Preseason Matchup Analysis
6/19/12
BAL | BUF | CIN
| CLE | DEN
| HOU | IND | JAX
| KC | MIA | NE | NYJ
| OAK | PIT |
SD | TEN | NFC
After being subjected to courtroom football for the majority of
last summer, there might not be anything better at this time of
the year than buzz that OTAs and minicamps produce. Seemingly every
team unearthed at least one gem in the draft or free agency and
nothing seems to get a fan base more energized in June and July
than hearing or reading about what their team’s draft class
has “under the hood” or what third-string veteran is
ready to make his move up the depth chart.
In my typical detailed fashion, I wanted to give each of you
the information that beat writers and, in some cases, national
columnists are providing us while also taking a way-too-early
“fantasy look” at all 32 teams. Because this time
of year is all about optimism (and since I haven’t even
attempted to begin projecting the season), most of my analysis
will reflect that glass-half-full thinking. Keep in mind, however,
the purpose of this two-part series isn’t so much to give
you my final fantasy analysis; rather, it is my hope that some
of this information will allow each of you to get a slight head
start on your own forecasts.
With this being a fantasy-focused column, I will devote my attention
over the next two weeks to the skill-position players for each
team making waves – good or bad – in their team’s
offseason workouts and provide some insight as to what it could
mean this season.
This week, we’ll take a look at the happenings in the AFC:
Baltimore
For a team coming off an AFC Conference Championship loss in a
game it could have easily won, the last thing the Ravens want
is a few of the offensive playmakers feeling underappreciated.
Unfortunately, that is the case right now as QB Joe Flacco enters
the final year of his contract believing he
is the best quarterback in the league and RB Ray Rice willing
to hold out for Adrian Peterson-like money. Flacco is supposedly
enjoying the
best offseason of his career to this point while the team
is not at all concerned that Rice
will be ready for the season given his history with the team
and strong work ethic. Despite the claims of Flacco and his agent,
fantasy owners do not need to concern themselves with the possibility
of Flacco emerging as a QB1 anytime soon. Baltimore has more offensive
talent than any time in recent memory, but it seems unlikely that
OC Cam Cameron will once again open himself to the harsh criticism
he receives from the team and fans alike when the Ravens forget
about Rice. On the other hand, Rice – assuming he reports
to camp at some point early in the preseason – should be
a lock for top-three status in just about every fantasy draft.
Sometimes a team will make a free-agent move with the idea of
making life easier on a player already on the roster as opposed
to hoping it landed a superstar. While Baltimore undoubtedly signed
Jacoby Jones in part for his return ability in the kicking and
punting game, the team was also thinking about what it could do
to make Anquan Boldin’s life a bit easier, too. Jones will
need to hold off a raw but supremely talented rookie prospect
in Tommy Streeter, but the Ravens hope that the speedy duo of
Jones and Torrey Smith on the outside will allow Boldin to operate
out of the slot full-time in three-WR packages. Given his
size and the physical nature in which he plays the game, it’s
a solid plan that may coax another fantasy WR2-caliber season
or two out of the declining Boldin.
Buffalo
One of the teams expected to make a move in the AFC next season
are the Bills, who should be exponentially better on defense with
a top 10 pick likely to start at CB (Stephon Gilmore) and a front
four that rivals some of the best defensive lines in the league.
Some analysts suggested Buffalo would have been wise to use that
first-round pick on a receiver like Michael Floyd, who may have
come in handy if Stevie Johnson’s return from groin surgery
takes long than expected. HC Chan Gailey suggested Johnson may
be ready for training camp, but any more delays would be devastating
to the team’s top wideout. Fortunately, Johnson is reporting
that while he is dealing with some residual soreness, it is not
in his groin area, but more in his hamstrings. Since exploding
onto the scene during the 2010 season, Johnson has yet to miss
a game and has performed well when he’s had to play through
pain. After seeing so many players affected by hamstring injuries
last year, it is worth keeping an eye on Johnson for that reason
alone. As of mid-June, he has started to participate in some
individual drills, so considering his track record, he should
once again be a solid fantasy WR2 as Ryan Fitzpatrick’s
favorite target in Gailey’s spread attack. And Buffalo needs
him healthy since it doesn’t have another player capable
of carrying the passing game if he were to miss substantial time.
Although the Bills have the utmost confidence in their other
skill-position starters (Fitzpatrick and RB Fred Jackson), it
is nonetheless very interesting that both players have high-profile
reserves waiting in the wings. For Fitzpatrick, his likely backup
is Vince Young, who was signed strictly to serve
as depth for Fitzpatrick. However, Gailey could easily be
tempted to promote him should Fitzpatrick suffer a second-half
swoon for the third straight season. As for Jackson, his starting
spot should be pretty secure despite C.J. Spiller’s exceptional
second-half showing at the end of 2011. While the 31-year-old
Jackson doesn’t have the wear and tear of most backs his
age, the three-year
deal he signed this offseason is team-friendly since only
the $3 M signing bonus was guaranteed. The team isn’t in
any rush right now to show Jackson the door, but Buffalo probably
wouldn’t mind it if Spiller forced its hand to make him
the feature back no later than the 2013 season. To that end, Fitzpatrick
believes Spiller “is a changed man” and ready to “make
a big jump” this season. Therefore, if Jackson enjoys
anything significantly less than the incredible start he had to
last season, the Bills might decide to move Spiller’s timetable
up and gamble that Jackson would accept a reduced role. It’s
a situation that redraft and dynasty league owners need to consider
when drafting Jackson this summer and should be enough of a concern
to keep him from being drafted like a true fantasy RB1.
Cincinnati
Perhaps the only player who has fielded more questions about his
arm strength this spring than Andrew Luck is Andy Dalton. So far,
his offensive
coordinator (Jay Gruden) and top
receiver (A.J. Green) have each predictably supported the
notion the second-year QB has the goods to get the job done and
be a long-term starter in the NFL. After the first half of his
rookie season in which some observers questioned whether or not
he was the next Drew Brees. Dalton suffered a second-half fade.
The truth of the matter is that in Gruden’s West Coast offense,
arm strength is not really that big of a deal. And until further
notice, Dalton doesn’t figure to be the center of the offense
anyway – just an important piece of it – since Gruden
and HC Marvin Lewis want the Bengals to remain a smashmouth running
team in a defense-oriented division. The major differences between
Dalton and Brees – besides age – are: 1) Brees’
willingness to take chances downfield and 2) HC Sean Payton’s
aggressive play-calling mentality. Dalton wasn’t exactly
asked to take a lot of “trust me” shots down the field
at TCU or during his rookie season and Gruden has exactly one
year of experience as an offensive coordinator. In fantasy, success
often happens when scheme and aggressiveness find a comfortable
middle ground. While Brees’ offense is perfectly suited
for big passing numbers, Dalton’s relies more on offensive
balance. Neither approach is more right or wrong than the other
in the actual game, but the former obviously lends itself to greater
fantasy success. There will be some owners who view Dalton as
a darkhorse fantasy QB1 based on his overall solid first-year
numbers, but don’t be one of those owners. Dalton’s
numbers should improve in 2012, but only slightly. After all,
it’s hard to imagine the Bengals will be that much more
explosive considering they really didn’t add dynamic playmakers
in the offseason.
Green has been
busy this offseason. In addition to talking up Dalton, he
is “cleaning up” his route running in order to build
upon his impressive rookie season. But while we have a pretty
good idea that Green will operate at an elite WR1 level for the
foreseeable future, it was what
he said about rookie Mohamed Sanu that raised eyebrows. Apparently,
Green is either very comfortable in his position as the featured
player in this offense or very impressed by the third-round rookie.
Here’s a clip of what he said about Sanu following a late
May practice: “Man, that guy is smooth. He works the middle
really well. A lot of people have questioned his speed, but the
guy has ‘football speed.’…He catches everything
with his hands, and he attacks the ball. He’s going to be
a special one…A lot of the older guys here compare him to
T.J. Houshmandzadeh. He can stretch the field and I think he’s
really going to help us out this year.” Now we know not
to trust everything that come out of practices without pads at
this point of the year, but it is telling that an athlete like
Green would be impressed by the “football speed” of
a player that rarely ever showed it – or the ability to
separate – at Rutgers. While the team
is also talking up Armon Binns and – to a lesser degree
– Brandon Tate, the team would not have selected both Sanu
and Jones with the idea that neither rookie would be a significant
player or starter at some point in 2012. Right now, that player
looks to be Sanu. So, given his well-earned reputation for working
the middle of the field, it wouldn’t come as a shock to
see Sanu eclipse the 50-catch mark as a rookie.
Cleveland
Whereas most running backs enter the league now destined for committee
work initially, rookie Trent Richardson has no such concerns.
The question becomes whether or not he’ll take on a Michael
Turner-like feature-back role (where he is replaced by a third-down
specialist of sorts) or command over 70-80% of the backfield touches
in the same way a Arian Foster or Ray Rice probably will. The
consensus seems to be that Richardson will fall in the latter
category, but it is much too early to say that for sure. The Cleveland
Plain Dealer’s Mary Kay Cabot suggests the Browns will attempt
to keep Richardson healthy in part by featuring
2011 free-agent pickup Brandon Jackson on third down. Jackson
is reportedly looking “fast
and explosive” in spring practices following the turf
toe injury that ruined last season. While Richardson has enough
receiving skills to be a threat in the passing game, expect Cleveland
to make sure it doesn’t run him into the ground either.
Look no further than the example set in Minnesota during the early
part of Adrian Peterson’s career (ironically, when new OC
Brad Childress was the Vikings’ head coach); Peterson –
who Richardson has been repeatedly compared to – regularly
ceded backfield touches to Chester Taylor for the three years
they played together for the Vikings. Now while there is a significant
difference between an in-his-prime Taylor and Jackson (now), the
fact of the matter is that Jackson is a very skilled receiver.
As such, look for Cleveland to stop short of “featuring”
Jackson on third down, instead using Richardson in a number of
short (less than three yards to go) and medium (4-6 yards) conversion
attempts. The rookie won’t set the fantasy world on fire
with his receiving totals, but he will contribute in that area.
Not since Braylon Edwards’ fourth-place finish during the
2007 season has any Cleveland receiver finished higher than 34th
in a PPR format. In fact, the team has only had one other receiver
land in the top 20 since 2000 (Kevin Johnson – 13th; 2001).
While much of the blame can be directed at the woeful quarterback
play that Cleveland has endured for the last decade or so, there
hasn’t exactly been an assembly line of receiving talent
for the team to develop either. Perhaps that one of several reasons
why there is cautious optimism that Greg Little will soon end
the recent string of ineptitude at the position. Little had a
surprising 61-709-2 line as a rookie last season despite not becoming
a regular starter until Week 6. To his credit, he had done what
he can on his end to improve in the offseason, dropping
11 pounds and doing
whatever he can to add quickness. However, one area of concern
remains his 12 drops from a season ago. Still, he’s the
closest thing the team has to a dynamic playmaker in the passing
game, so with a more talented passer (rookie Brandon Weeden) under
center, Richardson in the backfield and a full offseason to correct
his flaws, Little has a shot at high-end WR3 fantasy status this
season simply because he could be the latest reincarnation of
Brandon Marshall – a big receiver whose fantasy production
will remain somewhat consistent because he is a target monster
but suffer in terms of big numbers because he lacks enough quality
threats around him to get defenses to back off.
Denver
Difference of opinion can be a good thing. However, when there
is a stark contrast of opinion exists between members of the media
assigned to cover the team– particularly as it relates to
a player recovering from injury – there is a small problem.
Obviously, the reference here is to Peyton Manning, who got the
thumbs-down from USA Today’s Nate Davis when he stated “it
was clear…that Manning’s
velocity hasn’t quite returned”. On the very same
day, CBS Sports’ Pete Prisco pretty much suggested Manning
“can
still make all the throws” despite “maybe a tweak
here and a tweak there in the pocket”. (If this is in any
way indicative of the reporting we can sometimes get from a team’s
cap, it is little wonder we end up missing on a can’t-miss
stud from time to time in our drafts.) For those of us who use
information from writers and national columnists to give us a
slight early advantage in our leagues, it is a bit troubling that
“experts” who watched the very same practice could
have such a difference of opinion. Thankfully, ESPN.com’s
Bill Williamson sided
with Prisco a day later and longtime Colts OC Tom Moore provided
a similar opinion of Manning later in the week. It would be wise
not to underestimate Manning in Denver this summer. While he may
no longer have the skills necessary to match the elite fantasy
QBs in the league, Manning is certainly capable of another year
of prolific QB1 numbers – especially with his young and
talented receiving corps.
There has been a healthy amount of debate about the 2012 role
of third-round rookie RB Ronnie Hillman. And it is a more than
fair question considering that HC John Fox has long favored the
committee backfield approach and has stubbornly deferred to veterans
over rookies for most of his coaching career. Under the Fox regime
in Carolina, the Panthers drafted three notable running backs
(DeShaun Foster, DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart). The
good news – for Hillman supporters – is that Foster
secured 139 offensive touches, Williams 154 and Stewart 192. The
bad news is that Hillman is not the same kind of back as those
three and more like Mike Goodson, who saw a grand total of 24
offensive touches as a rookie in 2009. Granted, this analysis
is a bit lacking in that each situation is inherently different
and Hillman won’t be stuck behind Williams and Stewart,
but there is the small issue of beating out Knowshon Moreno and
Lance Ball. Hillman is starting
out fourth on the depth chart but will almost certainly move
up a spot as soon as the team decides to move on from Moreno.
On the other hand, Ball is probably the odds-on favorite to begin
the season as the third-down back since he will almost certainly
be trusted more initially by Fox and Manning, even if he lacks
the big-play ability of Hillman. Therefore, it is rather difficult
to envision a role at this point in which he sees more touches
than Foster did since he should essentially be splitting the majority
of snaps Willis McGahee doesn’t get with Ball. On the other
hand, he’s also not going to be resigned to special teams
like Goodson was either. As a result, owners should probably be
happy if he manages to reach Foster’s workload in 2012.
Houston
Ever since he joined the Texans in 2003 – the year after
they joined the league – Andre Johnson has been the one
constant on offense, when healthy. Although Houston transformed
itself into a run-heavy offense willing to lean on its impressive
young defense, it would no doubt like to give Johnson a tag-team
partner to make defenses think twice about smothering Johnson.
While Kevin Walter has proven to be a reliable receiver, he is
hardly the kind of player that alters gameplans. Despite spending
a third-round and fourth-round pick (DeVier Posey and Keshawn
Martin, respectively) on the receiver position, it could be a
relative unknown who makes this offense nearly impossible to defend.
An undrafted free agent out of Florida Atlantic, Lestar Jean was
the talk of the early part of the preseason last year before a
shoulder injury ended his year. However, his injury may have merely
delayed his breakout and given him an opportunity to absorb
the playbook. At the very least, Jean appears to have a great
shot at matching – if not exceeding – the 31-512-2
line Jacoby Jones posted last season as the team’s WR3.
But, in reality, it would be a small disappointment if the receiver
the team now calls “Big Play” didn’t exceed
that production since the team has him learning all three receiver
positions. Walter is an average possession receiver at best, so
it wouldn’t be surprising if the 6-3, 215-pound Jean is
starting over the similarly sized but less explosive Walter, who
will turn 31 in training camp. No one should expect Jean to enjoy
a Victor Cruz-like breakout in such a case, but be aware that
a top 40 WR finish isn’t out of the question for Jean.
Because the Texans figure to keep the rushing split between Arian
Foster and Ben Tate roughly the same (72% Foster, 28% Tate once
Foster returned for good from his hamstring injury) in 2012, let’s
focus our attention on the recovery of QB Matt Schaub, who missed
the final eight games of last season – including the two
playoff games – after suffering a Lisfranc injury. As far
as Houston is concerned, there is no
question he’ll be ready for training camp and the season.
With little changing in terms of offensive philosophy and receiving
talent (the rookies aren’t expected to contribute all that
much and Jean may only end up doing slightly better than Jones)
relatively unchanged, there shouldn’t be that great of a
disparity between the pace Schaub set last year (248 yards and
1.5 passing touchdowns/game) and this year. And let’s not
forget that he did that without the benefit of a healthy Johnson
for roughly half of those games. Those kinds of numbers –
even in today’s NFL – should be more than enough to
allow Schaub to serve as a high-end QB2/matchup play. As he proved
last season, he can still perform at a low-end QB1 level when
the running game is stalled or the team gets behind.
Indianapolis
While Andrew Luck’s starting job appears to be safe for,
say, the next 10-12 years, the same cannot be said for any of
the other skill-position players. Let’s begin at tight end,
where second-rounder Coby Fleener (Luck’s college teammate
at Stanford) could very well be vying for playing time against
third-round selection Dwayne Allen, considered by many as the
draft’s best all-around player at his position. But rather
than focus on two players who will almost certainly play a lot,
let’s instead address the running back situation. New RB
coach David Walker has already said Donald
Brown is the starter right now, but that the situation will
sort itself out in training camp. However, given new HC Chuck
Pagano’s edict that the Colts will be a physical, defensive-oriented
team, it doesn’t make much sense that Brown will keep his
spot all season long. Delone Carter probably fits the new offensive
thinking the best with his size, but he was largely ineffective
last season and struggled with ball security. His issues likely
contributed to the drafting of Vick Ballard, who I suspect will
be given every chance to lead what will almost certainly be a
committee attack. In the end, it wouldn’t be surprising
if the Colts were one of several NFL teams who fail to push one
runner rush over 600 yards, making it very difficult to recommend
any of them as anything more than bench material in fantasy leagues.
By virtue of reputation and the size of his new contract, Reggie
Wayne is almost certainly locked into one starting WR spot. After
that, it is anyone’s guess. Donnie Avery has always possessed
the speed to be one of the better deep threats in the league and
has the talent to fill the shoes of the departed Pierre Garcon,
but is so injury-prone that it would be a mistake for a team to
count on him being anything more than a role player. Rookie LaVon
Brazill possesses a healthier alternative to Avery and has a Garcon-like
resume (small-school deep threat), but it may be a bit much to
ask him to contribute right away coming out of the University
of Ohio. There’s also rookie T.Y. Hilton, who probably doesn’t
possess the size to hold up as an outside receiver but has the
ability to dominate in the slot.
Last but not least, there is Austin Collie – the likely
starter opposite Wayne whose best fit is as a slot receiver. After
a wonderful rookie season with Peyton Manning that rivaled anything
Brandon Stokley did in the slot in his heyday, Collie was well
on his way to a 100-catch season in 2010 before multiple concussions
ended his season. In 2011, he stayed on the field but Manning
obviously did not, so when the Colts opted to become more of a
running team, his opportunities in three-WR sets dropped off dramatically.
With Fleener’s role as the likely “move” TE,
Collie will be forced to prove he is also an outside receiver
since Indy figures to run a lot of two-TE sets, despite what Avery
says about what new OC Bruce Arians likes to do. Certainly,
Arians showed during his Steeler days that he is a pass-oriented
coach, but he also had the benefit of a dominant defense during
his Pittsburgh days, so three- to five-receiver sets are not going
to be nearly as prominent for the Colts in 2012 as they were for
the Steelers in recent years. Indianapolis’ main focus right
away should be ball-control football and picking up first downs
while taking deep shots off play-action when the running game
is working. As a result, the consistency Wayne and Collie offer
should win out over the speed Avery and Brazill bring to the table.
Wayne will still worth starting in fantasy, but just about every
other receiver needs to be considered a wait-and-see option for
now.
Jacksonville
First-round pick Justin Blackmon’s early June DUI arrest
was unfortunate to say the least, but it seems to have taken the
focus off what was the team’s biggest problem prior to the
rookie’s misstep – Maurice Jones-Drew’s potential
holdout. MJD is one of the few players in the league that doesn’t
seem to be the “holdout type” nor does he seem to
be the kind of player that would let himself slide physically
if he chose to skip mandatory workouts and/or the early part of
training camp. What is less certain, however, is to what degree
Rashad Jennings will eat into the workload of Jones-Drew this
year after sitting out all of 2011 with a knee injury. Jennings
has averaged nearly 5.4 YPC with his 123 career rushing attempts
and will receive the bulk of first-team reps for the new coaching
staff while MJD is away from the team. Jones-Drew was already
a poor bet to repeat his huge workload from last year (career-high
386 touches), but if Jennings can regain his old form this summer,
he could very well push MJD from a sure-fire fantasy RB1 to a
low-end RB1. New HC Mike Mularkey will run the ball enough that
Jones-Drew doesn’t completely fall from the ranks of the
fantasy elite, but be aware that a healthy Jennings will be a
drain on his overall value – like it was in 2010.
Very few fantasy owners looked to the Jags last season for huge
production in the passing game, but it would be a severe understatement
to say Mike Thomas and Marcedes Lewis just had an “off year”.
Lewis admitted to the Florida Times Union in late May that legal
issues with his infant daughter’s mother took away from
his focus and on-field production in 2011, a season that saw him
fail to reach the end zone after posting 10 TDs just one year
earlier. As for Thomas, he was supposed to be a serviceable fantasy
WR3 in PPR leagues, especially considering a slot receiver like
him should have benefitted from a rookie signal-caller. Nevertheless,
Mularkey has liked
what he has seen so far from Thomas at all three receiver
positions, meaning he could get a short-term statistical boost
if Blackmon happens to miss games. From a fantasy perspective,
it’s hard to like either player nearly as much as we did
this time last year simply because we now know how unprepared
Blaine Gabbert was last season. For Lewis, he should be considered
a mid-level TE2 who is unlikely to ever repeat any part of his
Pro Bowl season in 2010. As one of the league’s best blocking
TEs, he will stay on the field a great deal, but Mularkey’s
offense has not typically supported a fantasy stud at TE (Atlanta’s
Tony Gonzalez aside). As for Thomas, he should fill the slot role
better than Harry Douglas ever did for Mularkey in Atlanta, but
we must remember that Thomas will likely be the third or fourth
option in a run-based offense most of the time. Combined with
his lack of big-play ability, Thomas will probably not be worth
drafting in normal-sized redraft leagues this summer.
Kansas
City
Since most fantasy leagues don’t offer a position labeled
as “offensive weapon”, it will be interesting to see
if Dexter McCluster can manage enough statistical consistency
to serve as a fantasy reserve at RB or WR in his third season.
The Chiefs got almost exactly what they wanted out of him as a
rookie for about five weeks, but an ankle injury in Week 6 dogged
him for the rest of the season. Kansas City then asked him to
work full-time at RB last season, but that generated inconsistent
results for a team devastated by injury. This season, the coaching
staff has went back to the original
thinking, hoping that he can be mainly a matchup nightmare
– a role that will ask him to contribute in the slot as
well as chip in at running back when necessary. From a fantasy
perspective, McCluster faces a much different challenge than he
did in 2010, namely the fact the Chiefs have quickly assembled
a wealth at talent at WR and RB. In other words, while he will
likely produce explosive plays on a fairly regular basis, it is
hard to imagine he’ll contribute enough – barring
injury – to be a weekly fantasy factor assuming players
like Jamaal Charles and Steve Breaston stay healthy.
Because the Chiefs do not plan on letting Charles participate
in any pre-training
camp activities, the hype training cannot realistically start
for him until late July. It should be noted – as ESPN’s
Chris Mortensen reported in late May – that the team has
“no concerns whatsoever” about Charles’ recovery
from ACL surgery and is “excited about him”. As a
result, let’s move onto another supremely talented athlete
in second-year WR Jonathan Baldwin, a player Kansas City hopes
to use much more extensively than it did in 2011. While much of
his ineffectiveness can be blamed on being a rookie and a questionable
work ethic, it didn’t help matters when weak-armed Tyler
Palko was running the show either. To Baldwin’s credit,
he may have gotten the message about what he needs to do to be
a professional as has impressed
the team with his commitment this offseason. His main competition
for a starting spot right now appears to be Breaston, but with
any kind of dedication from the 6-4, 230-pound Baldwin, he should
be able to at least split snaps with the ex-Cardinal at some point
this season before taking the starting job from him in 2013. At
the very least, he has a great shot at being a “splash”
player who gives the Chiefs a much-needed downfield and red-zone
presence. Given the wealthy of talent in KC nowadays, it is hard
to imagine Baldwin will be that much of a consistent factor until
he is receiving the same number of snaps that a starter typically
does. However, if/when that happens, he could easily emerge as
a fantasy force and is worth considering as a late-round selection
this summer for that very reason.
Miami
Although the new coaching staff talked up TE Anthony Fasano shortly
upon their arrival on South Beach, they are certainly emphasizing
players with run-after-catch ability – a skill that
Fasano does not possess. While Fasano will still likely see more
snaps than any other tight end on the roster, it wouldn’t
be the least bit surprising if the Dolphins’ best fantasy
option at the position this season turns out to be Charles Clay.
Matt Moore, who has as good of shot as any Miami quarterback to
open the season as the starter, made
considerable use of Clay during OTAs. It’s easy to understand
why skeptics would quickly suggest Clay is just the latest “unknown”
to get hyped during meaningless May practices. However, on a team
lacking playmakers, it really isn’t that hard to believe
a versatile 6-3, 240-pound H-back wouldn’t be able to create
the occasional mismatch. It’s easy to forget that a player
like Chris Cooley, who was also an H-back coming out of Utah State,
was roughly the same size and entered the league in a similar
fashion – albeit on a slightly more talented team –
before exploding with 71 catches in his second season. That kind
of production shouldn’t be expected from Clay in 2012, but
a dramatic increase from the 16-233-3 line he posted last year
shouldn’t come as a total shock. On this team and in this
offense, a 40-50 catch season is well within reach for a tight
end. Even though the Dolphins drafted an athletic size-speed specimen
in rookie Michael Egnew, he may never become a good enough blocker
to contribute on a regular basis. Thus, look for Clay to be more
than worthy of fantasy consideration in 2012.
While it may be trendy to discuss Chad Ochocinco here, there
is also no guarantee he will start or even make this team. Therefore,
let’s turn our attention to the running game where GM Jeff
Ireland wants to see “development” from at least one
of his 2011 draft picks and is asking HC Joe Philbin to make sure
it happens. Perhaps no rookie runner hit the ground running as
quickly as Daniel Thomas did last season, only then to see to
his production nosedive as quickly as it had been achieved. After
missing Week 1 with a hamstring injury, Thomas pounded the Texans
for 107 rushing yards and the Browns for 95 more the very next
week before injury sidelined him for Week 4. From that point on,
Thomas was mostly ineffective while Reggie Bush exploded. Although
it may sound like an excuse to blame injuries as Thomas is, the
fact he showed well so early and so poorly after his second injury
setback makes it very possible that was, in fact, the problem.
The Kansas State product is now up to 235 pounds in hopes that
he will rediscover his leg drive and power through first contact
– two areas he was disappointed with as a rookie. He is
convinced he is better now – in terms of both his health
and ability to contribute in 2012. Part of the reason for his
optimism also has to do with the zone-blocking
scheme that Philbin and OC Mike Sherman are installing, something
Thomas is quite familiar with from his college days. Based on
last year’s performances, Bush will go much high in fantasy
drafts, but Thomas is a better fit in the new scheme changes than
perhaps any other runner on the roster. Thomas has the size to
hold up physically all season long and better vision than Bush,
so it would be far from shocking if he led the team in rushing
this season. With an ADP of 10.11, he’s shaping up to be
an extreme value pick this summer.
New
England
Get on the Brandon Lloyd bandwagon now. The obvious conclusion
almost everyone will jump to immediately is that Lloyd’s
production is a given in 2012 since he seems to be joined at the
hip with OC Josh McDaniels. But rare is the time when a single
factor is the only thing that separates good from great. Lloyd
credits McDaniels for his breakout in Denver because the coach
was one of the first to believe in him, but it was Lloyd and his
wonderful body control that really helped him put together a season
to remember in 2010. His production dropped off last season on
a team going through a quarterback transition in Denver and four
different signal-callers following his trade to St. Louis. Instability
at quarterback should no longer be a problem now that he is a
Patriot. I spoke to the huge upside Lloyd has for this year and
beyond during my dynasty ranking
series and the Boston Globe suggested that “the
sky is the limit” for him in this offense. There’s
no reason to believe Lloyd will be able to replace the kind of
production Randy Moss had in his short stay with the Patriots,
but owners need to recognize that in this pass-happy attack, Lloyd
has a great chance at approaching the fantasy production he managed
in 2010 with Tom Brady under center and no threat of a double
team in this future.
Fantasy owners have been waiting for some time for the Patriots
to commit to one running back, but it is highly unlikely we will
ever see a Bill Belichick team do that anytime soon. While McDaniels
will almost certainly make sure the Patriots use the run a bit
more than Bill O’Brien did last season, there once again
figures to be too
many mouths to feed for the 25-30 touches New England RBs
will probably see during a normal game. The obvious replacement
for the departed BenJarvus Green-Ellis is Stevan Ridley, who is
bigger and more athletic than his predecessor even if he lacks
the same ball-security skills as the “Law Firm”. As
a result, expect Ridley to be the leading rusher of the bunch
as well as the goal-line back. With that said, the team has three
potential all-purpose backs to complement him and any of them
could be the team’s best fantasy RB in a given week. Shane
Vereen is probably the best of the bunch when healthy and should
expect to be used in the same fashion as a younger Kevin Faulk.
Durability is also a concern for free-agent signee Joseph Addai,
who may serve only as insurance to Vereen or be the primary third-down
back given his experience edge over Vereen and size advantage
over Danny Woodhead. And, of course, Woodhead figures to get his
quarter-slice of the backfield pie as well, lining up all over
the field and serving as a sparkplug for this explosive offense.
For fantasy purposes, Ridley is the most desirable option –
followed by Vereen – but no back is worth more than a RB3
investment, as usual.
New
York Jets
In an offense that is directed by new OC Tony Sparano and executed
by the quarterback duo of Mark Sanchez and Tim Tebow, will this
passing game even have a realistic option some weeks? No one will
seems to question this offense will be as run-heavy as any team
in the league, but even the most ground-and-pound teams managed
to throw about 30 times. And when they do, who will catch it?
Santonio Holmes is hardly dependable and could
meltdown at any time, but has the best mix of ability and
experience on the roster at the moment. Rookie Stephen Hill certainly
has big-time talent, but how much can we really expect out of
such a raw prospect in his first season? TE Dustin Keller seems
like a natural answer, but his typical disappearing act after
September hardly inspires confidence in fantasy owners. One final
alternative: second-year WR Jeremy Kerley. While it is anyone’s
guess which one receiver Tebow will lock onto, Sanchez has enough
skill as a passer to find the open player with some regularity.
As it turns out, Kerley was actually used a lot when
he got a chance to play. One has to believe he will see more
than 241 snaps on passing downs this season with the lack of dependable
short and intermediate options in New York nowadays (remember
that a checkdown to LaDainian Tomlinson is no longer an option
either). It’s pretty obvious if Kerley averaged a reception
once every 8.3 pass plays (second-highest mark on the team), Sanchez
was subtly hinting that he needs to be a more regular part of
the offense. Also don’t forget that Kerley was the player
the Jets had in mind to replace Brad Smith, so it wouldn’t
be overly surprising to see the team work him into the “Wildcat”
packages, along with Tebow. The fantasy upside here isn’t
all that great, but owners would be wise to keep him in the back
of their minds.
New York has a love-hate (mostly hate) relationship with Shonn
Greene. For owners who play playoff fantasy football, he’s
been very good. Owning him during the regular season, however,
has been a lot more miss than hit. To his credit, Greene is no
longer a complete liability as a pass-catcher, nearly doubling
his career reception total last season with 30 catches. He also
set a career high in rushing attempts and has
been led to believe by Sparano that he will do so again this
season. It is also worth noting that while former OC Bryan Schottenheimer
didn’t try to make him into something he wasn’t (such
as using him on outside runs a lot), there may not have been a
better coach to pair Greene up with than Sparano, a former offensive
line coach who loves power football. On the other hand, a philosophy
is often only as good as the people executing it. In other words,
this is not the same run-blocking line the Jets had when Greene
was a rookie either – something that may be best illustrated
by the dramatic drop from his 5.0 YPC in 2009. With that being
said, there are so few 300-touch backs in the league anymore.
So, even if they lack the difference-making talent we’d
like all of them to have, we have to consider any back with the
potential for that kind of workload as a middle-of-the-pack RB2
option in fantasy at the very least.
Oakland
The Raiders’ backfield promises to be full of excitement
again this season – and not just for the most obvious reason(s):
Darren McFadden, when he is healthy and what happens after he
gets hurt. Let’s begin with his new handcuff, Mike Goodson
– the former Carolina Panther who came over in a trade in
late March. Goodson missed the majority of last season with a
severe hamstring injury after he performed admirably in relief
of DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart in 2010, even establishing
himself as the third-down back when the first two were both healthy.
As any former McFadden owner knows, locking up his handcuff is
just part of doing business with D-Mac and while it would be foolish
to expect new OC Greg Knapp to match former HC Hue Jackson in
terms of offensive creativity, the fact is that Knapp loves to
run the ball. Goodson can’t be expected to fill Michael
Bush’s shoes – meaning McFadden should see all the
goal-line carries when healthy – but he offers more of a
big-play element than Bush did. This alone makes him a must-have
handcuff for McFadden owners and a savvy stash for every other
owner hoping they have a second-half stud on their hands if D-Mac’s
injury history once again knocks him out for any length of time.
But what happens if the Raiders already have another Michael
Bush on their roster? At 6-3 and 240 pounds, FB Marcel Reese presents
an interesting dilemma. To this point of his career, he has really
only been used as a “matchup nightmare” in certain
offensive packages. But as Knapp returns to Oakland (he also served
as the OC in 2007-08), he’ll find that Reese – an
undrafted free agent college receiver making the transition the
backfield back in 2008 – is more than happy to see one
of his biggest supporters coming back to the fold. Considering
his receiver background, it would be difficult to place too much
trust in him as a Bush clone, but there’s no doubt that
his time as a fullback should have served him well in that regard.
It is his presence – and not that of second-year speedster
Taiwan Jones – which makes the McFadden handcuff situation
a bit more unpredictable than in recent years.
Last but not least, I would be remiss if I didn’t discuss
the emergence of second-year Denarius Moore after hyping him during
my dynasty series. There is
reason he is generating so much buzz and we’ve already seen
why with our own eyes on the field last season. ESPN’s Matt
Williamson believes he compares very favorably to Greg Jennings
and that he will be the
best receiver in the AFC West in three years. New HC Dennis
Allen suggests he is a “rich
man’s Lance Moore” who is an “exceptional
route runner” with more speed than the Saints’ receiver.
Knapp’s somewhat conservative offensive attacks caps his
fantasy upside somewhat, but Denarius Moore should have no problem
performing at a fantasy WR3 level with top-end WR2 upside.
Pittsburgh
Typically, the offseason is all about optimism and what late-round
pick/undrafted free agent is tearing up OTAs or minicamp. So it
is a noteworthy occurrence when a new play-caller joins one of
the league’s most successful franchises and quickly identifies
the players he wants to make the center of his offense. So far,
OC Todd Haley is singling out TE Heath Miller as one of his “favorite
players”. Since Tony Gonzalez was dealt before Haley
had a chance to coach him in Kansas City, Miller represents the
most established tight end he’s had since he was in charge
of the passing game in Dallas and had a chance to work with a
young Jason Witten. Obviously, no one is expecting Miller to roll
off a series of 80-catch seasons like Witten, but Haley wants
to put more emphasis on protecting Ben Roethlisberger and allow
him to throw more high-percentage passes. While it seems unfathomable
that Haley could eschew the deep passing game with Mike Wallace
and Antonio Brown that former OC Bruce Arians embraced and focus
his new offense around a running game that may not have a healthy
Rashard Mendenhall this season, the Steelers’ draft suggests
HC Mike Tomlin is on board with the new plan. As a result, it
may be difficult to count on Wallace as a top-flight fantasy WR1,
Brown as a potential WR2 or Big Ben as anything more than a good
matchup play in 2012. On the other hand, Miller may be ready to
challenge for low-end TE1 status in 12-team leagues, especially
if the Wallace contract situation does not get rectified soon.
As we know from last season, Isaac Redman is a more than capable
reserve and spot starter, but will he be overexposed if Mendenhall
is forced to spend almost the entire first half of the season
on the PUP list? Mendenhall is reportedly still dealing
with soreness and swelling in the knee he hurt (torn ACL)
on January 1 and GM Kevin Colbert has certainly braced for the
possibility of not having him early in the season. Redman has
just two career starts to his credit, so despite the fact the
team has no proven alternative behind him, the Steelers are eager
to see if Redman is ready to handle an increased workload. If
Mendenhall is forced to miss game action, look for Redman to be
featured in his absence with Jonathan Dwyer likely to fill Redman’s
old role. But the most intriguing option may be a player Haley
wants to be his new Dexter McCluster – fifth-rounder Chris
Rainey. And with all due respect to McCluster, Rainey is a better
fit for the “hybrid” role Haley wants him to fill.
Whether or not the initial 5-8 touches he will likely see each
week will be enough to make him fantasy relevant is another question,
but with his speed and elusiveness, he should be on the fantasy
radar in all but the shallowest of leagues. There’s still
too much mystery regarding Mendenhall’s knee to be sure
how this backfield will shake out, but until he is given a clean
bill of health, consider Redman a solid fantasy RB2 and Dwyer
a handcuff with minimal upside for the non-Redman owners.
San
Diego
In this new fantasy world we live in, we are often left with little
morsels of information in regards to a team’s plan at the
running back position. In fact, it’s uncommon we even get
to consider the possibility that a former committee RB could become
a feature back anymore. After two years of appearing as if HC
Norv Turner had decided to go with the flow and use a committee
rushing attack, he may as well be putting on a publicity campaign
for Ryan Mathews, who reminds
the coach of Ricky Williams – a Turner pupil nearly
10 years ago. And it appears Mathews’ physical and psychological
maturity – questioned by his lack of conditioning last summer
following the lockout – has taken a turn for the better.
Turner now believes Mathews can lead
the league in rushing and has basically gone all in on his
third-year RB by only adding Ronnie Brown to the mix. In short,
this is going to be Mathews’ show for the foreseeable future
and his newfound
commitment to his body should go a long way to helping him
stay healthier during the season than he in his first two years
as a pro. Thus, the case can be made now to put Mathews in the
same tier as the other three top fantasy backs – Arian Foster,
LeSean McCoy and Ray Rice. The likelihood that he’ll see
the most touches of the group is pretty high and the talent has
been there all along, so durability appears to be the only hurdle
between an average fantasy RB1 season and a top-place finish at
his position.
The reports coming out of Chargers’ camp about every skill-position
player have been incredible positive. TE Antonio Gates is apparently
back
to his pre-injury form, second-year WR Vincent Brown has impressed
and free-agent signee Robert Meachem is a more
complete receiver than San Diego could have imagined. Heck,
even Dante Rosario (yes, that one) has opened some eyes. While
that last bit is a small reminder that everyone is a draft-day
or free-agent steal during OTAs, it doesn’t mean there isn’t
some value to what teammates and coaches have to say about a potential
breakout candidate. Case in point: one of the more interesting
nuggets Turner has provided so far has to do with Eddie Royal,
who became a forgotten man in Denver. Turner told SI.com recently
that he thinks a lot of the passes that ended up going to running
backs last season – Chargers’ RBs had 123 catches
last season – will end up in Royal’s hands this season
since
he has excelled with “some higher percentage stuff”
like option, seam and post routes. As for Meachem, owners need
to start thinking about him the same way they did about Vincent
Jackson because the team loves what they see so far, so a top
20 finish at his position would not come as a shock. It seems
difficult to believe Gates is now completely healthy – and
will stay that way, most importantly – but until we see
evidence to the contrary, he is still an elite TE. He should go
off the board about a round after Rob Gronkowski and Jimmy Graham.
Brown is an intriguing fantasy WR5 pick to take in the later rounds
that should be starting in fantasy when Malcom Floyd suffers yet
another injury. Last but not least, it would come as little surprise
if Royal carved out a Lance Moore-like role in this offense. He’ll
probably go undrafted in most fantasy drafts, but he is arguably
in a better situation now than at any point since his 91-catch
season as a rookie in 2008.
Tennessee
HC Mike Munchak may
not specifically know why Chris Johnson had a down year in
2011, but most of us have a pretty general idea why he didn’t
look like the best running back in the league anymore: he held
out until September 1, underestimated
the importance of being in “football shape”, thought
too highly of his own talent and didn’t give himself enough
time to build any kind of timing with his offensive line in a
new offensive scheme. Certainly, the fact the offensive line didn’t
come close to blocking the way it did for him in 2010 didn’t
help matters, but in Munchak’s mind, Johnson spent too much
time panicking on one play and overcompensating for it the next.
The line has improved with the addition of new LG Steve Hutchinson
and Johnson has impressed his coach with his commitment to the
offseason program. While that probably sounds like the same old
rhetoric, most of what Munchak is saying about the 2011 version
of Johnson can easily be attributed to overcompensation (be it
trying to justify his huge contract or getting upset with his
inability to pop the big play as often as had in the past). Johnson
is one of the few feature backs in the league. In fantasy, it’s
often advantageous to load up on extremely talented players who
have something to prove that year and Johnson certainly meets
both criteria. Despite his “down” season, Johnson
should still be considered a top-five RB at worst this summer.
There used to be a time where Kenny Britt was a bigger concern
for the Titans off the field than defenses on it. Now that his
maturity is less in question, his inability to stay health is.
Fortunately, as with everything player-related in early June,
his knee (the one in which he tore the ACL in Week 3 last season)
is “doing
good” and “everything’s going to plan”.
His status is important for a number of reasons, including the
fact that he has elite WR1 talent. Beyond that, however, is the
playing time of rookie Kendall Wright. While it isn’t uncommon
for a first-round receiver to learn multiple receiver positions
in his team’s offense, Tennessee cannot assume Britt will
be completely ready to go in Week 1 nor can the team believe it
will have him all season long. As such, the difference between
Wright’s potential fantasy floor and ceiling is about as
wide as it is for any rookie, as I discussed in my
Rookie Impact article in late May. Sixteen games each from
Britt and Nate Washington probably equal a lot of time in the
slot and the chance for Wright to be an inconsistent fantasy property
that will post the occasional huge game. But if either veteran
should get hurt, Wright has a good enough situation that he could
easily be the best rookie receiver. In short, Britt’s injury
makes him a WR2 candidate with the potential for a top-five finish
at his position. Meanwhile, Britt’s uncertain status makes
Wright a fantasy WR4 option with WR2 upside should either one
of his teammates succumb to injury.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared in USA
Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each of the last
two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football analyst for
106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C). He is also a member
of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |