For the first time in several years, peace exists in the NFL. There
is no threat of a lockout – either by the players or the officials
– while the new rookie wage scale has led to a number of drafted
players to sign their contracts in time for mini-camp. While rookie
holdouts give the media something to talk about during training
camp, there are ultimately bad for business because they stunt the
overall growth of a young player that needs every advantage he can
get in order to contribute as quickly as possible.
Although dynasty owners have already started the process of evaluating
the new wave of players set to make their NFL debut, most redraft
owners are only in the initial stages of formulating opinions
about the kind of fantasy impact this rookie class will have.
Draft preparation is quickly evolving into a year-round job and
owners – dynasty, keeper or redraft – can quickly
find themselves behind their competition if they haven’t
started the process of becoming “the smartest guy in the
draft room” by now.
In a league where very little stays the same from year to year,
rookies represent the greatest of all unknowns. Running backs
continue to steal the show when it comes to immediate contributions,
but we have all been witness to incredible seasons from rookies
at quarterback, wide receiver and tight end in recent years. While
we can only speculate on which rookies will deliver the most impact
this season, there are some guidelines we can follow and questions
we can ask in order to help us identify the players who have the
best shot at becoming the next big thing. The following questions
give us a good starting point:
- Is he in a position to succeed? For a RB,
does he have a good line to run behind and an OC that likes
to run the ball? What is the likelihood of a consistent workload?
For a QB, does he have a good pass-blocking line and 2-3 quality
options in the passing game? For a WR or TE, does he have a
good QB throwing him the ball? Does he operate opposite a star
WR or is he being counted on to carry the passing game?
- What are his most obvious obstacles? This
question goes hand-in-hand with the first question, but the
successful fantasy owner cares just as much about why a player
will likely fail as he/she does about how/why a player will
thrive. For example, how much do we penalize Tavon
Austin for his lack of ideal size? Is natural talent along
with a huge void for a playmaker at receiver going to be enough
for Aaron
Dobson to overcome a huge step up in competition and make
an immediate impact in New England? Does the fact that Eddie
Lacy was drafted ahead of Johnathan
Franklin have much/any impact on which player will be the
better fantasy performer?
- Is he an offensive building block, complementary piece
or role player?
- How is the “fit” with his new team and does his style
mesh with what the team is trying to accomplish or is the offense
going to cater to his talents? (Unfortunately, we can’t
take for granted that personnel departments always do this for
themselves – need can be a terrible evaluator of talent.)
Does the return of zone-blocking guru Alex Gibbs to Denver help
or hurt Montee
Ball? Are Tyler
Eifert’s deep-ball skills a good fit in Cincinnati’s West
Coast offense? Can we trust OC Todd Haley will get the most
from Le’Veon
Bell in Pittsburgh?
Certainly, there are always going to be more questions than answers
at this point of the year. But to establish a baseline for a rookie,
I think this gives us a pretty good start. Over the next two weeks,
I will evaluate the likely top rookies from this class – covering
the back half of my top 20 this week and the top half next week
– and attempt to detail their situations in an effort to answer
whether or not they are worthy of your consideration in fantasy.
At the very least, I hope to provide each of you with my early assessments
on each player (complete with player strengths and weaknesses, mostly
from a fantasy perspective) before I really buckle down on player
evaluations in July and August using Preseason Matchup Analysis.
Note: The rankings
below are for the 2013 season only and are ranked in order of
likelihood of fantasy impact. (For example, QBs like Geno
Smith or EJ
Manuel may accrue more fantasy points given the nature of
their position, but the chances of them impacting a fantasy team
are slimmer than say, a potential fantasy WR3 in a three-WR league,
because the WR may end becoming an every-week fantasy starter.)
Players who just missed the cut (in no particular order):
Geno
Smith, QB NY Jets – In New York, the question isn’t if Smith
will win the quarterback competition, but when. The bigger question
is if Smith – who played in West Virginia’s up-tempo spread attack
– is a system fit in OC Marty Mornhinweg’s West Coast offense.
So why doesn’t he make the Top 20? Simply put, it’s hard to find
what Jets’ skill-position player is going to threaten the defense.
Chris Ivory was a solid, low-cost trade acquisition, but Dustin
Keller left for Miami, Santonio Holmes (Lisfranc) is far from
a lock to be ready for training camp and Stephen Hill did little
in his rookie year – outside of Week 1. Jeremy Kerley proved to
be a solid slot option last season while little-known TE Hayden
Smith was a standout in practices last season – according to ex-GM
Mike Tannenbaum – but that hardly qualifies as a cast of stars
ready to take Broadway by storm.
Tyler
Wilson, QB Oakland – While no owner should want to start a
Raider quarterback this fall, any signal-caller that has a good
shot at landing a permanent starting spot in his team’s lineup
needs to be on the radar in fantasy. Matt Flynn will enter training
camp as the likely favorite, but Wilson is only one forgettable
college season removed from being considered a potential top-10
NFL Draft pick. Wilson’s star faded during the 2012 season at
Arkansas for a number of reasons, not the least of which was a
poor offensive line. To his credit, Wilson continued to show resiliency
and toughness in the pocket despite the punishment he absorbed.
He won’t have a great line to work with in Oakland initially either,
but a re-emphasis on a power running game and a pair of talented
young receivers will help. Flynn was not acquired to be the long-term
answer, so it is very possible Wilson could surpass him on the
depth chart during training camp.
Denard
Robinson, RB Jacksonville – The Jaguars must have been pretty
convinced that “Shoelace” is going to make the switch from college
quarterback fairly quickly (or have a lot of trust in Justin Forsett,
which is highly unlikely). Of course, it helps that he produced
as a running quarterback in college and has looked like a natural
running back in limited snaps at the position. Robinson is obviously
going to be a project as a receiver out of the backfield and a
blocker, but there is little doubt he has the playmaking ability
to succeed as an “offensive weapon”. Jacksonville has already
suggested it will give him 10-15 plays initially, which is a pretty
decent starting point for a fifth-round pick learning a new position.
The Jags need as many explosive playmakers as possible and, with
Maurice Jones-Drew getting older and coming off injury, Robinson
isn’t too far away from fairly significant fantasy value.
Knile
Davis, RB Kansas City – Davis is an upright runner who was
unable to play at all in 2011 and was ineffective in 2012. Critics
also want to hold the fact that he managed only 3.4 YPC and fumbled
eight times in 123 touches in his final year against him. I have
little issue with the first concern since the entire Arkansas
team was torn apart by the Bobby Petrino fiasco and he was coming
off a serious ankle injury. The fumbling issue has merit, but
can be corrected. In fantasy, owners tend to gravitate to the
corner of Opportunity Road and Talent Drive, especially at the
running back position. Davis’ physical talent is undeniable, as
he showed at the NFL Combine. He was a two-time team captain and
obviously willing to pay the price, so he appears to have it together
above the shoulders. In Kansas City – like Robinson in Jacksonville
– Davis faces little in the way of true competition behind Jamaal
Charles for a coach in Andy Reid that has traditionally gotten
good production from his backs, especially in PPR leagues. Peyton
Hillis’ 7.3 touches/game from 2012 probably represents the ceiling
for Davis in Year 1, but the rookie could easily find himself
as the featured back if Charles was lost for a significant part
of the season due to injury.
Latavius
Murray, RB Oakland – The Central Florida product is a straight-line
223-pound back who packs a bit of a punch – making him a great
fit as Oakland returns to the gap-blocking scheme that helped
Darren McFadden thrive in 2011. Incidentally, he has been compared
to McFadden by some for that very reason while others – such as
NFL Films’ Greg Cosell – suggests his playing style resembles
DeMarco Murray’s. The sixth-round rookie will likely begin camp
third on the depth chart, but could easily ascend to the No. 2
spot behind McFadden if Rashad Jennings proves to be the plodding
back he was in Jacksonville last season. The No. 2 spot in Oakland
has been a solid source of low-cost fantasy production in recent
years given how often McFadden is sidelined, so Murray could be
more than useful in redraft leagues if/when “Run DMC” misses his
usual 3-6 games due to injury.
Da’Rick Rogers, WR Buffalo – Rogers is the ultimate boom-or-bust
player in redraft or dynasty leagues. Considered by many to be
a first- to second-round talent by many during the draft process,
Rogers could easily emerge as the WR1 in Buffalo in a year or
two. (That’s not a misprint.) In fact, one Bills scout compared
him to Eric Moulds. Or, he could be out of the league before the
start of the season (if new HC Doug Marrone is to be believed)
if he commits yet another substance-abuse violation – the same
thing that caused him to be dismissed from Tennessee. More talented
than fellow rookie Robert Woods or veteran Steve Johnson, Rogers
is a complete roll of the dice given his off-field history. However,
his talent is such that he could force his way past Woods into
the starting lineup before the end of the season if he has truly
moved past his off-field problems.
And now, the bottom half of my top 20 impact rookies for 2013:
20.
EJ Manuel, QB Buffalo
2013 Projected Role: Starting QB
by midseason
Positives: Manuel has at least
two key factors working in his favor if he hopes to become a starter
in 2013: 1) the durability of Kevin
Kolb and 2) top-notch physical tools. Kolb, who has never
played more than nine games in his six-year NFL career – has proven
to be an injury-prone backup-caliber quarterback at best, making
him something of the ideal placeholder for a rookie quarterback
that will need all the time he can get to develop. New HC Doug
Marrone and the Bills’ brain trust likely settled on Manuel as
their top quarterback in the draft because they want to become
an up-tempo offense that works out of the shotgun or pistol formation
and wanted to make the read-option an important part of their
attack. Manuel gives them that in a 6-5, 237-pound package and
should help open up running lanes for C.J.
Spiller initially.
Negatives: Manuel is a project,
make no mistake about it. Marrone acknowledged at rookie mini-camp
that Manuel needs help with his footwork and mechanics, although
that shouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone who watched him play
or go through the draft process. The biggest concern with Manuel
should be decision-making as a number of his other perceived weaknesses
should get ironed out when Marrone and his staff work on Manuel’s
footwork and mechanics on a daily basis. Although Buffalo brought
in some receiver upgrades in the draft (Woods) as well as through
the undrafted rookie free agent market (Rogers) and has Johnson
and Spiller to ease Manuel’s transition, at least half of his
likely supporting cast figures to be unproven when he cracks the
starting lineup.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: If Manuel
is counted on to carry the offense more than Spiller in 2013,
the Bills are doomed to fail. Manuel has more than enough talent
to be a future fantasy stud, but an up-tempo offense and the ability
to run isn’t enough to overcome the number of inconsistencies
he showed in his game at Florida St. Even with his obvious physical
talents, the mere fact that Manuel is likely to start at some
point in 2013 doesn’t make him a good (or likely consistent) redraft
option. Manuel makes the top 20 list simply because he plays a
position in fantasy where most leagues roster at least 24 of the
32 starting players, so there will be weeks in which his athletic
ability will allow him to be a passable option.
Fearless late-May prediction (eight starts):
143-of-275 for 1,595 yards, 10 TD and 13 INT; 65 rushes for 325
yards and three rushing TDs
19.
Terrance Williams, WR Dallas
2013 Projected Role: Cowboys WR3; role player.
Positives: Despite less-than-ideal track speed (4.52-40), Williams
was one of college football’s best field-stretchers in 2012
and joins an offense that doesn’t mind taking shots down
the field. While he has no chance at cracking the starting lineup
in the near future, Dwayne Harris represents his only real competition
for the WR3 role in Dallas behind Dez Bryant and Miles Austin.
Bryant is a physical receiver who played all 16 games for the
first time in his three-year career last year while Austin and
his balky hamstrings remain a concern, meaning Williams has a
realistic shot at drawing some starts in a very talented offense.
The selection of Williams was likely the Cowboys’ way of
not only trying to create solid depth, but also bring back the
dynamic three-receiver package that served the team so well back
in 2011 when Laurent Robinson enjoyed a career year.
Negatives: For a college player that was so productive in his
final college season (97 catches, 1,832 yards and 12 touchdowns),
Williams is a bit too one-dimensional at this point of his career.
The Baylor alum fell in the draft in part because he appears to
lack quick-twitch explosiveness and a physical element to his
game, which may mean his NFL upside is nothing more than a deep-ball
specialist. Williams also has had his problems with drops (which
carried over to Senior Bowl practices as well as rookie mini-camp),
but seems to be much more consistent in that area down the field
– likely meaning he suffers more from concentration lapses
than bad hands.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Williams offers some of the same qualities
Robinson gave the Cowboys two years ago and is a better receiver
than the team’s last WR3 (Kevin Ogletree), so he has a shot
to post a few solid fantasy lines this season. However, every
skill-position player in the team’s starting lineup is a
good – if not great – receiver and will be above Williams
in the passing-game pecking order, meaning Williams will likely
produce a few “splash” games followed by 3-4 games
with little to no statistical production. Bryant and Austin owners
will probably value him the most in redraft leagues simply as
insurance against injuries to whichever one of the Cowboys’
receivers they own because he is a likely injury (to Bryant or
Austin) away from low-end WR3 status in what should be a very
productive offense.
Fearless late-May prediction (four starts):
34 receptions for 535 yards and three TDs
18.
Zach Ertz, TE Philadelphia
2013 Projected Role: Eagles “move” TE; role player.
Positives: Ertz is a bit bigger than the prototypical “F”
tight end, a position that Aaron Hernandez has helped popularize
in recent years. But whereas Hernandez (6-1, 245) gets by more
on speed, quickness and versatility for a man with his physical
dimensions, Ertz is a field-stretcher in part because he has a
good blend of traditional tight end size (6-5, 250) and “sneaky
speed”. While Ertz isn’t going to serve as a ball-carrier
out of the backfield like Hernandez famously did during the 2011
playoffs, Ertz was drafted by the Eagles to be that “moveable
chess piece” that dictates defensive personnel and exploits
favorable matchups down the field in new HC Chip Kelly’s
up-tempo offense.
Negatives: It’s ironic that Stanford
made its name in recent years by using two- and three-tight end
sets and playing “smashmouth football”, but has produced a pair
of second-round players at the position in consecutive years that
are more “rocked-up receivers” as opposed to complete tight ends.
Just like Coby
Fleener was on the field less than most people expected in
2012, Ertz figures to be third in line when it comes to snap count
in 2013. Whereas Fleener only had to compete with fellow rookie
Dwayne
Allen for playing time, Ertz will need to overcome two very
capable and complete tight ends in Brent
Celek and James
Casey. And while it shouldn’t impact him long-term, Stanford’s
late graduation (which will limit his participation in OTAs) may
also reduce his chances of making an early impact in the NFL.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: In what will likely be the first of
many preseason mentions of the “Chip Kelly influence”,
Ertz figures to benefit from the new regime simply because tempo
and volume of plays means more opportunity to create mismatches
and generate fantasy production. Philadelphia is stocked with
tight ends, so stellar rookie numbers will probably be hard to
attain. However, Ertz is too good in the passing game not to be
useful at least a handful of times in fantasy this season. Kelly
loved to use his tight ends down the middle of the field at Oregon
and it’d be a surprise if that aspect of his offense did
not carry over to the NFL, especially since he has two players
in Casey and Ertz that can thrive as downfield receivers. Casey
(and Celek, if he remains with the team) will prevent Ertz from
achieving fantasy TE1 consistency in Year 1, but he has the talent
and is in the right offense for that kind of production down the
road if Kelly remains in Philadelphia long-term.
Fearless late-May prediction (zero starts):
32 receptions for 455 yards and three TDs
17.
Joseph Randle, RB Dallas
2013 Projected Role: Cowboys RB2; role player.
Positives: Randle offers (or at least should offer) something
Dallas has not consistently had at the running back position since
Emmitt Smith – durability. The 6-0, 204-pounder does a solid
job of using his blockers effectively and is an asset in the passing
game, which may be the way Dallas tries to keep DeMarco Murray
healthy more often. And it is in those two areas he serves the
Cowboys best – as a dependable back in the event Murray
again struggles to stay on the field and as a receiver in order
to preserve the team’s feature back. Randle also has the
ability to dodge a penetrating defender in the backfield and has
a little wiggle to make tacklers miss, traits that figure to come
in handy behind Dallas’ less-than-stellar offensive line.
Negatives: Randle possesses a few contradictory qualities that
will likely relegate him to little more than a clear backup to
Murray. He is an effective receiver out of the backfield, but
is not a breakaway threat or all that elusive. Randle showed that
he can run inside in college, but has limited power in his lower
body and doesn’t possess great balance, meaning he isn’t
likely to take the short-yardage and/or red-zone duties from Murray
either. While durability and receiving ability are two of his
most obvious strengths, Randle will be limited until training
camp due to right thumb surgery. Although owner Jerry Jones told
the Fort Worth Star-Telegram the team knew of the fifth-round
pick’s status prior to his selection, it obviously won’t
help him lock up the RB2 job in short order if one of his few
strengths is compromised.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Owners looking for this year’s
version of Alfred Morris or even Vick Ballard – a late-round
RB steal who produces at a high level – probably aren’t
going to find that running back in Randle. It is almost as if
Dallas decided to go in a completely different direction (slower
and more durable) from Felix Jones (faster but injury-prone).
In the end, Randle’s rookie contributions could very well
mirror Jones’ stats last season (111 carries for 402 yards,
25 receptions for 262 yards), assuming Murray is forced to miss
time due to injury again this season. Dallas smartly addressed
its offensive line in the draft with C Travis Frederick, which
can only help the running game. Still, Randle’s value in
2013 figures to come down to how often he must start in place
of Murray.
Fearless late-May prediction (four starts):
105 rushes for 440 yards and two TDs; 26 receptions for 180 yards
16.
Cordarrelle Patterson, WR Minnesota
2013 Projected Role: Vikings WR2; complementary piece.
Positives: Patterson is the quintessential big-play receiver
in a passing offense that will draw favorable looks almost every
week due to the attention Adrian Peterson demands. The 6-2, 216-pound
wideout is a fascinating blend of size, speed and elusiveness
and may be the most elusive big-bodied receiver to come out in
recent drafts. While expectations for him will be high in the
long-term, the pressure on him to carry the passing game anytime
in the near future should be relatively low as the team’s
second receiving threat behind Greg Jennings. Even though Patterson
is proportioned much differently than the man Minnesota hopes
he can replace one day (Percy Harvin), their games are not all
that dissimilar. In regards to playing time, Patterson should
see the field right away. While it is possible he’s not
an immediate starter, Jerome Simpson will not keep him out of
the lineup for very long.
Negatives: There were two main reasons Patterson’s elite
physical skill set did not translate into a top-10 pick in April:
1) he is an incredibly raw receiver who played only one year at
the FBS level and 2) evaluators had questions about his intelligence
and/or ability to pick up an offense. Then, there is the small
matter of Christian Ponder – a quarterback the Vikings needed
to manage over the second half of 2012. Let’s also not forget
that Patterson lands in an offense coordinated by Bill Musgrave,
which has fielded only one offense in four seasons as a play-caller
that finished in the top half in yards (12th, 2003 Jaguars) or
points (14th, 2012 Vikings).
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Because
of the talent Patterson brings to the table, it would be an upset
if he doesn’t pass Simpson on the depth chart and start Week 1
– even as raw as he is. Patterson drew comparisons to the likes
of Julio
Jones and Dez
Bryant throughout the draft process because he has that kind
of talent, but he is not as polished as either player coming out
of college nor does he have the same level of quarterback or offensive
coordinator to work with. Patterson’s rookie season should be
filled with several teasers – games that make fantasy owners drool
over the kind of player he could become, but how good he becomes
down the road will mostly depend on how right (or wrong) scouts
and general managers were about him above the shoulders. Owners
should target him as a high-upside WR4 in 2013, but he may not
have a true impact on fantasy until 2015.
Fearless late-May prediction (12 starts):
38 receptions for 590 yards and four TDs
15.
Justin Hunter, WR Tennessee
2013 Projected Role: Titans WR3, complementary piece.
Positives: Short of landing with an established elite quarterback,
Hunter probably couldn’t have asked for a much better situation
long-term. QB Jake Locker is certainly on the hot seat, but if
there are two areas of his game that evaluators do not question,
they are his athletic ability and arm strength. In a vertical,
big-play offense like the Titans, Locker’s strengths should
suit Hunter well. Kenny Britt – the player Hunter will likely
replace as the “X” receiver in 2014 – seems
to always be either in the training room or trying to avoid jail
time, meaning it is entirely possible Hunter could find himself
in a featured role before the end of his rookie season. NFL Films’
Greg Cosell – an avid film watcher – called Hunter
the “most physically-talented wide receiver" in this
year's draft class.
Negatives: Before Hunter can fulfill his massive potential, he’s
going to need to add weight since a 6-4, 196-pound player is considered
lanky even by basketball standards. Until he bulks up, it is unreasonable
to expect Hunter to be a short or intermediate threat in the passing
game. Compared to A.J. Green before his 2011 ACL injury, Hunter
appeared to struggle more mentally (12.1% drop rate) than physically
in his final year of college – a surprise given that his
hands were considered reliable before the injury. While his long-term
outlook appears bright, there is always the possibility this is
the year Britt turns his life around and/or Nate Washington remains
in town. Along with second-year WR Kendall Wright, Tennessee already
has three legit NFL talents at the position, so it is safe to
say that Hunter doesn’t have a clear path to a starting
job right away.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Hunter’s rookie impact is going
to depend largely on whether the “Z” receiver spot
– the position Hunter will learn first – is there
for the taking come Week 1. (It has long been suspected Washington
will be traded or released this offseason.) A former winner of
the high-jump competition at the 2010 USA Junior Championships,
Hunter is very much like a less physical version of Britt. Assuming
he grabs the starting spot before the start of the regular season,
Hunter’s 2012 floor should be roughly what Washington produced
last season (46 catches, 746 yards and four touchdowns). However,
Washington has enough left in the tank to remain on the roster,
at least until Hunter establishes himself.
Fearless late-May prediction (11 starts):
40 receptions for 625 yards and four TDs
14.
Zac Stacy, RB St. Louis
2013 Projected Role: Rams committee RB; complementary piece.
Positives: Stacy is what Isaiah
Pead and Daryl
Richardson are not: a tough inside runner that will fight
for extra yards. The Vanderbilt alum has quick feet and good balance,
yet is nimble enough to make a defender miss in the backfield.
Those qualities alone make him the odds-on favorite for short-yardage
and goal-line responsibilities in St. Louis from the start, now
that Steven
Jackson has moved on to Atlanta. Perhaps the most refreshing
thing about Stacy is that he is a natural runner – with good patience
and vision – and not an athlete a team hopes will develop those
instincts. Stacy, who recorded 438 touches from 2011-12, did not
miss a game over his final two seasons as a Commodore.
Negatives: On the downside of being what Pead and Richardson
are not is the fact that Stacy doesn’t have breakaway speed
and is likely destined to be a committee back as long as either
one or both players are around. While he is nimble, he isn’t
exactly elusive. The 5-8, 216-pounder also isn’t going to
much work in the passing game because he is somewhat average in
most aspects as a receiver, although he will likely hold his own
as a blocker. (Pead and Richardson figure to take care of most
of the receiving work out of the backfield anyway.) Stacy was
also a bit too loose with the ball in college (1.41 fumble percentage),
which teams will not tolerate from a back they want to close out
drives and games.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: The Rams went out and picked a couple
of speedy, somewhat undersized complements to Jackson last year
in Pead and Richardson. This year, Stacy represents the power
the Rams will try to replace after the loss of Jackson. Let’s
be clear: no one back is going to replace one of the best backs
in franchise history. In Stacy, however, the Rams should have
a player that is a 12-15 carry/game back that can convert at the
goal line as well as third-and-short opportunities. He’s
likely not going to spin on a dime or generate a ton of highlights,
but he should be in line for more regular scoring opportunities
than Jackson got for most of his career on a fast-improving St.
Louis team. As such, Stacy makes sense as a bye-week flex option
or high-upside RB4 in fantasy.
Fearless late-May prediction (two starts):
135 rushes for 585 yards and five TDs; 14 receptions for 100 yards
Keenan Allen's talent should allow him
to crack the starting lineup at some point in 2013.
13.
Keenan Allen, WR San Diego
2013 Projected Role: Chargers WR3, complementary piece.
Positives: Allen is a strong, competitive player with good ball
skills who is not afraid to go over the middle of the field, much
like the player he is often compared to – Anquan Boldin.
While he projects as an outside receiver, he’s more than
comfortable in the slot and could make an impact there right away
for the Chargers. At first glance, Allen appears to face a steep
climb up the depth chart. However, Danario Alexander has a long
injury history, Malcom Floyd has played one full NFL season in
eight years and Vincent Brown missed all of last season. Allen
is the type of player that can serve as a team’s emotional
leader and will endear himself to the coaching staff right away
for his ability to block and find holes in zone coverage –
the latter of which can often be a mystery to some young receivers.
Negatives: There were two key reasons why Allen lasted as long
as he did in the draft. Talent evaluators knew before the Combine
he wasn’t going to post a jaw-dropping 40 time, but the
bigger issue was the Grade 2 PCL injury he suffered to his left
knee that was slow to heal. The injury cost him his final three
college games and essentially sabotaged any ability he had to
improve his standing during the draft process. The lack of game-breaking
speed (even when healthy) will likely keep him from ever evolving
into an elite receiver while his injuries – he also needed
ankle surgery last offseason after getting injured playing basketball
– throws his durability into question.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Allen was considered a lock as a first-round
pick after his 98-catch, 1,343-yard effort in 2011, so the Chargers
have to be thrilled about landing him despite his recent run of
bad luck. How quickly he fully recovers will likely determine
where he starts on the depth chart at the beginning of the regular
season, but he’s at least the second-most talent wideout
on the team (behind Alexander). Allen is more than capable of
cracking the starting lineup at some point and could emerge as
the team’s top receiver at season’s end (given that
Alexander will be a free agent again after this year). The Cal
alum has substantial hurdles in his way at this point and should
be drafted as a WR4, but he could easily emerge as a quality WR3
option down the stretch in fantasy.
Fearless late-May prediction (eight starts):
45 receptions for 570 yards and five TDs
12.
Tyler Eifert, TE Cincinnati
2013 Projected Role: Bengals TE2; complementary piece.
Positives: Eifert was considered
the top tight end prospect for a number of reasons, not the least
of which is his ability to stretch the field at a position few
players can do that from – at any level. While he has more than
enough speed (4.68-40), it is his body control, focus and ability
to win the jump ball down the field that makes him a legitimate
intermediate-to-deep threat. Despite possessing enough size (6-6,
251) to be an effective in-line tight end, Eifert has enough athleticism
to move around all over the field in an effort to create mismatches
outside or in the slot. The 2012 Mackey Award winner also finds
himself in a low-pressure situation since A.J.
Green will almost certainly be the focus of every gameplan
for the foreseeable future.
Negatives: Despite his listed size, Eifert isn’t overly
strong and will need time to add weight, which may help him improve
as a blocker down the road. Combined with a lack of burst off
the line of scrimmage, Eifert may also be more of a zone-beater
early in his career rather than a player who consistently gets
open down the seam against man coverage. While Eifert did find
a situation in which he can benefit from not being the primary
option right away, Cincinnati is far from an ideal landing spot
for immediate production. Like it or not, Jermaine Gresham is
a two-time Pro Bowler that is tied to the team through the end
of the 2014 season while Andy Dalton is far from a polished intermediate
to deep thrower (as evidenced by his 20th-place finish in accuracy
percentage on throws 20+ yards down the field, per Pro Football
Focus).
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Regardless of how much of a disappointment
Gresham has been, it is unlikely that Eifert will unseat him as
a starter this year or end up playing more snaps. OC Jay Gruden
also hasn’t done a great job of using Gresham as a red-zone
weapon and I believe there is ample evidence to suggest that he
probably won’t get the most out of Eifert either. Gruden
has yet to show he is creative enough to showcase his players’
strengths and it is also possible Dalton won’t be able to
accentuate one of his finer qualities – coming up with the
jump ball down the field. He’s a solid dynasty prospect,
but owners may have to wait until 2015 to see a substantial return.
In redraft, he’s likely going to be a low-end TE2 at best.
Fearless late-May prediction (six starts):
36 receptions for 415 yards and four TDs
11.
Robert Woods, RB Buffalo
2013 Projected Role: Bills WR2; complementary piece.
Positives: While he doesn’t figure to be “Mr. Electric”,
Woods should be able to put an end to the Bills’ endless
search for a capable second receiver. The USC product has above-average
foot quickness and enough burst to be productive after the catch.
He also has above-average hands and knows how to get open and/or
“sit down” against zone coverage. Woods was considered
one of the more pro-ready receivers in this draft in large part
because of the pro-style attack he played in under HC Lane Kiffin
and the fact that he has already established he is able to succeed
in the short and intermediate passing game. Although he did sustain
a concussion against Utah last fall, Woods appeared in all 38
career games while starting 37, so durability is not a concern.
Negatives: Woods is unlikely to
make a huge impact in the NFL down the field, mostly because he
isn’t exceptionally fast nor does he have the leaping ability
(or the same explosion) as other higher-ranked prospects in this
class. He’s also not as strong as he needs to be yet (although
that should come in time), which leads to cornerbacks being able
to hold him up at the line of scrimmage. But his biggest obstacle
right now may be his likely quarterback. EJ
Manuel has a load of talent, but it is really just guesswork
at this point as to whether or not he will ever be anything more
than a semi-accurate athletic quarterback. Manuel’s development
will be more than a one-year project, which will obviously rob
Woods of the opportunity to max out his abilities during his rookie
season.
2013 Fantasy Assessment: Woods appeared to have a clear path
to the starting job up until the point where the team signed Da’Rick
Rogers, who was considered to be a first-round talent if it weren't
for his off-field transgressions. Woods is still almost certain
to be in the lineup Week 1, but he will be pushed at some point
by Rogers if he stays out of trouble. HC Doug Marrone’s
up-tempo offense may help Woods’ owners recoup some of the
statistical production they will lose as a result of Manuel’s
development, but the main reason why Woods finds himself as high
as he does on this list is due to the fact that he is more pro-ready
than Rogers and third-rounder Marquise Goodwin and a better player
than T.J. Graham and Marcus Easley. His 2013 fantasy ceiling isn’t
incredibly high, but his floor is not all that low either. Owners
should target him as a steady WR4 prospect this season.
Fearless late-May prediction (14 starts):
46 receptions for 575 yards and four TDs
Suggestions, comments, about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and appeared in
USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in 2010 and
2011. He hosted USA Today’s hour-long, pre-kickoff fantasy
football internet chat every Sunday this past season. Doug regularly
appears as a fantasy football analyst on Sirius XM’s “Fantasy
Drive” and for 106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C).
He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |