| 1st Quarter |
| No Scoring |
| 2nd Quarter |
| NYJ FG | 27 yards by Nick Folk. 9:01 Time Remaining. (9 plays, 69 yards. Time of Drive: 4:05). |
| CIN TD | 5 yard pass from Carson Palmer to Jordan Shipley. (Aaron Pettrey extra point is good). 0:43 Time Remaining. (10 plays, 63 yards. Time of Drive: 1:11). |
| 3rd Quarter |
| NYJ TD | 53 yard run by Brad Smith. (Nick Folk extra point is good). 14:13 Time Remaining. (2 plays, 69 yards. Time of Drive: 0:47). |
| NYJ TD | 13 yard pass from Mark Sanchez to Santonio Holmes. (Nick Folk extra point is good). 4:09 Time Remaining. (2 plays, 14 yards. Time of Drive: 0:48). |
| 4th Quarter |
| CIN FG | 28 yards by Aaron Pettrey. 12:33 Time Remaining. (6 plays, 15 yards. Time of Drive: 2:17). |
| NYJ TD | 89 yard kickoff return by Brad Smith. (Nick Folk extra point is good). 12:18 Time Remaining. (0 plays, 0 yards. Time of Drive: 0:15). |
| NYJ Safety | Carson Palmer sacked in the endzone. 6:52 Time Remaining. |
