OK, new assignment. I spent the past couple weeks talking about
players I think are overvalued and more likely than not to fall
out of the Top 10 this coming season. Now it’s time to discuss
the players I think have the best shot at replacing them. Some have
been there many times before and others would be making their first
appearance, but all of them would be outperforming their 2022 selves
should they prove me right. Also, full disclosure: Only two of them
have to do that for me to outperform MY 2022 self. LOL!
A quick reminder of the Top 10 fantasy RBs from last season…
Note: All rankings are based on FFToday’s
Non-PPR league scoring.
Aaron Jones,
GB: Exactly five running backs in NFL history have gained
more career yards per carry than Jones (minimum 750 carries). They
are Marion Motley, Jamaal Charles, Nick Chubb (!), Jim Brown, and
Mercury Morris (by a nose). That’s pretty elite company for a 5th
round flier from UTEP, wouldn’t you say? Too seldom used his first
two years playing for Mike McCarthy, AJ33 has blossomed under Matt
LaFleur and become one of the most reliable fantasy assets playing
the most volatile position. He’s been no worse than RB13 since 2019,
something only one other RB can boast of (see above).
In fairness to Coach McCarthy, Jones was pretty one-dimensional
his first couple years as a pro, hauling in just 35 receptions
on 53 targets, a pretty miserable (for a RB) 66% catch rate. This
despite playing with possibly the most talented thrower of footballs
in the sport’s history. Fast forward to 2022 and the transformation
into a true dual-threat became officially complete. Jones snagged
59 of Aaron Rodgers’ 72 intended pigskins last season (an
82% catch rate) for 395 yards and five scores, all Top 10 marks
for the position.
It’s absolutely fair to wonder how Rodgers’ abrupt
departure will impact his former teammates’ fantasy fortunes
moving forward. Most pundits are predicting Green Bay to take
a sizable step back in 2023 and I’m not afraid to admit
that includes yours truly. Nevertheless, the Pack still possesses
a Top 10 offensive line and a perfect complement to the smallish
Jones in AJ Dillon. Moreover, it’s hard to imagine Coach
LaFleur throwing the ball as frequently as he might have with
a future HOF’er under center. Are 275-300 more touches in
play here? If Jones gets them, he’s going to be a Top 10
back. Prioritize him on draft day.
Rashaad
Penny, PHI: If Jones is one of the
league’s most reliable fantasy assets, Penny has to be one of
its least. Since being drafted in 2018, the former San Diego St.
star has played in only 42 of a possible 82 games and is more
than 400 carries shy of that aforementioned career minimum. At
the rate he’s going, he simply won’t get there. This would be
a crying shame, BTW, considering his current career YPC average
(5.7) puts him on pace to...wait for it…tie Marion Motley for
best ever! He hasn’t played enough to truly excite fantasy GMs,
but when he does, the Aztec alum is one of the most efficient
rock toters who ever toted a rock.
If his rarely tapped potential piques my curiosity, Penny’s
off-season change of scenery grabs my undivided attention. Having
finished out his rookie contract with the Seahawks in 2022, he
opted to sign on with the Eagles, who could have won SB LVII and
are favored to rep the NFC again in SB LVIII. A lot can happen
between now and next February, but it’s safe to say Penny
will play for a much better team and behind a much better line
in 2023. The Birds’ front ranked 2nd overall in run block
win rate last season; meanwhile, the Seahawks ranked a distant
24th.
Philly’s not gambling their championship window on such
a fragile foundation, of course, so Penny is joined in the backfield
by D’Andre Swift, late of Detroit. The duo replaces Miles
Sanders and, I’m guessing, allows Nick Sirianni to throttle
back Jalen Hurts’ rushing attempts. My somewhat scientific
estimate has Penny touching the ball 200 times this year. At 5.7
YPC…well, that’s pretty easy math. The risk is substantial,
but the reward could be shiny.
Kenneth
Walker, SEA: In case you’re
wondering, I drafted both Jones and Penny this past weekend, putting
my money where my mouth would soon be. I rarely invest heavily
at the position, preferring to go big on QBs and WRs, then rounding
out my roster with best supporting actor types and educated dart
throws at RB. Penny was definitely the latter, but now that he’s
moved on from Seattle, the teammate he left behind probably qualifies
as the former.
Walker should have spent his freshman campaign in a supporting
/ timeshare capacity, but was thrust into the primary ball-carrying
role when Penny suffered a fractured fibula in Week 5. From Week
6 on, the Seattle rook averaged almost 20 carries and 82+ yards
per game. This included a prolonged flat stretch from Weeks to
10 to 13 when he averaged only 31 yards/game. All told, and despite
the mid-year dip, Walker compiled nearly 1300 yards from scrimmage
and nine scores in his first professional season. That is not
too shabby for a first-year RB and compares very favorably to
the numbers Chris Carson—the last Seattle back to finish
in the Top 10—put up back in 2019 (1500 yards v. nine scores).
Naturally, Pete Carroll couldn’t help himself this past
April and spent another high draft pick on an additional ball
carrier, UCLA’s Zach Charbonnet. You can never have too
many running backs, right Pete? Actually, you never CAN have too
many running backs in today’s game and I’m not certain
Charbonnet’s presence significantly clouds Walker’s
2023 outlook. While defenses focus on stopping the suddenly dangerous
Seattle passing game, these two can collaborate to deliver a strong
Seahawks run game while simultaneously lowering each other’s’
injury risk. Seattle puts one current and one former RB in the
2023 Top 10.