One of the jobs of a good fantasy analyst is not telling readers
who to select in their drafts, but rather to provide them with as
much relevant information as possible to make sound decisions. After
all, they are YOUR fantasy teams.
Change is one of the few constants in this world and the NFL
(and fantasy football, by extension) is no different in that regard.
To that end, it is often helpful to see if we can identify when
and why a particular event took place in the previous season when
looking ahead to the next one. Unfortunately, false narratives
are often created and certain myths are embraced as fact by the
fantasy community for any number of reasons, including but not
limited to wanting the easy answer to be the right answer.
Over the next two weeks, I'll attempt to see if there is there
some level of truth to the narratives and maybe even debunk some
myths while I'm at it. This week, I am taking a closer look at
four situations in the AFC that require more examination since
they had a dramatic effect on how the season played out last year
and figure to interest fantasy owners again in 2020:
Did DeVante Parker and Mike Gesicki break out only because Preston
Williams got hurt? What happens now that Williams is expected
back for the start of the 2020 season?
Contrary to popular belief, Parker
was already doing all right for himself in a bad situation before
Williams
was lost for the season with a torn ACL in Week 9. It's not a
surprise that many folks feel the latter led to the former, however,
as Parker's explosion synched up very nicely with the departure
of Williams.
Parker's rise to prominence wasn't necessarily an "A then B"
occurrence. We can almost write off the first six weeks of 2019
because the quarterback play was awful - when Ryan
Fitzpatrick wasn't getting pulled for a bad performance, he
was on mop-up duty after Josh
Rosen struggled in one of his starts. Miami opened the season
against the Ravens, Patriots, Cowboys, Chargers, Redskins, Bills
and Steelers. Some of the league's best corners last year (Marlon
Humphrey, Stephon
Gilmore, Byron
Jones, Casey
Hayward, Quinton
Dunbar and Tre'Davious
White among them) were just some of the cornerbacks attached
to those defenses. Good luck finding consistency against that
group.
Bad early matchups. Below-average quarterback play likely due
in part to all the roster turnover and unfamiliarity with OC Chad
O'Shea's scheme. Bad offensive line. The offense execution was
so pathetic that production in garbage time wasn't even a given,
so volume was often a problem as well. Yet, Parker was able to
keep himself relevant thanks to good touchdown luck. Even as Fitzpatrick
began to settle in around Week 7, Parker and Williams were on
equal footing at worst (24 targets apiece from Weeks 7-9). If
anything, what we saw during this span was Parker's floor in a
1A/1B situation with Williams.
If Weeks 7-9 were Parker's floor with competent quarterback play,
then what took place over the remainder of the year was an example
of how everything came together at the same time. Aside from a
second matchup with the Bills, the Dolphins finished the fantasy
season against a remarkably forgiving run of pass defenses. More
offensive continuity led to more volume (35.4 pass attempts over
the first eight games of the season, 40.9 over the last eight).
It's not as if Williams' absence didn't have some impact on Parker's
usage, but the latter's target share only went up about five percent
in the second half of the season. Three more targets per game
is a significant amount, but not usually the kind of thing that
turns the WR37 in the first half of the season into the WR2 over
the second half - especially when the target share is still below
25 percent. Fitzpatrick's trust grew in Parker in contested-catch
situations and he rewarded his quarterback by coming through virtually
every week. Williams' return probably won't change that connection.
Gesicki
is a different story and would presumably be a player to fade
this year if we assumed 2020 was a mere extension of the second
half of last season. Over the first eight weeks of last year,
Gesicki attracted four or fewer targets four times. He dipped
below six once thereafter. O'Shea deserves some of the credit
for the second-year tight end's second-half surge, ramping up
his usage in the slot and creating a natural mismatch against
defenders trying to hang with a 6-6, 245-pound athletic freak.
However, even before that spike in snaps inside, he was well on
his way to leading all tight ends in slot snaps (he finished with
a league-high 374, 131 more than second-place Greg
Olsen).
It is worth noting Gesicki is one of only 48 tight ends in NFL
history to enjoy a 50-catch effort in either one or both of his
first two seasons. The expectation is he will serve as the primary
option inside for the Dolphins under new OC Chan Gailey. Well
before the rest of the league joined the party, Gailey was spreading
the field with regularity and using tight ends such as 6-7, 270-pound
Scott Chandler out of the slot. Chandler was a limited athlete
but yet quite useful in fantasy at times during his best years.
Gesicki is a spectacular athlete and essentially an oversized
slot going back to his days at Penn State. While there's always
the possibility Tua
Tagovailoa may not immediately have the same kind of connection
with his tight end that Fitzpatrick already does, the counterargument
to that is that the No. 5 overall pick may already be a better
quarterback. So long as Gesicki holds off the likes of Albert
Wilson and Allen
Hurns for primary slot duties, he has 100-target and 70-catch
upside.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today
since 2006 and been featured in USA Today's Fantasy Football Preview
magazine since 2010. He hosted USA Today's hour-long, pre-kickoff
fantasy football internet chat every Sunday in 2012-13 and appears
as a guest analyst on a number of national sports radio shows, including
Sirius XM's "Fantasy Drive". Doug is also a member of the Fantasy
Sports Writers Association.