| 1st Quarter |
| CLE FG | 22 yards by Billy Cundiff. 4:51 Time Remaining. (15 plays, 91 yards. Time of Drive: 6:03). |
| 2nd Quarter |
| No Scoring |
| 3rd Quarter |
| BUF TD | 3 yard pass from Kyle Orton to Chris Hogan. (Dan Carpenter extra point is good). 8:04 Time Remaining. (8 plays, 84 yards. Time of Drive: 4:09). |
| BUF TD | 18 yard fumble return by Jerry Hughes. (Dan Carpenter extra point is good). 7:54 Time Remaining. |
| 4th Quarter |
| BUF FG | 49 yards by Dan Carpenter. 13:41 Time Remaining. (6 plays, 17 yards. Time of Drive: 3:01). |
| BUF FG | 34 yards by Dan Carpenter. 12:01 Time Remaining. (4 plays, 5 yards. Time of Drive: 0:58). |
| CLE TD | 10 yard run by Johnny Manziel. (Billy Cundiff extra point is good). 8:47 Time Remaining. (8 plays, 80 yards. Time of Drive: 3:14). |
| BUF FG | 34 yards by Dan Carpenter. 3:32 Time Remaining. (10 plays, 64 yards. Time of Drive: 5:15). |
| BUF FG | 35 yards by Dan Carpenter. 0:27 Time Remaining. (4 plays, 6 yards. Time of Drive: 2:16). |
