Young
can quickly become the second-best player on the front seven if
his athletic traits carry over. Perhaps that same athleticism
allows him to become a good coverage 'backer quickly, but the
outlook appears bleak for this unit to stop the run or defend
the bulk of capable running backs/tight ends this year.
While Jalen Ramsey did not play to his usual standards last season,
his trade to Miami leaves the Rams with a secondary full of potential
starters that have been selected on Day 3 over the last four drafts.
Durant (5-10) graded out well in 2022 but was limited to seven
games. Hodges-Tomlinson (5-9) is an athletic freak who should
become a solid slot NFL slot corner soon. Unfortunately, both
are a bit on the short side and could be liabilities if they get
isolated against the likes of DK Metcalf or Deebo Samuel very
often. Neither Robert Rochell (6-0) nor Kendrick (5-11) has played
well enough in their short time in the league to suggest they
can provide much help. The team picked up the 6-2 Witherspoon
in late June, but size may be his best quality. Fuller was limited
to 90 snaps last year; he may be the only player in the secondary
that gives the Rams any kind of hope entering the season.
Minnesota
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Danielle Hunter
ED
28
6
84.6
72.3
Harrison Phillips
DI
27
7
67.8
73.8
Khyiris Tonga
DI
26
7
73.3
Marcus Davenport
ED
26
7
72.4
69.7
Dean Lowry
DI
29
60.2
56.7
D.J. Wonnum
ED
25
57.1
60.2
Jordan Hicks
LB
31
6
7
52.5
80.2
Brian Asamoah
LB
23
6
7
78.1
74.2
Byron Murphy Jr.
CB
25
7
6
63.9
73.6
Mekhi Blackmon#
CB
24
4
4
Akayleb Evans
CB
24
5
5
40.5
76.0
Harrison Smith
S
34
7
6
69.1
64.0
Camryn Bynum
S
24
5
7
50.9
74.1
Lewis Cine
S
23
60.1
DC: Brian Flores (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Byron Murphy
Jr., S Harrison Smith
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CBs Mekhi Blackmon
and Akayleb Evans, S Camryn Bynum
Summary: While blitzing is not a magic elixir for a defense,
former DC Ed Donatell's blitz rate of 18.9 percent last year was
simply not enough. Enter Flores, whose Miami defense sent five
or more almost 40 percent of the time in his final year as the
head coach of the Dolphins. Perhaps the most difficult thing to
project in 2023 is whether the Vikings will be able to get into
enough third-and-medium or third-and-long situations to make Flores
look smart for being aggressive. Minnesota did not defend the
run particularly well with a more passive approach under Donatell
(4.5 YPC) and could be further taxed after losing Dalvin Tomlinson
to the Browns.
It will take a leap of faith for the Vikings to trust Asamoah
in a full-time role, but he flashed in coverage as a rookie in
2022 - albeit on 121 total snaps (63 in coverage). The idea of
pairing Hunter with Davenport would be appealing for a team with
a proven veteran secondary, but that duo's upside and patience
will be tested with this youthful set of cornerbacks. Minnesota
did well to replace Patrick Peterson with Murphy, but Evans, Andrew
Booth Jr. and Blackmon possess a whopping nine games of NFL experience
between them. At 34 years of age, Smith cannot be expected to
erase mistakes on the back end as often as he did five years ago.
Outside of Murphy, Minnesota figures to be a defense to exploit
for fantasy purposes - against the run and the pass.
New Orleans
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Cameron Jordan
ED
33
8
85.5
82.0
Khalen Saunders
DI
26
62.3
55.8
Nathan Shepherd
DI
29
6
60.0
58.6
Carl Granderson
ED
26
7
64.4
84.4
Payton Turner
ED
24
7
79.4
68.4
Bryan Bresee#
DI
21
Isaiah Foskey#
ED
22
Demario Davis
LB
34
7
7
79.8
73.6
Pete Werner
LB
24
6
7
69.5
59.8
Marshon Lattimore
CB
27
7
6
70.1
52.2
Paulson Adebo
CB
24
5
5
48.6
49.6
Alontae Taylor
CB
24
6
5
56.3
48.9
Tyrann Mathieu
S
31
8
6
87.9
62.9
Marcus Maye
S
29
7
7
71.3
67.2
DC: Joe Woods (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Marshon Lattimore,
S Tyrann Mathieu, S Marcus Maye, LB Demario Davis
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CBs Paulson
Adebo and Alontae Taylor
Summary: HC Dennis Allen will likely call the plays for the Saints,
but it would be an interesting development if Woods ends up running
the defense at some point because his conservative nature and/or
indifference against the run is a large part of the reason why
he was fired in Cleveland. With that said, a bigger issue for
New Orleans was losing proven run-pluggers David Onyemata and
Shy Tuttle in free agency this spring. Using a first-round pick
on Breese was a step in the right direction, although more is
needed; this defense ranked in the back half of the league in
stopping the run in 2022 (4.5 YPC). Jordan and Davis have been
consistently excellent for years now, so if the Saints get what
they expect from Breese and one of their two new arrivals inside
(Saunders and/or Shepherd), the run defense could return to the
high level of effectiveness it has enjoyed for most of the time
that Allen has been in charge.
Perhaps the biggest issue with New Orleans heading into 2023
is the lack of a second pass-rush threat after Jordan, although
Turner was drafted to be that guy two years ago. If Turner (eight
games) and Lattimore (seven) can stay healthier this year, then
the pass defense could also rebound from what was an up-and-down
campaign. Taylor flashed as a rookie, while Adebo finished better
than he started for the second straight year; both would benefit
from not lining up against the opponent's top receiver as often
as they had to in 2022. The safety position is in great hands
with Mathieu and Maye.
N.Y. Giants
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Kayvon Thibodeaux
ED
22
7
67.3
71.8
Leonard Williams
DI
29
7
64.2
66.3
Dexter Lawrence
DI
25
8
80.3
81.2
Azeez Ojulari
ED
23
53.0
52.4
A'Shawn Robinson
DI
28
7
60.8
68.7
Jihad Ward
ED
29
38.9
49.8
Jarrad Davis
LB
28
6
6
59.3
59.9
Bobby Okereke
LB
26
7
7
67.4
79.3
Adoree' Jackson
CB
27
8
5
71.0
62.7
Deonte Banks#
CB
22
5
5
Cordale Flott
CB
21
7
5
73.0
43.0
Xavier McKinney
S
24
6
6
58.8
58.3
Bobby McCain
S
29
7
5
69.5
33.9
DC: Don (Wink) Martindale (second year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Adoree' Jackson
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Deonte Banks
(at least early in the season)
Summary: The Giants have built an impressive starting defensive
line, amassing nearly a half-ton's worth of athletic humanity
among its top three linemen. Williams and Lawrence are both worthy
of commanding double teams against the run or the pass. Landing
Okereke in free agency to replace Jaylon Smith and push Micah
McFadden into more of a reserve role should only enhance a run
defense that should improve dramatically on its woeful finish
(5.2 YPC allowed) in 2022. New York may not quite be there yet
with its primary pass-rushers (24-year-old Ojulari and 22-year-old
Thibodeaux), but their time could come as soon as this season.
Martindale reportedly sees a bit of his former pupil in Baltimore
(Marlon Humphrey) in 2023 first-round pick Banks. If Martindale
ends up being right, he and Jackson could be the best cornerback
trio the Giants have had in a while. The primary area of concern
could be at the slot corner, although Flott performed well enough
last year to work his way into the nickel package eventually in
2023 - whether he ends up being the primary slot or pushes Banks
inside. The departure of S Julian Love to Seattle robbed this
secondary of a player who could line up just about anywhere and
do just about anything a team could ask from a defensive back
- a description that could easily apply to McKinney if he could
stay healthy. McCain is also a viable candidate to handle slot
duties at a reasonably high level.
Philadelphia
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Haason Reddick
ED
28
6
46.1
63.4
Jordan Davis
DI
23
8
60.0
72.2
Jalen Carter#
DI
22
6
Josh Sweat
ED
26
8
56.6
79.5
Fletcher Cox
DI
32
53.5
Brandon Graham
ED
35
79.5
69.7
Nakobe Dean
LB
22
7
7
75.8
69.6
Nicholas Morrow
LB
27
6
5
61.3
46.8
Darius Slay
CB
32
8
5
77.3
46.0
James Bradberry
CB
29
8
4
77.1
40.4
Avonte Maddox
CB
27
7
6
69.1
72.2
Reed Blankenship
S
24
7
8
70.8
89.4
Terrell Edmunds
S
26
7
6
68.0
63.4
Sydney Brown#
S
23
DC: Sean Desai (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CBs James Bradberry
and Darius Slay
Prominent players to target in the passing game: N/A
Summary: The move from Jonathan Gannon to Desai could actually
upgrade a defense that registered 70 sacks and pressured the quarterback
on 25.5 percent of drop-backs last year. Considering the talent
Gannon had at his disposal in 2022, Philadelphia's 4.6 YPC allowed
(ninth-most in the league) was inexcusable. With Davis entering
his second year and Milton Williams establishing himself as more
of a force on early downs, that number should come down a bit
under the direction of the more aggressive Desai. First-round
draft pick Carter could also quickly emerge as another player
on the front line that commands a double team. The biggest question
for this defense may be whether Dean is ready to fill the void
left behind by the ultra-productive T.J. Edwards. (He should be.)
It could be argued Philly's front four is even better than it
was in 2022, so Dean's job should be about as easy as any middle
linebacker's in the league.
The Eagles are almost as ridiculously deep and talented in the
secondary as they are up front. Opponents are more willing to
attack Slay than Bradberry, but neither option offers much upside
for quarterbacks. Maddox is one of the better slot corners in
the game right now, and Philly added two other big and talented
corners in Greedy Williams and fourth-round pick Kelee Ringo.
Former Steeler Edmunds may start the year for the Eagles, but
it may only be a matter of time before second-round selection
Brown overtakes him. Both he and likely breakout candidate Blankenship
can cover a lot of ground in center field AND make plays in the
running game. With the talent and depth in Philadelphia this year,
the Eagles are not a matchup fantasy managers want to see at any
position.
San Francisco
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Nick Bosa
ED
25
8
70.9
80.1
Arik Armstead
DI
29
6
59.6
55.9
Javon Hargrave
DI
30
6
60.9
49.0
Drake Jackson
ED
22
6
71.0
62.8
Javon Kinlaw
DI
25
59.8
28.8
Fred Warner
LB
26
8
8
80.4
89.7
Dre Greenlaw
LB
26
8
8
82.6
78.1
Oren Burks
LB
28
6
6
69.6
82.2
Charvarius Ward
CB
27
8
8
76.6
91.0
Deommodore Lenoir
CB
23
6
6
56.9
73.8
Isaiah Oliver
CB
26
7
7
72.2
81.5
Tashaun Gipson Sr.
S
32
6
7
60.7
89.9
Talanoa Hufanga
S
24
8
7
74.6
64.1
Ji'Ayir Brown#
S
23
DC: Steve Wilks (first year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Charvarius
Ward
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Deommodore
Lenoir
Summary: The loss of DeMeco Ryans will be felt on this unit,
but the 49ers possess far too much talent on defense to fall too
far and may benefit from a play-caller like Wilks who will likely
blitz a bit more. San Francisco finished in a tie with Tennessee
for the most dominant run defense in 2022 (3.4 YPC) and could
be poised for a more dominant campaign if Armstead and Kinlaw
can stay healthy. Warner, Greenlaw and Burks comprise one of the
best linebacker trios in the league - versus the run or the pass
- and obviously benefit from the presence of players like Bosa
and Armstead collapsing the pocket.
The reason the big offseason addition of Hargrave was not included
in the first paragraph is that he has mostly transitioned from
a run-stopper in the early part of his career to one of the best
at collapsing the pocket as a rusher. A healthy season from Armstead
or a breakout season from Kinlaw along with the continued excellence
Bosa provides would likely thrust this defense into another stratosphere.
Ward took his game to another level in his first season as a 49er
and is probably worthy of being considered a top 10-15 player
at his position right now. The most likely weak spots for this
defense are opposite Ward (likely Lenoir) and in the slot (Oliver
is expected to replace Jimmie Ward). Hufanga became a certifiable
stud in his second season and exhibits Troy Polamalu tendencies
at times. Gipson held up exceptionally well in his first year
with San Francisco and could have one more good year left in his
33-year-old body (in August). The 49ers should have his replacement
in Brown, who was a steal in the third round this spring.
Seattle
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Uchenna Nwosu
ED
26
7
64.9
73.8
Dre'Mont Jones
DI
26
5
61.3
41.8
Jarran Reed
DI
30
6
63.3
59.1
Mario Edwards Jr.
ED
29
6
53.7
72.7
Bryan Mone
DI
27
73.0
48.9
Derick Hall#
ED
22
Jordyn Brooks
LB
25
4
7
40.7
65.2
Bobby Wagner
LB
33
7
8
77.9
91.1
Tariq Woolen
CB
24
8
5
74.2
49.1
Devon Witherspoon#
CB
22
7
6
Coby Bryant
CB
24
6
52.2
66.6
Michael Jackson
CB
26
56.8
60.4
Quandre Diggs
S
30
7
7
75.0
65.0
Jamal Adams
S
27
5
7
81.0
58.0
Julian Love
S
25
7
6
70.9
55.5
DC: Clint Hurtt (second year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CBs Tariq Woolen
and Devon Witherspoon, S Quandre Diggs
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CBs Coby Bryant
and Michael Jackson
Summary: The Seahawks were among the worst run defenses in the
league last season (4.9 YPC) and it is hard to see where they
improved it much despite adding a wealth of talent to the first
level of the defense. Day 3 picks Cameron Young (fourth round)
and Mike Morris (fifth round) are Seattle's best hopes of it unless
Edwards can coax another decent year out of his 29-year-old body
(one that is playing for its seventh team). It would also help
if Reed could turn back the clock a few years or for Jones to
show something against the run. Bringing Wagner back for a second
tour of duty and adding Devin Bush will help matters, however,
and should somewhat offset two other potential soft spots - at
least early in the season - with Brooks (knee) and Adams (knee,
quad) recovering from serious injuries.
While the Seahawks' run defense has significant question marks,
it seems likely that the pass defense will rank among the best
in the league. Woolen was possibly the best late-round pick of
the 2022 draft and appears poised to be the best corner in the
Pacific Northwest since Richard Sherman. That assumes Devon Witherspoon
does not take that title from him though. This year's No. 5 overall
pick was arguably the most complete corner in the draft. Bryant
is going to be the weak link by default in this secondary because
his teammates are as rangy as they are good, but he should be
expected to take a moderate step forward in Year 2. Why? Because
Jones, Nwosu and second-round pick Hall should be able to put
more pressure on the quarterback than Seattle got in 2022. The
Seahawks' safety trio of Adams (when healthy), Diggs and the versatile
Love may be every bit as strong as their starting cornerbacks;
they could allow Hurtt to use "big nickel" as a regular
part of his game plan.
Tampa Bay
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Shaquil Barrett
ED
30
7
40.0
77.5
Vita Vea
DI
28
8
58.8
53.5
Calijah Kancey#
DI
22
Joe Tryon-Shoyinka
ED
24
6
69.3
63.2
Logan Hall
DI
23
59.1
30.2
Greg Gaines
DI
27
6
59.0
57.5
Anthony Nelson
ED
26
62.4
61.1
Lavonte David
LB
33
8
7
88.0
76.9
Devin White
LB
25
5
4
49.1
36.7
Jamel Dean
CB
26
8
6
75.6
82.5
Carlton Davis
CB
26
7
6
65.4
59.0
Dee Delaney
CB
28
5
5
67.6
50.7
Antoine Winfield Jr.
S
24
7
9
67.0
89.4
Ryan Neal
S
27
7
7
84.4
72.9
DC: HC Todd Bowles (fifth year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CBs Jamel Dean
and Carlton Davis, S Antoine Winfield Jr. and LB Lavonte David
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CB Dee Delaney,
LB Devin White
Summary: Kacy Rodgers and Larry Foote are listed as the team's
co-defensive coordinators, but Bowles remains very much in charge
of the defense. For the first time in what feels like a generation,
the Buccaneers were relatively lackluster in stopping the run
(4.5 YPC). It is hard to believe Tampa Bay will be better at stopping
the run this year without Akiem Hicks around, but the team's thinking
could be that it will be better off with a younger and more durable
Gaines instead. More importantly, Vea needs to stay on the field.
In the four games he missed or barely played last year, the Bucs
surrendered an average of 149.3 yards on the ground. Vea commands
double teams. His presence allows White and David to flow to the
ball. If Vea stays healthy, Tampa Bay will stop the run better
in 2023.
David is also exceptional in coverage, so it could be a long
day for running backs and tight ends who typically thrive over
the middle of the field. Tampa Bay did well to keep Dean from
leaving in free agency. Along with Davis, they form one of the
stronger starting cornerback duos in the league and allow Bowles
to bring pressure as he sees fit (28.3 percent blitz rate last
season). Delaney gets the unenviable task of trying to replace
Sean Murphy-Bunting as the preferred slot corner, although Delaney
got a taste of it last year when Murphy-Bunting was sidelined.
Without question, he will be the corner quarterbacks will target
the most. Tampa Bay caught a break when Seattle unexpectedly cut
Neal early in free agency. He is a more-than-capable replacement
for Mike Edwards (Chiefs) alongside Winfield, who is another defender
opponents will take steps to avoid most weeks.
Washington
Player
Pos
Age
23 Cov
23 Run
Cov Grade
Run D Grade
Chase Young
ED
24
8
85.3
73.9
Jonathan Allen
DI
28
6
61.5
66.5
Daron Payne
DI
26
5
54.9
49.5
Montez Sweat
ED
26
8
76.5
79.6
Phidarian Mathis
DI
25
61.9
James Smith-Williams
ED
25
56.9
58.8
Jamin Davis
LB
24
6
6
56.4
66.1
Cody Barton
LB
26
6
6
49.6
62.7
Kendall Fuller
CB
28
8
7
75.4
73.6
Emmanuel Forbes#
CB
22
6
4
Jartavius Martin#
CB
23
5
5
Benjamin St-Juste
CB
25
6
6
60.0
50.4
Darrick Forrest
S
24
7
7
69.0
63.2
Kamren Curl
S
24
7
8
80.8
80.5
DC: Jack Del Rio (fourth year)
Prominent players to avoid in the passing game: CB Kendall Fuller,
S Kamren Curl
Prominent players to target in the passing game: CBs Jartavius
Martin and Benjamin St-Juste
Summary: The Commanders boast four first-round picks along their
starting defensive line. While none of them was necessarily drafted
for their run-stuffing abilities, it is slightly troubling the
team has not been consistently dominant stuffing the run. (Last
year's 4.4 YPC allowed was tied for 15th in the league.) One major
issue has been keeping the defensive ends on the field, as Sweat
missed six games in 2021 and Young has been sidelined for 21 of
33 possible games since his impressive rookie season in 2020.
Assuming Sweat and Allen stay on the field and join relative ironmen
Allen and Payne, Washington should be much stingier against the
run. Their health also will obviously affect how well Davis and
free-agent addition Barton hold up. There is a decent chance the
front four's health and two years of NFL experience will allow
Davis to break out in 2023. Bear in mind that he was once considered
a first-round talent in part due to his coverage abilities.
Washington spent its first two picks this spring at cornerback,
which says a lot about what the team thought was its biggest weakness
in 2022. Fuller continues to play at a high level and remains
locked into one cornerback spot. First-round draft choice Forbes
could be this year's Trevon Diggs; he consistently displayed the
kind of anticipation and ball skills in college that should translate
to the NFL. He will also be playing in a defense that should generate
a lot of pressure with a four-man rush. The Commanders added Martin
in the second round this spring. He could battle St-Juste for
primary slot duties. It should not take long before opponents
target one of them instead of Fuller and Forbes. Curl broke out
in a big way in his third year last season, and it should come
as no surprise if fellow safety Forrest follows suit in his third
season.
As promised, here are my projected grades for each team's defense
(pass rush, run defense and coverage). A red shade means that
defense is not very favorable for the opponent, yellow is slightly
unfavorable, white is slightly favorable and green is very favorable.
Pass Rush Projected Grades
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
49ers
7.75
Bills
7.00
Chargers
6.75
Chiefs
6.25
Commanders
7.75
Bengals
7.00
Patriots
6.75
Saints
6.25
Browns
7.50
Lions
7.00
Falcons
6.50
Buccaneers
6.25
Eagles
7.50
Dolphins
7.00
Ravens
6.50
Panthers
6.20
Vikings
7.25
Titans
7.00
Texans
6.50
Rams
6.20
Giants
7.25
Cowboys
6.75
Jaguars
6.50
Bears
6.00
Jets
7.25
Broncos
6.75
Raiders
6.50
Seahawks
6.00
Steelers
7.25
Packers
6.75
Colts
6.25
Cardinals
5.50
Run Defense Projected Grades
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
49ers
10.00
Eagles
9.36
Cowboys
9.09
Lions
8.82
Steelers
9.91
Vikings
9.36
Browns
9.08
Bills
8.68
Commanders
9.71
Titans
9.36
Panthers
9.08
Texans
8.67
Dolphins
9.45
Broncos
9.36
Jaguars
9.05
Rams
8.64
Falcons
9.45
Colts
9.29
Seahawks
9.05
Bears
8.63
Giants
9.41
Ravens
9.23
Saints
9.04
Packers
8.23
Buccaneers
9.41
Bengals
9.18
Chiefs
8.91
Chargers
8.21
Patriots
9.40
Jets
9.09
Raiders
8.86
Cardinals
7.77
LB Coverage Projected Grades
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Packers
7.50
Giants
6.50
Vikings
6.00
Cardinals
6.00
49ers
7.33
Buccaneers
6.50
Titans
6.00
Colts
5.67
Ravens
7.00
Eagles
6.50
Broncos
6.00
Texans
5.67
Bengals
7.00
Cowboys
6.50
Jets
6.00
Falcons
5.50
Browns
7.00
Lions
6.50
Saints
6.00
Panthers
5.50
Chiefs
7.00
Steelers
6.00
Bills
6.00
Jaguars
5.50
Bears
6.67
Commanders
6.00
Rams
6.00
Seahawks
5.50
Dolphins
6.50
Patriots
6.00
Chargers
6.00
Raiders
4.50
CB Coverage Projected Grades
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Jets
8.00
Patriots
7.00
Titans
6.67
Cardinals
6.00
Eagles
7.67
Broncos
7.00
Texans
6.67
Falcons
6.00
Packers
7.33
Bills
7.00
Panthers
6.50
Jaguars
6.00
Browns
7.33
Seahawks
7.00
Ravens
6.33
Steelers
5.67
Dolphins
7.33
Chargers
6.75
Commanders
6.25
Colts
5.67
49ers
7.00
Giants
6.67
Bears
6.00
Raiders
5.67
Bengals
7.00
Buccaneers
6.67
Lions
6.00
Vikings
5.33
Chiefs
7.00
Cowboys
6.67
Saints
6.00
Rams
5.33
Safety Coverage Projected Grades
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Team
Gr
Ravens
8.00
Broncos
7.00
Jets
6.50
Lions
6.33
Patriots
7.50
Bills
7.00
Dolphins
6.50
Packers
6.00
Titans
7.50
Chargers
7.00
Chiefs
6.50
Bears
6.00
Saints
7.50
Buccaneers
7.00
Giants
6.50
Jaguars
6.00
Steelers
7.50
Texans
7.00
Cowboys
6.50
Colts
6.00
Eagles
7.00
Panthers
7.00
Cardinals
6.50
Bengals
5.50
Browns
7.00
Commanders
7.00
Vikings
6.50
Raiders
5.50
49ers
7.00
Falcons
7.00
Seahawks
6.33
Rams
5.50
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and has appeared as a guest analyst on several national sports radio shows and podcasts, including Sirius XM's Fantasy Drive, FantasyPros and RealTime Fantasy Sports. He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.