Hints, Allegations and Things Left Unsaid
9/8/09
With apologies to one fine album from Collective Soul, sometimes
all us fantasy football writers have are those three things. Our
job is mostly centered on "hinting" which players may
do well and the allegations that follow from our adoring readers
when they don’t pan out. The things left unsaid speak for
themselves. All kidding aside, what we can do is focus on the "hinting"
part of our job and be thorough enough with our research so the
last two don't come into play all that often. For the purposes of
this article, I will be throwing out a lot of hints and, this week
anyway, laying the allegations at the feet of some untimely moves
in Florida, Missouri and New York over the past week, all while
keeping the words I would really like to say to three organizations
to myself.
There used to be a time (last year and all the years prior to
2009, to be exact) when "Cutdown Day" meant only marginal
or overpriced NFL players were handed their walking papers. Apparently,
now the same can be said for offensive coordinators. In the final
week of the preseason, three play callers were given the axe over
a five-day span. (With that kind of heat on the OC's, don't think
for a second that fantasy football writers have it any different.
After all, a bad preseason by any one of us leads to the same
kind of mocking and hatred that play callers encounter when they
confront their fans after a few scoreless quarters.)
In all seriousness, though, has the NFL reached the breaking
point? In other words, can three franchises honestly say that
- in the same week no less - each of them realized the man they
entrusted to run their offense in January or February is no longer
fit to do so now, less than two weeks before the start of the
season? Football - more than any other sport - needs continuity
on both sides of the ball for a team to achieve and maintain any
degree of consistent success. This is particularly true on offense
as team execution is a must; very rarely can a player "freelance"
and hope to help his team move the ball down the field. On the
other hand, a player like Junior Seau made a living - especially
early on in his career - by working outside the framework of the
original defensive call. The point to be made here though is that
someone (typically an OC) is the one man responsible for overseeing
the offense's ability to execute on a daily basis. It is quite
possible whatever hope that Tampa Bay, Kansas City and Buffalo
had on offense this year is no more (at least for the Bucs and
Bills anyway).
Haley v. Gailey
In the case of Todd Haley v. Chan Gailey, I suppose it was only
a matter of time before Haley exerted his power. While Haley and
Gailey both led productive pass offenses last season, Haley doesn't
exactly strike me as the type of coach who wants to share much
of anything, including any credit he may get this year for getting
more production out of a Chiefs' offense than most people expect.
Of the three coordinator firings this week, this one should concern
fantasy owners the least. While Haley and Gailey shared similar
offensive approaches with their teams last season, the former
is a more aggressive play-caller in general and he probably did
not want to waste any time in making sure his players and bosses
understood that if the team is going to lose this season, they
are going to go down swinging.
Schonert, Really?
The most senseless firing to me is that of Turk Schonert in Buffalo.
If unemployment was his ultimate destination, it could have been
realized at the end of last season when the Bills' offense was
dreadful. Instead, Buffalo allowed Schonert to install the no-huddle
and spend countless hours diagramming ways to use Terrell Owens
and Lee Evans in a fast-paced attack. Realistically, could an
OC who likely spent the spring building his pass offense around
Owens be expected to get a great deal of production from his offense
in the preseason after his offensive centerpiece goes down to
a toe injury after the first series or two in the Hall of Fame
game? Furthermore, Schonert probably also had his mind on how
the running game was going to function without Marshawn Lynch
for the first three games of the season. In an interview with
a Buffalo TV station on Saturday, the former OC stated his side
of the story, which essentially boiled down HC Dick Jauron's feeling
that Schonert was using too many formations and that he needed
to simplify things. (This from the man who kept John Shoop, quite
possibly the worst play caller in all my time of watching the
NFL, around for three years in Chicago because his conservative
schemes were just what Jauron wanted.) Apparently, Trent Edwards
and Lee Evans led the movement of offensive players who made their
concerns about Schonert known to Jauron. When those complaints
were met with owner Ralph Wilson's agreement, change happened.
QB coach Alex Van Pelt and RB coach Eric Studesville take over
for Schonert and, while I didn't think the world of the latter
as an OC, I sincerely doubt the new OC combo has been burning
the midnight oil with their offseason preparations in hopes that
Schonert would get canned at the end of the preseason. Van Pelt's
only play-calling experience came with the Frankfurt Galaxy in
2005 (they went 3-7 that season) while Studesville spent most
of the last decade in his current position. In my mind, Buffalo
has gone from potential fantasy goldmine in the offseason to a
near wasteland. As of right now, Terrell Owens is the only player
in Buffalo I would feel comfortable starting on my fantasy team...and
that may be only as long as he stays healthy. Congrats, Bills
players...go make offensive magic happen now with two coaches
with next-to-no experience and no past success in their current
role.
At the expense of sounding like I'm piling on, the release of
Dominic Rhodes on Saturday is further proof to me that the Bills
don't know where they are going right now. A team letting go of
their fourth-best RB is not surprising, but cutting him after
proclaiming him as a strong veteran influence who will help reduce
wear-and-tear on Lynch AND doing so right before the starter begins
his suspension is puzzling. Fred Jackson and Xavier Omon are fine
players, but given the team's offensive line woes, the Bills may
need a third RB by the time Lynch is ready to return.
This One Grinds My Gears
The firing that gets me the most is the one in Tampa Bay with
Jeff Jagodzinski. Firing a coordinator for a lack of "precision"
and then suggesting he may be a better fit as a head coach is
essentially telling the rest of the league that he is clueless
at running an offense and has trouble dealing with authority.
The more notable problem here is that the Bucs failed Jagodzinski
and the entire team in the interview process. If the team did
not want to fully embrace a deep passing game and a zone-based
running game, the team shouldn't have felt compelled to hire Jagodzinski
because he was a "name coach". Now, the team must continue
applying Jagodzinski's principles without him or switch back to
the power-based running and short-passing game that Jon Gruden
ran for most of the last decade. Either way, nothing in Greg Olson's
(the new OC) resume suggests to me that he was qualified to run
another offense anytime soon after showing very little in stops
in Detroit and St. Louis.
Besides offering my opinion on what appears to be a rather senseless
and disturbing trend in the NFL, I detail the OC departures to
reinforce how delicate the balance is between making sure you
- the fantasy owner - pick the best players for your team while
also recognizing that same player's stock can fluctuate drastically
based solely with a change at the offensive coordinator position.
My other purpose for such a lead-in is to transition ever so smoothly
into some bold predictions for the 2009 season, which may become
even bolder now considering that 9% of the league's offenses changed
hands in less than five days.
Note: All
predictions/assumptions will be based on 12-team leagues that
start 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR and 1 TE.
Quarterbacks
Of the quarterbacks going after the 12th round,
Jason Campbell and Joe Flacco have the best chance to emerge as
a starting-caliber fantasy QBs.
Jason Campbell: Ready to explode on the
scene?
Starting with Jason Campbell, he has most of the requirements
necessary to finally explode onto the scene: two above-average
options in the passing game (Santana Moss, Chris Cooley), good
pass-catching RBs and a willingness to take what the defense gives
him (no INTs and 66% completion percentage through the first half
of last season). What he didn't have last season was experience
in Jim Zorn's West Coast offense or the faith from his head coach
to show off his arm, both of which he should have this season.
Everyone else that could have used another year in the system
in 2008 (second-year players Malcolm Kelly, Devin Thomas and Fred
Davis to name a few) should now be more adjusted to their surroundings
as well. But this prediction is based more on what any talented
player can do when his environment isn't changed from year to
year. And since we have already seen what Campbell can do when
he is in the same offense for more than one year (which has only
happened once in his college and pro career), it wouldn't come
as a terrible shock if he came fairly close to the 20:7 TD:INT
ratio he had in his breakout season with Auburn in 2004.
As far as Joe
Flacco goes, I'm choosing to put a lot of faith in OC Cam
Cameron. Quite often in his college and pro career, Cameron's
presence on a team's sidelines has resulted in a QB enjoying a
career year or coming pretty close. Without getting too deep into
his bio, he was the QB coach in Washington when Gus Frerotte made
his only Pro Bowl and also ushered in Trent Green's emergence
into the public's consciousness. After a five-year stint at Indiana
University when he made Antwaan
Randle El a household name as a QB, he returned to the NFL
to help push Drew Brees from possible second-round disappointment
to what he has become today. Heck, in his lone disastrous year
in Miami, he even made Cleo Lemon a usable fantasy QB! Getting
now to his work in Baltimore, Cameron appears willing to back
off the 600 rush-attempt goal of 2008 and let his second-year
QB open things up a bit more. I, like many others, felt early
on the Ravens’ preseason aerial display (37 attempts/game was
fourth in the league) may have just been an attempt to save the
RBs and work out the kinks in the passing game. I no longer feel
that way for a number of reasons, one of which is Ray
Rice's ascension to near-feature back status. Because Le'Ron
McClain will move to more of a fullback role this season, it's
safe to say that the Ravens' rush attempts will come down dramatically
as neither Rice nor Willis
McGahee figure to come all that close to 300 carries, much
less both of them. And given Rice's receiving abilities, it would
be foolish not to use him in that capacity more often. Lastly,
Derrick
Mason and Todd
Heap appear to be healthy while L.J.
Smith was added to complement Heap and help Flacco use the
whole field in 2009, as opposed to the routes outside the hashes
Cameron called for most of last season.
Running Backs
Out of the group of Ronnie Brown, Kevin Smith
and Ray Rice, at least two out of the three will emerge into fantasy
first rounders next season.
I've been firmly on board of the Ronnie
Brown bandwagon for some time now. I can't help it - I guess
- I'm just a fool for a 27-year-old, 230-pound RB who can catch
the ball and is in the best shape of his career. Prior to his
ACL injury in 2007, Brown was living up to his immense potential
as a complete back. Granted, that season came under the watchful
eye of Cameron, who just happens to oversee more productive fantasy
RBs than just about any other OC in recent memory. So while I
won't predict a return to the 2,288 total-yard, 11-TD pace he
was on in 2007, he should be the focal point of a power-running
game that should only get better in 2009. Ricky
Williams is another year older (32) and is unlikely to steal
another 161 carries and 29 catches from Brown again. Brown won't
keep Williams on the sidelines full-time, but Williams will probably
see his 2008 workload cut by a third in both the rushing and receiving
departments. If that scenario shakes down as I expect it to, Brown
would come close to 300 carries and 50 catches, totals that would
make him a PPR beast and solid RB1 in non-PPR leagues.
Much like Brown, Kevin
Smith should be able to ditch his biggest fantasy handicap
- namely, the other RB in the rotation. That Smith was so productive
last season - over 1,200 yards and eight scores in part-time duty
- on a winless team that had to abandon the run early in many
of its games speaks to his immense potential. With Rudi Johnson
out of the picture and OC Scott Linehan now in it, it would come
as little shock if Smith neared 350 touches in 2009. There are
a handful of opponents that make me cringe a bit (Pittsburgh and
Minnesota during the fantasy regular season and Baltimore in Week
14), but all told, it is hard not to like a runner who is going
to be so involved in his offense at a RB2 price.
With each passing day, I seem to become more enamored with Ray
Rice. Just this past Sunday, I chose him over a host of other
backs (Ryan Grant, Clinton Portis, Pierre Thomas and Smith to
name a few) in a big-money PPR league. The thing is, I’m starting
to believe his ceiling is Steve Slaton-kind of high. Heading into
the season, it appears as if Le'Ron McClain will indeed see most
of his time at fullback and Willis
McGahee could get worked in for a series here and there. And
if the preseason was any indication, McGahee may get the majority
of goal line carries. But if Cameron's history comes into play
as I think it will, Rice will emerge as a true feature back before
the end of the season. He's a fair bet to surpass 50 catches,
making him a very tempting RB2 in PPR leagues as is, but give
him 200-225 (or more) carries behind Baltimore's solid offensive
line and it wouldn't come as a complete surprise to see him surpass
the 1,000-yard mark on the ground. Perhaps he becomes little more
than a real poor man's Tiki Barber (ton of total yards but very
few scores), but the fact is he will lead the team in touches
and he will probably do so by a wide margin.
Jamaal Charles' fantasy production will either
nearly meet or exceed that of backfield mate Larry Johnson in
PPR leagues.
Based on what I saw in the preseason, it wouldn't be all that
shocking if Jamaal
Charles bested LJ in non-PPR as well, but I'll save that for
prediction for a prognosticator bolder than I am. (Although I'm
willing to roll the dice, I also know when to pull my money off
the table!) For the time being, we'll stick with PPR. While it
is convenient for me to use Haley's previous team as an example,
I think the Edgerrin James-J.J. Arrington arrangement from last
year applies here. From what I could tell during the exhibition
season, Johnson's role appears to be limited to when the offense
is "on schedule" (1st-and-10, 2nd-and-six, 3rd-and-2 or better).
Anything more than those distances seems to be Charles’ domain.
Considering the Chiefs will not be “on schedule” all that often,
working out of the spread a high percentage of the time and trailing
late in games, I tend to believe Charles will see the field at
least half the time. So if he can stay healthy all season, it
would not be the least bit surprising to see him catch 50+ passes.
Since LJ won't be hauling in many passes of his own or rushing
for many TDs, Charles may just win the fantasy battle between
the two.
Wide Receivers
Larry Fitzgerald will struggle being the most
productive fantasy WR...on his own team.
Let's get the most telling stats out there right away. Larry
Fitzgerald led Cardinals WRs in fantasy points on five occasions
last season, three of which occurred in the four games Anquan
Boldin missed. Worse yet, half of Fitz's 12 TDs were scored in
those same four weeks. Meanwhile, Boldin was Arizona's best fantasy
WR in seven of the 12 regular season games that he suited up for
in 2008. It's not easy for me to try to make Fitzgerald sound
bad because he is arguably the most consistent fantasy WR in the
game today. But with that said, there is no way I can recommend
him being the #1 WR taken in drafts after reviewing the aforementioned
numbers. Furthermore, Boldin averaged more than one target/game
more than Fitzgerald did last season. While I'll admit that doesn't
sound like much, those are not the numbers you want to see in
a player that you will need to spend a mid-first round pick on
to put on your roster.
Roy Williams will have the second-best season
of his career and will still be labeled as a "bust"
by the national media and fantasy owners alike.
Roy Williams: A bust for all the right
reasons.
Only once in Roy
Williams career has he surpassed 69 catches or 1,000 receiving
yards. He has yet to score 10 times in a single season. I mention
those numbers only as a reminder of the worst season Terrell
Owens posted as a Cowboy, a season during which many observers
noted that T.O. had lost a step. While Williams' 82-1,310-7 line
in 2006 serves as a reminder of what he is capable of when healthy,
it also spotlights the fact that he will need to come pretty close
to matching his career high every year he is in Dallas to make
the media forget about Owens. Yes, Tony
Romo has established himself as an upper-echelon QB, but unlike
the T.O. years, the Cowboys plan on being a running team this
season and Jason
Witten will remain his first option on most passing plays.
So while it is not right and it certainly is not fair, Williams
will need to overcome the team's new offensive philosophy, Romo's
affinity for Witten and his own injury history if he has any hope
of not being labeled a disappointment. That's a lot for one man
to overcome and it's probably not going to happen in 2009.
Tight Ends
Todd Heap will re-emerge as a top-15 TE once
again, barring injury.
It has come to my attention that this column is taking a Baltimore
tint, but the 2009 Ravens don't figure to be as much like the
2008 Ravens as most of us assumed going into the season. No, Baltimore
will not throw 40 times a game like it did in the preseason, but
the offense will open up more in Flacco's second season. Part
of the "opening-up" process includes throwing the ball
over the middle on a regular basis, which makes the TE a much
more likely option than he was a season ago. Now, I'll be the
first to admit that I don't typically recommend injury-prone TEs
who have to fight for catches with other injury-prone TEs (L.J.
Smith), but the preseason showed us that Todd Heap looks more
like his younger self this season than he has in a while and that
Flacco will look for him in the red zone. HC John Harbaugh echoed
those sentiments as well at the start of training camp, telling
the Baltimore Sun, "We want to definitely expand him in the
passing area. We want to control the middle of the field with
our passing game, and Todd Heap has got to be a big part of that."
I'm not sure a return to Pro Bowl form is in the cards for Heap,
I'd take the over on a 50-550-5 stat line from him this season.
Kevin Boss will make me regret not putting
him on the Big Boards.
Am I already having second thoughts on the Big
Board? Well, maybe not so much at the top, but somewhere down
the line, I'm getting a bad feeling the "Boss" is going
to make me look bad. My reasoning for not giving Kevin Boss any more
credit pre-Big Board was sound - my strong impression of Travis
Beckum stealing his work in the passing game from the H-back spot
- but then the rookie saw very limited work - two catches - in
the preseason. Although I still expect Beckum to be fantasy-worthy
at some point this season, Boss is one of the few trustworthy
options Eli Manning has entering this season. And Manning clearly
trusts Boss in the red zone (six TDs last season led all Giants
receivers in 2008), so I may need to swallow my pride and admit
that Beckum may not emerge as Eli's favorite TE target until 2010.
Miscellaneous
Percy Harvin and Aaron Curry will be the 2009
Offensive and Defensive Rookies of the Year, respectively.
The temptation to take the easy way out and select a RB as the
2009 Offensive ROY was tantalizing, but not a single rookie RB
even has a clear path to a full-time job (like Matt
Forte last season). Donald
Brown, LeSean
McCoy, Knowshon
Moreno, Chris
Wells, Shonn
Greene and even James
Davis all have the talent to succeed right away, but no one
from that group is any better than option 1A or 1B in their teams'
RB plans. Yes, the same could also be said for Steve Slaton and
Chris Johnson in 2008, but both Slaton and Johnson played on teams
with better run-blocking lines or stronger running game approaches.
The Colts, Eagles and Cardinals all figure to be pass-heavy teams
once again while the Broncos and Browns may not be strong enough
defensively to keep their RBs in the gameplan for four quarters.
Only Greene strikes me as the lone rookie that has the right combination
of playing in a run-heavy offense and a formidable offensive line,
but he stands third on the depth chart and is extremely limited
as a receiver. At QB, the Jets' offensive approach almost disqualifies
Mark Sanchez
as a ROY candidate, and while Calvin Johnson can do a lot of things
for a QB, I'm not sure he alone will be enough to help Matthew
Stafford's candidacy. The rookie WRs appear to be a mess with
Darrius
Heyward-Bey a definite project and Michael
Crabtree a definite holdout. So, by process of elimination,
Percy Harvin
is my choice to win the award. It's been pretty clear from the
outset that Minnesota intends to showcase his talents all over
the field. And as we all know, it is much easier for a player
to produce when he has opportunity and the team believes in his
talent. After watching how the Vikings plan to use him in the
preseason, I have no problem endorsing him as a WR3 in 12-team
PPR and non-PPR leagues and expect him to meet or exceed the projections
I placed on him in July.
Because fantasy football is primarily an offensive showcase,
we don't usually take much time to discuss impact players on defense.
Much like RB, picking a LB to win the ROY award is not taking
a great leap of faith. But unlike the offensive side of the ball,
I don't see too many challengers for Aaron Curry except maybe
the Bengals' Rey Maualuga or the Rams' James Laurinaitis. Maualuga
would have likely been my #1 choice, but his numbers will be stunted
by starting the season out on the strong side instead of in the
middle, meaning his tackle numbers will be down. Laurinaitis,
on the other hand, will be working in the middle, but probably
won't have the protection up front a MLB needs or play on a good
enough team to catch the eye of the voters. I'm not sure I expect
the world from the Seahawks, but the fact that Seattle intends
to use Curry as a pass rusher in addition to his normal linebacking
duties leads me to believe one of the best prospects at his position
to come out of the draft in recent years will be taking home the
hardware at the end of the season.
And with that, I am happy to announce that the next time fantasy
owners tune into this column, we will have seen each team kick
off in what is one of the best weekends in sports each year. I
will also be moving from Tuesdays to Thursdays in an effort to
adequately prepare each of you for the upcoming week of NFL action.
Since it also appears as if I will be free on Saturdays this fall,
I am contemplating ending each column this season with a "College
Spotlight" in which I highlight a player I watched over the
past weekend who I feel may be of some help to fantasy owners
in 2010 or beyond.
In the meantime, go pick up Cadillac
Williams like I advised you to do a week or so ago as he was
placed atop the Bucs' most recent depth chart on Monday. Since
Tampa Bay appears to be committed to a 2-2-1 split of RB carries
to open the season, Williams may get enough playing time to use
in a flex spot. But whatever happens with the Bucs’ RB rotation,
I assure you that starting NFL RBs are better off on your fantasy
bench than in someone else's lineup. Always consider potential
trade value! For example, if your WR5 is unlikely to see your
starting lineup and is just taking up a bench spot, then adding
someone like Williams makes a lot of sense because in 2-3 weeks,
he could bring back a WR3 or low-end TE1 in return from a desperate
owner.
|