Fantasy football is a wonderful hobby when everything goes according
to plan, every one of our players keeps the job they had to begin
the season and/or they all stay healthy. (The opponents in my most
important leagues this week better appreciate their luck in this
regard.) But for 99 percent of us, we don’t get to live in
that reality. (I certainly don't anyway.)
In one of my two aforementioned leagues, Ezekiel
Elliott is all that remains from the Week 1 starting lineup
that will take the fantasy field this week. The depth I initially
built at both running back and receiver is virtually gone, and
the few Week 1 starters that remain on my roster are no longer
worth starting. If that doesn't sound like a recipe for disaster,
I'm not sure what does. Yet, some savvy adds and trades along
the way have netted me Derek
Carr, Philip
Rivers, Thomas
Rawls, Pierre
Garçon, Taylor
Gabriel and C.J.
Fiedorowicz among others.
My story is not unique, as I'm sure most have a team in which
only one or two of their initial "building blocks" are
still contributing on a regular basis. Most of us know how important
winning the waiver wire is to our success in this hobby and one
could argue it is arguably more important to win it now than it
is in September. The downside is owners in a similar position
don't have the option of being wrong about placing their trust
in unknown quantities anymore. There is no next week to rebound.
The cliché "win-or-go-home" is not just a saying;
there is no more "I learned my lesson." At least not
in 2016.
At this point of the season, I think the most any self-respecting
fantasy analyst can do is help owners figure out what emerging
under-the-radar players might be for real (at least as when it
comes to the final two weeks of the regular season) and which
ones are not, with the obvious caveat being embarrassingly small
sample sizes in a lot of cases.
I'm limiting my scope this week to players who I believe would
generally be considered fringe options at best. The one exception
to that rule is immediately below, as there is plenty of talk
about a certain player taking the fantasy playoffs by storm for
a second straight season. While not a fringe player per se, I
felt his emergence was important enough to discuss outside of
the parameters I intended to stay within for this story. I've
placed the players in the order I would trust them by position.
Powell is a strong plug-and-play candidate should Matt Forte
be unable to play through his knee injury, which seems like a
distinct possibility at the moment. However, consider me skeptical
about his ability to the answer to your fantasy prayers. Yes,
I'm well aware of what he did last week in San Francisco, but
the 49ers are among the worst in history at stopping the run this
year. The bigger concern is the state of the offensive line, which
lost LT Ryan Clady early in the season as well as C Nick Mangold
and RT Breno Giacomini in recent weeks. (That is unlikely to play
well against a front four of DTs Ndamukong Suh and Jordan Phillips
as well as DE Cameron Wake and Andre Branch. Furthermore, the
Jets have been highly inconsistent in regards to calling run plays
all season long.) Miami just did a fine job against David Johnson
(albeit in a rainstorm) in Week 14 and it isn't blasphemous to
say that Powell is no Johnson and the Jets' supporting cast doesn't
possess the same talent as the Cardinals.
Powell would seem to be on the verge of becoming a fantasy playoff
stud for the second straight year, but something doesn't feel
right here. Last year's Jets had multiple weapons and could exploit
just about any weakness an opponent had, so when Chris Ivory got
hurt, Powell could step up. This year's squad doesn't appear all
that thrilled about using its best weapon (Brandon Marshall),
watched QB Bryce Petty get sacked six times last week by the 49ers,
fell behind San Francisco 14-0 in a heartbeat and is playing for
next year. What's worse for Powell's immediate value is that Miami
(Week 15) and New England (Week 16) each very much have something
to play for the rest of the way. Of course, this all assumes Forte
will miss this week, which isn't even a sure thing. I've been
wrong before and I'll be wrong again (probably in the very near
future, if not on this matter entirely), but I could easily envision
a scenario in which potential second-stringer Brandon Wilds plays
enough to make Powell more of a lead back than a featured one.
Verdict: With or without Forte
the rest of the way, I can only trust Powell as a flex. He deserves
better because he is an explosive player with a well-rounded game,
but the last time the Jets played somebody in the playoff hunt
(Colts in Week 12), New York laid a complete egg at home in primetime
and three Jets running backs combined for 16 touches (C.J.
Spiller, who was let go hours after the game, received three
touches to Powell's one) in one of the best matchups they had
all season, so forgive me if I don't see Powell as a slam dunk
against Miami this week or New England next week.
I spoke a bit about Farrow in The Tantalizing 10 back in mid-October
(it turns out I did a fairly good job with the list) and how he
reminded me of a less versatile version of former Charger do-it-all
back Jacob Hester. I feel the same way after watching him again
last week in relief of Melvin Gordon, who is likely week-to-week
after leaving early with a hip strain and knee sprain against
the Panthers. Box-score watchers will certainly point to his 22
touches in Week 14 and immediately hope they have landed a flex
option at worst. They might be right, although it could very well
be for the wrong reason. Ronnie Hillman has bounced around the
NFL more than most this season, but he was inactive against Carolina,
which left Farrow as the only active back. Hillman will almost
certainly operate as the change-of-pace or breather back in Week
15 and beyond should Gordon not play, possibly limiting Farrow's
workload. With that said, San Diego's remaining opponents are
Oakland and Cleveland, which rank ninth and third, respectively,
in terms of most fantasy points allowed to running backs. Farrow
showed he was a capable receiver last week and figures to keep
the early-down/goal-line work, so it is not a big ask for him
to catch 3-5 passes and get in the end zone once in each of the
next two contests. He lacks the statistical upside of Powell,
but I think he is actually a safer play.
Verdict: I'd hate to be in a position where I had to depend on
Farrow giving me 10 points in PPR and he is almost certain to
lose at least a bit of work to Hillman for however long Gordon
is out, but the plus-matchups should keep him on the flex radar.
His ability to be useful to title-contending owners over these
next two weeks will depend heavily on whether Oakland (12 rushing
touchdowns allowed to running backs) and Cleveland (14) continue
to be as kind to opposing rushers as they have been for most of
the season and just how much Antonio Gates' pursuit of the touchdown
record for tight ends becomes a central focus for the offense.
Move over Marshall: Make no mistake, Robby
Anderson has become the No. 1 receiver for the Jets.
Make no mistake, Anderson has become the No. 1 receiver for the
Jets, and it just so happens Petty has enough arm strength to
take advantage of his speed. Like it or not (I don't), the undrafted
rookie free agent has certainly proven to be more than just a
deep threat since Petty's promotion, however, and this quarterback-receiver
connection isn't new: Petty and Anderson connected on a regular
basis during the preseason as well. The Temple product has actually
seen as many targets as T.Y. Hilton (23) over the last two weeks
since Petty became a starter two weeks ago, although Hilton has
a decided advantage in catches over that time (18-10). New York
is likely to be playing from behind a lot down the stretch, so
his opportunities are unlikely to dry up anytime soon. Finding
a receiver on the waiver wire who is a near-lock for 10 targets
- remember New York rarely throws to the tight end - at this time
of the year is highly unusual and it should be noted the Dolphins
(Week 15) haven't fared too well against deep threats for most
of the season. Many will suggest Bilal Powell is the waiver-wire
darling of the week, but I'm going to lean toward Anderson.
Verdict: Quite often, the second consideration for owners (after
winning, of course) when setting a lineup is being able to make
peace with their lineup choices in the event they lose. Anderson
has quickly become one of those players I am willing to make peace
with despite a very limited track record. The talent and the opportunity
are there, and Brandon Marshall figures to remain the central
focus for opponents in the passing game the rest of the way regardless
of his recent production. Amassing 23 targets in two weeks is
a big deal regardless of who the quarterback is or how much of
a big-play threat the receiver is. If Anderson is available and
there is a void in your lineup for a high-upside WR3/flex, I would
not hesitate starting him. Game script is almost certainly going
to work in favor of the Jets passing 40-plus times over the next
two weeks.
There's nothing safe about starting Ginn this late in the season.
Quite honestly, I hope you don't have to. But if you are in a
spot like I am in my two most important leagues - where my top
three or four receivers have either been rendered nearly obsolete
in fantasy due to injury or someone else passing them on the depth
chart - then meet your new dance partner for at least one week.
There is an inherent danger in trusting big-play receivers who
don't see a ton of targets and we saw again it last week with
Ginn, as he was targeted only four times in a game Carolina controlled.
That seems less likely over the next two weeks, however, as Washington
(Week 15) and Atlanta (Week 16) are next up on the schedule. Both
opponents will likely force the Panthers out of their run-heavy
shell and probably aren't going to make stopping Ginn a priority
near as much as keeping Greg Olsen and Kelvin Benjamin under wraps.
While that could be said about every team Carolina faces, Benjamin
will likely see plenty of old teammate Josh Norman this weekend.
Ginn's most likely foe? Bashaud Breeland, who is ranked 98th of
120 qualified cornerbacks, according to Pro Football Focus. Ginn
may not be the best play in Week 16 as second-year LCB Jalen Collins
has really played well since becoming a regular in Week 9.
Verdict: There's a lot of reason to believe in Ginn this week
at the very least, although next week is another story. Breeland
and slot CB Kendall Fuller (ranked 94th by PFF) will likely see
the most of Ginn, so the matchup is about as good as he'll see
the rest of the season. As you might imagine, Ginn will occasionally
work out of the slot.
Lost in the huge recent spike of production from Zach Ertz is
the re-emergence of another Eagles tight end. In Week 13, Burton
logged 53 offensive snaps and was targeted nine times. In Week
14, he played 37 offensive snaps and was targeted 10 on them.
He even served as the team's third-string long-snapper after second-stringer
Brent Celek went down. Essentially put into offensive hibernation
after showing what he was capable of on Monday night in Week 2
against Chicago (5-49-1), Burton has seen his two highest snap
counts in the last two weeks and the production has followed.
He is fourth (!!!!) among tight ends in targets over the last
three weeks despite barely playing in Week 12. Carson Wentz barely
underthrew him on what would have likely been a 43-yard score
last week or else he would probably be among those mentioned as
the top waiver pickup ahead of Week 15.
If his solid all-around play doesn't warrant it on its own, his
role is probably only going to grow over the final three games
of the season. In a lot of ways, it already has. He lined up virtually
everywhere a pass-catcher could line up last week (in the slot,
out wide, in-line, as a fullback, etc.). Ertz and Jordan Matthews
can only absorb so many targets and Philadelphia will probably
have little choice to throw against the Ravens and Giants over
the next two contests. Darren Sproles took a massive blow to the
head while attempting to field a punt against Washington and could
easily miss a game or two with a concussion. And let's not forget
the receiver situation in Philly is as bad as any in league even
with Matthews. Second-string tight ends are about as risky as
it gets during the fantasy playoffs, but feel free to remind me
again just how many quality players there are at the position
this season. (If you need further convincing, consider Burton
has outscored Greg Olsen and Martellus Bennett among others over
the last three weeks.)
Verdict: If there is someone from this piece I trust more going
forward than Robby Anderson, it is Burton. He's seeing significant
time in the slot, which takes him out of the discussion when it
comes to Baltimore's (mostly) shutdown tight end coverage. He
obviously has quite the rapport with Wentz as well, and Philadelphia
has no one at receiver to threaten his playing time. I'll stop
just short of calling him a top 10 play at the position this week,
but he could be the only means by which the Eagles can move the
ball. I'll go one step further and say it would not surprise me
at all if Burton saw more targets and more production this week
than Ertz.
In PPR scoring, Indianapolis Colts' tight ends trail only Washington's
as the most productive in fantasy. I mention this because while
Jordan Reed and Vernon Davis are owned in a number of leagues,
Dwayne Allen and Doyle are not. A few folks likely chased Allen
after his three-TD blowup on Monday Night Football in Week 13,
but he took a back seat to Doyle again last week and is the better
blocker, which actually means something for owners moving forward.
The Colts lost standout LG Jack Mewhort for the rest of the season
from an offensive line that couldn't afford it in Week 14, which
increases the possibility Allen will be staying in to block more
often. Furthermore, Donte Moncrief aggravated a hamstring injury
and appears unlikely to miss Week 15 at the very least. Further
consider the upcoming competition: Vikings top CB Xavier Rhodes
will likely shadow T.Y. Hilton when he lines up outside in Week
15 before the Colts face Oakland in Week 16. One would think Minnesota
isn't going to let Hilton - especially without Moncrief around
- be the reason it loses to Indianapolis. On the other hand, the
Raiders have yielded a number of productive PPR performances to
tight ends this season even though they haven't surrendered a
touchdown to the position since Week 8. Doyle is beloved by his
teammates in Indy and I've already laid out the reasons why he
is probably no worse than second in the passing-game pecking order.
Better yet, we've seen Doyle have a few blowup games this season,
so he's already shown he is capable. In the leagues where I need
a tight end, it will be a close call between Burton and Doyle.
Verdict: I don't blame you if you don't want to trust Doyle at
this point of the season, given how inconsistent his production
has been. However, with Moncrief out and the offensive line likely
to struggle, Andrew Luck is going to need as many short-range
options as possible. I would not discount the possibility of Doyle
finishing with about six or seven catches and a touchdown in either
one or both of the next two weeks.
Griffin got a mention here last week and, as luck would have
it, he has a shot at being front and center on the fantasy radar
this week after C.J. Fiedorowicz suffered an apparent concussion
in Week 14. Hitching your tight end wagon to a player on such
a dreadful passing offense in a difficult matchup (Jacksonville)
is not usually how owners survive and advance in the fantasy playoffs,
but bear with me on this one. The Jaguars have been stingy against
receivers for most of the season and Brock Osweiler has really
struggled to get them involved even in plus-matchups for most
of the season. They've also defended tight ends well, but that
has also been the position Osweiler has leaned on for about two
months. Since Houston is also not getting running backs involved
in the passing game, it means the Texans will either run all day
and/or force-feed the tight ends. To that end, Houston tight ends
combined for seven catches and two touchdowns on 10 targets in
the teams' first meeting back in Week 10. Remove Fiedorowicz from
the picture and there might be a situation worth taking advantage
of, at least for one week.
Verdict: Much will depend on whether Fiedorowicz is cleared to
play or not by Week 15. I expect another heavy dose of tight end
targets against the Jaguars despite their ability to defend the
position and believe Griffin has the best chance of all Houston
players to score this week. Assuming Fiedorowicz is back for Week
16, I'd be thrilled to play him versus the Bengals, who ranks
second in terms of giving up the most fantasy points to tight
ends. For fantasy purposes, Griffin is essentially interchangeable
with Fiedorowicz and would likely be a target monster in both
games should the latter need more than two weeks to return.
Let's be clear: Derby is a much better dynasty prospect than
likely fantasy playoff stud, so he's only for the truly desperate
over the next week or two. With that said, he's playing in an
offense that can't run the ball at all and would be well-served
to find a reliable third option in the passing game beyond Demaryius Thomas and Emmanuel Sanders. I'm not sure if five targets in a
game in which the quarterback threw 51 times (last week against
Tennessee) qualifies as developing into a third option or not,
but let's remember he's only been with the team since late October
since getting traded from the New England Patriots. The Broncos
told him shortly after acquiring him they wanted him to contribute
as soon as possible and we are starting to see that play out (snap
counts of 45, 40, 34 and 36 over the last four games). He's not
going to be an option in Week 16 against the Kansas City Chiefs,
who usually use safety Eric Berry in shadow coverage against tight
ends, but he makes for an intriguing play this week against his
former team. The Patriots would probably rather not let their
old teammate have a field day, but the priority will be stopping
Thomas and Sanders, so it would be far from surprising if Derby
enjoyed his best day as a pro.
Verdict: By no later than 2018, we could easily be talking about
Derby as a fixture inside the top 10 tight ends. How much sooner
it happens depends almost entirely on how quickly the Broncos
want to make him the unquestioned starter at the position. Until
then, I think it is reasonable to view him as a TE2 with low-end
TE1 upside in any game in which one or both Denver receivers could
get limited by superb defensive talent or due to game plan (such
as the one the Broncos will likely see from DC Matt Patricia and
HC Bill Belichick this week). It's safe to view Derby as being
the replacement for the team's nonexistent running game. My only
apprehension about using Derby this week is the projected increase
in snaps I expect this week go to Virgil Green instead. It is
only for that reason I rank Derby below Burton, Doyle and Griffin.
The Cardinals were supposed to be an offensive juggernaut again
this year. Instead, we are at a point of the season where Gresham
is actually a decent option. How did we get here? Carson Palmer
is a shell of himself. The vertical-based offense has turned into
David Johnson left and David Johnson right with a heavy dose of
David Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald in the short passing game.
John Brown has dealt with the effects of his sickle-cell trait
all season. Michael Floyd has been Michael Floyd all year and
was released this week after picking up his second DUI in five
years. Fourth receiver Jaron Brown was lost earlier in the season
with a torn ACL. Despite HC Bruce Arians' fondness for him, J.J. Nelson is probably never going to be able to be a full-time receiver
in the NFL. The offensive line has fallen apart. Did I get all
the reasons?
Back to Gresham. With all the aforementioned chaos in Arizona,
Arians is short on pass-catchers. Since Palmer unable to threaten
defenses deep anymore, considerably more opportunities within
five to 10 yards of the line of scrimmage have opened up. Gresham
has seen at least six targets in four of his last five outings
and is the TE11 in PPR over that same time period. The former
Bengal isn't an upside play by any means, but his steady Fiedorowicz-like
floor may be of interest to owners who would be thrilled to get
roughly 10 PPR points from their tight end.
Verdict: This is a floor play with very little upside in my opinion.
Despite their reputation as a bad defense, the Saints have been
much better since rookie DT Sheldon Rankins joined the lineup.
New Orleans has bottled up Eric Ebron and Cameron Brate over the
last two weeks and each boasts more fantasy upside than Gresham.
I don't think he's a much better bet in Seattle against the Seahawks
next week either.
Doug Orth has written for FF
Today since 2006 and been featured in USA Today’s Fantasy
Football Preview magazine since 2010. He hosted USA Today’s
hour-long, pre-kickoff fantasy football internet chat every Sunday
in 2012-13 and appears as a guest analyst on a number of national
sports radio shows, including Sirius XM’s “Fantasy Drive”.
Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.