“Life is a lemon and I want my money back.”
- Meat Loaf
I’m a big fan of the soon-to-be 67-year-old rocker who
was once known as Michael Lee Aday, but while “Two Out Of
Three Ain’t Bad” is actually pretty accurate when
it comes to how often I want my teams to win in fantasy football
and “A Bat Out Of Hell” makes for a nice visual on
how I want my teams to perform, I don’t want the above song
title to apply to my feelings about the season to this point (even
though I do like the song). Substitute the word “life”
for “The NFL so far in 2014” and you’d pretty
much have how I feel after three weeks in a nutshell. It’s
not an insult to the games so much as it is a shot to the workforce
(or the lack thereof). I really don’t need to rehash any
of the ongoing off-field troubles that have dominated the headlines
lately, but that has really been just the tip of the iceberg for
fantasy owners. I have played fantasy football for roughly 15
years and cannot recall a year in which there was such a combination
of ineffectiveness from and injuries to consensus early-round
picks this early in the season.
I’ve heard Hall of Fame quarterback Steve Young say on
more than one occasion that September is the new preseason and
he’s right. Teams are so petrified of losing their key players
in the preseason that coaches often pull them after a confidence-building
drive or two in August. While injuries can be avoided in theory
by reducing the amount of needless punishment a body has to take,
the flip side of that strategy is that many players will see more
snaps in the season opener than they did in the exhibition season
combined. Think about that for a second. In what other walk of
life – much less sport – would the ideal strategy
be to prepare for a grueling marathon with a series of short sprints?
Is it any surprise that hamstring and calf injuries always seem
to dominate the injury report early in the season? Furthermore,
the Collective Bargaining Agreement has essentially removed tackling
in practice before and during the season, which seems smart on
the surface. However, watch any NFL game for any length of time
and the number of shoulder and/or horse-collar tackles is stunning,
which obviously contributes to the number of knee injuries we
see each year.
This discussion brings me back to the point(s) I want to focus
on this week, namely injuries and slow starts for fantasy teams.
Because fantasy football is more than just a hobby for me, I have
often wondered why it has become almost an annual rite for just
about every one of my teams to start slow, only to make a mad
dash beginning sometime in October. I play in roughly 7-8 money/expert
leagues every year, so I think small sample size can be eliminated
from consideration. One easy answer is that other fantasy teams’
warts don’t start showing until the bye weeks and multiple
injuries strike, which will ultimately test the depth each owner
has built and their ability to “win the waiver wire”.
Another answer – and the one I choose to believe –
goes directly back to Young’s assertion that three or four
regular-season games must pass before coaches can get a true handle
on what they actually have. Why? Because
they don’t get that out of the way in the preseason.
So, I guess it is better to lose a player for a substantial amount
of time in the regular season (when there is generally not enough
time to react and find a suitable replacement) than in the preseason
(when a team actually has a bit of time to address the void via
trade or final cuts). After all, why use the preseason to
prepare a team to play a full game? Former GM and six-time
NFL Executive of the Year Bill Polian touched
on this subject over a year ago on ESPN’s NFL Insiders
and I certainly think his points are worthy of discussion. It
cannot be a coincidence – as he stated on a later episode
– that injuries typically plateau around Week 8 or 9 and
then level off. I realize it will not be a popular opinion, but
most veteran fantasy owners in competitive leagues can probably
agree with me the rash of injuries in recent years has been extraordinary
– and not in a good way.
At any rate, I thought it might be helpful to give a semi-quick
rundown of the known injuries or suspensions to significant
fantasy players that each team is dealing with at the offensive
skill positions that has either caused a player to miss a game
already or likely affected their performance.
Arizona – QB Carson
Palmer (shoulder – despite a solid effort from Drew Stanton
last week, Palmer’s absence is a downgrade for the entire receiving
corps); RB Andre
Ellington (foot – preseason injury doesn’t seem to have affected
his workload, although he has virtually no shot at red-zone scores)
Atlanta – WR Roddy White
(hamstring – prior to the Falcons’ Week 3 blowout
win against the Bucs, NFL Network reported that HC Mike Smith
asked White if he wanted to play 30-40 snaps and the receiver
essentially replied that he wanted to be a full-go or a no-go,
suggesting he should be probably be active in Week 4)
Baltimore – RB Ray Rice (suspension);
TE Dennis Pitta (hip – out for season), RB Bernard Pierce
(thigh – missed Week 3 but on track to play in Week 4)
Buffalo – WR Sammy Watkins
(ribs)
Carolina – QB Cam Newton
(ankle, ribs – career-low two carries in Week 3 after running
only four times in Week 2); RB DeAngelo Williams (thigh –
missed Weeks 2 and 3); RB Jonathan Stewart (sprained knee, likely
out a month); FB Mike Tolbert (leg – IR/designated to return)
Chicago – WR Brandon Marshall
(ankle – sat out 15 of the team’s 67 snaps in Week
3 after missing just six of the team’s first 135 offensive
plays over the first two games); WR Alshon Jeffery (hamstring
– looked significantly better running in Week 3 than he
did in Week 2)
Cincinnati – WR A.J. Green
(toe – played only six of 72 snaps in Week 2, but managed
to log 47 out of 62 offensive plays in Week 3); TE Tyler Eifert
(elbow - IR/designated to return); WR Marvin Jones (foot –
likely due back after team’s Week 4 bye)
Cleveland – WR Josh Gordon
(suspension); RB Ben Tate (knee – possible committee after
strong play from rookies Terrance West and Isaiah Crowell in his
absence?); TE Jordan Cameron (shoulder – played 22 of 68
snaps in Week 1 and missed the following week)
Dallas – QB Tony Romo (back
– although he has yet to miss a snap, the Cowboys are likely
leaning on the run more than usual as a way to buy themselves
time with him)
Ball is one of many RBs not living up to
expectations.
Denver – RB Montee
Ball (appendectomy – hasn’t missed any time, but doesn’t possess
nearly the same burst he did during the second half of last season
either); WR Wes
Welker (concussion/suspension – saw 47 snaps in his first
game action of the season in Week 3)
Detroit – RB Joique Bell
(knee – preseason concern that hasn’t resulted in
a loss of playing time – his snaps are actually up from
48.5 percent last year to 52.3 this year)
Green Bay – RB Eddie Lacy
(concussion – played 31 of 62 snaps in Week 1)
Houston – RB Arian Foster
(hamstring – missed Week 3 after leading the league in carries
through two games)
Indianapolis – WR T.Y. Hilton
(groin, ankle – played only 35 of 77 snaps in Week 3 blowout
win in part due to latter injury, while the former injury hampered
him leading up to that contest)
Jacksonville – RB Toby
Gerhart (ankle/foot – Jaguars gave their “bell cow” 30 of
60 snaps and “change-of-pace” option Denard
Robinson 20 in Week 3); WR Marqise
Lee (hamstring – missed Week 3); WR Cecil
Shorts (hamstring – missed Weeks 1 and 2, returned in Week
3)
Kansas City – RB Jamaal Charles
(ankle – missed Week 3 after supposedly suffering a high
ankle sprain, but was practicing later in the week and appears
to be headed toward a “probable” tag ahead of the
Chiefs’ Monday Night Football meeting with New England)
Miami – RB Knowshon Moreno
(elbow – targeting a Week 6 return); TE Charles Clay (knee
– has seen his snaps cut back from 89 percent in Week 1
to 74 percent over the last two weeks)
Minnesota – QB Matt Cassel
(foot – out for season), RB Adrian Peterson (exempt list
– out indefinitely); TE Kyle Rudolph (sports hernia –
out approximately six weeks)
New England – WR Aaron Dobson
(foot – “supposedly” healthy scratch in Week
1 and 3 after playing 31 of 67 snaps in Week 2); TE Rob Gronkowski
(knee – played a season-high 46 snaps – out of 77
– last week after hovering around 40 percent in the first
two weeks)
New Orleans – RB Mark
Ingram (hand – out approximately three more weeks)
New York Giants – WR Odell
Beckham Jr. (hamstring – preseason injury that has been slow
to recover since June); WR Jerrel
Jernigan (mid-foot sprain – out for season)
New York Jets – WR Eric Decker
(hamstring – limited to 44 and 12 snaps, respectively, over
the last two weeks)
Oakland – RB Maurice Jones-Drew
(hand – missed Weeks 2 and 3, but claims he will be ready
for Week 4); WR Rod Streater (foot – likely out 4-5 weeks)
Philadelphia – RB LeSean
McCoy (various – dealt with a “small version of turf toe”
and a thumb injury during the preseason and took a helmet-to-helmet
hit in Week 3; has yet to miss significant time during a game,
however)
Pittsburgh – WR Lance Moore
(groin – played his first and only snap of the season last
week)
San Diego – RB Ryan Mathews
(sprained MCL – out 4-5 more weeks); RB Danny Woodhead (ankle,
fibula – out for season); WR Keenan Allen (groin –
has only missed six of his team’s snaps through three weeks;
quality of defenses has been bigger issue for him)
Seattle – N/A
San Francisco – TE Vernon
Davis (ankle – missed Week 3 after playing 55 of 72 snaps
in Week 2)
St. Louis – QB Sam Bradford
(knee – out for season); WR Tavon Austin (sprained MCL –
missed Week 3 after playing just 11 snaps in Week 2)
Tampa Bay – QB Josh McCown
(sprained thumb – likely week-to-week); RB Doug Martin (knee
– practicing in full this week after missing Weeks 2 and
3); WR Vincent Jackson (wrist – suffered small fracture
in his wrist in Week 3, but intends to play through it); TE Austin
Seferian-Jenkins (foot – missed each of the last two weeks
after playing 20 snaps in Week 1, but is practicing in full this
week)
Tennessee – QB Jake Locker
(wrist – injured in Week 3 and reportedly could barely grip
a football after the game; likely to miss Week 4)
Washington – QB Robert
Griffin III (dislocated ankle – likely out at least 6-8 weeks,
if not more); TE Jordan
Reed (hamstring – likely week-to-week; injured on his first
and only catch of Week 1 and has not played since)
Final count: eight quarterbacks,
22 running backs, 20 WRs and nine tight ends
While I recognize not each player above was drafted in every
single league, the vast majority were. So join the crowd if you
drafted one or more of them and buy a lottery ticket now if you
didn’t. By my count, 44 of the 59 players mentioned above
will either miss their first game this week or have already missed
a game and/or been sidelined for a significant amount of snaps
in at least one contest.
Of course, that isn’t enough. Elite quarterback options
like Aaron Rodgers and Drew Brees haven’t exactly delivered
their usual numbers. Darren Sproles, Knile Davis, Bobby Rainey,
Chris Ivory and Justin Forsett have all outperformed McCoy, Zac
Stacy, Ball and Lacy. Michael Floyd and Demaryius Thomas are among
the several that have been outscored by Steve Smith, Brian Quick,
James Jones, Jeremy Kerley and Eddie Royal in the same format.
Clay, Heath Miller and Jason Witten are among the potential TE1s
that are barely TE2s at the moment. And if that wasn’t bad
enough, here come the bye weeks.
OK, so you already knew the fantasy landscape was a mess and
didn’t need to reminded how grim the upcoming forecast looks.
Hey, it’s why I do what I do: take a look at appears to
be a bleak situation and help out my fellow fantasy friend. Even
if this is the worst opening three-week stretch in my fantasy
career, it will get better … it has to.
In the following paragraphs, I’m going to turn the spotlight
on three names at each of the main four fantasy positions that
I believe are set up for success in the coming week and should
be available in the majority of leagues. Fantasy football often
rewards the proactive – and not the reactive – so
the focus of the rest of this piece will be on finding value where
there appears to be next to none at the moment. And most importantly,
listen to Aaron Rodgers’ when he was asked about the Packers
through three games earlier this week: relax.
Note: most of my leagues
are 12-teamers with 18-man rosters, so keep that in mind when
considering the alternatives below. In other words, players such
as Kirk Cousins. Donald Brown, Brian Quick and Larry Donnell are
not still hanging out on the waiver wire.
Quarterbacks
1. Blake
Bortles, Jacksonville – If the Jaguars’ goal was to
make sure the No. 3 overall pick didn’t have to endure a summer
full of questions and hype, then they were successful. Bortles
probably isn’t going to be all that great from a “real” perspective
this season, but he should be pretty decent as a fantasy player
for two reasons: 1) he’s got a strong arm and 2) he can run. There’s
very little chance he evolves into anything more than a low-end
QB2 this year; let’s be clear that he’s not a polished quarterback
by any stretch and will make his share of bad throws. Bortles
doesn’t have a daunting slate of games the rest of the season
and will get a chance to build some value after this week against
an injury-ravaged Steelers’ defense, the Titans and a surprising
porous Browns’ defense.
2. Mike
Glennon, Tampa Bay – The Bucs have a built-in excuse
as to why their offense has been so horrid so far: first-year
OC Jeff Tedford has yet to call a play for the team. The offensive
line hasn’t exactly cooperated either, plus expected starters
Martin and Seferian-Jenkins haven’t played much. However, it does
seem pretty clear McCown’s success in Chicago had more to do with
HC Marc Trestman than anything (which shouldn’t have really been
a surprise to begin with). At any rate, Glennon is a bit more
of a known quantity to the Bucs anyway and fared pretty well given
some dire circumstances as a rookie. He has better weapons now
and a more talented front five than he did a season ago, so perhaps
his big arm will find his big receivers downfield in a way McCown
could not. Given the amount of talent he has to work with, Glennon
is more than worth the risk for owners that might be dealing with
an injury to Carson Palmer or RG3.
3. Ryan
Mallett, Houston – I really don’t think it was ever
the Texans’ plan to end up with Fitzpatrick as the starter. After
two carefully-managed victories against Washington and Oakland,
the bearded gunslinger we have all come to know and love showed
what he capable of on the wrong end of things in Week 3. Mallett
isn’t exactly a perfect alternative and is maddeningly inconsistent
with his footwork, but HC Bill O’Brien is a highly-respected teacher
of quarterbacks and the former Patriot backup certainly has a
skill-set that could lead to big things. Perhaps the most intriguing
part of Mallett is that Andre Johnson, DeAndre Hopkins and (a
healthy) Arian Foster is a trio that any quarterback should be
able to have success with going forward. It is extremely doubtful
a change happens within the next week or two, but a midseason
swap cannot be ruled out.
Running Backs
1. Branden
Oliver, San Diego – Expectations with this group need
to be kept small and that includes a preseason favorite of mine
in Oliver. Danny Woodhead wasn’t exactly seeing a ton of action
himself and he is an established passing-down back (30 snaps in
Week 1, 38 in Week 2). With that said, “Baby Sproles” is more
explosive and a bit more built to absorb punishment (5-8, 208)
than Woodhead as well as a capable receiver – as his nickname
implies. Donald Brown may be the featured back while Ryan Mathews
is out, but another repeat or two of the 31 carries (and 62 snaps)
he saw in Week 3 will probably lead to Oliver being the new featured
back in relatively short order. At the minimum, Oliver should
expect to assume part of Woodhead’s old role while Mathews is
sidelined.
2. Denard
Robinson, Jacksonville – Much to the dismay of Gerhart
owners everywhere, the poor play-calling and woeful play of the
offensive line has led the team to consider a quicker player that
can help make up for some of the Jags’ shortcomings. This recommendation
isn’t necessarily a shot at Gerhart, who I still believe will
return low-end RB2 value at some point and enjoy the kind of workload
many expected from him a month ago. There’s always a chance Gerhart’s
run as the featured back could go about like the plan to start
Chad Henne all year at quarterback too. But if the Jags’ coaching
staff is watching the same games I am, they have to be able to
see Gerhart is literally earning every yard on his own on roughly
90 percent of his carries. Robinson was the player I hoped Jacksonville
would feature last year in order to prepare the team for life
without Maurice Jones-Drew, although I ultimately feel Gerhart
is a better fit for the team the Jags want to be going forward.
Either way, Robinson may now be in the role many expected Jordan
Todman to occupy in 2014.
3. Joseph
Randle, Dallas – There really isn’t much reason to
put the second-year back on a fantasy roster right now, but DeMarco
Murray’s next injury never seems to be that far away. Much noise
was made in the offseason about Lance Dunbar serving as Murray’s
sidekick, but the North Texas alum has only seen 27 snaps through
three weeks. Randle has been even less involved (nine snaps),
although he seems to be the most likely option to be the lead
back – with Dunbar serving as the passing-down option – in the
event of a Murray injury. It is mindboggling to me that Randle
is not universally owned in deeper leagues and, while I admit
that he could be a waste of a roster spot if Murray can play all
16 games for the first time in his career, I have sincere doubt
the Cowboys’ top back can do that with his upright running style.
Wide Receiver
1. Jordan
Matthews, Philadelphia – I desperately wanted the Eagles’
rookie on multiple redraft teams this year in part because of
the limited obstacles he had in his way to fantasy success. Riley
Cooper leads all of his skill-position teammates in snaps (207),
yet has only nine receptions. Jeremy Maclin’s durability is the
only reason I didn’t include him among my top 15 receivers, but
his health will remain a concern going forward. While everybody
is healthy in Philly, consistency will be hard to come by for
the second-round draft pick. With that said, his stock would skyrocket
if anything happens to Cooper, Maclin or even TE Zach Ertz and
we saw an example of what he could do in Week 3 even when everybody
is in good shape. Matthews is a WR4 until further notice, but
possesses WR2 upside if injuries strike the Eagles.
2. Andre
Holmes, Oakland – This one is rather simple. With Streater
sidelined and Denarius Moore remaining highly inefficient, the
6-4, 210-pound Hillsdale product has an extended period of time
to become Derek Carr’s favorite receiver. Holmes was a bit of
a waiver-wire darling last season with Matt McGloin as his quarterback,
so it isn’t a stretch to suggest he could enjoy a nice little
run for a team that should throw the ball a lot in garbage time.
In leagues like the one I referenced above, there can be 60-70
receivers on rosters. Holmes’ upside is probably around a fantasy
WR4 when he sees more than half the snaps, which means he needs
to be owned in deeper leagues.
3. Jeremy
Kerley, New York Jets – Kerley is an uninspiring option
for fantasy owners in part because few owners want to rely too
much on a 5-9, 188-pound receiver that plays for the Jets. Do
me a favor real quick and see if there is another receiver that
is roughly the same size with similar stats through three games.
Owners may be a bit familiar with New Orleans’ Brandin Cooks,
whose 18-168-1 line (with 49 yards rushing) on 24 targets looks
remarkably similar to Kerley’s 15-141-1 line (with 37 yards rushing)
on the same number of targets as Cooks. Do I expect to remain
that way? Of course not. Does it speak to the fact that Kerley
may be a bit undervalued? Probably.
Tight Ends
1. Austin
Seferian-Jenkins, Tampa Bay – I made a small mention
of the second-round rookie in the injury section and talked about
him at length here,
so this will be short. ASJ is a 6-5, 262-pound former basketball
player that was the most dominant tight end I saw play in college
in 2012. A foot injury and a change in offensive philosophy in
his final year at Washington hurt his stock as much as anything
in May’s draft, but there are certain parts of his game that are
reminiscent of Rob Gronkowski (albeit less physical and aggressive).
Perhaps he ends up being nothing more than a 30-35 catch player
in 2014, but odds are he’ll be a significant red-zone threat.
2. Owen
Daniels/Crockett
Gillmore, Baltimore – This one depends entirely on
whether you need help in the short term (and based on the injuries
I cited above, who isn’t playing for the short term?) or are speculating
for future tight end talent. Ravens OC Gary Kubiak always has
and probably always will make the tight end a central part of
his offense. Early word has it that Baltimore will use a committee
to replace Dennis Pitta, although it is telling that Daniels has
out-snapped hybrid FB/TE Kyle Juszczyk and Gillmore 145-83-29,
respectively, through three games. Daniels wasn’t brought into
pass block, so it seems unlikely he’ll be asked to do so now even
after the Ravens lost LT Eugene Monroe (knee) this week. So why
do I recommend Gillmore? He’s more talented than Daniels, pure
and simple; Gillmore should have already been on the radar of
dynasty owners. In the wake of Pitta’s potentially career-threatening
hip injury, he now should be on dynasty-league rosters everywhere.
It also would not surprise me in the least if Gillmore passes
Daniels on the depth chart before the end of the season.
3. Coby
Fleener, Indianapolis – For the most part, I like to
build my team around good football players that are also good
in fantasy. Fleener is not a particularly good football player
in my opinion, but he benefits from former college Andrew Luck
as his quarterback and a scheme that uses a lot of two-tight personnel.
For those owners who are going to ride out the storm with Jordan
Reed or Kyle Rudolph over the next few weeks, consider Fleener
as a decent option every other week until the Colts’ bye
in Week 10, with the potentially good games beginning this week.
Fleener scorched the Titans last year (albeit without Dwayne Allen
around) and although much has changed, the third-year tight end
has seen at least seven targets in two of his three games so far.
Suggestions, comments, about the article
or fantasy football in general? E-mail
me or follow me on Twitter.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today
since 2006 and has been featured in USA Today’s Fantasy Football
Preview magazine since 2010. He has hosted USA Today’s hour-long,
pre-kickoff fantasy football internet chat every Sunday over the
past two seasons and appears as a guest analyst before and during
the season on Sirius XM’s “Fantasy Drive” as well
as 106.7 The Fan (WJFK – Washington, D.C). Doug is also a
member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association. |