4/23/12
As we have learned in recent years, there is no such thing as “down
time” in the NFL. If any group of people in the fantasy world
can relate to that sentiment, it is probably dynasty- and keeper-league
owners. Despite the fact the NFL season runs a shorter season than
any other major sport, it is next to impossible to take a long vacation
from football. Once the regular season is over, we have a five-week
postseason. Shortly after the Super Bowl, there is the NFL Combine
and a host of results from individual workouts to track leading
up to the draft. You get the picture…
It should stand to reason then if the NFL is constantly in motion,
then fantasy owners should be too. The irony of participating
in dynasty and keeper leagues is that owners are fans of football
– a subset of people typically considered to be impulsive
with a win-now mindset. One of many key characteristics in winning
in non-redraft leagues is channeling the passion for immediate
positive results and combining that with the knowledge that setting
your team up for success in the future is every bit as important
– if not more so – than winning this season.
In all honesty, everything I have said up to this point should
not be new information to the veteran dynasty or keeper league
owner. In order to help each of you begin the process of starting
your league year – just as the NFL does around this time
– on the right foot, I would like to present my thoughts
as to what players should appeal to those of us who need to look
at each of these players as a long-term investment as opposed
to a one-year stock.
This is the final installment of my four-part dynasty series
after discussing quarterbacks,
running backs and wide
receivers over the past three weeks. In an effort to be as
transparent as possible, I will list the different criteria (which
will change based on the position being discussed that week) that
I most strongly considered in the ranking process. I will attempt
to provide some perspective regarding their past performance by
attaching a percentage value that corresponds to the number of
times that player finished in the top 12 and top 24 at their position
when they have been in their current role. I will also provide
the player’s three-year consistency score in order to shed
some light on how good he has been in recent years.
Notes:
- In these rankings, I am using a full-point PPR league scoring
format where 10 rushing or receiving yards equals one point.
All touchdowns are worth six points and turnovers are -2.
- The “% Yrs Top 12” and “% Yrs in Top 24”
columns simply provide a percentage as to how often that player
has enjoyed a finish in that area in his current situation simply
because I didn’t see a great deal of value in putting
significant weight into Marshawn Lynch’s time in Buffalo
or Reggie Bush’s career in New Orleans, for example, due
to any number of reasons.
- The age listed will be the player’s age on September
1, 2012.
- An “*” in any column simply means the player
is a rookie, did not play in the NFL last year or is in a “new”
situation this season and therefore has no input to be listed.
- Because I feel reasonably good about where the top rookies
are headed, I have chosen to include them in the rankings. (Their
names and ages will be bolded and italicized.) Rest assured
I will be profiling the rookies following the draft, so I will
relay any substantial changes of opinion in those columns.
The Criteria
1) Elite production for at least three
more years
2) Scheme
3) Durability/long-term job stability
4) Proven consistency
5) Age (will penalize over 30)
- Typically, I'd set the bar at a higher number, but there are
so few receivers in the league right now over 30. Thus, age will
not be nearly the factor it was with quarterbacks and running
backs.
The Elite |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
1. |
Jimmy Graham |
NO |
25 |
2 |
50 (1/2) |
50 (1/2) |
33.51 |
2. |
Rob Gronkowski |
NE |
23 |
1 |
100 (2/2) |
100 (2/2) |
27.97 |
|
If ever there was a time to use 1A and 1B, it might be now when
trying to decide whether Gronkowski or Graham deserve top billing
at their position in dynasty leagues. (Ultimately, I went with
the latter at #1 because he will have less in-house competition
for top status and is still learning the game of football.) Whereas
Gronkowski excels in the red zone because of his size and power,
Graham is a fluid athlete that can turn a TE screen into a big
play or burn a safety and/or linebacker down the field with speed.
As a receiver, he can pretty much do it all. So until the NFL
is able to find bigger safeties who can match his athleticism,
Graham will continue to push 100 catches, 1200-1300 receiving
yards and 10-12 touchdowns for the foreseeable future in this
pass-happy offense.
Two seasons, 28 total touchdowns. It is easy to forget the reason
he slipped into the second round (and thus, was not the first
tight end drafted) of the 2010 NFL Draft was due to a back injury
that caused him to miss his final season at the University of
Arizona. That “gamble” by the Patriots has paid off
in a big way, giving Tom Brady yet another matchup nightmare (along
with Wes Welker and Aaron Hernandez). Perhaps only Calvin Johnson
presents the same red-zone dilemma that Gronk does in the sense
that he is such a huge target that he can defeat double teams
simply by rising above his defenders. Entering only his age-23
season, he could easily enjoy an Antonio Gates-like run atop the
TE leaderboard for the next 5-7 years. Perhaps the only potential
negative on his long-term outlook is the fact that Brady will
turn 35 before the start of the season.
The Near Elite |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
3. |
Vernon Davis |
SF |
28 |
8 |
100 (3/3) |
100 (3/3) |
22.12 |
4. |
Aaron Hernandez |
NE |
22 |
3 |
50 (1/2) |
50 (1/2) |
20.05 |
|
Vernon Davis: Alex Smith's most trusted
target.
For most of the 2011 season, Davis was a disappointment in fantasy,
especially for someone with his talents. Lo and behold, he managed
to post a 6-72-1 line in Week 15 – a game that signaled
one of the best finishes to a season a tight end has enjoyed in
recent memory. All told, Davis’ 19.2 fantasy-point total
in Week 15 matched his previous season high until he eclipsed
that benchmark in each of his last three games (Week 17 and the
Niners’ two playoff games). Davis later attributed his slow
start to initially being “overwhelmed” by HC Jim Harbaugh’s
offense and his fast finish to the fact he finally “got
it”. If that was in fact the case, one can only imagine
what kind of season he could have in 2012 with Randy Moss and
Mario Manningham around to open up the middle of the field. While
Michael Crabtree did have a career year last season, Davis is
unquestionably Alex Smith’s most trusted target. Harbaugh’s
tendency to lean on the run will hurt Davis’ potential to
match his career-best 2009 season, but the influx of talent should
allow him to score double-digit touchdowns over the next season
or two, which would allow him to be a fine alternative to the
owners who aren’t able to land Gronkowski or Graham.
Just about anywhere else, Hernandez would not only be the top
receiving tight end on the team, but perhaps its go-to option
in the passing game. (That’s if the team didn’t have
him buried on the depth chart due to his lack of ideal size.)
In New England, he’s simply just another matchup conundrum
who the Patriots like to use out of the slot in the short passing
game and sometimes even out of the backfield. While I would not
be surprised to see his role expand under new OC Josh McDaniels,
I can’t imagine he’ll ever be given the opportunity
to seriously challenge Gronkowski in the red zone. On the bright
side for his dynasty owners, I can see the time where he basically
begins to challenge Wes Welker for the most attention out of the
slot as the soon-to-be 31-year-old begins to lose his explosiveness.
It will also be interesting to see if McDaniels attempts to rely
a bit more on the run, which will obviously affect Hernandez’s
playing time negatively since he isn’t the blocker Gronkowski
is. Last but not least, let’s not forget that Hernandez
has missed two games due to injury in each of his first two seasons.
All in all, there’s reason for a bit of long-term concern
here for dynasty owners, but not so much that he isn’t a
top-five PPR option at his position.
The Talent Is There,
So Why Can’t I Count On You? |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
5. |
Jermichael Finley |
GB |
25 |
9 |
67 (2/3) |
67 (2/3) |
18.14 |
6. |
Fred Davis |
WAS |
26 |
13 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
5.68 |
|
Before the emergence of Jimmy Graham, Finley was supposed to
be the next great former-basketball-player-turned-tight-end. Prior
to the 2011 season, Finley was a fantasy risk due to durability
issues. But something funny happened on the way to his first 16-game
NFL season – his hands let him down (13 drops on 103 targets
for a league-worst 12.62% drop rate at his position). Since he
had a total of seven drops over his first three seasons in the
league, maybe we can attribute some of those drops to the lost
focus that can occur in the last year of a player’s contract.
Finley is every bit as talented as the tight ends rated above
him on this list and has the best quarterback in the league at
his disposal, so we should not bet against him in 2012 or beyond.
However, there is also enough risk with him that he should go
after the tight ends listed above him. So, as you may have guessed,
if Finley is past his durability and ball security issues, he
could easily join the elite tight ends over the next year or two.
After the first four tight ends, there is a fairly significant
drop-off. However, this tier does not lack for talent. In fact,
the only reason it exists is because the two TEs in this group
do not appear to be as “focused” as the first four
players. While Finley’s issues right now are certainly correctable,
the just is very much out on Davis, who is on the verge of receiving
a one-year suspension from the league if he fails another drug
test. HC Mike Shanahan seems convinced that Davis has made the
necessary changes to “kick the habit”, but he is a
risky choice for dynasty and re-draft owners alike since he has
basically run out of chances. On the field, few TEs were doing
it better than Davis for the first 13 weeks of the season as he
was operating as a mid-TE1 despite the fact he was catching passes
from Rex Grossman and John Beck. Obviously, the 2012 season will
be a much different animal with Robert Griffin III throwing the
ball and Pierre Garcon, Josh Morgan, Santana Moss and Leonard
Hankerson around to threaten defenses a bit more than the 2011
Redskins did. Therefore, while a good tight end and a good running
game are almost always a young quarterback's best friends, it
wouldn’t surprise me if Davis fails to match last season’s
12-game averages. But if you can live with one average season
from a tight end in your dynasty league, there should be a fairly
sizable payoff for his owners down the road.
High-Volume Pass
Catchers |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
7. |
Brandon Pettigrew |
DET |
27 |
6 |
67 (2/3) |
67 (2/3) |
10.90 |
8. |
Jason Witten |
DAL |
30 |
5 |
100 (6/6) |
100 (6/6) |
23.43 |
9. |
Jermaine Gresham |
CIN |
24 |
14 |
0 (0/2) |
100 (2/2) |
6.22 |
10. |
Greg Olsen |
CAR |
27 |
18 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
6.70 |
|
At this point, it is pretty clear in Detroit that Calvin Johnson
will receive the bulk of the scoring opportunities when the Lions
opt to pass in the red zone. But after consecutive seasons with
70+ catches and 700+ yards, Pettigrew has emerged as a lite version
of Jason Witten (in that he hasn’t shown quite the same
consistency Witten has). He’s not particularly explosive,
but he is generally very reliable and Matthew Stafford’s
safety valve over the middle. And it’s not a role that should
change anytime soon either since the Lions are not all that committed
to running the ball and will be forcing defenses to play soft
in an effort to take away Johnson and Titus Young. Although he
hasn’t quite established the same kind of bond Tony Romo
has with Witten, I’m going to give Pettigrew a slight nod
over Witte given the three-year age difference. Whereas I believe
Witten has enjoyed his best statistical years already, I think
we have yet to see the same from Pettigrew.
When a tight end manages a 79-942-5 line over the course of a
season and is considered a disappointment, you know he has created
a high standard. Witten did not score a single touchdown over
the final six weeks of the season and put up some meager fantasy
totals over the second half of the season. While most casual observers
will attribute that drop in production to his age, it was more
likely a function of the Cowboys’ three receivers all being
healthy for most of that stretch – especially in final month
of the season. But after comparing his 2011 target totals to those
in previous seasons, Witten wasn’t exactly neglected in
the passing game with 117 targets, only 11 off the pace from the
season before. He just didn’t reach the end zone as often.
Translation: with Laurent Robinson no longer in the picture, Witten
could easily return to his 80-90 catch days as Tony Romo’s
favorite option. And assuming Miles Austin and Dez Bryant can
stay healthy, defenses will likely let Witten try to beat them
over the middle. Since Witten doesn’t exactly rely on speed
or quickness to get open and has Romo’s unwavering trust,
he probably has 2-3 more solid years of TE1-level production left
in him.
While A.J. Green certainly enjoyed life with fellow rookie QB
Andy Dalton, the Bengals continued to underutilize Gresham’s
complete game even though he improved his rookie numbers. Besides
Gronkowski’s aforementioned back injury, one major reason
the ex-Sooner was drafted ahead of Gronk was because of his ability
to make plays down the field coming out of college. Through two
seasons, Gresham has one career catch over 30 yards, contributing
to his low 9.9 YPC. If Cincinnati is to take the next step as
an offense, it will need to find a way to show off Gresham’s
skill set because, quite frankly, two sub-600-yard seasons for
someone as talented as Gresham with a dearth of other proven playmakers
on this team is inexcusable. The Bengals seem likely to land a
highly-rated receiver in this draft, but as he develops, Gresham
could and should be Dalton’s second option on most passing
plays for the foreseeable future. If Cincinnati’s offense
wasn’t so conservative, I would suggest a breakout this
season was possible. However, we may just have to settle for gradual
statistical improvement, like his first 60-70 catch season in
2012.
Is this the year we can expect Greg Olsen to break out? After
all, Jeremy Shockey remains unsigned, Carolina isn’t rushing
to sign his replacement and Cam Newton will only get better, right?
The problem with that logic is that while two of three are likely
true, the Panthers like another TE already on their roster who
missed all of 2011 in Gary Barnidge. Despite a number of factors
working in his favor (such as the emergence of Newton, the lack
of quality receiving threats outside of Steve Smith and an OC
that loves involving the TE), Olsen still only managed to slightly
improve the numbers he posted in his final season in Chicago.
Still, as he enters his age-27 season, we probably need to give
him the benefit of doubt as a potential impact fantasy TE who
needed more time to learn a new offense. Olsen may never become
an elite option, but if the playbook was in fact his biggest hindrance
last seasons, he could be in line for a repeat of his career-best
2009 season. In this offense – for as long as OC Rod Chudzinski
is there – Olsen has 60-70 catch potential.
Aging Greatness |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
11. |
Antonio Gates |
SD |
32 |
7 |
100 (6/6) |
100 (6/6) |
40.87 |
|
Age and, in particular, injuries have begun to take their toll
on Gates, but when the soon-to-be 32-year-old isn’t battling
through severe foot pain, he is still an elite player in this
league. The problem is the durability that once made Gates a fantasy
favorite has evaporated over the last two seasons, which would
seem to suggest he is nearing the end. It also doesn’t help
matters that San Diego has lost two important playmakers over
the last two offseasons that used to make his job slightly easier
(Darren Sproles and Vincent Jackson). Despite all that, Gates
should remain among the best TE options in PPR leagues for another
year or two simply because he hasn’t lost his ability to
get open and Philip Rivers needs him perhaps now more than ever
as a red-zone weapon. Re-draft owners can continue viewing Gates
as a top-five tight end, but dynasty owners need to start judging
him on a year-to-year basis if they haven’t already started
doing so.
Ready to Rise? |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
12. |
Jared
Cook |
TEN |
25 |
16 |
0 (0/1) |
100 (1/1) |
-1.35 |
13. |
Zach
Miller |
SEA |
26 |
44 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
5.52 |
14. |
Jacob
Tamme |
DEN |
27 |
45 |
* |
* |
6.91 |
15. |
Brent
Celek |
PHI |
27 |
11 |
67 (2/3) |
100 (3/3) |
17.17 |
16. |
Coby Fleener |
TBD |
23 |
* |
* |
* |
* |
17. |
Kyle
Rudolph |
MIN |
22 |
34 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
3.92 |
|
One of my favorite breakout candidates in redraft leagues prior
to the 2011 season, Cook suffers from the same problem that affects
a number of football players each year – his play-caller (OC
Chris Palmer) refuses to adjust his philosophy to fit his personnel.
In the case of Cook, he is a “move” TE that struggles
as a blocker, which is why he loses playing time to Craig Stevens.
While I would rarely ever blame a coordinator for doing what he
can to protect the quarterback, it’s hard to understand how
Cook has less value as a playmaker than a fullback does as a blocker
in the Titans’ offense. (The blame doesn’t fall all
on Palmer since Cook could help himself simply by relentlessly working
on becoming a better blocker. On the other hand, Cook creates more
problems for a defense than a fullback leading the way for Chris
Johnson does.) Cook is an automatic mismatch for just about any
linebacker or safety that will cause defenses to play things a bit
more conservatively, which in turn should allow Johnson to be a
better runner. When Tennessee has decided to emphasize Cook at the
end of the past two seasons, he has turned in lines of 15-196-1
(2010) and 21-335-1 (2011) over the final three weeks, with each
stat pack leaving Cook among the top seven players at his position
over that time. Were he simply the No. 2 option in the passing game
behind Kenny Britt each week like he should be, I would have no
problem moving him near the top of the fourth tier. His age and
talent makes him a worthwhile dynasty “buy” because
the Titans will figure it out at some point. And when they do, dynasty
owners may just find they have a Pro Bowl-caliber tight end on their
roster.
I’m not exactly sure how HC Pete Carroll’s convinced
Miller to join the Seahawks last season when it was pretty clear
Seattle was a rebuilding team with a less-than-desirable quarterback
situation. With Tarvaris Jackson as his main QB in 2011, most
fantasy owners expected a down year from Miller as a result and
he met our expectations, delivering a 25-233-0 line over 15 games.
(That line was just more than half the production he was able
to muster as a rookie in Oakland back in 2007 when he was catching
passes from Daunte Culpepper, Josh McCown and JaMarcus Russell.)
However, the worst should now be over assuming Matt Flynn is able
to beat out Jackson as the team’s starting QB this fall.
While Jackson has shown he can lead a team to a few wins, he is
limited as a passer. On the other hand, Flynn has proven –
at least in his two career starts – that he can spread the
ball around and make defenses respect the entire field. Even if
Flynn is no better than a league-average QB in Seattle, Miller
should hover around 50-60 receptions each year, if for no other
reason than he is the team’s second-most dangerous playmaker
in the passing game when everyone is healthy. And if he is producing
at that level for the next 2-3 years, he stands a great chance
at finishing among the top 12 fantasy TEs each time.
There are several reasons Tamme is the toughest player to rank
this week. For starters, it is always difficult to gauge how much
a new environment will affect a player’s final numbers,
even if they get to play with the same quarterback at their new
destination. Second, if we call Dallas Clark below average as
a blocker, well, Tamme is near abysmal. This means that unless
Tamme upgrades that part of his game quickly, he might be a niche
player at best. Last but not least, fellow free agent addition
Joel Dreessen is the best all-around TE on the Broncos’
roster while both Julius Thomas and Virgil Green are certainly
more athletically gifted and possess more upside than Tamme. With
all of that said, however, Tamme has two rather big factors working
in his favor: 1) significant experience with Peyton Manning and
2) since he is such a liability as a blocker, will he even line
up as a tight end? In other words, will he be the regular slot
receiver enough though he’ll be listed as a TE? I think
the logical assumption is the 6-4, 236-pound Tamme will be used
in the same fashion the Pats use Aaron Hernandez. Additionally,
Tamme’s three-year, $9 M deal (when Denver knew what it
was getting beforehand) represents a pretty significant investment
in a “move” TE only, so I tend to believe Tamme will
have some staying power as the Broncos’ most fantasy-friendly
tight end.
As is so often the case in the NFL (and life for that matter),
when a person receives the opportunity to do what they do best,
they can make a substantial impact. By all accounts, Celek appeared
to be a one-year wonder when he followed up a breakout 2009 season
with a disappointing 2010 campaign. However, fantasy owners need
to keep in mind that tight ends run the highest risk of following
up a breakout season with a clunker because a big part of their
job description includes blocking. This becomes a big problem
in fantasy when a team suffers significant injuries across the
offensive line, thereby forcing tight ends to often become extensions
of the offensive line instead of another weapon in the passing
game. We basically saw this transformation happen more than once
in Celek’s career, in fact, you could argue he experienced
each side of it in 2011. One of the better pass-blocking TEs in
the league, the Eagles used Celek as such throughout the early
part of last season. But once the Eagles felt they could trust
their pass protection without keeping him at the line of scrimmage,
it became quite apparent he was still a viable threat for Michael
Vick. (Compare his game logs prior to Week 6 to the ones after.)
On an offense with so many weapons, Celek isn’t going to
be the best bet as a dynasty league TE since there is every possibility
he will be asked to block more often the moment the Eagles suffer
another injury on their offensive line. It is that delicate balance
that makes Celek nothing more than a top-end TE2 option for the
foreseeable future.
The only reason Fleener isn’t higher on this list is because
I don’t feel like I have a good gauge on where he will land.
(If I had to guess right now, it would be in Indianapolis at the
top of the second round.) Initially, he should be a “move”
TE that finds himself in the slot about as much as he should remain
in-line. I’m not suggesting he is going to have a Rob Gronkowski-
or Jimmy Graham-like instant impact just because he is a very
good athlete, but in a league that is all about matchups, most
defenses just don’t have the personnel to contain someone
with his speed and size. In terms of a comparison to another TE
we’ve already discussed, he is probably most like Greg Olsen
– which should give you a fair idea of what I expect from
him over the next few years. I like the Stanford rookie a bit
more than I did Olsen coming out of Miami, so the upside here
is fairly high. While rookie success at TE isn’t all that
common, be patient with him if he doesn’t hit the 40-catch
mark in 2012; his time will come soon enough.
Until the Vikings made the puzzling decision to outbid the world
for John Carlson, Rudolph was set to make a huge jump in fantasy
importance going into his second season despite my obvious lack
of faith in OC Bill Musgrave. As it stands now, I’m still
going to promote him simply because the decision to sign Carlson
suggests Minnesota will run a lot of two-TE sets and hand a lot
of playing time to each player. And given that Rudolph is “their
guy”, I can’t see how he isn’t playing the role
of Visanthe Shiancoe last season (who played just over three-fourths
of the team’s offensive snaps) while Carlson takes on Rudolph’s
2011 playing time (just under half of the snaps). Assuming Musgrave
simply lets his top players in the passing game play the majority
of the snaps – unlike last season – Rudolph could
easily enjoy a healthy bump across the board in all of his fantasy
numbers since he is, at worst, the second-most gifted receiver
on the team. For a player who won’t turn 23 until November,
Rudolph has plenty of time to emerge as a solid TE1 in dynasty
leagues. It probably won’t happen yet this season, but 2013
is a pretty reasonable expectation. Rudolph simply is too talented
to be held down much longer than that.
Great Potential
but Serious Flaws |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
18. |
Dustin Keller |
NYJ |
27 |
10 |
33 (1/3) |
100 (3/3) |
3.92 |
19. |
Martellus Bennett |
NYG |
25 |
49 |
* |
* |
-5.74 |
20. |
Tony Moeaki |
KC |
25 |
* |
0 (0/1) |
100 (1/1) |
2.68 |
|
As a fantasy commodity, it’s hard to love Keller because
he has established a reputation of starting out fast in September,
only to leave his owners wanting more after about Week 4. As a
football fan, it’s hard to understand how a team like the
Jets can’t find a way to feature him on a more regular basis.
And there within lies the rub: do fantasy owners draft talent
hoping the team sees what we see or do we draft the player for
the role he plays in the offense? To the Jets’ credit, Keller
did actually enjoy a relatively strong stretch in Weeks 15-17
this past season, but will his numbers continue to improve in
2012 with Mark Sanchez likely fighting for his job all season
long or when Tim Tebow is taking 15-20 snaps/game? In short, it’s
hard to find the long-term fantasy upside with Keller despite
the fact he is a pretty solid pass-catching TE. His offense will
be run-heavy, his quarterbacks are inconsistent and/or inaccurate
(to be kind) and the potential for team turmoil is quite high
when you mix a spark (the quarterback situation) with the powder
keg that can be Santonio Holmes. As a result, Keller is a strong
TE2 in 12-team leagues and will remain such until the Jets either
rely more on the passing game or secure a consistent quarterback.
Let’s get the negative out of the way right away with Bennett.
He hasn’t scored a touchdown since his rookie season in
2008 and has managed to catch just 85 passes in four years despite
the fact the Cowboys desperately wanted an excuse to use him more
often, which has helped him establish a reputation as an underachiever.
Now for the positive: Bennett is huge (6-6, 267), athletically-gifted
and known as one of the best blockers in the league, which means
he should be one of the few three-down TEs in the league with
New York. In addition to very competition for a starting spot
on his new team, he also has one other significant factor working
in his favor: his new TE coach (Mike Pope) is regarded as one
of finest – if not the best – at his craft. If you
need proof on Pope’s influence, just look at what he has
been able to get out of players like Kevin Boss and Jake Ballard
recently. With defenses likely to put the majority of their attention
on stopping Hakeem Nicks and Victor Cruz, they simply don’t
have enough resources to help the linebacker or safety covering
Bennett. Despite this rather high ranking for an unproven player
whose work ethic has come under scrutiny, it is very possible
that, by this time next year, I will need to move him up in my
rankings at least another five spots.
Every sport seems to have at least one player who has the talent
to be a real and fantasy stud, but just can’t seem to stay
healthy. One of the few players in the NFL that currently matches
that description is Moeaki, who is coming off an ACL tear and
has dealt with injuries since his college days at Iowa. Certainly,
it’s way too early to start writing the book on the career
of a player entering his third NFL season, but Moeaki will need
to string a couple of productive 14-16 game seasons together before
he can truly be considered a must-have dynasty TE. Moeaki should
be ready to contribute in 2012, but as is the case with most players
recovering from ACL surgery, he may not be all the way back for
another season. There is also the matter of Matt Cassel –
who may or may not be his quarterback in 2013 – and the
amount of competition and receiving talent for a team in Kansas
City that will try to remain a balanced offense for the foreseeable
future. With all the questions surrounding him and his situation,
I suppose it is appropriate that he be placed right in the middle
of TE2 territory.
What Does The Future
Hold? |
Rk |
Player |
Tm |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
21. |
Owen Daniels |
HOU |
29 |
15 |
50 (3/6) |
83 (5/6) |
11.17 |
22. |
Kellen Winslow |
TB |
29 |
12 |
100 (3/3) |
100 (3/3) |
10.05 |
|
Almost the exact opposite of Celek’s fantasy story, Daniels’
2011 season started relatively fast but ended with a whimper.
Although some of the blame goes to the absence of Matt Schaub,
Daniels disappointed in fantasy despite the fact he served as
the de facto top receiver in the Texans’ offense for over
half the season since Andre Johnson only played in seven games.
However, the biggest factor working against him now is the transition
the team has made, placing less of the fate of the team on injury-prone
players like Johnson and Daniels (and even Schaub to a certain
degree) and putting more of it on Arian Foster and the defense
Houston has spent so many high-round picks on over the years.
Daniels has yet to score more than five touchdowns in any of his
six seasons in the league and is only third in the pecking order
for the Texans in the red zone, so don’t expect that to
change anytime soon. Therefore, Daniels’ upside is somewhere
among the top half of fantasy TE2s.
What gives with such a low ranking on Winslow? After all, Winslow
– who will turn 29 just before the start of the season –
has shed the injury-prone label he earned early in his pro career
and has turned in three consecutive 16-game seasons, catching
no fewer than 75 balls in any of those seasons. The quick answer
to the question is that he simply isn’t the athletic marvel
he was before all of his knee injuries and he’s never been
a great red-zone weapon. Winslow also faces the possibility of
getting released sometime over the next season or two since he
is due base salaries of $4.5M and $5.5 M over the 2013 and 2014
seasons. Those salaries may be hard to swallow for a team that
likes what it has in Luke Stocker, who is also a better fit for
the run-oriented offensive approach HC Greg Schiano wants in Tampa.
Regarding his potential contributions for just this upcoming season,
the Bucs figure to have more skill-position talent than at any
point during his first three years with the team, meaning there
is a distinct possibility Winslow will have his worst statistical
season since his injury-shortened 2008 campaign. Since he has
never scored more than five times in a single season, it’s
hard to imagine he’ll set a new personal best now with two
legit red-zone options at receiver and a coach who wants to run
the ball in every situation.
Low-Upside Options |
Rk |
Player |
TM |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
23. |
Dennis Pitta |
BAL |
27 |
25 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
-2.54 |
24. |
Ed Dickson |
BAL |
25 |
17 |
0 (0/1) |
100 (1/1) |
-1.76 |
25. |
Heath Miller |
PIT |
29 |
19 |
29 (2/7) |
100 (7/7) |
6.93 |
26. |
Marcedes Lewis |
JAC |
28 |
30 |
20 (1/5) |
60 (3/5) |
0.36 |
|
(Dickson and Pitta) Dickson did enjoy a solid second season in
the NFL, but his production suffered as much as any player on
the Ravens’ offense when OC Cam Cameron decided to jump
on Ray Rice’s back and have his running back carry the team
to the postseason following Baltimore’s Week 10 loss to
Seattle. At the same time, Pitta’s importance to the offense
began to increase (all four of his touchdowns last season came
in the team’s final eight games). So what does it all mean?
In my opinion, this is pretty much what was expected of them when
they were drafted. Pitta was regarded as a weak blocker but strong
receiver while Dickson was regarded as the more complete tight
end of the two. Since there isn’t much reason to think the
identity of this offense will change anytime soon (the running
game), a continuation of the trend that began the week after the
Seahawks loss with Dickson and Pitta is a fair assumption to make
going forward: Pitta will probably be the slightly more valuable
PPR tight end of the two starting in 2012.
Despite a slight increase in his final numbers in 2011, Miller
appears to have hit the fantasy ceiling of his career. He has
firmly established himself as a 40-50 reception player who will
move the chains and block well, but not score a lot of touchdowns
despite his on-field connection with Ben Roethlisberger. Not only
do the Steelers have a wealth of receiving talent, but it also
seems rather unlikely that new OC Todd Haley will lean on the
passing game as much as former OC Bruce Arians did. This should
mean a bit more run-blocking for Milller, who will turn 30 during
the season.
The words few fantasy owners want to hear about their tight end
at a new coach’s first press conference: “he (Lewis)
is perhaps the best blocking tight end in the NFL”. While
that nugget ensures that Lewis will rarely ever leave the field,
it pretty much solidifies that another 30-40 catch, 400-500 yard
season with 2-3 touchdowns is probably in the cards. Blaine Gabbert
isn’t going to be as bad as he was last year, but new HC
Mike Mularkey has established a reputation as a coach who loves
his running game. He also has a history of excluding the tight
end – his old position – from the gameplan on a consistent
basis. Furthermore, Jacksonville may (sadly) be satisfied with
Lee Evans working as a starter opposite Laurent Robinson, allowing
the Jags to move Mike Thomas back into the slot. Obviously, all
of this is a problem for any owner hoping Lewis can recapture
the form that made him a fantasy revelation in 2010. His size
and athleticism should make him the top choice for Gabbert and
Mularkey when the team wants to throw in the red zone, but he’s
a poor bet as anything more than a low-end TE2 in dynasty leagues.
One Year Left |
Rk |
Player |
TM |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
27. |
Tony Gonzalez |
ATL |
36 |
4 |
100 (3/3) |
100 (3/3) |
22.92 |
|
Gonzalez has probably never seen a ranking this low in his entire
career, including his rookie season. However, we know longevity
has a lot to do with where a player is ranked in dynasty leagues
and it seems fairly certain Gonzalez is entering his final season.
I expect Gonzalez to end his career on a fairly high note for
fantasy purposes, although I don’t expect a repeat of last
year’s 80-875-7 line in what figures to be his swan song,
so dynasty owners willing to use him as a one-year serviceable
option at the TE position (while they wait for a player like Rudolph
to emerge) should consider him a bit higher than most.
The Call-Me-Crazy
Bunch |
Rk |
Player |
TM |
Age |
Pos Rk '11 |
% Yrs Top 12 |
% Yrs Top 24 |
Three-Year
Consistency Score |
28. |
Kellen Davis |
CHI |
26 |
35 |
* |
* |
-1.14 |
29. |
Julius Thomas |
DEN |
24 |
100 |
0 (0/1) |
0 (0/1) |
* |
30. |
Scott Chandler |
BUF |
27 |
21 |
0 (0/1) |
100 (1/1) |
2.30 |
|
If I had to select one player on this list that has been criminally
misused throughout his career, it might be Kellen Davis. As veteran
fantasy owners have known for some time, former OC Mike Martz
viewed the TE position predominantly as a blocking position in
order to get his receivers more time to run their deep in-routes.
New OC Mike Tice has a much stronger history with using the position
in the passing game and Davis came out of Michigan State in 2008
as one of that draft’s most freakish athletes. Now, at 6-7
and 267 pounds with Brandon Marshall around to occupy the defense’s
attention, is it finally time for Davis to break out in his fifth
season? I believe it is, as his team-leading five TDs last season
may attest. In fact, it wouldn’t surprise me much if Davis
goes on to enjoy himself a delayed career renaissance similar
to that of Visanthe Shiancoe with similar production after the
age of 26.
This offseason quickly went from good to bad for Thomas, much
like his rookie season. Initially, when Peyton Manning chose Denver,
Thomas appeared to be one of about 3-4 players whose fantasy value
was set to skyrocket since he was likely going to be the pass-catching
half of a TE committee with Virgil Green. But just like the high
ankle sprain suffered in mid-September that lingered and essentially
derailed his season, the Broncos squashed Thomas’ immediate
fantasy prospects by bringing in one of Manning’s buddies
from the Colts (Jacob Tamme) and a very capable all-around TE
(Joel Dreessen). I still expect Thomas to emerge as the starter
eventually, but that may not happen until 2013 or even 2014. There
is enough talent and fantasy potential here to stash him in a
deep dynasty league, but be willing to sit on him for a while
if you choose to go that route.
Chandler emerged as a waiver-wire darling early last season,
but once he scored his final two touchdowns of the season in Week
8, he was of very little use in fantasy. Despite a huge frame
(6-7, 272), Chandler is limited in his ability to be anything
more than a red-zone threat because he isn’t that great
of an athlete. His potential for fantasy greatness is also hurt
by the wide-open offense HC Chan Gailey runs. Buffalo wants to
play Chandler more than it did last season, but even though he
should see more than the 40% of the team’s offensive snaps
he did in 2011, he just doesn’t have a skill set that suggests
he’ll experience a fantasy explosion. That becomes even
more the case if the Bills land a first-round receiver like I
think they will later this week.
The Next Five
31. Robert Housler, ARI
Housler managed just 12 catches in his rookie season, which was
hampered by a groin injury. In addition to being injured, Housler
was drafted by Arizona months before it knew it would secure Todd
Heap. Heap is a free agent after this season and Jeff King fits
best as a TE2 – opening the door for Housler to make an
impact this season if/when Heap gets hurt again – or next
year at the latest when Heap’s contract expires.
32. Anthony Fasano, MIA
New HC Joe Philbin might have praised Fasano upon his arrival,
but GM Jeff Ireland wants an “explosive” young tight end in the
mold of Vernon Davis, Rob Gronkowski or Aaron Hernandez. Although
this draft has a player or two at the position (Dwayne Allen,
LaDarius Green) that may intrigue Miami after Round 1, it says
here that Fasano should be in decent shape to be fantasy-relevant
for another year or two as the Dolphins attempt to add viable
options at receiver.
33. Joel Dreessen, DEN
An under-the-radar player for the Texans, Dreessen makes a move
to the Mountain Time Zone essentially to keep the same role he
had in Houston. For those fantasy owners that remember Peyton
Manning’s early days with the Colts, I expect Dreessen to play
the Ken Dilger role in this offense while Jacob Tamme (and eventually
Julius Thomas) assumes the Marcus Pollard persona. His upside
for the next 1-2 years is roughly the 36-518-4 line he posted
in 2011.
34. Lance Kendricks, STL
As a rookie last season, Kendricks struggled with drops. While
Sam Bradford’s injury woes probably didn’t help his catch rate,
the bigger problem going forward is that St. Louis will lean on
the run and Kendricks has a long way to go to become an all-around
tight end. Still, there is upside considering new OC Brian Schottenheimer
took a similar athletic pass-catching specialist in Dustin Keller
and made him fantasy relevant, so Kendricks needs to be on the
dynasty radar.
35. John Carlson, MIN
I would have preferred putting a rookie TE like Allen or Green
here instead of Carlson, but the fact of the matter is that the
soon-to-be 28-year-old (in May) was a 50-catch TE in his first
two years as a Seahawk and still has significant upside if he
can stay healthy. Given the lack of current talent at WR in Minnesota
after Percy Harvin, it is highly likely Minnesota will be in a
lot of two-TE sets over the next year or two.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared
in USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each
of the last two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football
analyst for 106.7 The Fan in Washington, D.C. this past season.
He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.
You can also follow him
on Twitter.
|