| One of the oldest fantasy football axioms is “never sit your 
              studs”. It’s an interesting notion in the sense that 
              it assumes: 1) it is common knowledge who the “studs” 
              are; 2) their “status” don’t change from week-to-week 
              or month-to-month and 3) every fantasy team has enough great options 
              to consider benching them. The advice also works great because it 
              doesn’t leave the owner accountable should the strategy not 
              work (i.e. “it just wasn’t his week”).
 Somewhere after the league draft and before midseason – 
                let’s say between Week 4 and Week 6 – the round in 
                which a player was selected should be pretty much taken out of 
                consideration in terms of how often they are relied upon as regular 
                starters. (Some would argue that it takes less time than that…) 
                In my estimation, true “studs” should be able to produce 
                at the floor of their fantasy position (QB1, WR2, etc.) almost 
                without fail and consistently deliver numbers that meet or exceed 
                the expectations for that position.  To find that kind of information (position expectations) quickly, 
                owners need to look no further than FFToday’s 
                Consistency Calculator. Generally speaking, I would focus 
                mostly on how often a player has been subpar in relation to the 
                rest of his peers at his position because the expectation is that 
                a truly great player will at least meet the baseline fantasy-point 
                average just about every week.  As far as I’m concerned, new players could (and probably should) 
                be added and subtracted to the “Stud Club” every month – if such 
                a thing existed. Can anyone discount the fact that Shane 
                Vereen has yet to turn in a single-digit fantasy-point total 
                in PPR leagues? How about Andre 
                Brown? Rashad 
                Jennings? On the other hand, it is hard to believe that owners of backs 
                such as Alfred 
                Morris and Giovani 
                Bernard aren’t at least considering other options. Very few 
                would question Morris and Bernard are among the better fits and/or 
                talents at their position in the league, but fantasy production 
                doesn’t always reward for that as often as we would like it to. 
                In Morris’ case, he is a player that is utilized very little in 
                the passing game and dependent on his team to be able to establish 
                and maintain a lead – which it has done very little in 2013. As 
                for Bernard, he is a fantasy RB1 talent is on the borderline when 
                it comes to how much work he sees every game. Few doubt the rookie 
                could probably be a rock-solid top 5-8 fantasy option at his position 
                if the Bengals simply gave up the notion their offense is better 
                off giving the ball to BenJarvus 
                Green-Ellis (179 touches) more often than Bernard (162). However, 
                we don’t get to make that call; all we can do is take the information 
                we have at our disposal and make educated guesses based upon what 
                offenses have done against similar defenses and assume what their 
                likeliest plan of attack will be in the coming week(s).
 Danny 
                Woodhead has toyed with low-end RB1 status on occasion because 
                34.7% of his value comes from his 61 receptions. In standard leagues, 
                he’s more of a hit-or-miss RB2. The same can pretty much 
                be said about Pierre Thomas. Last year, I wrote a column “It’s 
                All Relative” in regards to the subject of never sitting 
                your studs and stand by the opinion that lofty status is not only 
                fluid, but relative. However, I wanted to expand on it a bit more 
                this time around and actually get more specific as owners prepare 
                to make the most important lineup decisions of their fantasy season.
 Below is a list of the players in PPR leagues who I think should 
                be considered “studs” (or unquestioned starters) for 
                the final three weeks of the season based on any number of factors 
                such as talent, role and production over the course of the season. 
                The players in this first table have all played eight games, performed 
                at a QB1/RB1/WR1/TE1 or elite level more often than most of their 
                peers and should be expected to maintain that level throughout 
                the fantasy playoffs. Quarterbacks will be held to a higher standard 
                than running backs, receivers or tight ends for the simple fact 
                that a down fantasy week from that position typically sinks a 
                fantasy team in that week.  Some final notes: 
                players are listed in the order they fall on the consistency calculator. 
                Players highlighted in green actually “belong” in 
                the group above, but haven’t fully earned my trust or have 
                injury/supporting cast situations that make me a bit leery. Those 
                players highlighted in red don’t meet all of the criteria 
                to qualify for the group they are in, but have done enough to 
                make me believe they are worthy of consideration.
 Note: Players 
                like Aaron Rodgers who are currently injured were intentionally 
                left off the list. Obviously, Rodgers will be a must-start if/when 
                he returns. Shane Vereen is another player that probably cannot 
                be removed from lineups given the likelihood he will see 8-10 
                carries in a chaotic backfield and handle pretty much all the 
                passing-down snaps as well, but given the fact he has played only 
                four games, I cannot place him above because I do factor durability 
                into this list. Rob Gronkowski has six games under his belt, but 
                is an obvious play as well. Most of the players on this list should not come as a surprise, 
                but I’d like to discuss the seven players I highlighted 
                in red in a minute. Before I get to those select seven, the first point I’d 
                like to reference is the rather low bar I had to set for running 
                backs – a position that has experienced its fair share of…er…uncertainty 
                this season. In two-RB PPR leagues, Charles and Forte have been 
                pillars of consistency with only one game apiece falling under 
                the 12.05 fantasy-point threshold. McCoy and Murray are the only 
                other two backs that have produced no more than two subpar performances. Now back to the “red seven”. Lynch, Bryant, Thomas, 
                Marshall and Jeffery are all players who actually failed to meet 
                the criteria at their position. The reason they are included, 
                however, is because I cannot imagine too many situations in which 
                I could imagine benching them. Bryant has turned in three single-digit 
                games, but has fallen under the 14.39-point threshold five times 
                because Tony Romo has the audacity to lean on players like Jason 
                Witten and Terrance Williams when defenses make stopping Bryant 
                their top priority. Thomas is a bit of surprise here as well with 
                double-digit performances in every game, although his yardage 
                totals are probably a bit lower than most would expect due to 
                number of times Julius Thomas, Welker or Eric Decker have stolen 
                his thunder. Marshall and Jeffery have essentially traded big weeks most of 
                the season and there is no reason to expect that to change. Jackson 
                has feasted on a number of poor secondaries, but has been a veritable 
                rock for his owners when compared to his previous five seasons. 
                With Detroit, Minnesota and Chicago left on the fantasy schedule, 
                owners can continue to expect huge numbers from him. Reed is a 
                bit of an oddity in the sense that it took him six weeks to mix 
                being healthy with having a substantial role in the offense. Additionally, 
                he has missed the last two weeks with a concussion, all of which 
                combines to make his 66.7% subpar rate a bit of a misnomer. 
 Note: Jay Cutler is a player who qualifies for this list 
                and is someone I would feel strongly about in this area. Let the questions and doubting begin. By “waiting for admittance”, 
                I am suggesting these players are on the outside of the stud club 
                looking in, but are making their case to the bouncer – in 
                a matter of speaking. Let’s run through all of them quickly: QBs: 
                Seattle is usually content relying on Marshawn Lynch and playing 
                defense, turning to Wilson when the running game isn’t working 
                or in comeback situations – even though the second-year 
                quarterback is more than capable of carrying the team with his 
                arm or his legs. It’s for that reason alone I don’t 
                feel like he is a fantasy stud – Seattle is capable of making 
                him an intermediary between the center and the running back in 
                any given game. The Seahawks lead the NFC in points scored, so 
                it is hard to argue with their approach. Romo could easily lead his fantasy teams to championships with 
                Chicago, Green Bay and Washington as his final three opponents. 
                The major question with him will be whether or not Dallas will 
                take that opportunity to feature DeMarco Murray on a regular basis. 
                The return of MLB Sean Lee should enable the team to be better 
                defensively, making it a real possibility the running game takes 
                priority. Rivers should be set up for success in Weeks 14 (Giants) and 
                16 (Raiders), but three of his last four (and five of his last 
                seven) games have been one-touchdown efforts. That recent history 
                is enough to suggest to me that he may not be able to put together 
                three straight solid efforts to close the season. It’s also 
                conceivable that Ryan Mathews and Danny Woodhead perform well 
                enough in Weeks 14 and 16 that Rivers isn’t needed as much. The Redskins’ season has been a lost cause, but Griffin 
                hasn’t been nearly as bad in fantasy as many have been led 
                to believe. If RG3 continues to run as much as he has in recent 
                weeks, he’ll hold up his end of the bargain in fantasy, 
                even if he doesn’t deliver elite numbers like he did as 
                a rookie.  RBs: Tread carefully with 
                Woodhead – who has no more than four catches or 70 total yards 
                in any of those contests, which has coincided with an increase 
                in passing-game usage for Ryan 
                Mathews. After many weeks of very good production, the ex-Patriot 
                is walking a thin line between RB2 and flex until his touches 
                and snaps increase to early-season levels. C.J. Spiller tweaked his ankle injury yet again in Week 13, meaning 
                Jackson is probably back on track to be a great RB2 in the fantasy 
                playoffs. He has been the passing-down and goal-line back all 
                season long, so it is hard to believe that will change now since 
                Spiller cannot stay healthy despite a reduced workload. Assuming 
                Jackson’s owners can get past a fairly difficult game in 
                Week 14 against Tampa Bay, they should be able to enjoy some very 
                nice production over the final two weeks (Jaguars and Dolphins). Bernard’s role isn’t going to change in all likelihood, 
                but 14 touches per game are enough for me to trust him in fantasy 
                – especially with remaining matchups against the Colts, 
                Steelers and Vikings. Assuming the Chiefs continue their recent defensive downswing, 
                Morris finishes off his fantasy season with winnable matchups 
                against Kansas City, Atlanta and Dallas. The only question in 
                any of those games figures to be whether or not the Redskins’ 
                defense can keep the team in the game long enough for Morris to 
                get the kind of touches he saw on a regular basis last season. At a position where so few players are a good bet for 20 touches, 
                Stacy stands out as a rare fantasy property. The rookie has seen 
                at least 20 touches in all but one week since Week 6 – he 
                left Week 12 early due to a concussion – and is the centerpiece 
                of the Rams’ offense now. Two of Stacy’s three remaining 
                matchups are not great, but it is doubtful many owners have more 
                than one option on their roster that will see as much work as 
                he will.  WRs: Not surprisingly, Fitzgerald 
                has been a much better fantasy receiver following the Cardinals’ 
                Week 9 bye, which apparently gave his hamstring(s) the necessary 
                time to heal. He’s not back to the elite receiver status 
                yet by any means – and may not get there against until Arizona 
                fixes its offensive line – but the Cardinals’ decision 
                to use more two tight-end sets in order to help the running game 
                and the pass blocking has gone a long way in giving Carson Palmer 
                a bit more time to find him. Tennessee and Seattle (Weeks 15 and 
                16) are poor matchups, but I feel confident a healthy Fitzgerald 
                can hold his own. Shorts will be a sight to behold when he actually has a legitimate 
                NFL quarterback throwing him the ball. Until that time, he’s 
                just going to have to settle being the ninth-most targeted receiver 
                in the league despite missing the majority of one game earlier 
                in the year. Two of his three remaining matchups are less than 
                ideal, but any receiver who can post 14 catches for 135 yards 
                and a touchdown while spending most of his last two weeks against 
                Johnathan Joseph and Joe Haden doesn’t need to be terribly 
                concerned about matchups. Allen will probably a top-15 receiver in next year’s drafts 
                at worst and his remaining fantasy schedule could solidify that 
                status. The Giants aren’t the greatest matchup on paper, 
                but they haven’t exactly slammed the door on many of their 
                opponents’ top wideouts. If Allen’s recent target 
                totals are any indication (12 and 10 over the past two weeks), 
                there’s a pretty good chance Denver and Oakland probably 
                won’t have much success against him either. In part because he has one touchdown since Week 4, Garcon could 
                shape up to be something of a value pick in 2014 despite the fact 
                he is probably going to catch 100 passes and surpass 1,100 yards 
                receiving. The ex-Colt has been reduced to a garbage-time possession 
                receiver over the last couple weeks as Washington’s offense 
                continually shoots itself in the foot for three quarters, but 
                it doesn’t get much better than Atlanta and Dallas in Weeks 
                15 and 16. With the exception of a possible Week 16 showdown against Aqib 
                Talib, Smith is going to have every opportunity to lift his owners 
                into their fantasy title games with soft matchups against Minnesota 
                and Detroit. Smith’s yardage numbers have dipped over the 
                second half of the season, but he’s made up for it with 
                three scores over the past four weeks. The Vikings and Lions should 
                allow him to have it both ways.  TEs: I initially had six 
                tight ends listed in “waiting for admittance”, but 
                I cannot make a strong case that Jordan Cameron, Charles Clay, 
                Tony Gonzalez, Coby Fleener, Antonio Gates or Jason Witten have 
                proven themselves worthy of it. No one will question the talent 
                of most of these players and most of them will start for owners 
                over these next three weeks, but that doesn’t necessarily 
                make them must-starts in my mind. As crazy as it may sound now, 
                I would strongly consider playing someone like San Diego’s 
                Ladarius Green over all of them. ----------------------------  Some of the regular readers are probably thinking, “Give 
                me some players that are actually available in my league that 
                I can use in the fantasy playoffs!” While I would not recommend 
                riding more than handful of these players for more than a week, 
                I can make a case for them in at least one of the next three games 
                due to matchups. I will bold the “handful” of players 
                I do feel could be useful as potential every-week starts in deeper 
                leagues: QBs: Joe Flacco (Week 14 vs. 
                Minnesota); Jay Cutler/Josh McCown (Weeks 
                14-16); Matt McGloin (Week 14 vs. NY Jets and Week 16 vs. 
                San Diego); Ryan Fitzpatrick (Week 14 vs. Denver and Week 16 vs. 
                Jacksonville) RBs: James Starks (Week 14 
                vs. Atlanta, Week 15 vs. Dallas); Dennis Johnson (Week 14 vs. 
                Jacksonville, Week 15 vs. Indianapolis); Roy Helu (Weeks 14-16) WRs: Robert Woods (Week 14 
                vs. Tampa Bay), Cordarrelle Patterson (Week 15 vs. Philadelphia); 
                Andre Holmes (Week 14 vs. NY Jets and Week 16 vs. San Diego – 
                assuming Denarius Moore remains out); Doug 
                Baldwin (Weeks 14-16) TEs: Dennis 
                Pitta (assuming he can play in Week 14, stash and make him prove 
                it); Brandon Myers (Week 14 vs. San Diego); Zach Ertz/Brent 
                Celek (Week 15 vs. Minnesota); Ladarius 
                Green (Weeks 14-16)
 Suggestions, comments, about the article 
                or fantasy football in general? E-mail 
                me or follow me on Twitter. 
                
 Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and appeared in 
              USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in 2010 and 
              2011. He is also the host of USA Today’s hour-long, pre-kickoff 
              fantasy football internet chat every Sunday. Doug regularly appears 
              as a fantasy football analyst on Sirius XM’s “Fantasy 
              Drive” and for 106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C). 
              He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.
 |