Misery Loves Company
9/23/10
Aggressiveness is a characteristic that tends to reward fantasy
owners more times than not. In the NFL, an offensive line will sometimes
hold up long enough to give the quarterback enough time to beat
man coverage down the field and make the defense look foolish against
a fierce pass rush. More often than not, though, when a defense
brings the heat and forces the action, crisis management becomes
the name of the game for the opposing team.
In that same vein, I hope to apply that same kind of pressure
to the owners in all of my leagues by beating my opponents to
the punch in regards to personnel moves. Sometimes, reaching a
conclusion about a player too quickly is much like trying to blitz
Peyton Manning – dangerous and painful. However, coming
to a correct conclusion two weeks or two minutes quicker than
your opponents is considered foresight. Fantasy owners can be
a uneasy lot, knowing that one two-or-three-game losing streak
can wreak irreparable damage to his/her team’s chances to
make a visit to the fantasy postseason. But just as it is in the
NFL and in life, it’s hard to land the big prize by playing
scared. Thus, I will strive each week to help each of you become
a smart blitzer, so to speak.
As much as we all embrace the joy of playing fantasy football,
there are some weeks in which we all wonder if should try our
hand at another hobby. This past week was one of those weeks for
yours truly. No one likes to admit they lose a game from time
to time, but it happens and I have always been one to take a bad
performance from my fantasy teams to heart. Let’s just say
that last week offered up more than one such opportunity.
Sometimes, even for the so-called “experts” of the
fantasy football industry, it can be cathartic to share our peaks
and valleys with the masses because it should go without saying
that we all have them. Fortunately, this past week did not come
without personal precedence. In what can only be described as
an odd coincidence, last year’s Blitz following Week 2 was
called “When Aggravation
Leads To Prospecting”.
To recap, the “aggravation” part of the 2009 article
had to do with the Dolphins’ insistence on limiting Ronnie
Brown to “Wildcat” plays and mostly inside runs while
Ricky Williams received most of the outside runs and work in the
passing game. The sour feelings continued as I lamented over the
plethora of goal-line backs in the league and the age of decreasing
RB workloads. Fast forward to this past week in which I ran into
buzzsaw after buzzsaw on the fantasy schedule. Long story short,
if I didn’t have the highest-scoring team in the league
in Week 2, I didn’t win.
The “prospecting” part of the 2009 article came as
I attempted to make sense of the early returns in terms of RB
touches and WR/TE targets and at the end of the piece when I offered
up some kind words regarding Cal RB Jahvid Best’s chances
at fantasy success. While I will not be prospecting college players
in this article, I will be seeking to answer some questions about
what has transpired thus far and digging for “fantasy gold”.
Brandon Marshall and Calvin Johnson will not remain scoreless
for much longer nor will Best and LeSean McCoy join the 20-touchdown
club. Best and McCoy’s owners are enjoying life right now,
but will they be just as happy after the former faces Green Bay
and Minnesota over the next couple weeks while the latter runs
up against Washington and San Francisco in Weeks 4-5? It’s
certainly possible, but just like in the financial investment
industry; a savvy investor is typically able to spot a good selling
opportunity just like he/she will usually be able to identify
a likely drop in a stock’s value.
But let’s not get too ahead of ourselves. I have long found
it useful to take a regular look at the consistency of workloads
for RBs and the target rates for WRs and TEs. For each position
this week, I set the cutoff at five targets or touches/game. While
they are hardly foolproof limits, once we get lower than those
numbers, we are typically dealing with players who should be readily
available on your league’s waiver wire or on the cheap from
an owner holding onto that player to fill out his/her roster.
As you will see, there are some notable exceptions on each list,
but expect most of those players to find their way back up the
chart before long.
The important things to remember before we start: keep things
in perspective and remember we are dealing with a small sample
size right now. Just like you, I’m a fantasy owner who is
trying to spot value in some players while also explaining why
other players are disappointing us.
Notable RBs who missed the cut:
Steve Slaton, Tashard Choice, Michael Bush, Beanie Wells (the
last two RBs have yet to play)
Quick Hits: Before we go into the
touch/target breakdown, allow me to show you what the top 10 looked
like last season after two games (sorted in order by touches/game):
1. Cedric Benson (27)
2. Fred Jackson (27)
3. Michael Turner (25.5)
4. Kevin Smith (24)
5. Frank Gore (23)
6. Mike Bell (23)
7. Adrian Peterson (22.5)
8. Matt Forte (21.5)
9. Maurice Jones-Drew (21.5)
10. Chris Johnson (20.5)
Time to shop McFadden.
There’s definitely some symmetry at the top of the board when
compared to 2009, with Foster playing the role of the somewhat
predictable breakout RB (like Benson) while McFadden is filling
the role of the RB who is performing well above expectations due
in part to a timely absence by his backfield mate (like Fred
Jackson when Marshawn
Lynch was serving his suspension). As much as I liked McFadden
coming out of college (and as often as I’ve criticized Oakland
for using him the wrong way), I don’t think there is any chance
McFadden can maintain his current workload given his history of
injuries. It’s debatable how quick the Raiders will revert back
to a committee, but I have a strong feeling that it (or the inevitable
McFadden injury) will happen, making the RBBC point moot. This
means now is probably a fine time to shop McFadden around your
league and see what he can bring in return. Oakland faces Arizona
in Week 3, so although Weeks 4-5 sees Houston and San Diego on
the schedule, it should also return Michael
Bush to the field. HC Tom Cable stated last week that Bush
and McFadden would share the workload upon the former’s return.
As we know from the QB situation in Philly, coaching decisions
can change by the day, but we’d be wise to remember that Bush
has outperformed McFadden for two years and was stuck in a committee
with him and Justin
Fargas. Let’s just say I need to see McFadden run well vs.
the Redskins in Week 3 before I’m about to change my mind on his
long-term fantasy prospects.
Reggie Bush’s broken fibula – along with the knee
injury suffered by preseason sensation Christopher Ivory –
has presented Pierre Thomas and his owners with the rare opportunity
to see what he can do in a non-committee situation, even if it
is for a limited time. Certainly, Ladell Betts will see some touches
while Bush and Ivory recover, but Thomas was already seeing more
work than he was last year even with Bush was healthy. Deep leaguers
may want to check upon the availability of Ivory (who is hopeful
to return in Week 4), as he may steal some of Thomas’ goal-line
work and assume the complementary role Bush played in this offense
until he can return around midseason. But as for Thomas, back-to-back
20-plus-touch games speak well for his future.
I’m torn on the outlook of Best. You may recall that I
had him rated as the #11 overall PPR RB on my Final
Big Board and considering how high I was on him as a college
player, I’m tempted to believe he is exactly what HC Jim
Schwartz wanted in Detroit: his very own version of Chris Johnson.
On the other hand, I’m a bit concerned about his ability
to hold up for an entire season, especially considering that he
never received more than 221 touches during his three-year college
career. Not only does his durability concern me, but his 2.5 TD/game
pace is obviously unsustainable. Since he was likely drafted as
a RB2 in most leagues, there shouldn’t be much rush to “sell
high” on him; however, Detroit will run into the stout run
defenses of Minnesota and Green Bay in Weeks 3-4, so progressive
owners may be wise to see what his value is in their league. If
another owner should come along with an offer that includes an
established RB1 or WR1 in return for him, it may be advisable
to see if you can use the rookie’s fast start to your advantage.
On the other hand, if you are looking to deal for him, I would
advise that you seek a trade after Week 4.
Depending on how quickly your league reacts to a slow start by
a player, now may be the time to pursue Ray Rice. For those folks
that religiously read my PSAs this summer, you may recall that
I warned that Ravens’ players may get off to a slow start.
Why? Three of the first four games were against the Jets, Bengals
and Steelers (Week 4). The other game? This week against the Browns.
Buying Rice now may allow you to get him at a slight discount
with the added benefit being that he only has one more matchup
after Week 4 that I would consider a poor matchup – Week
13 vs. Pittsburgh. On the subject of players who may have seen
their stock drop two weeks into the season (but figure to see
a quick increase in value), Jones-Drew, Benson, Turner, Charles
and Stewart all strike me as good backs to target now. I’m
even a bit tempted to throw Fred Jackson into that mix, as he
should see roughly 12-14 touches next week, but I’m not
sure I can believe in any Bills’ player right now.
Speaking of Jones-Drew, most loyal readers probably wonder why
I continue to drive his bandwagon. Some of it has to do with his
ability to run inside while also serving as a big-play threat
and some of it has to do with the fact that he has a mobile QB
in David Garrard that can affect a defense (in much the same way
Vince Young does for Chris Johnson in Tennessee or what Michael
Vick has already done for McCoy in Philly). Yet another reason
for my steadfast backing of MJD has to do with the receiving options
the Jags’ offense possesses (even if most of the fantasy
world doesn’t believe that Mike Sims-Walker, Mike Thomas
and Marcedes Lewis makes up a better-than-average supporting cast),
which in theory should mean Jones-Drew rarely has to see eight
men in the box. While all this may or may not be true, none of
it matters if Jacksonville continues its disturbing tendency to
forget the player it says is its featured player. Such was the
case again last week – much as it was several times last
season. Perhaps the Jags figured it didn’t make a great
deal of sense to overexpose MJD in a blowout loss to the Chargers,
but few games are so out-of-hand so quickly that a RB of his caliber
doesn’t have 13 touches by halftime. In case you are wondering,
his last touch in Week 2 came at the four-minute mark of the third
quarter (a 17-yard reception) with the Jags trailing 24-6. In
other words, the game was far from over. Rashad Jennings is a
fine backup, but any game in which he sees as many touches as
Jones-Drew should be considered a slap in the face to one of the
league’s best backs.
I cannot recall a time that a lead RB scored three times receiving
before scoring his first rushing TD. Such is the case for Forte,
who should be one of the most shopped players in fantasy over
the next week. While his overall fantasy production has been borderline
stellar, his 2.9 YPC as a rusher is every bit as embarrassing.
Defenses will almost certainly soon realize that Chicago’s
offensive line cannot hold up in the running or passing game and
assign a spy to Forte, hopefully forcing Jay Cutler into the QB
he was last season – a down-the-field thrower who is prone
to throwing interceptions. This is one of the most one-dimensional
offenses in the league right now and I wouldn’t be a bit
shocked if Green Bay exposes that fact on Monday Night Football
this week. Yes, Forte should easily match or surpass his career-high
receiving totals of 64 catches, 484 yards and four TDs in OC Mike
Martz’s offense, but the early returns suggest his rushing
totals will be ugly all season long. When defenses begin to account
more for Forte in the passing game, it may not take long for his
(and Cutler’s) stock to tumble.
One of the many “morsels of wisdom” I offered early
in the preseason was in my Rookie
Impact article in which I stated, “unfortunately, we
can’t take for granted that teams and their personnel departments
do this (make the judgment as to whether or not a certain player
fits into their system)”. While I was talking about rookies
in that piece, I could just as easily use that same adage for
coaches determining how veterans fit into their system as well.
Of course, I’m talking about how HC Todd Haley is running
the Kansas City Chiefs. Somehow, it has been determined that Thomas
Jones’ leadership (read: 3.7 YPC against two average run
defenses) is somehow more valuable than Jamaal Charles’
big-play ability (6.4 YPC in the same two games plus the team’s
only RB score). It may have occurred to you already that just
as in fantasy football, the real game doesn’t always reward
sound reasoning and punish stupidity. Deep down, Haley has to
realize his team is 2-0 thanks more to his special teams and defense
than his offense (which is supposed to be his specialty). With
that said, Charles’ owners knew that Jones could stand in
the way of Charles’ early success the day Jones signed with
Kansas City, so be advised that it might take a little while for
Charles’ stock to skyrocket again.
As critical as I just was about Haley’s lack of common
sense so far this season, I was even more mystified by the use
of the RBs in Buffalo in Week 2. The Bills insist none of their
RBs are available for trade, but if last week wasn’t a “showcase
game” to drive up Lynch’s price tag in a potential
trade, I don’t know what it was. Further consider that Buffalo
opted to start the one player (Lynch) against the one team (Green
Bay) that he has been linked to since Ryan Grant was lost for
the season. Otherwise, what kind of world do we live in where
the hot-shot, big-play rookie RB (CJ Spiller) receives one late
carry and five total touches while the third-string RB (Lynch)
who missed most of the offseason workouts is rewarded with the
feature-back role? To top it off, the one RB who is injured (Fred
Jackson) is the one who gets the goal-line carry? Yes, HC Chan
Gailey said before the season that Jackson would get worked in
slowly coming off his injury, but in a game vs. the Packers in
which Buffalo could have used all the big-play weapons it could
possibly muster, the combination of Spiller and WR Lee Evans saw
a combined four targets and five total touches in the passing
game (all Spiller’s).
It took all of one-week-plus for Mike Tolbert to throw himself
back into the goal-line back discussion in San Diego. As of right
now, Chargers HC Norv Turner believes that Tolbert and Ryan Mathews
will split the workload at the stripe, but the rookie stated on
Wednesday that he sustained the dreaded high ankle sprain in Week
2, which may open the door for Tolbert to claim the goal-line
job for himself while Mathews returns to full health. I only mention
the situation in San Diego to remind Mendenhall’s owners
to be prepared for the same fate with their likely RB1. Protect
yourself by picking up Isaac Redman, dealing Mendenhall while
he is still carrying his preseason value or risk losing a great
deal of value when the Steelers morph back into a passing offense
in a few weeks when Ben Roethlisberger returns. You’ve been
forewarned…
Notable WRs who missed the cut:
Devin Hester, Mike Williams (SEA), Mike Wallace, Lee Evans, Chris Chambers, Bernard Berrian, Nate Burleson, Robert Meachem
Quick Hits: Like I did for the
RBs, let’s take a quick look at the target leaders at WR
after two weeks last season (in order of targets/game):
1. Steve Smith - CAR (14)
2. Santonio Holmes (12.5)
3. Randy Moss (12)
4. Andre Johnson (11.5)
5. Ted Ginn Jr. (10.5)
6. Nate Burleson (10.5)
7. Steve Smith - NYG (10.5)
8. Calvin Johnson (10)
9. Roddy White (10)
10. Reggie Wayne (10)
Whites' 17.5 targets per game is music
to fantasy owners' ears.
The offseason bonding that occurred between Matt Ryan and Roddy
White must have really been something special. While some of his
obscene 17.5 targets/game can be attributed to the absence of
Michael
Jenkins, it doesn’t explain why he is also eating into what
should be an increased target rate for TE Tony Gonzalez. Regardless,
expect White to remain at or near the top of this list all season
long.
If owners are hoping to target a WR that is on the verge of having
a huge game, allow me to recommend Terrell Owens, Santana Moss
and Calvin Johnson. In all likelihood, “Megatron”
won’t be all that easy to pry away since his owner likely
invested a second-round pick into him. However, the target rates
for Owens and Moss are high enough that it is probably just a
matter of time before their fantasy numbers really take off. Owens
is likely the safer bet of the two given his supporting cast,
but one could easily make the argument that since Washington has
fewer mouths to feed in the passing game, Moss is the better bet
of the two to see consistently high target numbers.
I wasn’t entirely sure I wanted to invest anything of value
into Mark Clayton despite a dynamic Week 1 performance, but it
is becoming more and more clear that rookie QB Sam Bradford is
willing to lean on him. Despite being guarded by Raiders CB Nnamdi
Asomugha for most of the day, Clayton still saw five targets and
scored both of the Rams’ touchdowns, although neither TD
came against the Oakland’s top CB. With upcoming games against
the likes of the Lions, Bucs and Panthers in the first half of
the season; Clayton is nearing the point where we can consider
him a regular WR3 in 12-team leagues.
Another player that may be available on the cheap – given
that he did not play in Week 1 – would be Broncos’
rookie Demaryius Thomas. Since 1995, only three rookie WRs had
a better NFL debut than Thomas did in Week 2 (Anquan Boldin, Eddie Royal and Randy Moss). In Boldin and Moss’ case, we are
talking about elite physical talents. In Royal’s case, it
isn’t hard to recall how he took advantage of Brandon Marshall’s
absence in his debut, abusing then-Raiders CB DeAngelo Hall in
the second game of the Monday Night Football opener two seasons
ago. Thomas, while certainly a raw talent, is more in line with
the Moss and Boldin than he is with Royal in that regard. The
rest of the top 10 list of rookie WR debuts has its studs (Marvin
Harrison, DeSean Jackson), players who it is too early to make
a call on (Louis Murphy), pedestrian veterans (Deion Branch) and
players who flamed out quickly thereafter (JuJuan Dawson, Charles
Rogers). With all that said, QB Kyle Orton showed instant rapport
with his highly-touted rookie, targeting Thomas nine times in
just two series vs. Seattle.
By all accounts, “Bay-Bay” is a high-character, smart,
team-first player, so owners should not worry about a Rogers-like
ending. While Denver will be smart about limiting his snaps early
on (he was sidelined by a foot injury for most of the offseason
and training camp), Orton may make it clear in another 2-3 weeks
that he is ready to depend on Thomas in much the same way he did
Brandon Marshall. No, the rookie isn’t going to automatically
step into Marshall’s 100-catch shoes, but for owners looking
for a fairly low-risk but a potentially high-reward option, Thomas
may be a good investment if he is truly over his foot problems.
Still, those owners who invest in Thomas should be warned he should
be viewed as a roster stash for the second half of the season,
in part due to his abbreviated offseason but also because of the
Broncos’ upcoming schedule (Colts, Titans, Ravens, Jets,
Raiders and Niners before their Week 9 bye).
Perhaps it is a good time to invest in Darrius Heyward-Bey, but
I doubt it. In fact, like DHB, Ted Ginn used a huge Week 2 last
season to soar up the target list only to not be heard from again.
As you can imagine with such a small sample size, one big week
will skew the averages and I tend to believe owners will look
back at Week 2 and wonder why Heyward-Bey disappeared so quickly.
Substantial improvement should be expected from DHB in his second
season with reports that he enjoyed another great offseason, but
Louis Murphy and Zach Miller are the only players that should
be owned – much less used – from the Oakland passing
game.
Owners of Saints’ receivers know the drill by now. Drew
Brees does a great job of spreading the wealth, meaning a player
like Marques Colston suffers in fantasy because RBs like Reggie
Bush and Pierre Thomas collect 80+ receptions in the short-passing
game and two deep threats (Devery Henderson and Robert Meachem)
steal a good deal of his potential down the field. However, in
light of Bush’s leg injury that may sideline him six weeks,
New Orleans will need to re-evaluate its pass distribution. Certainly,
Thomas figures to get some of Bush’s touches, but look for
Moore and Colston to benefit as well. While Bush is a big-play
threat, he often receives the ball near the line of scrimmage.
Those throws won’t leave the offense just because Bush is
absent, so I’d imagine the Saints’ two best possession
receivers will get more work, meaning Colston should see his numbers
improve while Lance Moore could again be worth a look.
I’ll wrap up this segment by discussing a player I was
very high on two weeks ago: Dwayne Bowe. Let’s just say
that all the goodwill that HC Todd Haley built up with me over
his career as an assistant and coordinator is quickly being tested.
Mind you, I don’t often make it a habit to criticize 2-0
teams, but not acknowledging that Charles is one of the league’s
most dynamic runners is one thing; not using Bowe when he is the
only established receiving threat on the team is a whole other
issue. Certainly, rookies Dexter McCluster and TE Tony Moeaki
appear to be on their way to being solid pros, but the fact that
Bowe has only been targeted on 10 of Matt Cassel’s 50 throws
so far is mind-boggling. What makes this even more puzzling is
that Bowe – who wasn’t exactly known for a strong
work ethic – was praised for his willingness to take a leadership
role with the team and his work habits this offseason. Also, let’s
remember that a less mature Bowe was a dominant pro WR with the
likes of Tyler Thigpen and Brodie Croyle serving as his QB just
a few years ago. While his two-game start to the 2010 season is
highly disappointing, the weather conditions in San Diego in Week
1 limited the passing attack and the Browns’ dismal offense
didn’t exactly force the Chiefs to turn their passing game
last week. With upcoming games against the Niners, Colts and Texans,
expect the passing game (and Bowe) to be called upon more often.
Notable TEs who missed the cut:
Brent Celek, Heath Miller, Owen Daniels, Tony Gonzalez
Quick Hits: Because tight ends
are people too, let’s take a quick look at the target leaders
at TE after two weeks last season (in order of targets/game):
1. Kellen Winslow (9.5)
2. Brent Celek (9)
3. Chris Cooley (8.5)
4. Antonio Gates (8)
5. Tony Gonzalez (8)
6. John Carlson (8)
7. Owen Daniels (8)
8. Jason Witten (7)
9. Dallas Clark (7)
10. Jerramy Stevens (7)
Who could have imagined that four of the top TEs from last season
would struggle to see targets through two weeks? Miller’s absence
from the list is acceptable considering he hasn’t had Ben Roethlisberger
under center and Daniels can be excused because his snaps are
being limited as he recovers from knee surgery. But Celek and
Gonzalez’s disappearing act thus far is shocking. However, two-game
“dry spells” are fairly common in fantasy, so owners are advised
to ride their starts out just a bit long, even if they have contributed
to your team’s slow start.
The best thing owners of these struggling TEs can do is look
to the waiver wire and see if the likes of Tony
Moeaki, Aaron Hernandez or Marcedes
Lewis are still available. Moeaki’s target rate speaks for
itself, although he had trouble staying healthy while he was in
college. I’ve seen Hernandez play in the preseason and in each
of his two regular season games; let’s just say that I wondered
during their Week 2 loss against the Jets if Tom Brady went to
management last season and asked for his very own Dallas
Clark. The rookie from Florida reminds a lot of a smaller
but faster version of the Colts’ TE. Lewis, on the other hand,
was on my radar in the preseason as he enjoyed his finest offseason
as a pro, according the Jags’ coaches. He won’t record a nine-target,
70-yard performance every week like he did in Week 2, but as his
two-score Week 1 will attest, he is one of David Garrard’s favorite
red-zone options. Perhaps the most comforting thing I can say
to Gonzalez and Celek owners is that players such as Vernon
Davis and Zach Miller did not appear on the top 10 list above
at this point of the season last year, so be patient.
As most of us know by now, a high target rate does not guarantee
production; it only serves as one of several indicators that help
predict future production. Much as was the case last year, Carlson
finds himself in the area of a decent percentage of Matt Hasselbeck’s
pass attempts, but only about half of them are connecting. Fantasy
owners knew to be leery of the Seahawks’ passing game this season,
but it is not a good sign that Carlson has yet to score when you
consider what he has around him. Carlson will find the end zone
from time to time, but I’d certainly be willing to bench him (if
I owned him) for any of the three TEs I mentioned in the paragraph
above at the moment.
Conversely, Witten’s owners should keep sticking him in their
lineup, although they have to be wondering what happened to Tony
Romo’s best friend. In my research, I discovered that Witten’s
“connect rate” with Romo was 76% last season; after two games
this season, it is just 50%. While it’s tough to see Witten so
low on the rankings after two weeks, you can be assured that if
he continues seeing eight targets/game, his numbers will come.
Do you need something else to consider? Witten could easily have
enjoyed a monster PPR game in Week 2 as five of Martellus
Bennett’s eight targets came after the team refused to let
Witten go back into the game after he sustained a concussion.
We’ll conclude this edition of the Blitz by welcoming back Keller
to fantasy relevancy. The Jets’ TE greatly benefited from OC Brian
Schottenheimer opening up the offense in Week 2. Assuming New
York allows Mark Sanchez to play a bit of QB from time to time
and doesn’t always him to be a “caretaker”, Keller could eventually
become a low-end TE1 in fantasy. Still, Keller’s owners should
have another decent TE option on their roster just in case.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article or fantasy football
in general? e-mail me.
|