Preseason Matchup Analysis
6/26/12
ARI | ATL | CAR
| CHI | DAL | DET
| GB | MIN | NO
| NYG | PHI | STL
| SF | SEA | TB
| WAS | AFC
When I was a kid, I often anticipated and dreaded my middle-of-the-summer
birthday. On one hand, another year entailed the customary receipt
of birthday gifts eating of chocolate cake. On the other hand, the
end of June marked the halfway point of my summer break and meant
another year of advancing my education was on the horizon.
As June melts into July, serious fantasy owners should view this
time as the halfway point of their preseason fantasy preparation.
Since the attention of many fantasy football owners is probably
spread in any number of directions at this point of the year,
any bit of knowledge that can be gathered or opinions that can
be researched and solidified at this point of the offseason can
be considered gaining an edge on your competition. Certainly,
most of us recognize that much of what is being reported right
now is overly optimistic, but that does not mean all the information
coming from team camps during the summertime can’t be useful.
As a result, I find there is significant value in taking the
information that beat writers and, in some cases, national columnists
are providing us now and providing a way-too-early “fantasy
look” at all 32 teams. Because this time of year is all
about optimism (and since I haven’t even attempted to begin
projecting the season), I’ll try my best to remove the rose-colored
lenses that many of these reporters are looking through. At the
same time, I will attempt to identify some of the players you
should keep in mind. Remember, the purpose of this experience
isn’t so much to give you my final fantasy analysis; rather,
it is my hope that some of this information will allow each of
you to get a slight head start on your own forecasts.
Since we took a detailed look at the AFC
last week, I’m going to turn my attention this week
to the skill-position players for each NFC team making waves –
good or bad – in their team’s offseason workouts and
provide some insight as to what it could mean this season.
Arizona
After showing the toughness and willingness to play with pain
last season the coaching staff has wanted to see from him since
he was a first-round pick in 2009, Beanie Wells will begin his
fourth NFL season in much the same way he has the first three
– as a question mark. In late January, Wells underwent a
knee surgery for the second time in three years that was thought
to be arthroscopic, but his unwillingness
to provide details about it (other to say “it was more
complicated than repairing a torn meniscus” and smiling
when asked if it was microfracture) casts doubt on his ability
to follow up on a breakout season. Then, there is the issue of
Ryan Williams – a player many thought could take Wells’
job last year until he tore his patella tendon – who the
team hopes to have back by training camp, just like Wells. As
we know from players like Cadillac Williams, recovery from a patella
tendon injury can sometimes take years as opposed to months. So,
given Wells’ history and the seriousness of Williams’
injury, it’s only natural to wonder if either player will
be effective in 2012 and if the Cards will need to give significant
touches to Alfonso Smith at some point. During the team’s
OTA in early June, both Wells and Williams were doing
rehab work while the rest of the team was practicing although
it appears “certain” the latter will see the practice
field before the former. As we stand here in late June, it is
nearly impossible to determine how this is going to shake out
for fantasy purposes as both players are significant injury risks.
While Wells earned respect for his gutty play last season, Williams
is the better all-purpose back. In the unlikely event both players
make it all the way back and play a full schedule, consider Wells
a low-end fantasy RB2 given his likely roles as early-down pounder
and goal-line back. Conversely, expect Williams to be a useful
flex option because he will probably secure most of the work in
the passing game and is more elusive in the open field than Wells.
While there is plenty to be decided at quarterback, it is possible
a more fantasy-relevant situation is shaping up at tight end.
Despite the fact that Arizona tight ends combined for 65 receptions
– more than the team had in 2009 and 2010 combined –
no player had more than Jeff King’s 27. Todd Heap couldn’t
get healthy again after a September injury and admits
this year is “huge” for his future. One reason
for that is the likelihood that second-year TE Rob Housler assumes
a bigger role this season after dealing with his own injury woes
as a rookie. Arizona would very much like to use two-TE formations
on a more regular basis this season and Housler has the kind of
speed and athleticism to be a fantasy factor. TE coach Freddie
Kitchens estimated that Housler could
have easily had 4-5 touchdowns last season on plays where
he was “just screaming down the field”. It’s
probably too much to ask Housler to push 40 catches this season
if Heap and King are both healthy, but the Cardinals want him
to succeed and the threat of Michael Floyd and Larry Fitzgerald
on the outside should open things for him down the middle. Therefore,
he is the tight end to own on this team in fantasy and a player
to keep in mind as a possible breakout candidate.
Atlanta
The Falcons’ offense figures to be dramatically different
in 2012 despite the fact they experienced virtually no turnover
among their core group of skill-position players. The reason:
new OC Dirk Koetter. As the long-time play-caller in Jacksonville,
Koetter regularly had to bypass his preferred method of attack
(the passing game) due to average talent and lean on Maurice Jones-Drew
to move the offense. The early indications are that Michael
Turner’s workload will be more closely monitored, the
screen
game will be much more prominent and Roddy White will see
the ball less. While these were all changes that were likely
coming anyway, the transition was made easier by the coordinator
change and the fact that ex-OC Mike Mularkey’s run-based
attack failed to lead to any success in the playoffs. Obviously,
all these changes mean increased touches for Julio Jones, Jason
Snelling and Jacquizz Rodgers (perhaps even Harry Douglas). Turner
has been rumored to see fewer touches for several years now, but
this season is when it will likely become a reality because the
Falcons now have no reason to remain a conservative offense with
two of the best receivers in the league at their disposal and
an explosive Rodgers coming out of the backfield. While White
may not hit the 100-catch plateau for the third straight season,
he’s almost certain to turn in his sixth straight year of
80+ receptions because of the absolute trust QB Matt Ryan has
in him. The sky is the limit for this offense with a renewed emphasis
on the passing attack, meaning White and Jones may both end up
as WR1s in fantasy while Atlanta tries to turn Rodgers into the
6-8 touch-per-game version of Darren Sproles. Snelling could also
see a slight bump in value as well if the team follows through
on its hopes to back off Turner.
Obviously, it takes more than a couple of glowing reports about
offensive change to really start “buying the hype”
on an offense. A shift from a run-first offense to a pass-heavy
attack leads to more opportunities, but can also backfire with
increased turnovers and less overall offensive efficiency. However,
when a team smartly chooses to allow its quarterback more leniency
to operate the no-huddle offense when he’s proven he is
adept at doing so, there is definitely potential for huge fantasy
numbers. Fortunately, that seems to be exactly what Koetter
wants to do this season, so with a bulked-up Ryan exhibiting
more arm strength in OTAs, there’s plenty of reason to be
optimistic about the incredibly high ceiling this offense has
in 2012. Assuming all this plays out as Koetter seems to believe
it will, Ryan should improve on his eighth-place finish among
fantasy QBs and take yet another step towards elite status.
Carolina
Whether or not Brandon LaFell has really been as good as the Panthers
keep telling us he has been this offseason is a matter of some
debate, but HC Ron Rivera once again noted in mid-June his third-year
receiver “looks
much more comfortable” and is quickly “building
a rapport” with QB Cam Newton. While cautious optimism is
still the way to go with LaFell, he did start coming on a bit
more during the second half of last season (catching five balls
in one game and going over 50 yards three times after not doing
either one once in the first half). The Panthers further showed
their faith in LaFell by not drafting or signing a high-profile
receiver, meaning the LSU alum should only really have to hold
off David Gettis. Even though his reception total actually dipped
a bit from his rookie (38 to 36) despite playing two more games,
LaFell’s YPC jumped from 12.3 to 17.0 in large part due
to the stellar quarterback play Newton gave the team. While we
cannot simply give LaFell all 44 of Legedu Naanee’s catches
from last season, there’s reason to believe he can get about
half of them if we are to believe Rivera. That boost would easily
push LaFell into the 50-catch club and give the team the kind
of threat opposite Steve Smith it has wanted since Muhsin Muhammad
retired. While there doesn’t seem to be a sense that LaFell
will threaten Smith’s lead receiver status at any point
of his career and become a fantasy star, he does have enough size
and skill to be a valuable red-zone weapon and fantasy WR4 in
2012.
Since I provided my opinion on what I expect to happen in the
Panthers’ backfield a couple of weeks ago in my Free
Agency Review, I will instead devote some more time to Newton
and the Carolina passing game. With Newton proclaiming the improvement
he has made over the last few months is “through
the roof”, it is worth wondering who else besides Smith
and maybe LaFell will help him prove it. First of all, the team
should be able to threaten defenses deep even more this season
with Gettis returning from injury and rookie Joe Adams each possessing
enough game-breaking speed. Secondly, the team is still “really
high” on TE Gary Barnidge’s ability as a downfield
threat even though he has just 12 career catches in 45 games with
the team. An ankle injury ruined any chance Barnidge had to shine
in 2011, but the team thought enough of him to let Jeremy Shockey
walk. Even though it is entirely possible that none of these players
(Gettis, Adams or Barnidge) ever come close to fantasy relevance,
defenses will have to account for that team speed and when they
do, Newton could enjoy even more success as a rusher than he did
as a rookie. With that being said, the most likely beneficiary
of Newton’s improvement should be the running game, which
should be a bigger staple of the offense this year anyway in order
to preserve the quarterback’s health.
Chicago
Whatever Matt Forte is lacking in terms of money right now (with
his holdout), he appears to be making up for it in terms of muscle
mass. In a recent
interview with Jay Cutler, the quarterback reported the Bears’
starting running back was “huge, all ripped up” and
that all he does is “go to the weight room…I’ve
got nothing else to do.” Although Forte has mostly dispelled
the pre-draft notion that he lacked breakaway speed, it’s
probably not the greatest thing for him to put on much too weight
– be it the good or bad kind – since his elusiveness
is one of his best traits. Cutler also expressed in the same interview
that he would be “shocked” if he doesn’t sign
his tender in mid-July and report to training camp on time. Chicago
Tribune beat writer Brad Biggs suggested in mid-May there was
“no
chance” Forte would skip regular season games, so given
that the RB has been nothing but a standup player so far in his
career, we can probably go along with Cutler and Biggs. As to
what he will be returning to, new OC Mike Tice should make the
running game more of a staple than former OC Mike Martz did, so
it shouldn’t be a stretch for Forte to return to his 2009
or 2010 workload if he plays all 16 games as he did in each of
his first three seasons. Michael Bush’s presence will probably
cap Forte’s scoring ceiling at about six touchdowns, but
assuming all the key parts of this offense remain healthy, Forte
should have low-end fantasy RB1 value in what should be a surprisingly
good offense this season.
One big reason Chicago should field a dynamic offense this season
is due to the presence of new QB coach (and passing game coordinator)
Jeremy Bates, the same QB coach Cutler had in his final season
in Denver when he threw for a career-high 4,526 yards. Although
working with then-HC Mike Shanahan probably influenced Bates to
get Cutler outside the pocket, Bates wants Cutler to use
his athleticism – as he did in Denver on rollouts and
such – and not confine him to Martz’s somewhat rigid
dropback approach. As a result, Cutler now warrants low-end QB1
consideration in fantasy. But while the addition of Bates as well
as receivers Brandon Marshall and rookie Alshon Jeffery are all
key parts of the newfound optimism in Chicago, the biggest fantasy
surprise coming out of the “Windy City” this fall
could very well be Kellen Davis, who I hyped back in April during
my Dynasty Rankings series.
As we know, Martz was rarely ever a friend of the tight end in
the passing game – other than as a blocker – so almost
any change was going to be a good one for the Bears’ top
tight end. But Davis may feel like he really hit the jackpot with
Tice as the former NFL tight end has typically managed to coax
fantasy-relevant seasons from the likes of George Wrighster, Jermaine
Wiggins and Byron Chamberlain. Davis is certainly a more talented
receiver than any of those players, so when he suggests he is
hoping
for at least 40-60 catches this season, he may not be far
off. Certainly, Bates will have some say about that, but Davis
will be on the receiving end of a number of Cutler rollout throws.
Because he was such an underused asset under Martz, Davis may
not even get drafted in regular-sized leagues, but don’t
be surprised if he makes a push to be a top 15 fantasy TE in 2012.
A committed Dez Bryant would easily become
a top five fantasy receiver.
Dallas
There’s a good chance that if Dez Bryant’s first three
years are in any way indicative of the rest of his career, he
could become a permanent fixture in “Early Observations”.
In January, he managed to make the news again when he confronted
a heckler outside of a Miami club, although nothing came of it.
Later that same month, the Dallas Morning News’ Rick Gosselin
suggested that Bryant “still
doesn’t know how to run routes”, which comes as
little surprise to people like myself who have stated for some
time the receiver makes most of his plays either on screens or
deep balls. Bryant revealed that he never
fully healthy last season and also admitted his conditioning
probably wasn’t “at its best”. Despite the
fact he is being considered a relative disappointment this far
in his career, he seems to be embracing the notion that he is
a professional more and more. So while he may still be prone to
a bout of immaturity here and there, the coaching staff thinks
he is starting to “get it”. And let’s be honest,
if his 63-928-9 line over 15 games last season is what he does
when he is not completely healthy or not in the best of shape,
wait until he starts showing some pride in his craft, as he
appears to be doing this offseason. A fully-engaged Bryant
that can actually run routes probably profiles into an Andre Johnson
clone in fantasy, which makes this offense downright scary considering
Miles Austin appears to be in “outstanding
shape” as well this summer. There is virtually no limit
on how good this offense can be if Bryant is committed, Austin
is healthy and QB Tony Romo plays the way he did during the second
half of last season. Romo likely won’t come cheap in fantasy,
but previously-burned owners may pause with Bryant or hesitate
on Austin because of his hamstring issues last season, so if either
one (or both) can be snagged in the fourth or fifth round of fantasy
drafts, they should represent significant value.
Jerry Jones can’t help but sell everyone on the idea Dallas
is in prime position every year to win the Super Bowl; he does
it every year and he does it so much that he tends to set Cowboys
fans up for disappointment. Indirectly, Jones also has a bit of
influence on the fantasy world since his team just happens to
be one of the most high-profile franchises in the league, so it
often just seems like he is always in front of a microphone. And
most fantasy owners aren’t any different from the rest of
the world, when they see or hear something enough, they start
to believe it more and more. What do I mean? Last year, Felix
Jones was the clear workhorse in the Cowboys’ backfield.
A few years ago, Jerry Jones thought Tashard Choice was “too
valuable” to trade despite being the third-string running
back on the roster. This year, the owner believes DeMarco Murray
is the new workhorse while also saying Felix Jones is an “integral
part of our firepower”. So where does the hype end and
truth begin? Murray can actually be the centerpiece of this running
game, but he isn’t the most durable player around –
something that followed him from his college days. If he can stay
healthy this time around, he should have an improved line to run
behind coordinated by one of the most respected OL coaches in
the league in Bill Callahan. The “sell job” applies
a bit more to Felix Jones, who just doesn’t seem capable
of being anything more than a complementary runner. While he will
see some work, it’s unlikely to be more than an inconsistent
5-10 touches per game; Murray
is healthy now and should get as much work as he can handle.
Murray’s injury history suggests he should be considered
a fantasy RB2, but he should make a fine RB1 for any owner that
decides to go with a QB or WR in the first round. On the other
hand, Jones is probably a flex option at best.
Detroit
Few teams have become as entertaining on the field and perplexing
off of it recently as the Lions. By now, most of us are familiar
with how Mikel Leshoure spends his leisure
time. Already faced with an uncertain future in just his second
year in the league due to the seriousness of his Achilles’
injury last season, Leshoure is by no means a lock to produce
in 2012 as he continues to rehab and faces a two-game suspension
for his marijuana-related arrests. On the other hand, Jahvid Best
enters yet another season with the worry of adding to his concussion
history. To his credit, he has caught
the eye of GM Martin Mayhew this offseason, so he represents
one of the finest examples we have of risk-reward picks in fantasy
football. When healthy, he is a 15-touch player who will produce
at a RB1 level more often than not. And then there is Kevin Smith,
who set the fantasy world abuzz with his Week 11 destruction of
the Panthers last season. But he could not stay healthy either
and it ultimately sabotaged what could have been a fine end to
his season. While he makes for an interesting stash in redraft
leagues this season, his injury history is probably the worst
of the three. Smith is addressing it, however, and hopes the
eight pounds he dropped from last year – while adding
muscle mass – will help him stay on the field a bit longer.
In short, we have three different types of backs who all have
the talent to play at a RB1 level for the most pass-happy team
in the league, but little in terms of clarity. Best will get the
starts – and probably the most touches – when everyone
is healthy, but it gets pretty cloudy beyond that. As a result,
the current ADPs of Best (6.09), Leshoure (9.11) and Smith (12.02)
all sound about right given the risk each player carries.
Continuing the entertaining/perplexing theme from above, keep
your eye on Titus Young – literally and figuratively.
That sorry attempt at humor comes after the second-year receiver
reportedly punched S Louis Delmas when he wasn’t looking
during a May practice, a move that resulted in Young’s dismissal
from voluntary workouts. He has since apologized to the team and
stated that he and Delmas were joking around shortly after he
was allowed to return. As for the reason he is actually in Detroit,
Young has looked “amazing” and is “catching
nearly every ball thrown his way, including the less than
perfect passes”. Although the second-year Boise State product
was about as inconsistent as any rookie receiver is, he began
to string together some solid performances late in the year and
is now likely on the verge of forcing the Lions’ hand at
the position. Young will probably overtake Nate Burleson as the
starter at some point this season, allowing Burleson to move into
the slot full-time until rookie Ryan Broyles eventually nudges
him out of that spot in a year or two. It’s no secret that
Young (or Burleson) will operate opposite the most difficult receiver
to defend in the league in Calvin Johnson, so with guaranteed
single coverage for the foreseeable future, a big-play receiver
like Young has 1,000+ yard and 6-8 touchdown potential. To what
degree Burleson and Broyles steal targets from him is another
story, but in this pass-heavy attack, there is potential for 3-4
receivers to be worthy of fantasy consideration. Young is another
player who should be drafted as a low-end WR3 in fantasy, but
has all the tools he needs to finish as a top 25 receiver.
Green
Bay
By the time Jermichael Finley started playing at the level most
expected him to perform in 2011, most of his owners had either
traded him away or lost any hope that he would live up to his
fantasy draft spot. A big part of his “limited” production
– he did catch 55 balls after all, second-most in team history
for a tight end – was a lack of consistent focus, perhaps
best illustrated by his 13 drops on 103 targets. Finley attributes
his disappointing season to a number of factors, including but
not limited a lack of chemistry with QB Aaron Rodgers, no offseason
and a back-of-the-mind concern about the same leg injury that
limited him to four games in 2010. Perhaps the most interesting
factor he cited was his former TE coach Ben McAdoo, who apparently
caused Finley to overthink his job. McAdoo is now the QB coach
and Finley believes the switch to Jerry Fontenot will allow him
to “freestyle”,
which will allow him to play loose and less like a “robot”.
One NFC scout went so far as to say “other than Calvin Johnson,
there’s probably not a scarier guy in the (NFC North) than
Finley”. There’s little doubt that Finley wasn’t
all there mentally last season and it is reflected in his drop
percentage, which was 12.6% in 2011 as opposed to 5.1% over his
first three seasons. As easy as it is to count him out as an elite-level
tight end, it would not be wise to let him slide too far in a
fantasy draft. Rodgers still has a high opinion of his tight end
and understands the kind of production a focused and motivated
Finley brings to the offense. In fact, there probably isn’t
a better candidate to join Rob Gronkowski and Jimmy Graham as
the league’s new elite young TEs.
With Ryan Grant no longer in the picture, could Green Bay be
returning to the feature-back approach? The term “feature
back” may be a bit of an exaggeration, but given the notion
that Alex Green is no guarantee to contribute heavily to the team
following last year’s knee surgery and Brandon Saine is
the only other realistic option, there’s an awfully good
chance that James
Starks will be the primary back. HC Mike McCarthy did suggest
that Saine may be his most
consistent back, but the only way Starks isn’t going
well over 200 touches this season is if he suffers yet another
injury – which is probably the biggest concern fantasy owners
have about him. Somewhat amazingly, Packer RBs combined for 392
regular-season touches in 2011. Even if we use that number as
a benchmark and give goal-line threat John Kuhn 80 touches –
almost double of what he had last season – that gives Starks
a great shot at eclipsing 200 touches in 2012. It may not be the
stuff of legends, but since he can also catch a few passes (30-plus
would not be a stretch), that kind of activity is more than serviceable
as a flex option.
Minnesota
Were it not for the presence of Visanthe Shiancoe in 2011, then-rookie
TE Kyle Rudolph could have easily enjoyed a rather successful
first season in the NFL. When it became clear Shiancoe would not
return, Rudolph appeared to be set up for a breakout, that is,
until the Vikings inexplicably handed free-agent TE John Carlson
a deal worth $5 M per year. On the surface, it seems simple enough:
a team wants to run the ball and control the short passing game
with two very capable receiving tight ends. But is it that simple?
Even the biggest Rudolph supporter has to admit Carlson’s
new salary is a big chunk of change for a player who will supposedly
see less activity in the passing game than the second-year tight
end. However, don’t tell 2011 NFL Draft classmate QB Christian
Ponder that, as his draft classmate called Rudolph’s hands
“freakish” and that “he’s
going to make a lot of plays this year”. Naturally,
people will then wonder – after a handful of tight ends
across the league put up some ridiculous numbers – if his
quarterback is so thrilled with him, will another athletic tight
end like Rudolph join the crowd? The answer is almost certainly
“no” for a number of reasons. Durability has been
a concern recently, but his biggest problems are the presence
of Carlson, lack of an elite quarterback and a conservative offense
(when Adrian Peterson is healthy). Without Carlson around, Rudolph
could be a top 10 fantasy tight end since his situation and talent
in that situation would have been comparable to Greg Olsen when
he was a Bear, which probably represents his fantasy upside as
well. As it stands, Rudolph should be considered one of top fantasy
TE2s in 12-team leagues.
Sometimes, it is fair to wonder whether Adrian Peterson is a
mere mortal. Heck, one of physical assistants for noted Dr. James
Andrews – the man who repaired his ACL and MCL tears –
suggested that even the football players he is working with this
offseason (such as Packers CB Tramon Williams and Bucs DT Amobi
Okoye) “recognize Adrian’s
different…he has a different protoplasm than the rest
of the world.” There is nothing wrong with believing he
will return this season and return strong. In fact, if there is
anyone that can, it is probably him. The problem – and this
is where fantasy owners can sometimes fall into the “hype
trap” – is when they start subscribing to the notion
that “it will happen because he’s Adrian Peterson”.
His current ADP – according to Fantasy Football Calculator
– is 2.02, which is acceptable considering he won’t
be asked to carry his fantasy team from that spot (and could even
be a RB2) but the obvious downside is that his owners are virtually
guaranteed to get a fraction of the AP they are used to seeing.
There is also every possibility Minnesota will decide to take
it easy on him this year and lean a bit more on Toby Gerhart.
HC Leslie Frazier sounds pretty certain the leaner yet meaner
Gerhart
will be relied on at the start of the season, as he told the
Star-Tribune in early June “there’s a very good chance
he’s going to have to really carry the load early on”.
Remember, AP didn’t suffer the injury until Week 16 of last
season, so he’s not going to have the same benefit of time
that some other football players who suffered a similar injury
much earlier in the season. The point to be made is that owners
cannot allow themselves to get caught up in buying into AP this
season because he is more “affordable” now than he
has been since he was a rookie. As difficult as it might be to
read (and for me to type), there is a small yet realistic chance
that Gerhart matches or exceeds Peterson’s production this
season, especially if the lack of trust that most ACL survivors
have in their knee following surgery plays tricks on his mind.
New
Orleans
The Drew Brees contract saga has managed to do the impossible:
take some of the focus away from the fallout resulting from the
“bounty” suspensions handed out by the league. Despite
the absence of one of the league’s best triggermen, the
Saints’ receivers are still worth discussing. It’s
pretty clear Marques Colston and Lance Moore will remain high-volume
targets for Brees when he returns, but who is next in line? Devery
Henderson is the veteran and best deep threat on the team –
now that Robert Meachem is a Charger – so his role appears
set as well. After that, it’s a problem many teams would
like to have. The team has long wanted an excuse to give more
playing time to Adrian Arrington, but he may find himself in the
exact same situation he did the first four seasons. Interim HC
Joe Vitt suggested second-year Joseph
Morgan is a “young Meachem” while OC Pete Carmichael
thinks fourth-round pick Nick
Toon is comparable to Colston. Most teams are stretched to
keep six receivers on the active roster and some will roll with
five, so one of the aforementioned wideouts may need to find a
new home. But why does the Saints’ No. 4-6 receivers matter
for fantasy purposes anyway? For the same reason Meachem and Henderson
had some relevance in fantasy in previous seasons: this offense
is dynamic enough to ensure that two players (Colston and TE Jimmy
Graham) are every-week starters while Henderson, Moore and at
least one other receiver usually reside on fantasy benches. Toon’s
6-4, 218-pound frame likely means he will join Colston and Graham
as the primary red-zone threats while Morgan will have a chance
to assume the production Meachem left behind. And in case that
wasn’t confusing enough, undrafted free agent Chris Givens
(from Miami of Ohio) is picking
up steam. As sportsnola.com suggests, Arrington and Henderson
(a free agent at the end of the season) may both be on the roster
bubble if Givens continues to impress.
One of the more interesting phenomena from year to year in fantasy
is the “tumble” a hyped rookie takes when he fails
to live up to his fantasy draft status. Based on the way he was
used during the 2011 preseason, Mark Ingram appeared to be a sound
fantasy investment in the fourth to fifth round area, but the
lead-back role that he appeared destined for never materialized.
It also didn’t help his final numbers that Darren Sproles
took on a bigger role than most expected and Pierre Thomas didn’t
fall victim to injury, as his injury history suggested he could.
The final straw was a turf toe injury that essentially ended his
season in Week 13. Ingram’s current ADP is the late eighth
round, which seems a bit extreme for a player that is ticketed
for goal-line carries and 10-15 carries per game in one of the
league’s highest-scoring offenses. Maybe some of the initial
skepticism has to do with his additional
offseason arthroscopic knee surgery, but fantasy owners have
to assume the Saints will expand his responsibilities a bit more
this season, assuming his fine for the start of training camp.
Factor in the likelihood that Thomas’ injury history should
prepare us for another layoff from him and it may just be the
window necessary to turn this into a two-horse backfield. Either
way, it is hard to imagine that Ingram will post such meager totals
again in 2012.
New
York Giants
The natural assumption to make with the reigning Super Bowl champs
is that the running game is probably not as important to the Giants
as it once was, especially considering Eli Manning nearly threw
for 5,000 yards last season (over 900 more than his previous career
high). While that notion may not be entirely wrong, it’s
probably not all that accurate either. HC Tom Coughlin will always
want his team to run the ball and limit turnovers and he has proven
that time and again over the years, even when the running game
hasn’t always been all that productive. And if the recent
reports on rookie David Wilson and Ahmad Bradshaw are accurate,
the running game could very well be as efficient AND productive
as it has ever been under Coughlin. For those who may have doubted
my take on Wilson from
a couple of weeks ago, OC Kevin Gilbride pretty much confirmed
it and took
it one step further, suggesting the first-round pick is one
of the most explosive players – regardless of position –
to wear the Giants’ uniform since he has been with the team.
He went on to say, “In this guy, you’ve got the kind
of explosion that I’m not sure how many guys in the league
have.” Pass protection will limit his playing time initially,
but Wilson will be nipping at Bradshaw’s heels for more
playing time starting in 2013, in all likelihood. And, of course,
there is the matter of Bradshaw’s troublesome right foot.
For now, however, the veteran is saying his foot feels “great”
and that his limited participation at OTAs was because he wanted
to “take it slow”. The presence of Wilson –
and his big-play ability – figures to threaten Bradshaw’s
fantasy numbers more than Brandon Jacobs did, so fantasy owners
should be conservative with their expectations for Bradshaw. He
should remain a fantasy RB2 – while Wilson should be a solid
flex play – but it would be a mistake to expect Bradshaw
to post huge numbers now just because Jacobs is gone; his final
numbers in 2009 and 2011 are much more likely.
Staying with the running back theme, what player benefits most
from Jacobs’ departure? Considering Bradshaw is a remarkable
15-of-24 at scoring touchdowns from five yards out or less over
the last three years, he seems pretty certain to secure half of
the meaningful short-yardage scoring opportunities yet again.
But New York is unlikely to turn him into the full-time goal-line
runner and Wilson probably won’t fill that role either since
he is unlikely to earn the trust of the coaching staff in those
situations right away. And if we take Gilbride at his word, he
has already stated “Wilson has a lot to learn” before
the Giants can “tap into (the explosion)” the rookie
possesses, which could mean someone from the group of D.J. Ware,
Da’Rel Scott and Andre Brown joins Bradshaw. Ware is a bigger
back known for his contributions in the passing game, but has
limited upside. Scott probably has more raw talent, but durability
has been an issue for some time. So perhaps the “new Brandon
Jacobs” is the one player who is actually trying to emulate
him. Brown is now up to 240 pounds and feeling
confident now that he’s finally had a chance to learn
just one playbook. Brown has endured through a multitude of struggles
since joining the NFL, but the recent lifting of his four-game
suspension for performance-enhancing drugs and relatively good
health of late – plus staying in the same offensive system
– may be just the break he’s been waiting for. It
is also quite likely the team “approved” of the 16-pound
weight increase in order to give them a bulldozer-type to go along
with their two speedsters. For now, Brown should only be considered
a longshot, but he also has a better chance to be a flex-type
option this season than most people think.
Philadelphia
It could be argued that only one aspect of the “Dream Team”
lived up to his end of the bargain last season – LeSean
McCoy. Once considered too small to carry the load, McCoy amassed
273 carries in 2011 – the ninth-highest total in team history
and most since Brian Westbrook in 2007. Shortly after the season,
beat writer Jeff
McLane tweeted that HC Andy Reid “may lessen his load
a little this season to increase his shelf life”. That concern
– for fantasy owners anyway – gained more steam on
draft weekend when the Eagles brought in two very talented backs
that fell in the draft (Bryce Brown) or completely out of it (Chris
Polk) for different reasons. But let’s take a look at some
facts here: Reid was the driving force behind getting McCoy’s
five-year, $45 M contract extension done this spring, McCoy played
81.1% of the plays from scrimmage last season – far and
away the highest percentage in the league – and he won’t
turn 24 until the middle of July. Furthermore, OC Marty Mornhinweg
believes the fourth-year pro has “the opportunity to be
one
of the great ones”. Even with his short history as the
featured back, McCoy is going to be fantasy relevant regardless
of whether or not he loses a few touches here or there. But given
Reid’s history with Westbrook, there’s a pretty good
chance McCoy’s touches (21.4 per game last season) will
stay about the same – even if his rushing attempts decline
a bit. With the way the Eagles uses their main running backs in
their offensive system, players like McCoy and Westbrook are virtually
matchup-proof, so there is virtually no reason why he shouldn’t
be a top three fantasy pick in just about every draft. In fact,
a strong case can be made that he should be the No. 1 overall
pick.
Nothing drives the hard-core fan crazy quite like a player who
acts like he takes it for granted. By his own admission, Michael
Vick has admitted his focus hasn’t always been on the field.
As he enters his fourth season with the Eagles – and second
as the starter – and his age-32 season, Vick appears ready
to atone for his turnover-plagued 2011 in what is his first actual
full offseason with the team as the unquestioned starter. Although
it is cliché, the National Football Post reports that Vick
has been first-in
and last-out at the NovaCare Complex this offseason “according
to those who know”. This comes as great news for fantasy
owners who want great upside at the QB position and less of the
sticker shock that players like Aaron Rodgers, Tom Brady and Drew
Brees will carry in most draft this summer. Vick’s newfound
dedication also is probably great news for Jeremy Maclin, who
the quarterback compared
to Michael Irvin. Vick isn’t the only one that thinks
Maclin is ready to take the next step as one Eagles coach told
the Philadelphia Inquirer – without hesitation – that
Maclin
will make his first Pro Bowl this season. Despite the mysterious
health scare that threatened his livelihood, cost him the bulk
of training camp and led to a limited role in Week 1, he was on
pace for 88 receptions and 1,212 yards at midseason last year
before injuries caught up with him. The former University of Missouri
speedster is now 205 pounds, seven pounds over his listed weight
last season. With a current ADP of 5.06, he is an absolute steal
as a WR2 since he should finish the season as a top 10 fantasy
receiver.
Seattle
All indications are that the Seahawks’ quarterback race
will not be determined until training camp and that third-round
rookie Russell Wilson, Tarvaris Jackson and free-agent pickup
Matt Flynn will have “a
fair shot” to win the starting job. If anything, Jackson
has a
slight edge over Flynn right now. As we know, quarterback
competitions are not usually settled in May or June and the “advantage”
Jackson has right now is the familiarity he has with OC Darrel
Bevell’s system. Despite a 5-3 finish to the 2011 season
and the coaching staff’s insistence this is a three-way
battle, Jackson faces long odds to begin the season as the starter.
Flynn’s three-year, $26 M contract will probably serve as
the first tiebreaker while GM John Schneider thought Wilson was
one of the top three players he scouted last fall and likened
him in some ways to Jeff Garcia and Drew Brees in terms of his
ability to slide, find lanes and create for himself in the pocket
as well as from an accuracy and anticipation standpoint. That
kind of high praise means Seattle probably wants Wilson to start
in 2013 and Flynn’s contract suggests he will be the starter
for at least 2012. Admittedly, there isn’t going to be a
lot of fantasy impact coming from this passing game regardless
of which player is named the starter, but the winner figures to
have a big say on just how much a healthy Sidney Rice is worth
on draft day.
Since Rice represents about the only other player besides Marshawn
Lynch on Seattle’s roster worth drafting in the early to
middle rounds in most leagues, let’s discuss his latest
injury nightmare. While Rice’s three concussions over a
12-month stretch garnered the most attention for obvious reasons,
the Seahawks’ top wideout actually had both
shoulders repaired in the offseason as well. As the linked
article details, Rice tore his right labrum in training camp last
year and asked doctors to look at his left one as they were mapping
out the details to repair the right shoulder. (As it turned out,
Rice needed 11 anchors in each shoulder after a 360-degree tear
was discovered in the left one!) Somewhat amazingly, Seattle did
not add any blue-chip talent to the receiver position and Schneider
expects Rice to be the healthiest
he’s ever been as an NFL player by training camp. Rice’s
goal is to be ready for Week 1 but not necessarily training camp
as he has yet to be cleared for contact. Schneider’s comments
aside, Rice is one of the quintessential boom-bust picks in fantasy
because his durability makes him a risk as anything more than
a WR3, but his talent screams WR1. Fortunately, with a current
ADP of 8.08, owners seem to be doing a good job so far of recognizing
both his talent and injury history.
San
Francisco
All aboard the Alex Smith bandwagon? Fantasy owners may not have
a choice considering the amount of receiving talent the Niners
acquired during the offseason. However, the one receiver that
has captured the imagination of the team isn’t the first-round
pick (A.J. Jenkins) or the player who made a pivotal catch in
the Super Bowl (Mario Manningham), but rather the player who played
for three teams during his last pro season and sat out all of
2011. That player, of course, is Randy Moss. According to a
team insider, “you can still see the Hall of Fame skills”
and “at times, he’s been unstoppable”. OC Greg
Roman confirmed Moss’ commitment by saying, “He has
really been as good as you can possibly ask for in terms of being
totally engrossed in football.” It’s no secret that
the 35-year-old Moss probably has the talent to play until 40
if he wanted to, but the question for most of his career has been
his willingness to stay “interested” when he wasn’t
being challenged, seeing the ball enough or part of a losing team.
Amazingly, the early-drafting public has been slow to buy into
the idea of a reborn Moss as his current ADP is in the ninth round.
As I stated in my Free
Agency Review, I believe that Moss is at worst an every-week
WR3 this season, meaning he is an incredible value pick right
now. He may not have a vintage Moss season, but the odds are rather
good that he’ll win his owners at least a game or two this
season almost by himself. There is a
long list (larger than one might expect) of receivers that
have been productive during or after their age-35 season and few
– if any – of them had the natural talent Moss does.
In short, another 60+ catch, 1000-yard, 10-touchdown season is
entirely possible.
On the other end of the spectrum is Jenkins, who has done little
but disappoint the coaching staff since the team surprised many
by taking him at the end of the first round in April. Roughly
two weeks after he was drafted, HC Jim Harbaugh was less
than impressed by the stamina of his prized rookie. One month
later, he struggled
with consistency during OTAs. Neither offense is an unforgiveable
crime and, in most cases, is completely expected from a rookie
receiver. The problem is that while his conditioning was no longer
an issue by minicamp, standing
out in a positive way was. Thankfully, neither San Francisco
nor fantasy owners were expecting immediate contributions from
him, but it’s a safe bet the team did not want the likes
of Nathan Palmer and Brian Tyms – two undrafted free agents
– impressing it more than Jenkins has to this point. In
case it wasn’t already obvious, Jenkins faces a long road
to even see playing time ahead of Manningham – the likely
third receiver – this season, so he is pretty much off the
radar in redraft leagues.
St.
Louis
Not since Torry Holt in 2007 has a Rams receiver finished than
29th in PPR scoring. Although there’s a pretty good chance
that drought will not end this season, there is a lot of reason
for optimism. RB Steven Jackson recently made a public plea to
second-round rookie Brian Quick to “work real hard”
for the rest of the offseason because the team is “going
to lean heavily on him”. This was in no way meant to be
a jab at Quick for a lack of work ethic, but rather a nod to the
rookie since he saw the same kind of talent in Quick that the
front office did. In fact, St. Louis believes Quick
is every bit the prospect Justin Blackmon is, with more size
and without the character red flags. In fact, about the only question
marks anyone had with Quick throughout the draft process was his
small-school background (Appalachian State) and tendency to take
his time getting into the flow of a game, as was the case during
Senior Bowl week. At 6-4 and 220 pounds, Quick will almost certainly
start because he offers the Rams something no one else on their
team does – size – and will be a key part of their
ability to give Jackson some space, not to mention he also projects
as well as the team’s first two options in the red zone.
And in case none of this starts his hype train, perhaps the fact
that Ray Sherman – his new position coach – sees “a
lot of similarities” between him and Terrell Owens (again,
minus the red flags). In fantasy, Quick will almost certainly
be drafted as a low-end WR4 or WR5, but his upside is much higher
than that. Considering the fact he has a better quarterback than
Greg Little, it would not surprise me at all if Quick outperforms
the Browns’ 2011 rookie who found himself in a similar (hopeless)
situation last season.
Lost in the buzz of Quick and fellow rookie Chris Givens is the
fact that St. Louis has a former 100-catch receiver on its roster.
It’s pretty clear that few people are counting on Steve
Smith to have much impact after seeing his 2011 season come to
an end with the Eagles after just 11 catches, but it was a small
miracle he was even on the field to begin with last season. No
team wants to start a pair of rookie receivers and the Rams are
no different. Since St. Louis will essentially hand Quick one
of the starting jobs, it is fair to say it would probably like
a veteran to handle the second spot. That’s why, in my opinion,
more fantasy owners need to focus on Smith and Greg Salas and
less on Givens in 2012. Smith
came on strong during the spring practice period and should
really be considered the favorite to start opposite Quick if he
is anything close to the player he was prior to his knee injury.
Then again, a healthy Danario Alexander is probably the most talented
receiver of the group at the moment, so the pecking order will
not be decided until sometime in training camp. Just don’t
be overly surprised if the Rams manage to provide fantasy owners
with at least two receivers this fall (Quick and Danny Amendola)
that can be used on a matchup basis and maybe even three if Smith
is truly close to 100%
Tampa
Bay
Given the way last season ended for the Bucs, LeGarrette Blount
appeared to be on the verge of becoming a non-factor, largely
because of his ball security issues and inability to contribute
much in the passing game. That sentiment was further advanced
when the team traded back up into the first round to select Boise
State RB Doug Martin. However, the Tampa Bay Times suggests there
is “clearly
going to be a role” for Blount despite the investment
in Martin. Since new HC Greg Schiano loves to run the football,
I went back to the 2005 season at Rutgers to research the run-pass
breakdown of every season since Schiano directed the Scarlet Knights
program to their first winning season and bowl game in recent
memory. In all but one season (2011), Rutgers ran the ball more
than it passed and in all but two seasons, the Scarlet Knights
ran the ball at least 121 more times than it passed. The last
time Schiano had the same kind of backfield talent he has at his
disposal now (Ray Rice and Brian Leonard, 2005-06), he oversaw
an offense that called nearly 200 more runs than passes (197 in
2005, 198 in 2006). Granted, there is only so much information
we can realistically obtain from play-calling tendencies from
the middle of the last decade, but it is clear the new coach will
run the ball (423 carries was the lowest mark over that seven-year
period). As a result, there may be some hope for both Blount and
Martin owners after all. It seems rather doubtful Blount can win
this competition in training camp, but based on my research, 150-175
carries does not seem like an impossible feat. Of course, that
would leave Martin with a solid 225-250 carries while fellow rookie
Michael Smith picking up the scraps. Throw in Martin’s likely
role as the passing-down back and it becomes evident that despite
losing more touches to Blount than he probably should, Martin
could maintain solid fantasy RB2 value, especially if gets the
goal-line carries. Although Blount’s size would suggest
he should be the goal-line back, he has scored on just four of
11 carries inside the 5 in his career.
Is it really possible that Mike Williams could go from unstoppable
rookie to the bench in less than two years? While it isn’t
likely, it
is possible. QB Josh Freeman singled out Preston Parker during
a mid-June mandatory minicamp practice, calling him “one
of the Bucs’ most
improved players”. Williams, on the other hand, has
the same work ethic and physical strength question marks that
he did when he slipped to the fourth round of the 2010 draft.
Meanwhile, free agent acquisition Vincent Jackson has received
high marks for his commitment in the very same areas that
Williams is reportedly struggling with. WR coach P.J. Fleck remarked
in mid-June that Jackson has “made it very clear to me that
he wants to become an elite player”. While that is refreshing
news for a Tampa Bay team that hasn’t received a great deal
of year-to-year consistency from a receiver in some time, it seems
unlikely that his yearly totals are going to change all that much
from his days as a Charger. In other words, Jackson should still
continue to post one of the highest YPC averages in the league
and go over 1,000 yards receiving. However, it seems unlikely
that he’ll be able to break his career highs of 68 catches
or nine touchdowns in such a run-heavy offense unless OC Mike
Sullivan makes a commitment to him as the main option on short
and intermediate routes as well. Jackson will likely remain the
boom-or-bust fantasy WR2 he has been for years while Parker and
Williams’ roles will hopefully be sorted out by training
camp. Both are worth drafting in fantasy, but expecting consistency
from either one figures to be a tall order since this will be
such a run-heavy offense.
Washington
Lost in the buzz of all the improvements the Redskins made on
offense this offseason is that one of the key cogs over the years
hasn’t left. Pierre Garcon is pretty much guaranteed a starting
spot, but somehow after one down season, Santana Moss has pretty
much been eliminated as a receiver worthy of fantasy consideration
despite being just one year removed from a 93-catch campaign.
Certainly, few will argue that Moss is on the back end of his
career at age 33 and should transition into a part-time slot receiver.
Furthermore, Leonard Hankerson and Josh Morgan are better fits
physically for the West Coast offense. But if we are to believe
what OC Kyle Shanahan and WR coach Ike Hilliard have to say, Moss
is not quite ready to accept his fate from Father Time quite yet.
Moss
has reportedly dropped 15 pounds and “came in possessed”,
according to Shanahan. Although Moss spent most of his time in
the slot last season, Shanahan also suggested that Moss could
also see some time on the outside and push Hankerson or Morgan
inside in order to get the matchups they desire. While it is not
entirely unjustified based on his final 2011 numbers, Moss’
ADP of 11.01 is too low for someone capable of a 60-plus catch
season. There’s a very distinct possibility that he outperforms
the likes of Lance Moore and Sidney Rice, players going a full
round or two ahead of him in early drafts. As long as he is healthy,
he should have no problem fulfilling WR4 value in PPR leagues.
It’s not uncommon for a rookie to “earn” a
nickname from his teammates, but few players earn a moniker like
“The
Arm” about a month after the draft. Of course, for those
that watched Robert Griffin III at Baylor and during the draft
process, his arm strength isn’t exactly surprising. The
bigger key for a young quarterback is his ability to process information
quickly and command the respect of his teammates. By all accounts,
he
has done just that. The same disclaimers that exist with any
rookie – especially quarterbacks – apply here as well,
but fantasy owners would be wise to consider the possibility that
one year after Cam Newton knocked the NFL off its kilter, Griffin
could be poised to do the same thing. Obviously, excelling in
OTAs and minicamps isn’t the same thing as doing it during
the regular season, but one could argue that RG3’s college
offense was more demanding than Newton’s – from a
passing perspective – and that he is more pro-ready than
the player he is most often compared to in Michael Vick. It is
certainly risky to even consider a rookie signal-caller as a low-end
QB1 in fantasy, but RG3 in Washington with Team Shanahan is a
perfect marriage of offense and skill set. There will be bumps
in the road along the way as defensive coordinators begin to exploit
his flaws, but the running game will be a prominent enough part
of the gameplan that his highs will outweigh his lows. Considering
the likes of Mark Sanchez and Ryan Fitzpatrick finished among
the top 11 fantasy QBs last season, it is entirely possible Griffin
that could end up as a top 12 fantasy QB in 2012.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared in USA
Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each of the last
two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football analyst for
106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C). He is also a member
of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |