Most fantasy football drafts are 16 rounds long, but once you don’t
consider the kickers – they don’t matter all that much
in the draft – and the defense – that one or two guys
who are you forced to take as a handcuff – the draft is down
to 12 or 13 rounds. That means out of the 100-plus players taken
and the many more that are not, you get 11 or 12 shots at getting
it right. Every single pick you make can be, and usually is, a huge
determining factor in how well your team does this year.
The following 10 players, I believe, are going way too early
in most drafts, strictly based on ADP. They have the ability to
ruin your draft, if you choose to select them in their current
general spots. This is not a “do not draft these players”
examination, as I actually like at least half the guys listed
here. These are players should be avoided at their current ADP,
however, and should only be selected at a bargain price.
Note: ADP based
on a 12-team standard scoring league.
Manning is a stud but quality quarterbacks
will be available to you in the middle rounds of your draft.
QB
Peyton Manning, DEN
(ADP: 1.10, QB1)
If he stays healthy Peyton Manning will have another very good
year in 2014. He will most likely be a top-five fantasy quarterback
and possibly even win a few games singlehandedly. Yes, Manning
will come through in many ways this season, but one way he will
not is the ridiculously high draft pick you will need to use to
get him. As almost always the first quarterback taken, and normally
as a first-round pick, Manning is the opposite of a value pick
for many reasons, but here are the main ones:
Change in personnel: While many
people believe Manning made Eric
Decker, the truth is that Decker is a very solid, smart player
that played his role almost perfectly within the system. With
Decker statistically being Manning’s most productive target last
season, there is no way we can say Manning should be even near
as good as was last year without Decker in the mix.
Schedule: Manning and the Broncos
may play in a relatively weak division but they play four games
this year against arguably the toughest division in football,
at least certainly in terms of defense.
Broncos defense: The Denver defense
should be much improved this year with new acquisitions and key
players returning to health. If the defense plays near its potential
then there should not be near as many shootouts as there was last
season, meaning the ball gets taken out of Manning’s hands and
into a running back’s.
Quarterback depth: There are 10
or 11 quarterbacks this year that excite me and another one or
two that I could live with and be happy as my starter. In other
words, you can basically wait until the middle roudns of your
draft and still get a very quality guy. Sure, maybe they will
be outscored by Manning, but most likely be way better value,
and overall your team will really miss losing out on an elite
running back or wide receiver that you could have taken with that
first-round pick.
Overall, Manning is a safe, stud player but he plays a position
that is not at a premium in fantasy leagues, and therefore should
be bypassed in the first couple of rounds. Grab a top-end running
back or wide receiver in addition to a near elite quarterback
a few rounds later and your team will be much better overall.
QB
Aaron Rodgers, GB
(ADP: 2.08, QB3)
I could have easily put Drew Brees in this spot, as he is going
just one pick later, and both players are simply terrible values
this year. I would like both guys to have great seasons in 2014,
and either could end up the best fantasy quarterback. There are
seven other guys who could easily end up as good or better than
Rodgers and Brees, however. Only two years ago, the Packers and
Saints were extremely pass-heavy, with running backs as an afterthought,
or in the Saints case, used more like an additional receiver.
This type of game plan made Rodgers and Brees hot commodities
in fantasy football as their volume of work lent itself to big
numbers. Both teams have begun to put more emphasis on the run
and even more importantly, a lot of other teams with good quarterbacks
have become more pass-happy, raising their values closer to that
of Brees and Rodgers. Matthew Stafford himself could easily outperform
both Brees and Rodgers, and you can get him in the fourth round
without sacrificing the pick of a stud receiver or running back
in Round 2. Seven other quarterbacks who could approach, equal
or pass Rodgers and Brees this year yet none of them are being
taken before the fourth round and most are taken after the fifth.
Missing out on Jordy Nelson, Antonio Brown, Alshon Jeffery and
Julius Thomas might make you sick, as they are some of the safer
guys in the league who also have extremely high upsides. My personal
strategy this year is to wait until at least the sixth round to
draft a quarterback.
RB
Arian Foster, HOU
(ADP: 2.08, RB11)
Arian Foster is getting dangerously close to my “Do Not
Draft” list. If injury history, workload concerns, surgery
and age weren’t enough of a concern, then you add in missed
practice time already this year and retirement talk, and you have
the makings of a real headache. For me, the first few rounds of
the draft have to be guys that can not only carry my team on a
given week, but also have a reasonable chance of being available
to do it all year long. At fantasy’s most erratic, yet valuable
position, I want someone who I am not going to have to worry about
every week, especially when I am spending one of my first two
picks on him. This is why I am avoiding Foster, especially in
the first two or three rounds:
Health: Far and away the first
reason, Foster has a growing injury history. In the offseason,
Foster underwent back surgery. He remains to carry a consistently
heavy workload and has been dinged up already in training camp.
He is a bit passed his prime in age and will be getting a ton
of work early and often – if healthy. You might as well plan on
not having Foster around for fantasy playoff time.
Retirement talk: I know this is
a small thing, but I find it difficult to trust someone who could
have one foot out the door already and might get even more frustrated
if forced to miss time again. Foster comes across to me as a guy
who cares a lot about things other than football. This is great
in terms of Foster’s life experience, not so great if you own
him in fantasy football.
Quarterback woes: The Texans offense,
in theory, will be in large part all about Foster. While I realize
that volume can lead to success in fantasy, it also means defenses
are going to key in on Foster and make Ryan
Fitzpatrick beat them. This could lead to a ton of eight man
fronts and a lot of hits on Foster.
While Foster has the skills and opportunity to be a fantasy star,
there are just too many things that make a second-round investment
too high. I would much rather take guys like Giovani Bernard,
Jordy Nelson, Alshon Jeffery and Doug Martin, all of which are
currently being drafted after Foster.
RB
Alfred Morris, WAS
(ADP: 2.10, RB12)
In most standard scoring leagues Alfred Morris finished right
around 14th for running backs last year. With a new coaching staff
that seems to be pass-heavy and prefers backs that can catch the
ball (which Morris does not do well), why is Morris being drafted
(on average) as the 12th running back this year? I understand
that Morris will still get a good amount of goal-line touches
and play a good amount on first and second down on a team with
some solid receivers who should take the pressure off the line
of scrimmage. BenJarvus
Green-Ellis also fit that exact description last season. I
do not expect Morris to fall quite that low this season, but let’s
be honest about one thing here right away: Morris is not really
a special talent. He has excellent vision and is a smart, tough
player, but he was also just a sixth-round draft pick with below-average
measurables. In other words, it is still possible that he just
came along at the right time and fit into a system that will now,
gradually start to be phased out. Morris is a guy with a relatively
high floor but also a low ceiling and not a lot of real upside
on a team that could be redefining his role. That kind of player
is a guy I wouldn't mind having as a flex player or solid backup,
but Morris is being drafted as a high-end second running back
and in some cases, even a first. That is not a risk I do not want
to take. I’d much prefer taking a stud running back in round one
and then a top-end wide receiver instead of Morris in that late
second-round area with Jordy Nelson, Antonio
Brown, Alshon
Jeffery and Randall
Cobb. If getting another RB in that range is imperative to
you go with a guy like Andre
Ellington or even C.J.
Spiller, as guys whose ceiling can take you to the promise
land.
RB
Reggie Bush, DET
(ADP: 3.09, RB16)
In both mock and real live drafts that I have done so far Reggie
Bush continues to be one of those guys that I always think “I’m
so glad somebody else picked him,” especially in the first few
rounds. While a nearly perfect storm hit last year with Bush staying
relatively healthy, missing just two games and reaching 1,000
yards rushing and 500 receiving, it could easily go down as his
career year when we look back in a few years. With a new coordinator,
new weapons for Matthew
Stafford to throw to and some legitimate competition in the
backfield, Bush’s ceiling has lowered. His floor is still where
as it always has been, as a semi-injury prone back who is more
of a playmaker and third-down back-type than a true consistent
force as a ball-carrier. While I could possibly justify Bush being
a PPR league asset, I actually see his backfield mate Joique
Bell, as being the more valuable of the two in a standard
league, even though Bell is going two rounds later. Bush is a
classic case of a guy being drafted based on last year’s performance
rather than taking his whole past history and current situation
into account. The third and fourth rounds this year are goldmines
for quality players at receiver and running back and I would hate
to waste my pick on a guy who we have most likely already seen
his best, and that best was still not a top-ten running back finish.
If you look at the current ADP’s for players in the third and
fourth rounds there is almost no player I would take Bush over,
and there are in fact guys in the fifth and sixth rounds who I
think will outperform Bush quite easily this season. I’m not saying
Bush is a bad player or washed up or anything, but he has too
many strikes against him in my book.
RB
Darren Sproles, PHI
(ADP: 7.10, RB35)
While I understand that a guy taken in the late seventh round
is probably not going to totally ruin your draft, as I said in
the opener, every pick counts. When you can minimize the players
that are not going to help you, regardless of round, you need
to do so. In a PPR league, Darren Sproles is still a low-end flex
option this season. Surprisingly – to me at least –, Sproles is
being drafted in standard scoring leagues as a top-35 running
back. The problem here, besides the horrible value, is that unless
LeSean
McCoy gets hurt, there is no way Sproles can start for you
in a standard scoring league. Ever. Now, I know people are saying,
“I’m drafting Sproles as a handcuff, not as a starter.” To this,
I have a simple counter-argument. The late seventh round is still
too early for a handcuff unless it is a clear-cut role with high-volume
opportunity. In this case, even if McCoy went down, I believe
Sproles’ role would only increase slightly as part of a committee
filling the void left by the Eagles offensive centerpiece. In
standard scoring leagues, Sproles does not offer enough value
to be taken in the middle rounds as a flex play. You’re better
off taking a chance on an actual starter or a guy with a clearer
path to playing time like Golden
Tate, Bernard
Pierce, Kendall
Wright, Eric
Decker or Carlos
Hyde. All of them are being drafted after Sproles and could
be in your starting lineup as a flex option, and/or offer higher
upside if injury opportunity presents itself.
WR
Wes Welker, DEN
(ADP: 4.07, WR17)
The first half of last season Wes Welker was an absolute beast,
scoring nine touchdowns and racking up 45 catches. After the bye
week in Week 9, the magic seemed to run out and Welker scored
just one more time then missed the last three regular season games
due to a concussion. Now, as a 33 year old, Welker will not only
be fighting for targets with Demaryius
Thomas, an improving Julius
Thomas and newcomers Emmanuel
Sanders and Cody
Latimer, but he will also be on thin ice if he gets another
concussion, after his two from last season. Welker’s touchdowns
during the first half of last year were a bit of a fluke, as he
had never had more than nine in an entire season previous to last
year. Without as many touchdowns, Welker was fairly ordinary in
standard leagues. With the addition of Sanders, who can play the
slot, Welker could lose a bunch of volume, which is where most
of his value lies. While I still like Welker in PPR leagues as
a sort of safety valve player who will get you solid points every
single week, I just do not see him as a top 20 wide receiver in
standard leagues. With little red zone ability, more competition
for targets, a quickly increasing injury history and an aging
body, Welker is kept around for his leadership, experience and
smarts. This type of player is fine for having as a flex or maybe
third receiver, but Welker is being drafted as a high-end second
receiver and that to me is a waste of a pick. In the fourth round
I’d much rather have Andre
Johnson, Roddy
White, Cordarrelle
Patterson or Michael
Floyd, who all have much higher ceilings and with floors that
are similar to Welker’s.
WR
Percy Harvin, SEA
(ADP: 5.05, WR23)
For one of the most physically talented and explosive players
in the entire league, Percy Harvin would initially seem like a
bargain as an early fifth-round pick. With a closer analysis,
however, you should pass on him anywhere near his current ADP.
For starters, Harvin scored one point during last year’s
entire fantasy season after playing in just one game. Despite
his relatively short career, Harvin’s injury history reads
like an anatomy book: He has struggled with his hamstring, hip,
shoulder, ankle, ribs, finger and leg, on top of a concussion.
Add this to the fact that Harvin is a player who goes over the
middle a lot and returns kicks for a living. You begin to realize
the tables are set for him to be physically beat up every week
he gets on the field, making Harvin one of the bigger injury risks
in the league. That alone, however, is not the only thing holding
him back. Seattle’s run-heavy offense, combined with a defense
that allows for a conservative offensive approach, equals a lot
less volume of passes being thrown, and thus, much fewer for Harvin
to catch. Sure, Harvin can take it to the house on any play, but
he is just as likely to put up a four-catch, 39-yard day than
he is a two-catch 100-yard day, if he gets on the field at all.
I like Harvin’s ceiling but he is a guy that fits the perfect
mold of a flex player or low-end boom-or-bust WR3, not a WR2,
as he is being drafted. In his ADP range there are several players
with nearly as much upside but much safer. These would include
Michael Floyd, Jordan Cameron and Torrey Smith to name a few,
all of which have a later ADP than Harvin. Don’t be fooled
by his Super Bowl performance; Harvin cannot be trusted as a consistent
weekly source of solid fantasy points and therefore is a waste
at his current ADP.
WR
Sammy Watkins, BUF
(ADP: 7.05, WR33)
A year from now we could be talking about Sammy Watkins as a
major breakout candidate but he is unfortunately on the cusp of
being drafted as one this year, as generally the 31st wide receiver
off the board. Watkins’ talent is undeniable as he is a unique
combination of speed, burst, solid build and route-running ability.
There is no doubt he will make some highlight reels this season
and probably have a couple blow-up games in the process. The issue
with Watkins this year is two-fold. First and foremost, he is
on a run-heavy team with some semi-major issues at quarterback.
Second, he is a rookie at a position that generally takes a year
or two to contribute at a high level. With a very solid stable
of running backs and a shaky second-year quarterback to protect,
the Bills are going to run the ball and run it some more. Watkins
is not a legitimate red-zone threat so he is going to have to
do most of his damage with either a high volume of targets or
an extra amount of big plays. Because of the Bills conservative
offense, the likelihood of Watkins getting a ton of targets is
low and while he can certainly make big plays, the consistency
of these occurring is going to be relatively low. This makes Watkins
a boom-or-bust type of player, which should put him in the WR4
range rather than the WR3 range that he is being drafted in. There
are much safer and/or higher upside options to choose from including
Robert
Griffin III, Jordan
Reed, Cam
Newton, Kendall
Wright, Rueben
Randle and Eric
Decker.
TE
Vernon Davis, SF
(ADP: 5.08, TE4)
Vernon Davis is a solid fantasy tight end. Last season he finished
second among tight ends in most standard scoring leagues thanks
in large part to 13 touchdowns, the most in his career in a single
season. The reason why Davis could ruin your draft is simply a
matter of value. There are three “elite” tight ends this year:
Jimmy
Graham, Rob
Gronkowski and Julius
Thomas. Davis, on most people’s lists is the fourth-rated
guy at the position, alhough many people including myself like
Cameron better. This is what I like to call “draft panic.” When
a specific position has a run on players at a certain – usually
high – tier many people worry they will miss out on a good player
at the position and therefore reach to get the next best player
at that position. This is what I believe is happening with Davis.
Of course if Davis were to put up the exact same numbers he did
last season, it would not be much of a reach at all. The likelihood
of this happening, however, is relatively low. First, we all know
touchdowns can be fluky, as Davis’ stats themselves tell us: He
had two touchdowns in 2008, then 13 in 2009. This happened again
a few years later as he had five touchdowns in 2012 and then 13
in 2013. Without a lot of volume – Davis has just one season over
70 receptions – and without a ton of yards – Davis has averaged
just over 700 the past three seasons – he becomes very touchdown-dependent,
and that is a big gamble in fantasy football. Second, the 49ers
are still a run-heavy team and this does not look like it will
change anytime soon. Finally, with Michael
Crabtree healthy, the addition of Steve Johnson and the presence
of Anquan
Boldin, Davis could find himself fourth in targets on a team
that does not pass a whole lot. What it all boils down to is that
Davis is fine to have on your roster but he is more of a seventh
round or later pick, and more of a significant reach at where
he is going. With guys like Torrey Smith, Tom
Brady, Emmanuel
Sanders and Marques
Colston all going after him, the value is simply not there.
If you want to get a solid tight end wait a few rounds and get
a guy like Jordan
Reed or Kyle
Rudolph, you will not be disappointed.
Suggestions, comments? E-mail
me.
|