Preseason Matchup Analysis
6/5/12
Relatively speaking, there are a select few in every field that
combine the talent with the discipline necessary to do great things.
Quite often, greatness happens when preparation meets opportunity
– the same recipe that people often use to describe luck.
Realizing that we are all flawed is part of what makes it special
when we achieve greatness. But once that greatness is achieved,
it can set the stage for a dramatic fall because the fame that typically
follows also increases expectations – something not everyone
is equipped to handle.
Focus can be defined as the “concentrated effort or attention
on a particular thing”. Quite often, it is one of the select
few qualities that allows the elite to separate themselves from
the very good in just about any segment of society. While I will
undoubtedly spend more time on the importance of focus when it
comes to achieving fantasy success as we advance through the summer,
the reason I chose to highlight it this week was primarily due
to the early Sunday morning arrest of Jacksonville’s first-round
selection, receiver Justin Blackmon.
Although I possess a psychology degree and it is my job to predict
the future – at least as it relates to fantasy football
– I would never claim to know if this will be the incident
that scares Blackmon straight or if this is just the continuation
of a pattern likely started during his college days. We often
don’t stop to remember that each new wave of players that
join the pro ranks every year are men in their early 20s who want
to do the same things (sometimes irresponsible) that most of us
did following graduation. Thankfully, most of them do a great
job of combining “living life” with being a professional
and contribute a great deal to their new communities. What I do
know is that like a NFL general manager or investment advisor,
it is my job to tilt the scales to guaranteed production and growth
as much as possible, only entertaining great risk at the point
where I don’t lose much if my selection tanks but benefit
greatly if it thrives.
So, why the heavy introduction into a piece about fantasy rookies?
The fact is that most of us can debate the positives and negatives
about each and every player from now until their career is over,
but one of the greatest factors that will ultimately determine
where each player takes his career from this point on is the same
subject I just discussed – focus. While a player’s
ability and determination to digest a playbook is always a good
indication of their focus on football, it doesn’t help us
predict whether their potential personal demons will sabotage
their career or not. Since we don’t get a say into which
players want “it” more than the others, there will
always be mistakes made during just about every evaluation process.
Speaking of the evaluation process, we have to finish the initial
evaluation of this rookie class. Last week, I began my Preseason
Matchup Analysis series by disclosing the bottom
half of my top 20 rookie players that I feel will have an
impact in fantasy during the 2012 season. While it makes for great
discussion, most of those players don’t figure to contribute
much to the bottom line of championship fantasy teams. The same
cannot be said, however, about most of the players I will detail
this week. And as an added bonus, I have continued the tradition
that I started back in 2010 to rank the newcomers for owners preparing
for their rookie drafts in dynasty leagues. While many owners
will not need to rank 50 rookies, I have chosen to do so for the
brave souls who play in those kinds of leagues.
Much like I said last week, a good part of the preparation process
at the beginning of each season is trying to ascertain the floor
and ceiling of each newcomer. In most cases, running backs steal
the show when it comes to immediate contributions, although a
number of players at other offensive skill positions have stolen
the show in recent years. Last season alone, Cam Newton, A.J.
Green and Julio Jones quickly made their presence felt in fantasy,
matching – if not exceeding – the high bar set by
players such as Sam Bradford and Rob Gronkowski in 2010. While
we can only speculate on which rookies will deliver the most impact
this season, there are some guidelines we can follow and questions
we can ask in order to help us identify the players who have the
best shot at becoming the next big thing. The following questions
give us a good starting point:
- Is he in a position to succeed? For a RB,
does he have a good line to run behind and an OC that likes
to run the ball? For a QB, does he have a good pass-blocking
line and 2-3 quality options in the passing game? For a WR or
TE, does he have a good QB throwing him the ball? Does he operate
opposite a star WR or is he being counted on to carry the passing
game?
- What are his most obvious obstacles? This
question goes hand-in-hand with the first question, but the
successful fantasy owner cares just as much about why a player
will likely fail as he/she does about how/why a player will
thrive. For example, how much do we penalize Brandon Weeden
or Trent Richardson – one of the best RB prospects to
come out of the draft in recent memory – because they
will play five fantasy games each year against Pittsburgh, Baltimore
and Cincinnati? Is natural talent along with a huge void for
a playmaker at receiver going to be enough for Brian Quick to
overcome a huge step up in competition and make an immediate
impact in St. Louis?
- Is he an offensive building block, complementary piece
or role player?
- How is the “fit” with his new team and
does his style mesh with what the team is trying to accomplish
or is the offense going to cater to his talents? (Unfortunately,
we can’t take for granted that personnel departments always
do this for themselves – need can be a terrible evaluator
of talent.) Can we really expect Justin Blackmon to adequately
fulfill the Roddy White role in new HC Mike Mularkey’s
offense for Jacksonville? How much of a boon is it for Alshon
Jeffery and Michael Floyd that both players will have established
Pro Bowl receivers opposite them…or will it stunt their
development? How quickly can we really expect significant contributions
from Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III and will each team make
good use of their incredible athletic ability?
Certainly, there are more questions that can be asked, but to
establish a baseline for a rookie, I think this gives us a pretty
good start. Over the next two weeks, I will evaluate the likely
top rookies from this class – covering the back half of
my top 20 this week and the top half next week – and present
a compelling case as to whether or not they are worthy of your
consideration in fantasy. At the very least, I hope to provide
each of you with my early assessments on each player (complete
with player strengths and weaknesses) before I really buckle down
on player evaluations in July and August, courtesy of the newly
renamed method I use for my fantasy predictions – Preseason
Matchup Analysis.
Note: The rankings
below are for the 2012 season only and are ranked in order of
likelihood of fantasy impact. (For example, QBs like Brandon Weeden
or Ryan Tannehill may accrue more fantasy points given the nature
of their position, but the chances of them impacting a fantasy
team are slimmer than say, a potential fantasy WR3 in a three-WR
league, because the WR may end becoming an every-week fantasy
starter.)
Blackmon: A potential menace for defenses
in the NFL if the Jags feature him in the slot on a regular
basis.
10.
Justin Blackmon, WR Jacksonville
2012 Projected Role: Offensive
building block.
Positives: Some players just
play bigger than they really are. Such is the case for the 6-1,
207-pound Blackmon, who has a thick build and often plays like
a receiver who is about 2-3 inches and 10-15 pounds bigger than
he is. He also plays the ball in the air about as well as any
receiver in this draft class. Although the typical college “spread
receiver” isn’t always schooled well on the ability to read coverage
– as opposed to reacting off what his defender is doing – such
is not the case for Blackmon as he generally shows he has a pretty
good idea what the defense is doing pre- and post-snap. Even though
the two-time Biletnikoff Award winner is sure to create fear wherever
he is lined up, he could be a potential menace for defenses in
the NFL if the Jags feature him in the slot on a regular basis
in part because he knows how to “sit down” in zone coverage and
is so thick that nickel CBs will be hard-pressed to play him without
drawing a penalty. Last but not least, Blackmon will begin the
season as an unquestioned starter for a Jacksonville team that
hasn’t had a receiver that struck fear into a defense in years.
Blackmon should quickly establish himself as one of the better
run-after-catch receivers in the league.
Negatives: Unlike the top receivers
from the 2011 NFL Draft, Blackmon does not possess the elite size/speed/quickness
combination of A.J. Green or Julio Jones. This is not to say he
doesn’t have enough of each, but rather that his play-caller (HC
Mike Mularkey) will need to be a bit more creative with him than
the play-caller Green or Jones (who, incidentally, was also Mularkey)
in order to get Blackmon the numbers a lead NFL receiver should
have. Blackmon also isn’t as quick off the ball as one might expect
from the top receiver in a draft class, although given his build
and athleticism, it is probably only a matter of time and professional
coaching before that problem corrects itself. His consistency
as a blocker is lacking and he will need to sharpen his route-running
skills as he gets older since he won’t always be able to count
on winning a jump-ball situation in the NFL. Of course, Blackmon’s
ability to contribute as a rookie will be directly affected by
the improvement of QB Blaine Gabbert, who was clearly rushed into
the starting lineup in 2011. And just this past Sunday morning,
Blackmon was arrested for an aggravated DUI after police discovered
his blood-alcohol level was three times over the Oklahoma state
limit.
Fantasy Assessment: Drawing
apt comparisons to Dwayne Bowe and Hakeem Nicks throughout the
draft process, Blackmon has the opportunity (clear path to starting
job), talent and a viable threat opposite him (free-agent WR Laurent
Robinson) to produce for owners right away. He even has an elite
running game working in his favor, which should make it highly
unlikely that he ever has to face anything more than single or
zone coverage early in his career. Thus, the question will be
to what degree Gabbert improves. In a league where 60% is considered
to be on the low end of an acceptable completion percentage, Gabbert
stood at just 50.8% in 2011. As the “Z” receiver (Roddy White’s
position in Mularkey’s offense), Blackmon has 60-70 catch upside
already this season if Gabbert is able to operate closer to a
league-average level than he was able to last season. It says
here he’ll improve, but more like at a 56-58% clip than 62-64%.
As a result, Blackmon will fall short of being the most productive
rookie receiver in this class because of Gabbert, but mostly due
to the games he will miss as a result of being a repeat DUI offender.
Fearless early-June prediction (12
starts): 48 receptions for 610 yards and five TDs
9.
Alshon Jeffery, WR Chicago
2012 Projected Role: Complementary piece.
Positives: During the 2010 season, Jeffery dominated some of
the finest teams in college football as a sophomore, posting a
8-192-2 line against eventual national champion Auburn and a 7-127-2
line against Alabama en route to eight 100-yard receiving games.
Jeffery plays much bigger than his current 6-3 and 215-pound listing
suggests since he has 33” arms, 10 ¼” hands
and impressive jumping ability to boot, making him a wonderful
complement to Brandon Marshall, who has long dominated in the
short- and intermediate-passing game when his head is in the game.
His new position coach, Darryl Drake, has praised Jeffery’s
hands repeatedly since the Bears drafted him. It also helps that
Drake is recognized as one of the best WR coaches in the business,
so the second-round selection will have that working in his favor
as well. Jeffery also lands in a pretty good spot for future NFL
production, because despite the brutal conditions the Bears sometimes
play in, Jeffery’s ability on deep balls should play well
with Jay Cutler’s strong arm in just about every game.
Negatives: Despite being listed at 6-4 and 230 pounds during
his junior year (Calvin Johnson-like physical dimensions), Jeffery
has never been nor will ever be “Megatron”. While
he does have good timed speed for a receiver of his size, he is
a long strider who wins more jump balls than foot races downfield.
His biggest concern during the draft process was the fear he lost
substantial weight for his pro day (213 pounds) after playing
most of his final season at South Carolina around 235-240. It
was that weight fluctuation (and the subsequent work ethic questions)
as much as anything that thwarted any chance Jeffery had of challenging
Justin Blackmon and Michael Floyd as the top receivers in this
draft class. Jeffery’s 2011 season was also great affected
by South Carolina’s musical-chair approach at QB –
caused mostly by Stephen Garcia’s inability to take advantage
of a number of chances to correct his off-field behavior.
Fantasy Assessment: One has to wonder how much blame for 2011
goes to the QB situation and how much goes to the weight gain.
And despite swearing he will never play at 230+ again, the question
must be asked: will he let himself go again once he gets his first
big paycheck? It’s enough to cast doubt on him, but Jeffery
won’t be asked to carry the passing game like some of the
higher-ranked receivers on this list will, so he will have a bit
more time to learn the nuances of his position and ease into his
role more smoothly than they will. NFL Network’s Charles
Davis used Marques Colston as a NFL comparison to Jeffery and
it was probably a very apt statement to make (without Colston’s
injury history, of course). With Marshall around, Jeffery probably
will not set the world on fire in the reception department, but
he should be a valuable red-zone threat as soon as he is named
the starter.
Fearless early-June prediction (13
starts): 39 receptions for 580 yards and six TDs
8.
David Wilson, RB New York Giants
2012 Projected Role: Complementary piece.
Positives: In a lot of ways, Wilson is a lot like Ahmad Bradshaw
– the running back he will be partnered with over the next
few seasons minus the injury history. Wilson is very explosive
(as evidenced by his 41” vertical jump at the Combine) and
quick-twitched, which gives him the ability to show off his track
background. He hits his top speed very quickly and does not shy
away from contact like other young 5-10, 206-pound running backs
might. Part of the reason for his fearlessness is because he wears
his size well (in other words, he is strong for his size). Although
he wasn’t asked to catch the ball all that often at Virginia
Tech (37 receptions), his hands are good enough to get him on
the field in passing down situations once he shores up his blocking
technique, something that come rather quickly given his willingness
to absorb contact.
Negatives: There’s rarely ever a dull moment with Wilson,
which is both good and bad. The ACC Player of the Year made several
highlight runs in college by reversing field, a move that winds
up losing yards much more often in the NFL than in college football.
Wilson’s pad level can also get high when he goes into “playmaker
mode”, which often lends itself to turnovers and/or injuries.
In fact, a lack of ball security is probably the main reason he
wasn’t considered a surefire first-round prospect. While
there is something to be said about the ability of a running back
to make something out of nothing, that same player also needs
to learn that not every play is “the big one” and
let his offensive line do their job in order to make his easier.
Wilson doesn’t always show enough patience in this regard,
often believing he has to deliver the “knockout shot”.
Fantasy Assessment: Bradshaw is the clear starter in New York,
but the Giants already know he’s not a 20-plus touch/week
feature back, so they would prefer not to expose him to that kind
of punishment. And although Bradshaw has played through an incredible
amount of pain in his career, his durability will likely remain
a question for the rest of his career. While Andre Brown has reportedly
added weight in the offseason to become the Giants’ new
Brandon Jacobs, Wilson should see the same kind of workload Brandon
Jacobs did before giving way to Brown or Bradshaw in the red zone.
Since the two veterans figure to be the likely goal-line backs,
Wilson will need to convert a few big plays in order to become
a flex option in fantasy or an injury to Bradshaw to be considered
a fantasy RB2.
Fearless early-June prediction (two
starts): 118 carries for 480 yards and three TDs; 14 receptions
for 95 yards
7.
Coby Fleener, TE Indianapolis
2012 Projected Role: Complementary piece/likely starter.
Positives: The most obvious advantage Fleener has going into
his rookie season is that he will be catching balls from the same
player who helped him score 18 touchdowns – including 10 in 2011
– at Stanford, Andrew Luck. As for the physical gifts he brings
to the table, Fleener has more than enough athletic ability to
be used as a slot receiver, making him an obvious mismatch for
just about any defensive player since he is 6-6 and 247 pounds.
He uses that size well to separate from defenders and had the
benefit of operating in a pro-style based offense in college,
which certainly did not hurt him when it came to reading coverages,
selling routes (usually off play-action in Stanford’s power-rushing
attack) and finding the weaknesses in coverage. Fleener finds
the ball in the air, has top-notch run-after-catch ability and
will almost certainly be the “move” TE for the majority of his
career in Indianapolis, which should help him produce immediately
despite his notable shortcomings – a below-average blocker who
is somewhat surprisingly average coming off the line of scrimmage.
Negatives: It is a bit disturbing that a tight end playing for
one of the most physical running teams in the nation enters the
NFL as a below-average blocker. Still, it’s a skill that
can be developed and something he will undoubtedly improve at
given his size and the fact he has shown improvement in that area
as his college career came to a close. Another surprising shortcoming
is his tendency to get knocked off his route, be it because of
a jam or later in the route. While Fleener couldn’t have
asked for a better situation to start his career (with Luck),
his immediate production may take a hit with the selection third-round
TE Dwayne Allen, who was regarded as this draft’s most complete
tight end. In fact, unless Fleener is able to become a passable
blocker relatively early in his career the few times he will be
asked to block in-line, his playing time may fall behind Allen’s
since the Colts want to be a physical, run-oriented team under
new HC Chuck Pagano.
Fantasy Assessment: Even though they sometimes surprise us, it’s
often a good idea to set low expectations on rookie tight ends
given the complexity and all-around nature of the position. Given
his skills and relationship with Luck, the chances are quite high
that Fleener will post fantasy TE1 numbers on occasion in 2012.
While few will argue that Indianapolis is in rebuilding mode and
Fleener should be the offense’s top target in the passing
game, we can’t completely dismiss the possibility that he
may not even see more playing time than Allen nor can we forget
about Reggie Wayne or Austin Collie. It’s a lot to ask of
Luck to make four receivers/tight ends fantasy worthy in his rookie
season, so it’s a good bet at least two – if not all
four – fall a bit short of expectations in what the coaching
staff hopes will be a run-based offense. For those reasons, Fleener
should be considered a top-end to middle-of-the-pack TE2 in his
rookie season from a consistency standpoint.
Fearless early-June prediction (13
starts): 48 receptions for 620 yards and four TDs
6.
Michael Floyd, WR Arizona
2012 Projected Role: Complementary piece/likely starter.
Positives: Much like the receiver across the field he will try
to emulate in Larry Fitzgerald, Floyd shines when he is asked
to adjust to a less-than-perfectly thrown ball because he possesses
such good body control and is not afraid of traffic. He also has
prototypical size for a receiver (6-3, 220) and puts it to good
use after the catch, showing uncommon power and vision in the
open field. His size also serves him well as a blocker, a quality
that will help him stay on the field in just about every situation.
Unlike many other top-rated rookie receivers from this draft class,
Floyd has the benefit of learning the craft from perhaps the most
respected receiver in the game today in Fitzgerald, who will also
ensure the rookie will probably never see anything more than single
coverage for the first 2-3 years of his NFL career. In addition
to adjusting well to poorly-thrown balls, Floyd has repeatedly
shown an ability to use his length in order to secure the catch
in the tightest of spots.
Negatives: Floyd doesn’t possess the awesome speed and
quickness combination of other blue-chip receivers taken in recent
drafts although he is still above-average in both areas for a
receiver with his size. Even though his timed speed at the Combine
turned heads, he does not play that fast and makes about the same
number of plays above his defender that he does past him. For
a receiver with his physical dimensions, he is not as strong as
one would expect and has dealt with a number of injuries (knee,
shoulder and hamstring) throughout his career already. Training
with Fitzgerald this summer will undoubtedly accelerate his learning
curve, but he may need more than one offseason to sharpen his
route-running abilities in order to create more separation on
a regular basis. Like many top college receivers every year, Floyd
can get away with a sloppy route-running technique because his
defender does not possess the same kind of size/talent he does.
In a division that is quickly collecting quality defensive backs,
he will need to correct that flaw.
Fantasy Assessment: Unlike some of the receivers on this list,
Floyd will not be asked to carry the passing attack. Like many
of his fellow draft classmates, there is some question as to how
good the quarterback play will be (or in Arizona’s case,
which QB will be throwing him the ball?). For the foreseeable
future, though, Floyd won’t be asked to do much more than
produce more than the combination of Andre Roberts and Early Doucet
did as starters while making defenses pay for committing too many
resources to stop Fitzgerald. That in itself should lead to a
fair amount of fantasy consistency – especially for a rookie
– even if it doesn’t allow him to become anything
more than a respectable WR3 over the next year or two. In no way
will Floyd make the Cardinals forget about the days of Anquan
Boldin working opposite Fitzgerald, but he certainly has the necessary
tools to turn in a 60-catch season as a rookie if Arizona settles
on a QB early on and trusts him enough to run a balanced offense.
Fearless early-June prediction (15
starts): 52 receptions for 675 yards and five TDs
5.
Brian Quick, WR St. Louis
2012 Projected Role: Offensive building block.
Positives: Quick possesses
just about all the characteristics a fantasy owner could ask for
in a rookie receiver, especially for a non-first round selection.
Aside from the fact the Rams do not have a reliable option that
possesses the size and talent of Quick in their receiving corps,
the Appalachian State product is virtually a healthy version of
Danario Alexander (6-4, 220) in terms of size and is an excellent
blocker. He is a former basketball player and high jumper, two
skills that carry over to his play on the football field. Despite
his relative inexperience as a football player, he has a knack
for getting open and understands how to run good routes. As one
might imagine, his size and long arms (34 ¼”) allows him to be
an asset in the short passing game. New Rams WR coach Ray Sherman
told
Yahoo! that Quick reminded him of another small-school player
he coached several years ago: "I see a lot of similarities to
Terrell Owens. The way the kid goes and gets the ball, the physicality,
the desire…he has a chance to be special, no doubt."
Negatives: As is the case with just about every player who comes
from a non-BCS school, Quick’s level of competition will
be questioned as will his relatively limited experience in football.
Throughout his college season and during the pre-draft process
(most notably, during the first 1-2 Senior Bowl practices), Quick
appeared overwhelmed by the magnitude of the moment only to rebound
as the game (or week) moved on, almost to the point where he was
dominating the competition once he got comfortable. Regardless,
just because Quick is immensely talented, it wouldn’t be
a surprise to see Quick struggle mightily early on in 2012 only
to have the light come on near the end of the season.
Fantasy Assessment: It’s hard to remember the last time
a Day 2 or 3 receiver basically walked into a situation in which
the WR1 role for his team was pretty much a formality. A healthy
Danny Amendola will likely finish the 2012 with better overall
receiving stats, but Quick will almost certainly be the focus
of defensive coordinators when the Rams find themselves in known
passing downs and should be Sam Bradford’s favorite red-zone
option the day he first steps on the practice field. Whether or
not that will mean only 4-5 touchdowns playing for an offense
like the Rams remains to be seen, but given how impressed the
Rams have been with Quick so far (in his pre-draft individual
workout and rookie minicamp), he’ll be given every chance
to beat that number.
Fearless early-June prediction (16
starts): 56 receptions for 740 yards and five TDs
4.
Andrew Luck, QB Indianapolis
2012 Projected Role: Offensive building block.
Positives: Luck has been called the best quarterback prospect
to enter the league since John Elway. The first quality of his
that leaps off the film is his accuracy, which is already among
the best among NFL quarterbacks. Luck may not have a cannon for
an arm, but his understanding of the game and uncanny accuracy
help “make up” for the above-average arm strength
he does have. Unlike many other college quarterbacks, Luck is
solid mechanically, has a great deal of experience running an
offense from the line of scrimmage and is comfortable going through
his progressions, all qualities that are rare for even the highest-rated
QBs. At 6-4 and 235 pounds, Luck is physically proportioned well
enough to absorb punishment, but he moves and slides well enough
in the pocket (and gets rid of the ball quickly enough) so that
he rarely ever takes a big shot from a defender. Perhaps the most
underrated part of his game, however, is his athleticism. Casual
observers sometimes make the mistake of taking the Peyton Manning
comparisons to an extreme, but Luck’s Combine numbers are
actually quite similar to Cam Newton’s. Luck has the build
to run over unsuspecting defenders and speed to pick up first
downs with his feet. Although his new team’s supporting
cast will be a question mark, he will get to work with his college
tight end (Fleener) and an experienced NFL play-caller in new
OC Bruce Arians, formerly of the Steelers.
Negatives: Especially for an early-entry quarterback, it speaks
volumes that Luck’s biggest “weakness” as he begins his NFL career
is the team he will be joining. Reggie Wayne is in decline, Austin
Collie and Donnie Avery each have significant injury histories
and the new starting tight ends are both rookies. At running back,
Indianapolis doesn’t exactly have a set of players yet who figure
to threaten the defense on a weekly basis. As for Luck himself,
most of his perceived flaws either never had much credibility
(arm strength, for example), were functions of a run-based offense
with limited talent at receiver or a combination of both. Granted,
he does not possess Elway-like arm strength, but who does? If
he does have one minor flaw, it might be that he knows he is accurate
and has forced the ball into double coverage on rare occasions.
But as a whole, he is rarely ever fooled and does not make many
mistakes.
Fantasy Assessment: Luck, Newton and Robert Griffin III are part
of the new wave of quarterbacks who just also happen to be incredible
athletes. Like with any rookie signal-caller, early growing pains
should be expected with Luck, but it also wouldn’t be terribly
surprising if he throws for 3,500 yards and accounts for upwards
of 25-30 total touchdowns as a rookie either. After all, he will
be forced to throw a lot to compensate for a weak defense and
may end up as his team’s best red-zone runner in 2012 since no
one from the group of Donald Brown, Vick Ballard and Delone Carter
may emerge as an above-average goal-line option. The Colts face
long odds in reaching .500 this season, but it won’t be because
Luck failed. With his talent and iron-clad starting status, fantasy
owners should view him as a high-upside QB2 already this season.
Fearless early-June prediction (16
starts): 322-of-513 for 3420 yards, 17 TDs and 12 INTs;
62 rushes for 325 yards and two TDs
3.
Robert Griffin III, QB Washington
2012 Projected Role: Offensive building block.
Positives: It’s not a stretch to say Griffin is a better,
more developed version of a young Michael Vick. In fact, RG3 may
be the best athlete to play the quarterback position since Vick
went No. 1 over 10 years ago. Where Griffin is better than Vick
is his accuracy and feel in the passing game – his dropbacks
are better than one might expect for a player who spent the majority
of his time in the shotgun formation and his comfort level is
high while in the pocket. Based on his traditional pure quarterbacking
skills alone (and not on his speed or quickness), RG3 may still
have been a first-rounder. However, the part of Griffin’s
game that allowed him to challenge Luck as the No. 1 overall pick
this year was what he can do on the edge and after a play breaks
down, something that HC Mike Shanahan will take advantage of from
Day 1. In a Shanahan offense, the running game will always be
a threat, meaning Griffin’s elite speed and quickness will
put defenses in a bind when he bootlegs. Safeties that typically
move up a few steps to stop the run will almost certainly be forced
to play back since he has more than enough arm to also stretch
the field vertically. Obviously, all of this means Griffin should
have ample opportunity to make linebackers look silly in the open
field when they are put in one-and-one situations. Griffin will
also be joining a vastly improved supporting cast in Washington
(as opposed to the one Rex Grossman and John Beck had last season)
with deep threat Pierre Garcon joining athletic TE Fred Davis
and a running game spearheaded by explosive second-year running
back Roy Helu.
Negatives: Although he showed the nation last season he is not
just a running quarterback, it wouldn’t be surprising to
see RG3 run a bit more often that he or Shanahan would prefer
initially as he tries to acclimate himself to the speed of the
pro game, both from an offensive and defensive perspective. Griffin
did not regularly need to identify complex coverage, make many
hot reads or work through his progressions all that often in Baylor
HC Art Briles’ offensive system. On the other hand, Griffin
is certainly a bright enough person to pick up the nuances of
the pro game in short order. Perhaps his biggest correctable shortcoming
right now is his short-ball accuracy. While his intermediate and
deep-passing skills are well above average, RG3 doesn’t
always remember how strong his arm is and can put too much muscle
into his underneath throws.
Fantasy Assessment: Initially, it will be RG3’s world-class
athleticism that makes fantasy owners drool. His height (6-2)
was a slight cause for concern for talent evaluators, but Shanahan’s
system should go a long way in easing those fears. It is not entirely
out of the question to think Griffin could enjoy a Cam Newton-like
rookie season, but in the end, look for Shanahan to do what he
can to maximize his runs rather than to repeatedly put his new
quarterback in harm’s way by using him often as a runner.
While this will hurt his fantasy upside, it should keep him healthy
enough to play a full season. Still, his potential for huge fantasy
games – and there will be some in 2012 – makes him
worth considering as a low-end QB1 candidate in 12-team leagues,
although he will ideally be one of the first QB2s off the board
instead.
Fearless early-June prediction (14
starts): 255-of-435 for 3210 yards, 19 TDs and 16 INTs;
84 rushes for 555 yards and five TDs
2. Doug Martin, RB Tampa Bay
2012 Projected Role: Offensive building block.
Positives: One of the “core covenants” new HC Greg
Schiano preaches is ball security, which only begins to explain
why Tampa Bay saw fit to trade back into the first round to select
a runner after LeGarrette Blount fumbled the ball much too often
in 2011. In addition to the fact Martin is more careful with the
football than Blount, he is a thick yet explosive runner who can
be trusted in just about every facet of the game. He is adept
at running inside, decisive as a ball carrier and can be trusted
in late-game situations. While he lacks the explosion of the NFL
player he was compared to during draft season (Ray Rice), he has
more than enough athletic ability to get to the edge and turn
it upfield in a hurry. Thanks in large part to his size (5-9,
223 pounds) and fearlessness, he hits the hole hard. He can also
make a defender miss in space although that is not typically his
style. Martin is also ahead of the game when it comes to his abilities
as a receiver out of the backfield. Although he is not the kind
of athlete coordinators will necessarily try to isolate on linebackers
in the slot, he is more than capable of cleanly catching the ball
out of the backfield to keep the offense on schedule and convert
on third down.
Negatives: About the only knock on Martin is the lack of one
truly special skill. He could stand to be faster and more dynamic
as a receiver in the passing game once he gets his hands on the
ball, but those are minor complaints at best. Although he values
the ball more than Blount, he does tend to carry the ball away
from his frame; his fumble percentage (1.13) is merely average
and too high for a Schiano RB. Even though Martin will enter training
camp as the prohibitive starter (and likely three-down back),
there is a strong chance he’ll receive Blount’s best
shot as the veteran makes his case that he could at least share
carries with the rookie. Martin is the better back and should
win easily, but Schiano may try to ease the load on him a bit
with a motivated Blount looking for another chance to prove himself.
Fantasy Assessment: Martin hasn’t (and won’t) receive the same
fantasy fanfare of Trent Richardson – the one back selected before
him in this draft – but he probably should. Not only does Martin
possess many of the qualities necessary for a huge fantasy season
for a running back – talent, solid run-blocking offensive line
and receiving skills among them – he should also rarely ever leave
the field since he is already the team’s superior short-yardage
option as well. In fact, my only concern with Martin at the moment
is the degree to which Schiano will try to appease Blount. Will
he only come in when Martin needs a rest or will the coach manufacture
a small role for him? It’s enough of a question to keep Martin
from being ranked No.1 on this list for now, but not so big that
he won’t produce at a top-end RB2 level this fall.
Fearless early-June prediction (16
starts): 248 carries for 1150 yards and eight TDs; 38 receptions
for 230 yards and one TD
1.
Trent Richardson, RB Cleveland
2012 Projected Role: Offensive building block.
Positives: There’s very little not to like about Richardson,
a player many analysts suggest is the best runner to come out
of the draft since Adrian Peterson. The comparisons are apt to
a degree, making him one of the few true bellcow running backs
to enter the league lately. Richardson is extremely physical and
has a devastating stiff arm to boot, making him a handful to tackle.
He also is one of the best college running backs in recent memory
at running through initial contact; rare will be the time he’ll
go down on the first square hit he receives, much less an arm
tackle. While other bigger backs rely on their size to overwhelm
an oncoming defender, Richardson has incredible patience and vision
and can make a linebacker miss in the hole just as much as he
can run him over. Similarly, Richardson’s fire-hydrant frame
(5-9, 227) combined with his track speed (4.49 at the Combine)
make him an absolute nightmare once he gets to the perimeter or
into the secondary. Although he is not a natural receiver in terms
of route running, he is more than capable at catching the ball
and using the same urgent running style he does in between the
tackles that he does when he is in space.
Negatives: If anything, Richardson almost runs with too much
power, something that may catch up to him down the road and make
him something of an injury risk. Like Martin, he’s adept
at catching passes and will be a plus in the screen game, but
he’s probably not someone Cleveland will flex out as a slot
receiver because he is so proficient at running routes. Other
than that – and perhaps the one reason Martin may outproduce
him as a rookie – is a limited supporting cast. Cleveland
is slowly assembling some young talent on offense, but it might
take more than a year for the Brandon Weeden-Greg Little connection
to scare defenses enough not to load the box on Richardson. Although
he will still get his share of yards, they will come harder for
Richardson than they will for Martin.
Fantasy Assessment: There is little doubt Richardson is one of
the better RB prospects to come along the last 5-10 years. In
fact, about the only concerns he has at the moment is the rugged,
defensive-oriented division he plays in and his long-term health
due to his fearlessness and willingness to absorb contact. In
a league where fewer and fewer running backs are logging 300 carries,
Richardson has a realistic shot at not only hitting that number,
but leading the NFL in that category in his rookie year if he
stays healthy. Another consideration is a healthy Brandon Jackson,
who is a good bet to replace him on obvious passing downs, meaning
Richardson’s ceiling is probably 30-35 receptions. Still,
given the knowledge that he will be so heavily involved in the
offense and his obvious talent, Richardson is one of the few rookie
running backs in recent years worth considering as a low-end fantasy
RB1.
Fearless early-June prediction (15
starts): 297 carries for 1320 yards and eight TDs; 26 receptions
for 175 yards and one TD
As I have done for the past two seasons, I’d like to once
again provide a bonus for the dynasty league owners out there
that want another opinion on the players they should target in
their upcoming rookie drafts. In my hope to remain consistent,
I will use the same kind of criteria to rank the prospects of
this class that I did for my dynasty
rankings back in April. The major difference, however, will
be that I will be stretching the “elite production”
time limit out to 5-10 years since most of these players are in
their early 20s. “Proven consistency” is also a non-factor
since these players have yet to play a pro down.
Some notes:
1) I will likely always value potential three-down RBs higher
than any other position – even though their careers will
be shorter – because finding those players is still the
name of the game (in my opinion) given the dearth of acceptable
RB1 options;
2) While I will not comment on each rookie below, I will focus
primarily on the players who have yet to be mentioned in this
series;
3) The contract status – in terms of the veterans these
rookies may soon replace – will be a consideration in the
ranking of these players as will the depth at each position. (In
other words, the fact this class was loaded with good, but not
great, receiver prospects will push their collective value down);
4) More than anything, what I’m trying to do here is
try to predict how these players will come off the fantasy “Big
Board” in about three years. While my focus is the
same 5-10 years I stated above, understand the roster turnover
rate in the NFL is roughly 25% each year. When most of the players
hit their prime, they will be doing so with a completely different
supporting cast.
Here is my early-June long-term overview on the class of 2012:
1. RB Trent
Richardson, Cleveland
2. QB Andrew
Luck, Indianapolis
3. QB Robert
Griffin III, Washington
4. RB Doug
Martin, Tampa Bay
5. RB David
Wilson, NY Giants
6. TE Coby
Fleener, Indianapolis
7. WR Michael
Floyd, Arizona
8. WR Brian
Quick, St. Louis
9. WR Kendall
Wright, Tennessee
10. WR Justin
Blackmon, Jacksonville*
11. QB Ryan
Tannehill, Miami
12. WR Alshon
Jeffery, Chicago
13. WR Mohamed
Sanu, Cincinnati
14. RB Lamar
Miller, Miami
15. RB Isaiah
Pead, St. Louis
16. QB Russell
Wilson, Seattle
17. WR A.J.
Jenkins, San Francisco – Should be a consistent contributor
opposite Michael Crabtree once Randy Moss leaves (likely after
this season) and Manningham follows (signed contract that ends
after 2013 season).
18. QB Brandon
Weeden, Cleveland
19. WR Marvin
Jones, Cincinnati
20. WR Chris
Givens, St. Louis
21. WR Rueben
Randle, NY Giants
22. WR Stephen
Hill, NY Jets
23. WR Jeff Fuller, Miami
24. RB Ronnie
Hillman, Denver
25. TE Dwayne
Allen, Indianapolis
26. RB LaMichael
James, San Francisco
27. WR Ryan
Broyles, Detroit – It may take two years to nudge Nate Burleson
out of the mix at receiver, but if he can stay healthy, he should
have a long successful career in the slot.
28. WR Devon
Wylie, Kansas City – Ditto the Broyles comment, adding Steve
Breaston’s name and subtracting Burleson’s.
29. TE Ladarius
Green, San Diego – Love the athleticism Green possesses and
although he will need time to develop, he has a great mentor in
Antonio Gates to emulate and an offense that throws to the tight
end.
30. WR Juron
Criner, Oakland
31. WR Tommy
Streeter, Baltimore – Very raw receiver, but upside is through
the roof if he can be developed.
32. WR Greg
Childs, Minnesota
33. TE Adrien
Robinson, NY Giants – Could easily be TE coach Mike Pope’s
next third-day draft find. Along with the player ranked right
below him (Thompson), he has the athleticism to be the best tight
end from this draft.
34. TE Taylor
Thompson, Tennessee – Is blocked by the highly athletic Jared
Cook, but former DE is the tight-end version of Streeter.
35. RB Vick
Ballard, Indianapolis
36. QB Ryan
Lindley, Arizona – There’s just enough mediocrity at QB in
Arizona that Lindley – who certainly has a NFL arm but needs help
with his footwork and accuracy – has an outside shot at a starting
job by 2014.
37. RB Terrance
Ganaway, NY Jets – Will probably make the Jets’ roster based
on his versatility, but has an outside shot at a starting job
in 2013 if the team passes on re-signing Shonn Greene.
38. RB Robert
Turbin, Seattle – Marshawn Lynch should just be entering his
prime, but his underachieving history gives this rookie a bit
of hope since Lynch will also be nearing 1,500 career carries
with another huge workload this season.
39. WR Nick
Toon, New Orleans
40. WR B.J.
Cunningham, Miami
41. RB Chris
Rainey, Pittsburgh – New OC Todd Haley has his new Dexter
McCluster. If any player from this class could emulate
the 2011 version of Darren Sproles, it is probably Rainey.
42. RB Bernard
Pierce, Baltimore
43. QB Nick
Foles, Philadelphia
44. WR T.Y.
Hilton, Indianapolis – It’s unclear if he’ll ever have a major
role for the Colts outside of special teams, but if he is ever
given the opportunity to man the slot full-time, his speed and
explosion could easily make him fantasy worthy.
45. WR Keshawn
Martin, Houston
46. WR LaVon
Brazill, Indianapolis
47. QB B.J.
Coleman, Green Bay – The Packers hope they landed the player
that will give them the same piece of mind Matt Flynn did over
the last two years. It’s quite possible Coleman is that guy.
48. TE Orson
Charles, Cincinnati
49. WR Travis
Benjamin, Cleveland
50. RB Michael
Smith, Tampa Bay
* Dropped due to recent concerns about DUI
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared in USA
Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each of the last
two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football analyst for
106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C). He is also a member
of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |