We’ve spent the last week or so talking about Top 10 players
likely to disappoint this coming season. Now we turn our attention
to those who could theoretically replace them. I say “theoretically”
because (full disclosure) I haven’t been very good at this
little exercise the past two summers. After correctly identifying
six of nine Top 10 Risers in 2021, I’ve only hit on three
TOTAL since then for a dismal 16.6% success rate. Yuck! Staying
on top in the NFL is pretty difficult, but more difficult still
is predicting who will rise to the top. Nevertheless, my mama didn’t
raise no quitters, so…following are my best guesses for the
2024 season.
A quick reminder of the Top 10 fantasy WRs from last season…
Note: All rankings are based on FFToday’s
Non-PPR league scoring.
Ja’Marr
Chase, CIN: Chase was featured in
this space last August and for the exact same reason: I needed /
still need a Top 10 Riser W in the worst way and he’s the
chalk heading into 2024. Of course, the fact he’s featured
for the second consecutive summer means he didn’t get it done
last year, despite being a prohibitive favorite. He was really close,
though, and did have a pretty legit excuse, his quarterback missing
seven games to close out the season.
To be fair, Jake Browning did a passable job as Joe Burrow’s
replacement from Week 12 on, even connecting with Chase 11 of
12 times for 149 yards and a score in a narrow Thursday night
win over the Jags in Week 13. Alas, Chase’s Burrow v. Browning
splits over the whole season told a very different story. In 10
games with Joe Cool at the helm, Cincy’s WR1 scored 11.9
FPts/G (comfortable Top 10 territory). In seven games with Browning
taking snaps, that per-game average dropped almost in half (6.3).
Burrow is back with his new platinum blonde coiffure and the
Bengals have to be excited about having their full arsenal of
offensive weapons, old and new, available to start the 2024 campaign.
Or…will they? There are only two reasons Ja’Marr Chase
doesn’t do what I think he’ll do this season: 1) if
he or Burrow is injured again; or 2) if he truly does have the
gumption to force Cincinnati’s hand on a new contract by
sitting out regular season games. We see this movie every August
and it usually ends happily ever after, but this one is starting
to make me nervous. I’ve already drafted Chase this month,
so (gulp) here’s hoping the two sides can settle their differences
soon.
Drake
London, ATL: If Chase’s 2023
splits don’t make clear how vital good QB play is to a receiver’s
fantasy fortunes, consider the case of Drake London. The SC product
headed into last season with fairly high hopes after a solid if
not spectacular rookie performance (WR36) in 2022. It was reasonable
to expect better production and better TD production when the
Falcons added another threat (Bijan Robinson) to the offense but
no real competition for WR targets. Instead, London provided slightly
worse production (WR42) and exactly TWO touchdowns, a 50% dip
from the year prior. Yuck.
It’s not fair to blame the ATL QBs entirely, though Desmond
Ridder and Taylor Heinecke were quite bad. Arthur Smith’s
Stone Age offense was also largely to blame. Only Baltimore and
Chicago ran the football more in 2023. I’d run it a lot
too if I had the aforementioned Robinson in my backfield, but…see,
Smith felt the need to split the carries between his star rookie
and Tyler Allgeier almost evenly (roughly 54% / 46%), maddening
Falcons fans and fantasy GMs across the land. Who over-indexes
on the running game and then wastes all those carriers on a guy
who averages 3.7 per tote?
Smith and Ridder were shown the door this past off-season, and
replaced by Raheem Morris and Kirk Cousins, respectively. The
latter is a massive upgrade under center, which is what matters
most for London. Setting aside last year, when he was injured,
Cousins’ favorite targets in a six-year Minnesota tenure
never ranked lower than WR13 (Stefon Diggs in 2019). His favorite
target in Atlanta, though not in the same class as guys like Diggs,
Adam Thielen, and Justin Jefferson, should take a huge leap in
2024. London’s showing up on breakout candidate lists for
a reason, folks. Grab him.
Amari
Cooper, CLE: I was an arts and letters
guy, so I don't have the mathematical chops to determine if this
is scientifically true, but…is there a steadier option at
the WR position than Amari Cooper? Despite playing for three different
teams in nine seasons, the Bama product has never averaged fewer
than 6.8 targets per game or more than 8.53. He’s also dipped
below 8.0 FPts/G just once (barely, in 2017), but also never scored
more than 10.5 (2019). Those are some tight ranges for an almost
decade-old NFL player.
Coop’s also never missed more than two games in a season,
though that’s precisely how many he missed last year, costing
him a possible Top 10 finish. One of those misses was in Week
17, a week after he clinched fantasy championships for a lot of
you with a monster 38.5-point explosion against the Texans. He
was less effective in the playoff rematch just two weeks later
(5.9 points), but who cares about the playoffs, amiright? We care
about the fake football playoffs and that’s where you could
find yourself again this year if you’re willing to roll
the dice on a wideout who’s reached the productivity danger
zone (the 30-and-over club).
Cooper will have to adapt to catching balls from Deshaun Watson
again, granted. Watson missed 11 games in 2023 and is several
years removed from his stratospheric Houston days. Regardless,
and despite Joe Flacco’s improbable / insane backfill work,
Cooper averaged 10.36 FPts/G with Watson slinging the pigskin.
His full year average was 10.33. The man is simply impervious
to what’s going on around him, it seems, making him a good
bet to replicate that Steady Eddie act one more time this season.