| 1st Quarter |
| CLE FG | 34 yards by Phil Dawson. 9:52 Time Remaining. (11 plays, 69 yards. Time of Drive: 5:08). |
| NYJ FG | 27 yards by Nick Folk. 5:52 Time Remaining. (9 plays, 33 yards. Time of Drive: 4:00). |
| CLE TD | 12 yard run by Peyton Hillis. (Phil Dawson extra point is good). 0:16 Time Remaining. (5 plays, 61 yards. Time of Drive: 2:50). |
| 2nd Quarter |
| NYJ TD | 25 yard pass from Mark Sanchez to Jerricho Cotchery. (Nick Folk extra point is good). 11:09 Time Remaining. (9 plays, 76 yards. Time of Drive: 4:07). |
| CLE FG | 23 yards by Phil Dawson. 5:13 Time Remaining. (10 plays, 66 yards. Time of Drive: 5:56). |
| NYJ TD | 1 yard run by Mark Sanchez. (Nick Folk extra point is good). 0:23 Time Remaining. (11 plays, 80 yards. Time of Drive: 4:50). |
| 3rd Quarter |
| No Scoring |
| 4th Quarter |
| NYJ FG | 25 yards by Nick Folk. 2:42 Time Remaining. (13 plays, 56 yards. Time of Drive: 7:45). |
| CLE TD | 3 yard pass from Colt McCoy to Mohamed Massaquoi. (Phil Dawson extra point is good). 0:44 Time Remaining. (10 plays, 59 yards. Time of Drive: 1:58). |
| Overtime |
| NYJ TD | 37 yard pass from Mark Sanchez to Santonio Holmes. 0:16 Time Remaining. (1 plays, 37 yards. Time of Drive: 0:08). |
