This is a 12-team, serpentine draft with
16 rounds to field a 1 QB / 2 RB/ 3 WR/ 1 TE/ 1 K/ 1 DEF line up.
The scoring
system is standard.
Here are the owners, the order they drafted, and how many times
their peers gave their team a top four voting after reviewing the
draft.
9-Route |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Adrian Peterson (MIN) |
8 |
MIN |
1.01 |
WR |
Braylon Edwards |
5 |
CLE |
2.12 |
WR |
T.J. Houshmandzadeh |
8 |
CIN |
3.01 |
RB |
Darren McFadden ® |
5 |
OAK |
4.12 |
TE |
Kellen Winslow |
5 |
CLE |
5.01 |
RB |
Rashard Mendenhall ® |
6 |
PIT |
6.12 |
WR |
Anthony Gonzalez |
4 |
IND |
7.01 |
QB |
Matt Hasselbeck |
4 |
SEA |
8.12 |
RB |
Pierre Thomas |
9 |
NO |
9.01 |
DEF |
Minnesota Vikings |
5 |
|
10.12 |
RB |
Tim Hightower ® |
7 |
ARI |
11.01 |
WR |
James Jones |
8 |
GB |
12.12 |
WR |
Ted Ginn Jr. |
4 |
MIA |
13.01 |
QB |
Trent Edwards |
6 |
BUF |
14.12 |
K |
Nate Kaeding |
9 |
SD |
15.01 |
RB |
Kenny Watson |
8 |
CIN |
16.12 |
|
Team Name: 9-Route
Owner Name: Rinku
Dhawan
Draft Spot: 1.01
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? Selecting first overall allowed
me the opportunity for a super foundation with either Tomlinson
or Peterson. From there, my desire was to build a balanced roster
with potential top 3 players at the major positions. However,
with 4 QBs selected among the first 23 selections overall, it
was difficult to place the cogs into my plan.
I selected Peterson due to the Sam Bouie effect. The first 3 players
in the 1984 NBA draft were Hakeem Olajuwon, Michael Jordan (both
voted among the sport’s 50 greatest players of all-time),
and the other guy, Sam Bouie. Yes, the Portland Trailblazers general
manager passed on Jordan and instead selected Bouie. Ouch. Tomlinson
has been great (and of course is no Sam Bouie), but I don’t
want to be the guy who missed out on the first 2400-yard (and
record breaking) rushing season by a running back. Is Peterson
capable of this? Sure he is. What is the likelihood of this? Slim
to none. Is the point of fantasy football to be entertained? Sure
it is. Will Peterson keep me excited, and my opponents jaw-dropped
all season? Absolutely!
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I liked the “style” of my team the most.
In baseball, a lineup of DiMaggio, Gwynn, and Rose would be great
at manufacturing runs with consistent, steady hitting. Instead,
I assembled the equivalent of Bonds, Ruth, and Aaron---home run!
I love the explosive big play capability of Peterson, McFadden,
and Edwards. What is better than having your weekly opponents
shudder at the sound of FOX commentator Joe Buck chiming in with
a “GameBreak”, then curse and endure watching your
player sprint 65-yards for a touchdown? Having them endure it
3 times!
3. What did you like the least?
Despite the youth and big play ability, my team is largely assembled
with unsure bets, something upon which I generally frown. Mendenhall,
Thomas, Hightower, and Gonzalez all have veterans ahead of them
in their respective situations.
4. Who was your best value? Hasselbeck
falling to me in the 8th round was a gem. Mike Holmgren clearly
has a passing team now, and Hasselbeck posted career highs in
yards and touchdowns last season. I know there are injuries at
their receiver position (which probably scared other owners away),
but I like the depth of guys like Burleson, Taylor, and Obomanu.
5. Who was your biggest reach? I
reached for Pierre Thomas in the 9th round. I like his huge potential
in the potent New Orleans offense, but other players with a little
more certainty were available, including Maurice Morris, Bradshaw,
Cutler, and Favre.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were already picked?
I wanted Fred Taylor at the end of the 8th round. He was selected
about 7 picks ahead of my selection.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding yours)
and give a brief explanation why?
Dallas Dynasty: A great team anchored by explosive Romo, a deep
running back stable with Lynch and Jacobs supported by Fred Taylor
and Maurice Morris, and he even handcuffed his franchise back
with Fred Jackson. Burress, White, and Berrian are all WR1s, and
Dallas Clark remains a 10-touchdown threat.
Warbirds: I am regarded as the WR-General of fantasy football,
so I obviously loved the opening swing pair of Owens and Wayne.
The HB duo of Turner and White will get lots of carries and be
solid. Gonzalez is as steady as they come at tight end. He obviously
loved Schaub as a breakout QB, but I like Favre and Chambers with
great upside.
Husky Jerks: The HB corps is great and potentially great. Addai
is a top3 player to me, and the McGahee/Rice situation seems ready
to burst onto the fantasy stat scene with new offensive coordinator
Cam Cameron. Bowe will be steady in a new Chan Gailey pass game,
and I saw a lot of promise from Kevin Walter at Texans Training
Camp 3 weeks ago. Aaron Rodgers may not have Favre’s polish,
durability, or win record, but he will log good stats in a potent
pass attack. The tight ends are reception (Daniels) and touchdown
(Miller) specialists.
Hellboy: a potentially explosive squad. I am among the believers
in the Browns continuing their ascent, so Anderson is a top QB
to me. Barber is a stud touchdown producer in all of fantasy football,
and adding the home run threat in Felix Jones was a nice touch.
Many believe that Jonathan Stewart was the rookie HB to snag ahead
of my own McFadden; he will at least see a lot of Stephen Davis-esque
goal line opportunities. Colston is poised to improve for another
great season, and Steve Smith is still a speed demon. Vincent
Jackson could benefit if Gates’ toe hampers him; Utecht
is an intriguing touchdown threat in the Bengal red zone pass
game.
Team Marx |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
LaDainian Tomlinson |
9 |
SD |
1.02 |
QB |
Drew Brees |
9 |
NO |
2.11 |
WR |
Chad Johnson |
8 |
CIN |
3.02 |
RB |
Reggie Bush |
9 |
NO |
4.11 |
WR |
Donald Driver |
8 |
GB |
5.02 |
WR |
Santana Moss |
10 |
WAS |
6.11 |
TE |
Jeremy Shockey |
9 |
NO |
7.02 |
RB |
Justin Fargas |
5 |
OAK |
8.11 |
WR |
Jerry Porter |
7 |
JAC |
9.02 |
DEF |
San Diego Chargers |
7 |
|
10.11 |
WR |
Sidney Rice |
8 |
MIN |
11.02 |
RB |
Steve Slaton ® |
8 |
HOU |
12.11 |
WR |
Deion Branch |
4 |
SEA |
13.02 |
RB |
Jamaal Charles ® |
6 |
KC |
14.11 |
WR |
Muhsin Muhammad |
9 |
CAR |
15.02 |
K |
Taylor Mehlhaff ® |
9 |
NO |
16.11 |
|
Team Name: Team Marx
Owner Name: Mark Shutters
Draft Spot: 1.02
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it?
In the two prior mocks I was selecting at the tail end of the
first round and knowing the elite RB’s would be gone my
strategy was to go WR-WR and build a team around that. In this
final mock I was dealt the #2 overall pick. Given that I was going
to get either Peterson or Tomlinson, my strategy obviously changed
in this draft. I still feel that outside of the first several
RB’s that there isn’t much difference in a 2nd round
RB and a 4th round RB. In reviewing 12-team ADP’s I felt
I could simply go best available player until my starting lineup
was filled and wind up with a very good team of starters. The
only drawback to this strategy looks to be RB depth but with some
sleepers lurking I thought I could pull it off.
With the #2 overall pick I felt fortunate enough to have Tomlinson
fall to me here. Had he not, I would have taken Westbrook. Maybe
I’m over-thinking this, but I like RB’s on teams with
balanced offenses. Minnesota doesn’t fit this bill. Plus
I’m still not sold on Peterson’s durability for a
full season. Fortunately for me it’s a decision I didn’t
have to make. I know Tomlinson’s nearing the end of his
prime, but I think he’s got one more year comparable to
last season in him.
With pick 2.11 I chose to go with Drew Brees. I actually have
Brees at #3 on my QB board and with only him and Carson Palmer
remaining on the board as elite QB’s I pulled the trigger
here. It turned out to be a mistake, as Palmer didn’t go
until 5.07. But sticking with my strategy of drafting the most
productive player, I feel Brees will outscore the three RB’s
picked just ahead of him and QB won’t be a position I have
to worry about this season.
With pick 3.02 I grabbed WR Chad Johnson. Andre Johnson was up
for consideration, but I don’t like the risk of him not
finishing a season and I like the Bengals’ offense better
than Houston’s for productivity and scoring chances. This
gives me a very good WR to go with my elite RB and QB. (Note –
I just watched CJ being helped off the field in their pre-season
game tonight)
It’s a long wait picking and the ends, and as I waited
I watched every RB whom I thought might fall to me for my #2 RB
come off the board. It was looking like my strategy may have backfired
but a strange thing happened. No one wanted Reggie Bush. I even
had to do a quick search before I pulled the trigger on him at
4.11 to be sure he hadn’t suffered and injury that I missed.
I’m not sure how this worked out but I’m happy to
have him as my RB 2.
Coming back at 5.02 I went with WR Donald Driver. This is well
higher than his ADP, but I feel with an unproven QB that Driver
will be the go-to guy in Green Bay. In addition I’m not
sold on Jennings’ health for a full season.
Given that this league starts three WR’s I felt the need
to grab my third WR at 6.11. Santana Moss had the most potential
of any left on the board and hopefully with a more imaginative
offensive coach, Moss will be utilized to his full ability and
be a capable WR 3.
Turning around at 7.02 I wanted to grab my starting TE. At this
point there were two I felt good about. Cooley and Shockey. In
retrospect I wish I’d have gone with Cooley, but I’ll
take Shockey because I think he becomes the #2 receiving option
on that team. However it gives me three Saints so I’m really
depending on New Orleans offense to be very good.
That completed my starting lineup outside of DST and Kicker.
I then proceeded to fill out my depth. I was happy to get Justin
Fargas at 8.11 as I think he’ll remain a part of the Raiders
plans even with McFadden. I also took the first DST off the board,
grabbing the Chargers DST at 10.11. I know you don’t go
DST early, but why take another mediocre WR when I can grab one
of the top units from last season with a soft schedule this year.
Looking at my week one starters (Brees, Tomlinson, Bush, Chad
Johnson, Driver, Moss, Shockey, Chargers DST) I feel I executed
the strategy well of grabbing the best available players to fill
out my starting roster spots.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I like the starting
lineup. I have 4 players that are more than likely to finish at
the top 5 in their position (Brees, Tomlinson, Chad Johnson, and
the Chargers DST). I have above average players at TE and RB #2
in Bush and Shockey. Driver and Moss aren’t my ideal WR#2
and #3 but I’m satisfied with them in this deep of a league.
3. What did you like the least? My RB depth. While I was drafting
starting WR’s and TE’s, other teams were grabbing
their RB #3 and #4. So when it came time to address my RB depth
there wasn’t much to choose from. I was happy to get Fargas
where I got him. My last two RB’s are simply guys whom I
have a suspicion will see some playing time early in the season.
Steve Slayton and Jamaal Charles are both Rookies whom fit the
role of 3rd down back, meaning they’ll at least get on the
field for 5 or more touches potentially. Slayton arguably could
contribute more as Ahman Green will be hurt before the end of
September and there isn’t much in front of him on Houston’s
depth chart.
4. Who was your best value? Clearly Reggie Bush. Getting him at
the VERY end of the 4th round was more that I could have hoped
for here. The next three RB’s selected were Selvin Young
(16 games? I wouldn’t bet on it), Matt Forte (The Bears
might not score 16 points all year), and Jonathan Stewart (Could
be more productive, but will probably not come early in the season).
I didn’t want to have to count on one of those guys each
week. Bush is a player whom I feel I can start each week at RB#2
without too much worry. He’s not a #1 RB, but he’s
a good #2 RB for a team where I ignored the RB 2 position until
the 47th overall pick.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Donald Driver in the early 5th
may be a pick I regret. There were several other WR’s who
have more upside and there were a couple of RB’s still on
the board who could have greatly improved my depth here. I don’t
regret the pick now, but I certainly may if his performance declines
again this season.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? I was
hoping LenDale White would fall to me in the 4th, but he went
11 picks earlier. Ray Rice is another RB that I think will have
an impact sooner than most think. He went 2 picks before I was
ready to grab him. Jerricho Cotchery is another player I thought
I could get later in the draft but apparently others feel as I
do that he’ll be the primary benefactor of Favre’s
abilities.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding yours)
and give a brief explanation why?
First I’ve got to say that there was a lot less separation
between the top four teams as it took me quite a while to pick
my top four. All the teams are pretty close. That being said…
Rookies – I think they got great value where they drafted
McNabb and Delhomme. I think that combination should be good to
start most of the season. He has great RBs in Grant and Westy
plus some depth with Selvin Young. WR’s are not great but
not bad with Andre Johnson anchoring and Burleson and Bryant Johnson
starting. Hopefully one of those two has a very productive season.
Cooley is a top 5 TE. My only question is the skins DST. I think
there were better available and the Skins play in a division where
all the offenses are above average.
The Prototype – Got the best value of the draft at the
QB position in Carson Palmer in the 5th round. Has 5 RB’s
that will start on opening day –the question is, how long
will those guys start. Larry Johnson and Thomas Jones are locks,
but Ahman Green, Duce McAlister, and Rudi Johnson all have playing
time issues. However we’re talking about depth here not
starters for his team. He also managed to get great WR’s
with Randy Moss, Boldin (another steal for where he was picked),
and Coles anchoring the team. The only issue I have is Heap at
TE. This guy doesn’t do the 16-game schedule and I don’t
want to pay the price you have to pay to get him for him to then
miss half the season.
Hellboy – My evaluation of this team hinges on the performance
of Mr. Anderson. I think he’ll be close to his stats from
last season, but it’s tough to evaluate with only a year
in the league. If he’s back this is a strong team. I like
the RB trio of Willie Parker, whom is undervalued, Marion Barber
and Jonathan Stewart. Throw in Chris Perry who could see an increased
role in Cincy and he’s as deep at RB as any team in this
league. Steve Smith is a big question at WR but if he gets his
act together Smith paired with Colston makes for a great WR duo.
WR 3 is suspect but every team is going to have a suspect position
in this league. I like the potential of Utecht at TE as well.
He’s an unknown but if the Bengals utilize his skills he
could be productive in that offense.
Compiler Guy – I think the QB’s are the biggest question
on this team as Cutler and Young are both still developing and
I’m not exactly sure either of them is what you’d
want to count on as your starting QB. This is another team with
Great RB depth. Portis and Graham are solid starters. Kevin Smith
looks to be the primary back in Detroit and Ricky Williams is
arguably the best RB in Miami. The WR’s are no slouch either
with Fitzgerald, Jennings and the potential of Calvin Johnson.
This may be the best starting WR trio in the league.
Rookies |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Brian Westbrook |
7 |
PHI |
1.03 |
RB |
Ryan Grant |
8 |
GB |
2.10 |
WR |
Andre Johnson |
8 |
HOU |
3.03 |
QB |
Donovan McNabb |
7 |
PHI |
4.10 |
RB |
Selvin Young |
8 |
DEN |
5.03 |
WR |
Nate Burleson |
4 |
SEA |
6.10 |
TE |
Chris Cooley |
10 |
WAS |
7.03 |
WR |
Bryant Johnson |
9 |
SF |
8.10 |
QB |
Jake Delhomme |
9 |
CAR |
9.03 |
WR |
Donte’ Stallworth |
5 |
CLE |
10.10 |
RB |
Brandon Jackson |
8 |
GB |
11.03 |
WR |
Jabar Gaffney |
4 |
NE |
12.10 |
WR |
Derek Hagan |
4 |
MIA |
13.03 |
RB |
Derrick Ward |
4 |
NYG |
14.10 |
DEF |
Washington Redskins |
4 |
|
15.03 |
K |
Josh Brown |
5 |
STL |
16.10 |
|
Team Name: Rookies
Owner Name: Chris Eakin
Draft Spot: 1.03
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? I was going to take whatever RB fell out of AP, LT, and Westbrook.
With no hold out I would have considered Steven Jackson instead.
At 2.10 and 3.03 I wanted to get a top WR and either another RB
or WR depending on who fell at RB on the return. After that my
strategy is to just target values and players I want that fill
depth needs. Drafting near the end of serpentine formats I often
reach a round early on players that I covet otherwise they usually
don’t make it back to me.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I’m feeling
good about my RBs and QBs. Ryan Grant I consider a top 10 RB and
he was the last RB on the board coming back to me at 2.10 I thought
more valuable than a second WR. I was a little surprised he fell
and couldn’t pass on him. Selvin Young has potential to
start for my team and be explosive so having a starter (for Denver)
that’s not expected to share carries a great deal and is
great to have as a backup. I prefer a guy like him at RB#3 over
many of the young rookies that may or may not get enough carries
to start on a weekly basis. At QB both McNabb and Delhomme will
be interchangeable top 10 starters with top 5 potential at their
position.
3. What did you like the least? I reached for McNabb on my 4th
pick. I knew I wanted him but there were still guys like Anderson,
Palmer, and Roethlisberger on the board so I could have gotten
away with taking my WR#2 here instead and picked up either Driver,
Jennings, or Welker and still had a shot at him. I just didn’t
want to risk losing out on those 2nd tier QBs. As a result I never
got back on track with my WR position. Burleson is a great WR#3
but a slight reach for a WR#2. If he plays well than I’m
going to have a real solid team.
An interesting note: When I realized I was weak at WR I really
thought things were going bad, and that’s the second time
this has happened to me around rd 5-7. I then started peeking
at everyone else’s teams to see how bad I was looking and
every team seemed to have a hole as big or potentially worse than
mine, which was the case last time we drafted. One, having played
mostly 10 team leagues there’s a tendency to feel this way
in 12-team leagues and two, there are always good values to fill
in your depth later in the draft if you are prepared so don’t
panic if you miss a few guys at a position.
4. Who was your best value? Well, getting a Selvin Young and the
2000 yards he guaranteed for my fifth pick certainly qualifies.
Ryan Grant for the 22nd overall pick is solid as well. For my
late rounds I really like Derek Hagan in the 13th round. I think
he’s going to start next to Ginn Jr. and he will catch a
lot of balls with Chad Pennington now at QB. He could be an equivalent
to a Jerricho Cotchery from last year but with better red zone
ability. People forget what a stud he was at ASU.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Some would consider McNabb a reach
at 4.10 but I had him last season and down the stretch he was
a big part of my championship. All we heard was how it takes two
years coming back and this is year two the last time I checked.
He will be good, no doubt. Nate Burleson for WR#2 I discussed
earlier but at the time my choices were Santana Moss, Laveranues
Coles, and Hines Ward. Moss is too inconsistent, Ward is not the
#1 option anymore and I don’t trust Brett Favre this year.
Burleson is the #1 option on a team that will throw as much as
any team in the NFL this year and he has had some solid years
in the past.
6. Which players did you covet but
were already picked? Boy, Wildman was killing me all night.
I really expected and hoped Jamal Lewis be my RB#2 when he plucked
him. He also grabbed Robert Meachem later, which left me dazed
and confused as to whom to take instead. He couldn’t have
slept well with that much guilt. One main cause for my reach at
McNabb was due to that Coxsackie Virus grabbing Jason Witten two
picks before me. I feel better now that I called him a name though.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding yours)
and give a brief explanation why?
Wildman - If Marvin Harrison is 80% of what he was pre-injury
then that shores up his only weakness. I absolutely love his back-up
RBs in Chris Johnson and DeAngelo Williams. They could be explosive
if the cards fall right. Roethlisberger to Holmes is a lethal
combo.
Compiler Guy- Now I know where all my receivers went. They were
compiled here. (Cheesy I know) His RB depth is great with 3 starters
and two guys with big upside in Ricky Williams and Chris Brown.
He handcuffed his top pick in Portis as well. Nice job here. He
needs Jay Cutler to perform, but over the course of a season his
overall depth will show.
Husky Jerks – This a good job drafting. His RBs are handcuffed
with guys that can perform if need be and his WRs will be solid
once Marshall comes back. My only concern would be two unproven
commodities at QB in Leinart and Rodgers but both have hordes
of talent around them to succeed so it’s likely one of them
will.
Hellboy - When Steve Smith comes back he will pair him with Colston
and have a top WR core. I thought Willie Parker was really getting
undervalued this year and it seems I’m not the only one.
Fast Willy and Marion Barber at RB give me the chills. Between
Chris Perry and Jonathan Stewart I like the odds of one of them
being a breakout to provide depth. I’m not sold on Derek
Anderson but I think it’s because he looked like a newborn
moose at Oregon State and now he’s changed but my mental
picture of him hasn’t. If he performs again then this is
a playoff team.
Husky Jerks |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Joseph Addai |
4 |
IND |
1.04 |
RB |
Willis McGahee |
10 |
BAL |
2.09 |
WR |
Brandon Marshall |
8 |
DEN |
3.04 |
WR |
Dwayne Bowe |
6 |
KC |
4.09 |
WR |
Wes Welker |
4 |
NE |
5.04 |
RB |
Edgerrin James |
7 |
ARI |
6.09 |
WR |
Hines Ward |
6 |
PIT |
7.04 |
RB |
Ray Rice ® |
10 |
BAL |
8.09 |
TE |
Owen Daniels |
8 |
HOU |
9.04 |
QB |
Aaron Rodgers |
8 |
GB |
10.09 |
RB |
Dominic Rhodes |
4 |
IND |
11.04 |
DEF |
New England Patriots |
10 |
|
12.09 |
TE |
Heath Miller |
6 |
PIT |
13.04 |
QB |
Matt Leinart |
7 |
ARI |
14.09 |
WR |
Kevin Walter |
8 |
HOU |
15.04 |
K |
Phil Dawson |
5 |
CLE |
16.09 |
|
Team Name: Husky Jerks
Owner Name: Mike Krueger
Draft Spot: 1.04
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it?
Picking from the fourth position, I was looking for an RB with
minimal risk while not overextending myself on a quarterback.
Having a chance at Brady, Manning, or even Romo in Round 2 wasn’t
likely (turns out I was right), so I wanted to concentrate on
building depth at the running back and receiver positions and
grab my QB late. Mission accomplished.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I was able to
execute my pre-draft strategy, which doesn’t happen very
often. Outside of a couple players I missed out on, this draft
played out like I thought it would.
3. What did you like the least? A couple of my targeted players
were snaked from me, but that’s to be expected, especially
with this group of seasoned ff’ers. My one strategic blunder
was taking TE Owen Daniels at 9.04 while still needing a starting
QB. Jay Cutler was my target and while I’m perfectly happy
getting Aaron Rodgers a round later (10.09), I could have let
Daniels go (Heath Miller was still available at 13.04) and grabbed
Cutler as my starting QB.
4. Who was your best value? RB Edgerrin James’ current ADP
is 5.08 for twelve-team leagues. I was able to get him at 6.09
as my third running back. He’s not a touchdown machine and
despite being on the wrong side of thirty, he is a starter, and
you can’t beat that value.
5. Who was your biggest reach? I would say Brandon Marshall at
3.04 but actually the selection of Willis McGahee at 2.09 is quite
risky considering his recent surgery. I had a choice between him
and Ryan Grant, but I took the gamble with Willis with every intention
of grabbing Ray Rice a round or two early as a handcuff.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? As
much I love Brandon Marshall, I was hoping Andre Johnson would
slide to me in Round 3. The Rookies took him one pick ahead of
me. Having gambled on Marshall, I wanted to add a quality #4 wideout
with upside potential later in the draft. My target was Justin
Gage or Steve Smith (NYG) but having to take Ray Rice a round
or two early and the questionable decision of Daniels at 9.04,
allowed Dallas Dynasty and Compiler Guy to nab these wideout prospects
in front of me.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding yours)
and give a brief explanation why?
The Rookies – He’s solid at all positions expect wide
receiver but that can quickly be fixed with an early-season waiver
wire pickup. If Grant and Westbrook stay healthy, this is likely
a playoff team.
Wildman – I love the DeAngelo Williams pick and think he
will pay great dividends. Again, wide receiver is the position
with the most question marks, but a return to form by Marvin Harrison
makes Wildman look like a draft-day genius.
Compiler Guy – I think Jay Cutler will be Mike MacGregor’s
starting QB before he knows it. I really love the upside potential
of his backs (Kevin Smith, Ricky Williams, Ladell Betts) and receivers
(Calvin Johnson & Steve Smith). This could be one of the deepest
teams in the league by Week 4.
Warbirds – You have to love running Owens and Wayne out
there every week, especially in a three-wideout lineup. Tack on
one of the best fantasy tight ends (Gonzalez) and you’ve
got the makings of a contender. His QBs and RBs won’t knock
your socks off but I’m more comfortable with Schaub and
LenDale White than most. LaMont Jordan was a great value pick
and could be a huge asset late in the season.
Coxsackie Virus |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
QB |
Tom Brady |
4 |
NE |
1.05 |
RB |
Maurice Jones-Drew |
7 |
JAC |
2.08 |
WR |
Torry Holt |
5 |
STL |
3.05 |
TE |
Jason Witten |
10 |
DAL |
4.08 |
RB |
Matt Forte ® |
8 |
CHI |
5.05 |
WR |
Jerricho Cotchery |
5 |
NYJ |
6.08 |
RB |
Julius Jones |
4 |
SEA |
7.05 |
WR |
Patrick Crayton |
10 |
DAL |
8.08 |
RB |
Ahmad Bradshaw |
4 |
NYG |
9.05 |
WR |
Javon Walker |
5 |
OAK |
10.08 |
DEF |
Dallas Cowboys |
8 |
|
11.05 |
RB |
Leon Washington |
5 |
NYJ |
12.08 |
WR |
James Hardy ® |
6 |
BUF |
13.05 |
QB |
Philip Rivers |
9 |
SD |
14.08 |
DEF |
New York Giants |
9 |
|
15.05 |
K |
Robbie Gould |
8 |
CHI |
16.08 |
|
Team Name: Coxsackie Virus
Owner Name: Antonio
Arcangelis
Draft Spot: 1.05
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? With the fifth pick, I had to select either the odd man out
of the top five running backs (Tomlinson, Peterson, Westbrook,
Addai and Steven Jackson) or go in a different direction –
there’s just not enough value in taking Marshawn Lynch,
Marion Barber or even Frank Gore in that spot. In a PPR, I’d
have seriously considered Moss or even Steven Jackson, but taking
the best QB in football coming off a landmark year seemed like
the safest bet. The rest of my draft strategy followed pretty
closely in line with my standard philosophy – load the team
with as many talented young backs as possible and get value wherever
I could find it.
I ended up with a few of my targets – including Maurice
Jones-Drew, Jerricho Cotchery, Matt Forte, and Ahmad Bradshaw
– and snagged #3, #4, and #5 WRs with what I consider to
be a much-better-than-average upside in Patrick Crayton, Javon
Walker, and James Hardy. For me, drafting from the fifth spot
with this bunch was much more difficult than I had anticipated.
The staff at fftoday.com is especially adept at finding value
in unlikely positions and keying on backs that offer intriguing
possibilities.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I like having
Brady backed up by a seriously undervalued Philip Rivers, two
great defenses (Cowboys and Giants) that I can use on a matchup-to-matchup
basis – largely depending on the protection offered by the
opposing team’s offensive line, since most team defenses
score points by getting to the QB – and a very deep bench
at RB. I’m not overly enthusiastic, but I feel like I did
well out of the tricky #5 slot.
3. What did you like the least? My WRs may have upside –
but there’s a ton of risk in taking Crayton and Javon Walker
at #3 and #4. And while I’ll argue that adding Brett Favre
boosts Cotchery’s value from a typically strong #3 to a
#2 WR, the guy needs to get into the end zone since this isn’t
a PPR league. And in my backfield, Jones-Drew hasn’t yet
proven he’s a reliable #1 RB – but he was the best
available value when my second round pick finally got back to
me.
4. Who was your best value? I snagged Ahmad Bradshaw at 9.05 and
was once again happy to do so. The defending Super Bowl champs
have a ton of offensive weapons, but they’re still running
the football and Brandon Jacobs has proven he’s not going
to shoulder the burden alone. He has the potential to be a quick
hitter, can see the holes and will be a fantasy goldmine if and
when Jacobs goes down. Obviously, Javon Walker in Round 10 is
a steal if he plays at half his potential in ’08. Rivers
(14.08) will offer some trade value if the Chargers get off on
the right foot, the Giants D in the second-to-last round is a
steal, and Leon Washington (12.08) is a sleeper that I’ve
always been high on.
5. Who was your biggest reach? My biggest reach was probably Tom
Brady – but only if he fails to throw at least 35 TDs. Anything
more than that, and I’ll consider it a solid pick. I felt
happy to get Julius Jones in Round 7, but that’s a reach
based on his current depth chart status behind Maurice Morris.
Hopefully he’ll get a shot to start by Week 1. Also –
Crayton at 8.08 playing for a Dallas team loaded with other options
(TO, Jason Witten, Barber, Felix Jones) could prove to be a pointless
pick that early when more proven WRs were lurking, including the
likes of Joey Galloway, Isaac Bruce and Jerry Porter.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? Wow
– too many to list here, but I remember hoping either Houshmandzadeh,
Chad Johnson or Andre Johnson fell to me in the third (which they
didn’t – thanks fellas), preparing to come back with
either Santonio Holmes or Plaxico Burress in Round 4 (nope) or
pull either Chris Johnson or Ray Rice in Round 9 (Waldman and
Krueger saw to it I didn’t). I was also ready to back up
Jason Witten with Heath Miller when Krueger did it to me again
in Round 13.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding
yours) and give a brief explanation why?
1. 9-Route - Rinku did quite well from the #1 slot, easily drafting
the team with the most upside and potential to blow out fantasy
opponents with Adrian Peterson, Braylon Edwards, Housh, Darren
McFadden, Kellen Winslow, Rashard Mendenhall as his #3 RB and
Matt Hasselbeck as his QB. It’s hard to find anything wrong
with the guy’s technique from the #1 slot, aside from possibly
his #1 pick – a debate that will probably engage us all
until the fantasy playoffs are upon us.
2. Team Marx - There’s a ton of major scoring potential
in any lineup that includes Tomlinson, Drew Brees and Reggie Bush.
At WR, Chad Johnson, Donald Driver and Santana Moss provide a
solid starting three, and there’s lots of value with his
bench WRs – Porter, Sidney Rice and Deion Branch. Shockey’s
a nice compliment to the receiving corps and his DEF – the
Chargers – is one of the best in fantasy football.
3. The Prototype - He’s stacked at WR – Randy Moss,
Anquan Boldin, Lavernues Coles at 1-3 with Engram probably returning
as a starter once he’s back from injury – and all
the other moving parts are there, including a solid QB in Carson
Palmer and serviceable RBs in Larry Johnson, Thomas Jones and
Rudi Johnson – who’s not dead yet. He gets a small
ding for only having four RBs – I like to draft five –
but that’s nitpicking.
4. GWave - With Peyton Manning, good running backs, and Antonio
Gates at TE, this is a strong team. His bench is especially strong,
considering Ronnie Brown is his third RB and Jacob Hester –
possible trade fodder for a deal with Team Marx, is his fifth
back.
GWave |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Steven Jackson |
5 |
STL |
1.06 |
QB |
Peyton Manning |
4 |
IND |
2.07 |
RB |
Laurence Maroney |
4 |
NE |
3.06 |
WR |
Roy Williams (WR) |
4 |
DET |
4.07 |
TE |
Antonio Gates |
9 |
SD |
5.06 |
WR |
Lee Evans |
6 |
BUF |
6.07 |
RB |
Ronnie Brown |
4 |
MIA |
7.06 |
WR |
Joey Galloway |
10 |
TB |
8.07 |
RB |
Jerious Norwood |
7 |
ATL |
9.06 |
WR |
Reggie Brown |
7 |
PHI |
10.07 |
DEF |
Chicago Bears |
9 |
|
11.06 |
RB |
Jacob Hester ® |
9 |
SD |
12.07 |
K |
Nick Folk |
10 |
DAL |
13.06 |
WR |
Devin Hester |
8 |
CHI |
14.07 |
TE |
Tony Scheffler |
8 |
DEN |
15.06 |
QB |
Kurt Warner |
7 |
ARI |
16.07 |
|
Team Name: GWave
Owner Name: Dennis Dies
Draft Spot: 1.06
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it?
I tried to follow the same strategy I tried in an earlier mock
and that was to try and get a high profile player at each position
without sacrificing too much depth. I followed my strategy for
the most part, but looking back, there were definitely some opportunities
to stray from that strategy that I didn’t take advantage
of.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? Landing a top
QB is always a goal for me and I feel like I have one of the best
in Manning. Peyton will once again finish at the top of the league
and is always tough to match up against on a week-to-week basis.
3. What did you like the least? Depth is always a concern when
you go after high profile QB’s and I was once again very
surprised to see some very talented signal callers fall further
than I expected.
4. Who was your best value? Had Steven Jackson been in camp and
since day one, he probably would have gone 3 picks earlier. Calling
a 6th round pick may not be considered “value”, but
he has the potential to finish as the #1 RB when the season is
over.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Manning in the middle of round
two could be considered a reach when you look at the talent that
went 3-4 rounds later, but his consistency is unparalleled at
the position.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? I
was hoping for a little more depth at running back and Lendale
White was a player I was saving a roster spot for…unfortunately
I waited a round too long.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding yours)
and give a brief explanation why?
1. 9-Route. Very strong team with Peterson, Edwards, Housh and
Winslow. If McFadden pans out, he will be very tough to beat.
2. Wildman. Has a very deep team, especially at running back.
3. Prototype. A very solid starting lineup with some depth.
4. Tie. Husky Jerks & Team Marx. Both have a decent squad
but depth could haunt them.
The Prototype |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
WR |
Randy Moss |
4 |
NE |
1.07 |
RB |
Larry Johnson |
6 |
KC |
2.06 |
RB |
Thomas Jones |
5 |
NYJ |
3.07 |
WR |
Anquan Boldin |
7 |
ARI |
4.06 |
QB |
Carson Palmer |
8 |
CIN |
5.07 |
RB |
Rudi Johnson |
8 |
CIN |
6.06 |
WR |
Laveranues Coles |
5 |
NYJ |
7.07 |
TE |
Todd Heap |
10 |
BAL |
8.06 |
WR |
Bobby Engram |
4 |
SEA |
9.07 |
RB |
Deuce McAllister |
9 |
NO |
10.06 |
QB |
Marc Bulger |
5 |
STL |
11.07 |
DEF |
Baltimore Ravens |
8 |
|
12.06 |
RB |
Ahman Green |
8 |
HOU |
13.07 |
K |
Adam Vinatieri |
4 |
IND |
14.06 |
DEF |
Indianapolis Colts |
6 |
|
15.07 |
WR |
Josh Morgan |
9 |
SF |
16.06 |
|
Team Name: The Prototype
Owner Name: T.J.
Thomas
Draft Spot: 1.07
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? I believe sticking to my board early on and just picking the
value that falls to me was important and I think a thorough look
at my draft will reveal I did just that. With my first three picks,
I landed players I have listed at #5 (Moss), #8 (Larry Johnson)
and #20 (Thomas Jones) overall. It was tough for me to go with
Moss over Gore in Round 1, but I just felt Moss would be more
of a "sure thing" than Gore.
Additionally, I have no problem counting on LJ as my #1 RB with
Moss already on the roster. Beyond that - and having several days
to consider what I would do with my early picks - I knew I would
go with Brees or Thomas Jones - who I have a late second-round
grade on - with my third-rounder assuming he was still there.
After that, it was simply a matter of following my board and then
listening to my gut on any close calls.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? As much as I
try not to develop a bias for any certain player, I have become
quite enamored with Jones...and that was before Brett Favre came
onto the scene; I would be happy with Chester Taylor-like production
- circa 2006 - from him. I use the Taylor example because much
like Taylor, the Jets added a potential Hall of Fame guard (Alan
Faneca; Vikings added Steve Hutchinson a few years), FB Tony Richardson
(who blocked for Taylor in 2006 and Adrian Peterson in 2007).
Unlike Taylor, Jones has the benefit of Brett Favre's big arm
now, which will back off defenses even more off the line of scrimmage
and, with Faneca and Richardson, will probably raise his per carry
by a yard from 3.5 last season.
Additionally, I continue to be surprised Palmer can make it into
the fifth round (more on that below). Lastly, I was quite pleased
to land Rudi Johnson as my #3 RB. People are scared off by his
hamstring injury from last season as well as his cumulative workload
and the presence of Chris Perry. While the Michigan alum may eventually
steal the job from Rudi, I need to see Perry stay healthy for
an extended amount of time before I really get too worried. Despite
how good Perry has looked so far, Johnson is still the only power
rusher that the Bengals have on the roster and power running is
what coach Marvin Lewis wants to get back to in 2008. I expect
Perry and RB Kenny Watson to steal a series here and there but
not so much that he doesn't have another 1,000-yard campaign and
8-10 scores.
3. What did you like the least? Very few owners worth their salt
are ever satisfied with their RB depth. In my case, I have four
RBs who were pretty much useless fantasy-wise in the second half
of last season, all because of injury. The one that made it all
16 games - Jones - scored all of one rushing TD in 2007. That
said, it is difficult to find a RB anymore that plays 16 games
season after season, so I'm just happy to have landed two players
at the position who will log a high percentage of their teams'
carries and another (Johnson) who I think will be quick to disprove
the critics that have said his previous workload has caught up
to him.
4. Who was your best value? Palmer. I can't tell you again how
surprised I was to see a potential top-five QB still available
to me at this spot, just as I was in July. Whether the Bengals
are able to revive their running game or not, Palmer is the type
of QB that can keep me competitive in the weeks I have to face
the Manning or Brady owners in this league. Ultimately, I think
Cincinnati will rediscover the ground game, making Palmer even
more dangerous. And there has been very little talk regarding
the signing of TE Ben Utecht and the return of Perry - two players
who will make this passing game more potent than it was a season
ago.
Additionally, if I thought I stole Bulger in the ninth last month,
I committed grand theft larceny by getting him in the 11th this
time around. Lastly, I think Morgan will become the latest WR
to thrive in Mike Martz's offensive system in San Francisco. He
has lit up Oakland and Green Bay so far in the preseason and,
with Bryant Johnson's inability to stay healthy, I expect solid
#3 WR numbers from the Virginia Tech rookie who fell in the draft
due to some minor scrapes with the law in college. He is having
such a good camp, in fact, that the Niners may have no choice
to start him over Johnson.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Maybe Deuce McAllister, but I'm
not quite sure. As a #4 RB, I don't think he can be considered
a big reach, but his shelf life figures to be somewhat limited
considering he will be coming back from his second ACL tear as
well as a microfracture surgery. I suppose with a player like
Deuce, if he plays in three games like last year, he will have
been a reach. If he plays 12-16 contests, then he becomes a definite
value.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? Missing
out on Jeremy Shockey in round 7 and Perry in round 10. While
I considered Shockey with my sixth pick, I wasn't about to take
him there over Rudi Johnson. That said, I still would have liked
him to slide to me in the seventh. Instead, I was forced to take
another injury-prone TE, Todd Heap, in round 8 - a pick I'm not
all together unhappy with. The one that got me the most was Perry,
who looks not only to assume his role as receiving back in 2006,
but also push Johnson as the starter at some point.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (not including yours)
and give a brief explanation why:
9-Route - The Darren McFadden pick will define this team's ability
to win. If D-Mac is anything less than what the Raiders want him
to be, this team could fall apart quickly as the backs and receivers
on his bench are part-timers at best right now. That said, I expect
McFadden to post solid numbers and to be at least a very serviceable
#2 fantasy RB. Braylon Edwards was a steal at the end of round
2, Houshmandzadeh is better than many teams' #1 WRs, Winslow is
a top 3-4 TE and both Hasselbeck and the Vikings defense should
be good, if not great, at points throughout the season.
Team Marx - Assuming good health, Marx has the firepower to be
beat any team on any given week. He was able to assemble a team
that has at least one bonafide stud at every position. Brees-LT-Bush
is downright scary. Add to that the only time he has to worry
about pulling someone from his lineup is Week 9 and he's in great
shape. In Chad Johnson, Santana Moss, Donald Driver and Jeremy
Shockey, he has four players capable of scoring like top WRs in
any given week. However, he will need to hit on some players on
the waiver wire throughout the season as I'm not crazy about his
depth.
Hellboy - Probably as deep of a team as there was in this draft.
Marion Barber should visit the end zone 12-14 times this year
and top 1,000 rushing yards without a problem, making him a consistent
weekly threat. Colston and Steve Smith (when he's done with his
suspension) make for an incredible 1-2 punch at WR. With those
three players as his nucleus, Anderson-Campbell should be an effective
QB duo to complement them. He then filled his roster out with
high upside RBs in Jonathan Stewart, Felix Jones and Chris Perry,
meaning he should be in good shape all season long at the RB position,
barring a string of injuries.
Compiler Guy - His draft doesn't stand out to me per se, but he
basically has a solid team. I don't like Earnest Graham as a #2
RB or Jennings much as a #3 WR, but he has enough depth at both
positions to play the matchups. Cutler/Young make for a nice QB
duo and Crumpler was a nice pick late. Compiler Guy will need
to be a sound decision-maker with his lineup every week, but the
overall talent on his roster is such that he could make a run.
Wildman |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Frank Gore |
9 |
SF |
1.08 |
RB |
Jamal Lewis |
5 |
CLE |
2.05 |
WR |
Santonio Holmes |
6 |
PIT |
3.08 |
WR |
Marvin Harrison |
4 |
IND |
4.05 |
QB |
Ben Roethlisberger |
6 |
PIT |
5.08 |
WR |
Kevin Curtis |
7 |
PHI |
6.05 |
RB |
DeAngelo Williams |
9 |
CAR |
7.08 |
RB |
Chris Johnson ® |
6 |
TEN |
8.05 |
TE |
Vernon Davis |
9 |
SF |
9.08 |
WR |
Reggie Williams |
7 |
JAC |
10.05 |
QB |
David Garrard |
7 |
JAC |
11.08 |
WR |
Robert Meachem |
9 |
NO |
12.05 |
RB |
DeShaun Foster |
9 |
SF |
13.08 |
RB |
Andre Hall |
8 |
DEN |
14.05 |
DEF |
Tennessee Titans |
4 |
|
15.08 |
K |
Shayne Graham |
8 |
CIN |
16.05 |
|
Team Name: Wildman
Owner Name: Matt Waldman
Draft Spot: 1.08
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? If you step into my shoes, you’ll understand quickly
why this is not my typical fantasy football draft:
a. The competition: I’m facing other fantasy football writers
and at least three of them have competed in showcase leagues or
exhibited a strong level of knowledge about players and draft
strategy. Although facing this level of competition is nothing
new for me, these writers…
b. Have Inside Information: Not that I presume they read my work
regularly, but if I were drafting against someone who posts his
rankings online and I’m drafting a pick or two before or
after him I would keep them on a tab of my Internet browser.
I decided the best way to go was to take risks at the top of
my draft and apply a “plus one strategy” of picking
certain players a round earlier than their average draft position.
The problem with this strategy is it can cost you in the second
half of the draft. Honestly, I have mixed feelings about my picks,
which I’ll explain below.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I love the big
game upside of my picks and my 1-2 punch at RB. Although I have
Marion Barber and Clinton Portis ranked higher than Frank Gore,
I’m sold on the fact Gore has done everything within his
power to prepare himself as the centerpiece of Mike Martz’s
offense. Besides, Marion Barber might be the starter but I think
Felix Jones looks like he could be a much better version of Julius
Jones in the Cowboys offense. Jamal Lewis in a real offense was
a sight for sore eyes last year. Lewis was the sixth-best back
in many leagues last year and I got him in the middle of the second
round.
3. What did you like the least? It was tough to pass up Clinton
Portis and Marion Barber for a player on an offense that sputtered
in 2007. Selecting Jamal Lewis over Larry Johnson was more difficult
than it should have been. When it comes to running talent, I’d
rank LJ up there with LT, Peterson, and Gore. But I couldn’t
pull the trigger with the Browns’ bell cow sitting there.
Marvin Harrison and Kevin Curtis don’t inspire confidence,
although their upside is undeniable. Unfortunately, my receiving
depth is also risky if these guys don’t pull through. Tack
on Vernon Davis and I’m going big or not at all.
4. Who was your best value? I love Jonathan Stewart when healthy,
but he’s not completely there and DeAngelo Williams has
improved enough to get a shot to start. He averaged five yards
per carry down the stretch last year with an undrafted free agent
cut by the Cowboys at the end of the preseason as his quarterback
(Matt Moore). I could wind up with a top-15 runner I took in round
seven. A Rookie Scouting Portfolio guy I picked late that could
pay big dividends is Denver RB Andre Hall. I really liked his
skills when he was the University of South Florida offense. New
England reputedly had him graded as a third round pick a couple
of years ago. The word from some analysts out of Bronco camp is
that some debate Hall to be the best overall runner on the team.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Kevin Curtis was anything but
a consistent producer last year (as I heard from my trash-talking
colleagues). Jerricho Cotchery, Santana Moss, and Nate Burleson
are all options that could have much better seasons. Yet, I got
him in a spot where many would expect him to go. Judging by the
reactions to the pick, Marvin Harrison as a fourth round pick
over Anquan Boldin, Roy Williams, and Dwayne Bowe was a huge reach.
It could be but I decided I would ignore the doom and gloom forecast.
Isaac Bruce, Jimmy Smith, Rod Smith, and Jerry Rice are examples
of several receivers who produced as strong fantasy starters after
the age of 35. I think people believe Harrison is through because
he couldn’t come back strong after missing most of the year.
I chose to believe Harrison rushed back too soon, but he’ll
be ready to be a strong option 1-A to Reggie Wayne.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? There
were three I wanted that I lost being sandwiched between T.J.
and Craig: Steve Smith, Laveranues Coles, and Chris Perry. The
last two hurt the most, because Coles would have really solidified
my receiving corps and I believe Perry will play his way into
becoming the starter. He is one my top-three “steals of
the draft.”
7. Rank the top 4 teams (not including
yours) and give a brief explanation why:
I have changed my mind a few times already, but here it goes…
Compiler Guy (Mike MacGregor) – This is the type of team
I like to draft. Mike acquired a nice mix of strong veterans,
quality depth, and youthful upside. I wish I had Portis, Fitzgerald,
Calvin Johnson, and Ricky Williams this year. One thing I was
shocked about was how Mike went for Vince Young as early as round
seven and still got Jay Cutler in round ten. I would have expected
these players to go in the opposite order.
The Prototype (T.J. Thomas) – I have some issues with the
picks in the second half of his draft, but his starters more than
make up for it. His RBs aren’t sexy picks this year, but
they should be more than adequate. His starting trio of receivers
is excellent.
Team Marx (Mark Shutters) – I loved first half of his draft,
but not crazy about the second half. If his starters all play
as expected, he’s a team to beat. I just think his picks
of Slaton and Charles were major reaches and Deion Branch coming
off an ACL tear doesn’t excite me.
Husky Jerks (Mike Krueger) – Rinku Dahwan, Craig Englander,
and Joe Kilroy were tough to leave out, but I had to give the
final nod to Mike’s club. Mike’s team isn’t
flashy, but his picks are solid. His first three picks at receiver
are good and I like Hines Ward more than many this year. As with
Harrison, people are writing off Ward too soon. I’m not
a fan of Willis McGahee, but following up with Ray Rice (just
in time, I might add, because I wanted him) was a key move. I
think Rice is the one of the two best backs in this rookie class.
Mike’s quarterbacks should help him as long as picks the
best match up.
Hellboy |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Marion Barber |
10 |
DAL |
1.09 |
WR |
Marques Colston |
9 |
NO |
2.04 |
WR |
Steve Smith (CAR) |
9 |
CAR |
3.09 |
RB |
Willie Parker |
6 |
PIT |
4.04 |
RB |
Jonathan Stewart ® |
9 |
CAR |
5.09 |
QB |
Derek Anderson |
5 |
CLE |
6.04 |
WR |
Vincent Jackson |
9 |
SD |
7.09 |
RB |
Felix Jones ® |
10 |
DAL |
8.04 |
WR |
Courtney Taylor |
4 |
SEA |
9.09 |
RB |
Chris Perry |
8 |
CIN |
10.04 |
QB |
Jason Campbell |
10 |
WAS |
11.09 |
DEF |
Pittsburgh Steelers |
6 |
|
12.04 |
WR |
Ben Obomanu |
4 |
SEA |
13.09 |
WR |
D.J. Hackett |
9 |
CAR |
14.04 |
TE |
Ben Utecht |
8 |
CIN |
15.09 |
K |
Matt Prater |
8 |
DEN |
16.04 |
|
Team Name: Hellboy
Owner Name: Craig Englander
Draft Spot: 1.09
1. What was your general strategy
and did you get to execute it? I wanted to get WR-rich
while still having a steady dose of RB. I planned on getting two
receiving studs and grab MacNabb or Hasselbeck in the 7th round.
At 3.09, I got my second stud in Steve Smith. Had Wildman not
snagged Santonio Holmes in the 3rd, I probably would have gone
RB in round 3, expecting Holmes to fall to me in the 4th. There
were enough RB2s like Michael Turner, Brandon Jacobs, Earnest
Graham, Reggie Bush, and Thomas Jones to pick on the way back
down in the 4th. When Derek Anderson was still on the board at
my 6th pick, I abandoned my strategy and grabbed a QB earlier
than I anticipated.
2. What did you like the most about
your draft? Having Barber available to me at number nine
allowed me to play it a little safe to start. While I reached
to get Colston at the 16th pick, I got a guy I coveted and my
first two picks are red zone focal points on teams, which should
put the ball in the end zone a lot.
3. What did you like the least?
I tend to be a running back guy. I’m not in love with RB
corps at all. The RB2s started flying off the board in the next
six picks after I grabbed Steve Smith in the 3rd round. Jacobs,
Graham, Turner, and White - all gone in the six picks between
my 3rd and 4th round. I panicked and jumped early on Willie Parker.
Finally, having Parker and Stewart, I really expected that in
round seven or eight I would handcuff one of them. That didn’t
happen and I ended up handcuffing Barber with Felix Jones.
4. Who was your best value?
Getting Derek Anderson at 64th pick a full round later than his
ADP of 53 was good value. I also liked Steve Smith in the late
3rd round and was fortunate enough to grab D.J. Hackett in the
14th to pick up the slack when Smith is out. I like Ben Utecht
simply for the fact that if he puts up anything remotely similar
to guys like Shockey, Heap, Davis, Daniels, or Cooley, then it
proves I didn’t have to give up Vincent Jackson, Felix Jones,
or Chris Perry to get a TE.
5. Who was your biggest reach?
I think when the article is written I will be the guy who reached
in rounds two and four. Colston at the 16th pick may have been
overreaching on his value, but I went with my gut instead of the
numbers. He is a red zone receiver on a team that will score,
which weighed favorably in my analysis. While I picked FWP at
4.04, his ADP, I htink this was a horrid pick and I could have
loaded up on a third receiver like Harrison, Boldin. or Roy Williams
and pick up a serviceable RB2 like Edge, Rudi Johnson. or Julius
Jones in the next round.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but
were already picked? Picking behind Wildman is a coveter’s
nightmare. I was cautiously hopeful that Gore would come to me
at the 9th pick when I saw Brady and Moss go in the first seven
picks - Wildman (8th pick). I love Santonio Holmes and thought
I could snag him early in the 4th round - Wildman (3rd). I thought
possibly Harrison could fall to me in the 5th - Wildman (4th).
I wanted to handcuff either Stewart or Parker but 9-Route grabbed
Rashard Mendenhall in the 6th and DeAngelo Williams – Wildman
(one pick before me).
7. Rank the top 4 teams (excluding
yours) and give a brief explanation why?
9-Route: This team has 4 studs in AD, Edwards, Housh and Winslow.
He got great value nabbing Hasselbeck as a QB in the 8th (and
not jumping on him in the 3rd like that four-letter network did
earlier that evening). If McFadden turns out to be the stud the
Raiders are predicting he will be, this could be the toughest
starting line-up. However, if McFadden is simply Raider-myopia,
9-Route has no true RB2 and is relying on three rookie RBs to
find one to carry the load with zero depth at receiver.
Compiler Guy: Two stud receivers in Fitzgerald and Calvin Johnson,
followed closely by Jennings. Also has depth at receiver. Two
very solid running backs in Portis and Graham, with depth at that
position as well. While I was not big on the VY pick, he backed
him up with a guy who generally gets drafted earlier in Cutler.
Wildman: Since he snatched four guys I wanted, I am compelled
by my own ego to say this is a strong team. I’m on the Gore
train (again) and I think that Jamal Lewis is one of the best
RB2s (I didn’t put him in my covet category only because
there was a snowball’s chance in Hades he would drop to
me at 3.09). I’ve got Holmes in the Pro Bowl this year and
age doesn’t bother me with receivers, so with everything
coming out of training camp, I like Harrison. I know I’m
against Training Camp Hype, but I really like what I am seeing
and hearing about DeAngelo Williams and Chris Johnson, which provides
Wildman with seemingly good depth at the RB position.
Team Marx: How can I not like a team that has one of my all-time
favorite RBs (Tomlinson), and two RBs from my favorite college
(Bush and Fargas)? He is definitely not hurting at QB either with
Brees, who I expect to end up as one of the top two fantasy QBs
this year. While his receiving corps is not flashy, it is stacked
with veterans who show up every year in Chad Johnson and Donald
Driver and I even have a gut feeling that Santana Moss will excel
in Zorn’s offense. Having a number one at three different
positions (Tomlinson, Brees and the Charger D) should make this
team competitive each week.
Dallas Dynasty |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Marshawn Lynch |
6 |
BUF |
1.10 |
QB |
Tony Romo |
10 |
DAL |
2.03 |
RB |
Brandon Jacobs |
4 |
NYG |
3.10 |
WR |
Plaxico Burress |
4 |
NYG |
4.03 |
TE |
Dallas Clark |
4 |
IND |
5.10 |
WR |
Roddy White |
7 |
ATL |
6.03 |
WR |
Bernard Berrian |
8 |
MIN |
7.10 |
RB |
Fred Taylor |
7 |
JAC |
8.03 |
RB |
Maurice Morris |
4 |
SEA |
9.10 |
WR |
Justin Gage |
6 |
TEN |
10.03 |
QB |
Eli Manning |
4 |
NYG |
11.10 |
RB |
Fred Jackson |
6 |
BUF |
12.03 |
DEF |
Green Bay Packers |
7 |
|
13.10 |
K |
Rob Bironas |
6 |
TEN |
14.03 |
WR |
Antwaan Randle El |
10 |
WAS |
15.10 |
TE |
Randy McMichael |
5 |
STL |
16.03 |
|
Team Name: Dallas Dynasty
Owner Name: Scott Segal
Draft Spot: 1.10
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? After looking at my mock draft and really getting dirty analyzing
the ADP, I wanted to employee an Average Value Theory (AVT) strategy
with my draft. I did the AVT numbers and baseline for my 14-team
league and applied it to this draft. I did not feel like a reduction
of two teams would skew the numbers. Conversely, if there were
a reduction of two teams, I would have had to reassess the numbers.
With that being said, the strategy was in effect for my starting
lineup. From there I planned on going with upside guys. But a
funny thing happened as the draft unfolded, I reversed my strategy
and picked up value guys on my board very late. Lynch was ranked
high on my board, but Romo was my third QB and to take him over
my number one guy could prove to be a risk I regretted. I do believe
that Fantasy Football should be fun and Romo being my favorite
player and knowing he would not be there was too tough to resist.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? I absolutely love
my stable of running backs. Lynch was the fifth RB on my board
and Jacobs was thirteenth. My goal was to be above the AVT mean
for my starting lineup which picking from the ten spot was going
to be tough. Taylor and Morris add proven depth in the event of
the inevitable Jacobs nicks. Jackson I feel is one of the higher
quality handcuffs in the league. I felt like both Jacobs and Lynch
had handcuffs that would not have a very significant drop in production
in the event of injury. These factor fairly heavily in my rankings
for running backs.
I also love the talent I have at quarterback. Eli Manning I feel
is good enough to be a starter in a 12-team league. Of course
he is only going to see the field in the event of an injury or
bye.
3. What did you like the least? I would have liked a shot to get
a Brandon Marshall as my lead WR. Plaxico Burress was a tough
decision over Welker and Boldin. I chose Plax due to his affinity
for the end zone. I don't have the marquee names, but still feel
my WR corps will produce and not let me down.
4. Who was your best value? Considering I had Jacobs rated as
the best RB2 and I landed him in the 3rd round, he would be the
pick.
5. Who was your biggest reach? Dallas Clark would likely be the
one most would pick and I cannot argue with the logic. To pick
a TE before a WR2 in a league starting three receivers certainly
has some risk. I just did not want him gone before the turn came
back to me and I felt like White would still be there, which he
was.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? I
really wanted Ahmad Bradshaw to protect my Jacobs investment.
I also was hoping to land Patrick Crayton as my WR3. Other than
that, I think the draft went well.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (not including yours)
and give a brief explanation why:
In no particular order, I liked 9-Route, Prototype, Husky Jerks,
and Hellboy. I liked 9-Route and his RB and Receiver core a lot.
I am not sold on Hasselbeck, but he has managed to put up numbers
regardless of the circumstances lately. I love Prototype’s
lineup. Moss is certainly going to produce and Boldin and Coles
are solid at the WR2 and WR3 spot. The RBs have potential to blow
it up. I like the potential of the Husky Jerks receiving corps.
I think he may be able to have three WR1 guys by season’s
end and the RBs aren’t too shabby either. I like Hellboy
due to his starting lineup and RB depth. His receiving depth is
very shaky so an injury would make this a bottom 4 team.
Compiler Guy |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
RB |
Clinton Portis |
10 |
WAS |
1.11 |
WR |
Larry Fitzgerald |
7 |
ARI |
2.02 |
RB |
Earnest Graham |
10 |
TB |
3.11 |
WR |
Calvin Johnson |
4 |
DET |
4.02 |
WR |
Greg Jennings |
8 |
GB |
5.11 |
RB |
Kevin Smith ® |
4 |
DET |
6.02 |
QB |
Vince Young |
6 |
TEN |
7.11 |
RB |
Ricky Williams |
4 |
MIA |
8.02 |
WR |
Isaac Bruce |
9 |
SF |
9.11 |
QB |
Jay Cutler |
8 |
DEN |
10.02 |
WR |
Steve Smith (NYG) |
4 |
NYG |
11.11 |
TE |
Alge Crumpler |
6 |
TEN |
12.02 |
RB |
Ladell Betts |
10 |
WAS |
13.11 |
RB |
Chris Brown |
8 |
HOU |
14.02 |
DEF |
Buffalo Bills |
6 |
|
15.11 |
K |
Mason Crosby |
8 |
GB |
16.02 |
|
Team Name: Compiler Guy
Owner Name: Mike MacGregor
Draft Spot: 1.11
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it?
I just can't seem to buy a break and get an early pick this year.
Four drafts so far: #8, #9, #8 and now in this one, #11. The strategy
comes down to seeing what table scraps the other guys leave, especially
at #11 as opposed to a little earlier. Hope for Barber. Nope.
Hope for Lynch. Nope. Okay, Portis it is.
I don't believe in the line of thinking to draft 2 WR in the first
two rounds, which is growing in popularity. I especially don't
believe in it for leagues with no points for receptions like this
one. I was pretty sure Moss would not be available at my pick,
which is okay. I typically don't draft last year's #1 player at
a position. Historically that is a low value proposition. So,
RB in the 1st, likely WR in the 2nd, allowing for the best flexibility
and still realizing there is good value at RB later. Sure to miss
out on Brees and Romo from my draft spot, rounds 3 and 4 should
net another RB and WR. I'm not drafting a TE early this year unless
I can get Witten or Winslow at value... and again, that isn't
happening with a late draft spot.
Execute it? Yes, pretty much. This was a strong draft with not
a lot of players free-falling. I waited on QB and waited on TE.
As a result, RB and WR look good each with quality depth. QB looks
fine regardless of my waiting, and hopefully TE does okay.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? Knowing I couldn't
draft Brees or Romo, I'm glad I waited on QB. I even overpaid
a bit for Vince Young as the 9th QB off the board because I was
targeting him, and knew Wildman would snag him if I didn't jump
in there. VY is a little erratic though, so I wanted to get another
good starting quality QB relatively soon after. Targeting either
Rodgers or Cutler, they kept falling and falling together all
the way to the 10th round, when I finally grabbed Cutler as the
14th QB drafted. That is good value.
I'll add, VY is a good target for this league with 4 points per
passing TD but 6 points per rushing TD. This bumps him up the
QB rankings a bit since he should be good for some rushing scores.
That said, I actually have Cutler projected higher overall.
3. What did you like the least? I'll keep hitting this point...
drafting from the #11 spot. Top of the draft is much better, and
I'm not just talking about the 1st round which is obvious enough.
With an early draft spot, there is a better opportunity to take
Brees or Romo (although Dallas Dynasty did take Romo at the 2.03
in this draft - can you same homer pick?). If you want a top TE,
Witten and Winslow are usually going late 4th, early 5th, again
favoring those with an early draft spot. Sure, its great "value"
to wait, but sooner or later you need stud players on your team
that are going to win games for you. People drafting at the top
of the draft, assuming they know what they are doing, create better
separation in points from those drafting late. Drafting early
in the 2nd round due to a serpentine format is not that advantageous.
4. Who was your best value? Cutler is a good one as mentioned
above, but I'll say Ricky Williams here, drafted in the 8th round.
He is looking good at this point of the preseason and I don't
think people are discounting Ronnie Brown enough considering his
injury from last season. Mind you, Brown didn't get picked until
the 7th round in this league of sharp drafters.
The Miami RB position looks like at least a split carries situation,
and quite possibly more to Williams. We know the guy is talented
and he is talking the talk about being motivated. As my RB4 I'm
quite happy with this pick.
5. Who was your biggest reach? I reached a bit on Vince Young,
but more significant, I reached a bit on Calvin Johnson taking
him in the early 4th round. I had a number of WR projected similar
or higher than CJ at this point, but I thought I'd swing for the
fences on this pick. Its not a point-per-reception league, so
TDs play a bigger impact in the scoring. Just getting a guy who
catches a lot of passes but can't find the end zone with frequency
is nice but not putting me over the top. Lets see if CJ can live
up to his potential by making a statement in just his second year.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? WR
Santonio Holmes - He's been rising, but wow, middle of the 3rd.
That is pretty high. It would have been a tough call for me between
Holmes and Johnson. I'd lean to Holmes.
TE Owen Daniels - Although I do have him in a couple leagues already,
when Daniels and Vernon Davis were both drafted, that caused me
to wait even longer at TE.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (not including
yours) and give a brief explanation why:
9-Route - While I think his depth is a little questionable and
I would have gone a different direction at QB, he's got 2 great
receivers, Winslow and, oh yeah, that Peterson guy is pretty good.
Rookies - The WR after Andre Johnson are sketchy to me, but if
you're going to skimp in this league it might as well be a receiver.
Love the McNabb pick although it surprised me he went that early.
I like Cooley and how he insured Ryan Grant with Brandon Jackson.
If one of Burleson or Bryant Johnson pan, this team will be a
force.
Husky Jerks - Probably waited too long at QB, and had I let Cutler
go he would be on this team. I didn't care for the McGahee pick
but locking up Ray Rice helps mitigate that. Needs to ride out
Brandon Marshall's suspension but after that, if one of the young
QBs shine, this team is playoff bound.
Hellboy - Ben Utecht? I know who he is, but just surprised he's
even getting drafted in a 12 team league. I would rather take
a flier on Kevin Boss or rookie Dustin Keller (both not drafted).
Still, I really like Marques Colston. Hellboy took him a bit over
his ADP but I like the move. He has a solid RB duo of Barber and
Parker, as I think people are little too down on Parker. Felix
Jones looks like a better fit for a point-per-reception league
but early reviews are very promising. Ride out the Steve Smith
suspension and this team is in excellent shape.
Warbirds |
Pos. |
Player |
Bye |
Team |
Acquired |
WR |
Terrell Owens |
10 |
DAL |
1.12 |
WR |
Reggie Wayne |
4 |
IND |
2.01 |
RB |
Michael Turner |
7 |
ATL |
3.12 |
RB |
LenDale White |
6 |
TEN |
4.01 |
WR |
Chris Chambers |
9 |
SD |
5.12 |
TE |
Tony Gonzalez |
6 |
KC |
6.01 |
RB |
Chester Taylor |
8 |
MIN |
7.12 |
QB |
Matt Schaub |
8 |
HOU |
8.01 |
WR |
Derrick Mason |
10 |
BAL |
9.12 |
QB |
Brett Favre |
5 |
NYJ |
10.01 |
RB |
LaMont Jordan |
4 |
NE |
11.12 |
QB |
Jon Kitna |
4 |
DET |
12.01 |
K |
Stephen Gostkowski |
4 |
NE |
13.12 |
DEF |
Jacksonville Jaguars |
4 |
|
14.01 |
TE |
L.J. Smith |
7 |
PHI |
15.12 |
RB |
Sammy Morris |
4 |
NE |
16.01 |
|
Team Name: Warbirds
Owner Name: Joe Kilroy
Draft Spot: 1.12
1. What was your general strategy and
did you get to execute it? The answer to the second part of that question is yes and
no. I usually try and grab two good running backs when starting
with a late pick in the first round of a snake format draft. Especially
in a league like this that doesn't give points for receptions.
I would've taken Clinton Portis if he fell one more spot and then
grabbed Jones-Drew with my next pick. Once Portis was taken though
I decided I'd rather have Terrell Owens and Reggie Wayne over
a combo like Maurice Jones-Drew and Ryan Grant.
After deciding to select wide receivers with my first two picks
things pretty much went how I hoped they would. I expect pretty
good numbers out of LenDale White and Michael Turner, so I felt
good about getting them to start for me at running back in the
third and fourth rounds.
2. What did you like the most about your
draft? After I decided
to take receivers with my first two picks the rest of the draft
unfolded how I hoped. I would have liked to have better depth
at running back, but when I had the chance I decided to take Chris
Chambers and Tony Gonzalez instead of using it on backs like Kevin
Smith and Edgerrin James.
3. What did you like the least? I don't mind having Chester Taylor
as my third back, and I don't mind relying on LaMont Jordan or
Sammy Morris to become a factor in the Patriots offense enough
to become a solid fourth running back, but I would have felt better
about my depth at the position if I handcuffed Jerious Norwood
to Turner or Chris Johnson to White. If not that it would've been
nice to have grabbed someone like Edgerrin James or Kevin Smith
as a third back, but I decided to grab my starting tight end and
third wide receiver instead.
4. Who was your best value? Getting Derrick Mason at 9.12 as
a fourth wide receiver surprised me. Taking Tony Gonzalez at 6.1
I didn't mind considering he's one of about three or four tight
ends that are capable of a thousand yard season. Had Gonzalez
gone where Dallas Clark was taken I would have grabbed a running
back over Gonzalez.
5. Who was your biggest reach? I took Matt Schaub at pick 8.1.
I figure that's about the earliest he's been going in drafts,
but he was the last of the quarterbacks available that I was willing
to take somewhat early. I didn't want to risk seeing him go off
the board before my next pick at 9.12. Taking LaMont Jordan at
the end of the eleventh round felt like it was earlier than he
should go, but the way running backs went in this draft he probably
wasn't bad value there.
6. Which player(s) did you covet, but were
already picked? I
wanted to handcuff Norwood to Turner, but he went earlier than
I thought he'd go. Selvin Young is another back I was hoping would
slip a little bit and make it to me later than he did. Receivers
Kevin Walter and Jabar Gaffney were two other players I would
have taken had they fallen to me in the rounds they were taken.
7. Rank the top 4 teams (not including yours)
and give a brief explanation why:
Husky Jerks - Husky has a real good mix of players to start every
week at running back, wide receiver, and tight end. A team with
that kind of depth at those positions is usually tough to beat.
His quarterback situation could be a problem, but both Rodgers
and Leinart come with good upside. If he needed a better QB he
could probably use his depth at other positions to deal for one
during the season.
Rookies - Rookies managed to pair Brian Westbrook with Ryan Grant,
pick-up Selvin Young as his third back, and still get a good mix
of receivers to choose from every week with Andre Johnson leading
the way. He also got one of the top tight ends with his Chris
Cooley selection. McNabb and Delhomme may frustrate him at times,
but if they stay healthy it shouldn't be much of an issue.
9-Route - Owning Adrian Peterson makes it more plausible that
9-Route could get by with using Darren McFadden, Rashard Mendenhall,
and Pierre Thomas in some kind of rotation as his number two back
throughout the year. It also helps that he has Braylon Edwards
and T.J. Houshmanzadeh as two of his three starting receivers
with Kellen Winslow at tight end. He could have trouble at QB
if Matt Hasselbeck disappoints.
Compiler Guy - I had a tough time picking between Compiler Guy
(CG) and The Prototype. I went with CG though because I like his
stable of running backs more, think his wide receivers are good
enough to get things done, and while Heap is a more productive
tight end than Alge Crumpler, there is always a risk injuries
will cost him parts of the season.
Recap By Round
|