Identifying favorable matchups has long been a critical part of
my process (and ultimately, my success, in this hobby). The major
difference between identifying favorable matchups during the summer
and now is that the former is more of an educated guess based on
the previous season as well as player strengths and weaknesses,
while the latter comes with a bit more certainty based on roughly
two months of games during the current season.
As was the case last
week, my goal will be to highlight some non-elite players
who could be cheaper trade targets (maybe because they are coming
off a down game or two, battling through an injury or attached
to a bad offense) because they are poised to enjoy a strong second
half of the season based on multiple "soft" matchups.
I will highlight four receivers and two tight ends this week.
The focus will be the rest of the fantasy regular season. I will
likely highlight favorable matchups for the fantasy playoffs at
some point in the coming weeks.
Note: Opponents highlighted in green represent what should
be favorable matchups. Opponents highlighted in red represent
what should be unfavorable matchups.
It could be argued Thomas is already an elite player. That's
fair, although an argument could also be made that elite receivers
tend to earn at least five targets in more than half of their
games. Thomas has five or fewer targets in three straight and
five of nine games overall. What has put him on the brink of being
an elite player is the frequency with which he is hitting the
big play, which tends to be an inconsistent thing until a player
proves otherwise. He has caught each of his three contested-catch
targets on deep throws (20-plus yards) and recorded a reception
on eight of his 13 deep targets overall for 325 yards and three
touchdowns. Only Jayden Reed (90 percent) and George Pickens (64.3)
have a higher catch rate than Thomas (61.5) on deep throws among
receivers with at least 10 such targets.
The case for Thomas being a second-half stud was already strong
before Jacksonville lost Christian Kirk (collarbone) for the season
in Week 8. Gabe Davis has predictably done next to nothing for
the offense this season outside of Week 6 (21.5 of 51.7 PPR fantasy
points came in that game). Parker Washington is a better fourth
receiver than most teams have, but he cannot be expected to be
a one-for-one replacement for Kirk in the slot. Even if we assume
Evan Engram continues to average the 7.5 targets he is seeing
since his return in Week 6, Thomas is a near-lock to see more
targets than he did over the first eight contests (6.1).
While we did not get to see what his upside could be in Week
9 due to his chest injury and an improving Eagles defense, better
days should be ahead shortly. The Vikings (Week 10) and Lions
(Week 11) have done a great job of defending the run all season
and tend to work in positive game script just about every week.
Minnesota has surrendered the most points per game to receivers
(43.6), while Detroit ranks third (42.2). The Texans check in
at No. 7 (35.9). The Titans (Week 14) rank as the third-stingiest
defense against receivers, but some of their success in that area
is a product of Tennessee's opponents only targeting their receivers
139 times because the Titans have trailed by at least one score
most of the season. Even if the Titans are as good as their fantasy
points against numbers say they are, Thomas has among the most
pristine matchups for any receiver leading up to the fantasy playoffs.
Downs should be an obvious starter at this point. Then again,
the notion that Downs was ever a free agent in traditional leagues
boggles my mind. He was a sixth-round value on my Big Boards despite
entering the season with a high-ankle sprain. This is a player
who was not healthy for roughly 75 percent of his rookie season
and still earned 95 targets. There were also multiple glowing
reports about him being the most dominant receiver in training
camp.
Let's cut Downs some slack and say it took him two weeks to trust
his ankle again after missing the first two weeks of the season
to complete his recovery. Per Fantasy Points Data, Downs ranked
18th among all receivers (minimum 100 routes) in Average Separation
Score in Weeks 5-9. The point is he gets open A LOT and typically
works out of the slot, which only makes him harder to stop. Further
helping his cause is Michael Pittman Jr.'s health (or lack thereof).
Pittman has dealt with the back issue for over a month and seems
unlikely to return to form this season because of it. While it
is fair to question if Downs can handle the mantle of being the
team's lead receiver, I would argue he has already been doing
that. Furthermore, defenses do not have the luxury of committing
too many resources to Downs since Jonathan Taylor demands so much
attention.
Even without the threat of Taylor, it could be argued that he
will consistently have the easiest path to success of any receiver
on his team for the rest of the season. While the next two games
(Bills and Jets) are not great matchups for anyone in the passing
game, Downs will easily be the best option for Joe Flacco in both
games. The Lions have been among the most forgiving defenses against
receivers all season long and have been particularly susceptible
to slot receivers. For the most part, Downs will avoid Christian
Gonzalez in Week 13 and square off against Marcus Jones more often
instead. While Jones has had his moments in 2024, he was targeted
10 times during Jaxon Smith-Njigba's first big game in Week 2
and nine times against the Jets (many of which came while covering
Garrett Wilson) in Week 8. In short, Jones is not a matchup to
fear.
The entire Chicago passing game has fallen off the rails since
the team's Week 7 bye. While the Commanders and Cardinals' improved
defenses have played a role in that, very few teams have the personnel
necessary to line up confidently across from DJ Moore, Keenan
Allen and Odunze. This passing attack will find its way again.
Moore has been almost invisible over the last three games and
Allen has produced only decent fantasy performance all season
long. No player has been immune to the demise, but Odunze is the
one player who has been the least affected by it. Over the last
three games, Odunze has 10 catches for 185 yards and no scores
on 15 targets. By comparison, Moore has compiled 10 catches for
100 yards and no TDs on 18 targets. In short, if you have been
starting Moore based on his reputation recently, then you should
have been starting Odunze as well.
If things are so bad for the Bears, why am I recommending anyone
from their passing game? The way that things typically work in
the NFL is: 1) talent eventually wins out or 2) an offense that
is struggling either figures things out or the play-caller loses
his job. While OC Shane Waldron has probably performed poorly
enough for the team to question whether he should be allowed to
finish the season, one of the worst things a team can do for a
young quarterback is to keep changing things up from a coaching
and scheme perspective. Caleb Williams has shown enough flashes
- albeit mostly against the worst pass defenses in the league
- to give Waldron more time to figure things out.
Rookie receivers - especially those who are talented enough to
go inside the top 10 picks in the draft - tend to make a big leap
after a bye. Odunze has been the Bears' most productive receiver
over the team's two post-bye games. He should also remain the
opponent's secondary or tertiary concern. This likelihood should
mean teams like the Patriots (who will likely have stud CB Christian
Gonzalez shadow Moore) or the Packers (Jaire Alexander) will take
their chances on letting the rookie beat them.
Odunze's role should only grow over the remainder of the year.
If taking advantage of teams prioritizing Moore over the next
two weeks does not help the rookie, then perhaps a pair of matchups
against two of the three most forgiving receivers in Weeks 12-13
will. Odunze may not emerge as Williams' top option as a rookie,
but he has already carved out a target share on their level. With
a pair of 100-yard games on his resume and his contested-catch
ability, it would be stunning if he does not finish the season
strong.
The Titans rank 31st in passing offense at 170.8 yards per game.
DeAndre Hopkins (28.8 yards per game) is no longer in Tennessee.
Tyler Boyd (23.0) has become an afterthought. Chigoziem Okonkwo
(19.9) has exceeded 16 receiving yards twice all season. Nick
Westbrook-Ikhine has come on in recent weeks, but he has topped
60 receiving yards only four times over his five-year NFL career.
The point of this exercise is that whatever number fantasy managers
believe is a good per-game number for the Titans' passing game
for the rest of the season, there is a great chance Ridley (49.9)
is likely to be responsible for at least a third of it.
Quite often in fantasy, the "who else is going to get it"
argument is a poor one to make. I will not make it here, although
I think this is one of the rare cases where it makes sense to
do so. In two games since the Hopkins trade, Ridley has been targeted
23 times (15 versus the Lions and eight against the Patriots),
which works out to be a 32.4 percent target share. While Tennessee
does not have high-end quarterbacks on its roster, it has at least
one capable one in Mason Rudolph. (The jury is still out on Will
Levis.) While it may be too much to ask Ridley to maintain a target
share in the low 30s, who is going to keep him from doing so on
this roster? Good receivers with that kind of target share are
going to be useful in fantasy almost regardless of any other factor
- outside of perhaps extremely low volume, highly difficult individual
matchups or horrible quarterback play.
Fortunately for Ridley, most of the remaining matchups are not
overly imposing. The Chargers (Week 10) have been the stingiest
defense against receivers - by far - of the teams left on Tennessee's
schedule. Minnesota (first), Houston (seventh), Washington (15th)
and Jacksonville (fourth) rank inside the top half of the most
forgiving matchups for receivers. Only the Commanders - with their
recent addition of Marshon Lattimore - should scare Ridley's fantasy
managers, however, as the Chargers have given up three 10-plus
target games (and 14-plus fantasy points) to three receivers over
the last two weeks alone (Chris Olave, Cedric Tillman and Jerry
Jeudy). Olave had his huge game with Spencer Rattler and Jake
Haener combining for 41 passes in Week 8. The point is this: Ridley
should be considered no worse than a high-volume WR3 with legitimate
upside in four of the next five weeks.
Without question, the Dalton Kincaid experience has not been
what any of his fantasy managers wanted. The targets have been
there lately (no fewer than six since Week 3), but a 58.5 percent
catch rate (24-of-41) over that six-game span for a player with
an 8.8 aDOT (average depth of target) is poor, to say the least.
Still, a 21.4 percent target share for a tight end is always going
to be attractive to fantasy managers who are hoping for a difference-maker
down the stretch.
Matchups may not matter for Kincaid moving forward since Khalil
Shakir should get a large chunk of the work inside 10 yards and
behind the line of scrimmage (88.7 percent of his targets have
come in those two ranges). Kincaid typically does most of his
damage in the same areas. Once he is healthy, Amari Cooper will
steal some of those targets as well while also taking the bulk
of targets in the intermediate and deep passing game.
With that said, it is impossible to ignore what lies ahead for
Buffalo. The Colts (fourth) and Chiefs (second) rank inside the
top five of most forgiving matchups for tight ends. The 49ers
(22nd) are not a great matchup, but the Rams (seventh) are. If
Kincaid's managers have been able to survive this long with his
three double-digit efforts and a 13.1-point ceiling, their patience
should be rewarded at least once or twice between now and the
end of the fantasy regular season.
Sanders may not be a familiar name to most fantasy managers,
but he is a fourth-round rookie who is probably going to be on
many sleeper lists next season. He is the TE18 over the last three
weeks and has scored at least 9.9 fantasy points in three of his
last four, so he has provided a decent floor despite playing with
two quarterbacks in an uninspiring offense. In those same three
"good" weeks, Sanders has attracted a 22 percent target
share despite running only 65.6 percent of the team's routes (anything
under 70 percent for a tight end is a bit on the low end for fantasy
purposes). However, he has made up for the relative lack of routes
by leading all tight ends with 117 yards after the catch and 56
yards after contact in those same "good" weeks (Weeks
6, 7 and 9). Just as encouragingly, Sanders has run 57.6 percent
of his routes out of the slot in those same weeks.
The Carolina passing game is not going to support more than one
or two pass-catchers most weeks, but it is hard to say with any
confidence that any Panther receiver will step up once over the
next month. As a result, we should not be surprised if Sanders
plays a huge role in each of the two green matchups above and
at least one of the red ones. Kansas City and Philadelphia's cornerbacks
should be able to limit the likes of Adam Thielen (if healthy),
Jalen Coker and Xavier Legette, while Tampa Bay (Week 13) could
easily force the Panthers into negative game script for most of
the second half. The Panthers may not possess anyone who is a
"league winner" this year, but Sanders may be that cheap
piece off the waiver wire that can get some managers in deeper
leagues through the tough times at tight end and into the playoffs.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and joined the
Fantasy Points website before the start of the 2024 season. He is
also a highly successful high-stakes player who often appears as
a guest analyst on Sirius XM. Doug is also a member of the Fantasy
Sports Writers Association. Please check out his new podcast with
JJ Wenner called "The All-Out Blitz."