Maximizing value is the most important factor in having a successful
draft. With that in mind, I present to you 10 players that I feel
are being over-drafted for various reasons and should be avoided
at their ADP, and possibly all together. While I may not necessarily
hate all the players I name, I hate where they are being taken,
and therefore would let other owners take the plunge. After six
seasons of doing this piece, 34 of the 50 players I named ended
up being considerably over-drafted. Here’s to increasing that
percentage in 2016.
Note: ADP based on 12 team standard scoring leagues
Draft smart: Everyone loves DeAndre Hopkins,
but you're overpaying for him in the middle of Round 1.
Hopkins is the highest ADP player on my list and I want to make
it clear that I don’t think he will be a bust by any means,
but in the middle of Round 1 you’re are overpaying. He was
an absolute beast last season and isn’t much of an injury
risk, plus he has extra motivation with a contract year coming
in 2017, so why do I believe he is being over-drafted?
Hopkins’ 192 targets from last season will be hard to repeat,
but several things have changed that make a repeat less likely.
First, the Texans should emphasize and have more success in the
run game, with newly signed Lamar
Miller taking over as a workhorse back. Miller’s arrival means
less pass attempts for the Texans overall. Second, the team drafted
Will
Fuller and Braxton
Miller this season and both have had their moments this preseason.
Sprinkle in the apparent development of Jaelen
Strong, and you have a more competent receiving corps around
Hopkins this season. Third, is the quarterback change to Brock
Osweiler, which might look good on paper, but he’s not exactly
a sure thing and the amount of chemistry he has with Hopkins remains
to be seen. Finally, the news is out on Hopkins. He will be a
marked man on the field. Overall, a drop-off of 40-plus targets
wouldn’t be shocking, making last seasons’ numbers almost impossible
to duplicate. While a solid season is certainly likely, I think
you will be disappointed if you take Hopkins inside the first
round. He’s a mid-2nd round pick, outside the top 8 receivers
on my cheatsheet.
Rawls (ankle) had a big season last year before getting hurt
and with the retirement of Marshawn Lynch, most people saw Rawls
as an easy top 15 fantasy back headed into the 2016. Problem is,
his ADP (RB14) represents his ceiling he and comes with considerable
risk/downside. The Seahawks drafted three running backs this off-season,
including C.J. Prosise in the third round, and with the apparent
resurrection of Christine Michael, the backfield suddenly looks
crowded. In a best-case scenario Rawls loses a handful of first
and second down touches to Michael and most, if not all the third
down work to a combo of Michael/Prosise.
While the Seahawks will still run quite a bit, they appear to
be trending into a Russell Wilson-led passing team, as the coaches
get more and more confident in their franchise quarterback and
emerging receiving corps. Throw in the fact that Rawls was slow
to recover from his ankle injury and that mid-third-round price
looks steep. With an upright, aggressive, punishing running style
Rawls does not shy away from contact, making him a perennial injury
risk. Overall, he is a moderately high-reward/high-risk player
that I wouldn't feel comfortable taking in the first four rounds.
After two injury prone and unproductive years Martin rebounded
last year to be a top 10 running back in all formats, racking
up the second most carries in the league and catching a respectable
33 passes. His current ADP (RB12) in standard leagues, isn’t
an extreme reach but it represents poor value. With a rookie quarterback
under center, the Bucs had little choice but to rely on the run
game, but all reports on Jameis Winston have been glowing this
off-season leading to an expectation of a more balanced offense
in 2016. Coming off a 300-touch season, and a new contract extension,
it is doubtful the Bucs will want to run Martin into the ground,
and the emergence of Charles Sims almost certainly means less
overall touches for Martin.
While I don’t mind Martin if you go WR in the first there rounds,
you're simply not going to get him in the fourth, and that’s fine
with me. I’d much prefer Amari
Cooper, Brandin
Cooks, T.Y Hilton, Sammy
Watkins, C.J.
Anderson, Latavius
Murray, and Carlos
Hyde, over Martin. Martin is a decent player and may have
a decent year, but simply put, you are overpaying based on last
year’s performance rather than looking forward to this year’s
probable outcome.
In the seven seasons Rodgers has played 15 or more games, 2015
was his worst, fantasy-wise. A lot was going against him, namely
the loss of his best receiver (Jordy Nelson), and sub-par protection
from the o-line. He was still a top 10 fantasy quarterback, but
he didn’t come close to the return on investment most owners
made when drafting him. This year most believe, including myself,
Rodgers will rebound, but there is still reason to pause, especially
given the late-third pick most people will have to spend.
The upside and high floor of Rodgers is very similar to Andrew
Luck, Russell
Wilson, and even Drew
Brees, yet he is being drafted a full round to two earlier.
I’m on board with the late-round QB approach personally but even
if you have your eyes set on a stud QB, why would you take one
in Round 3 when you can get basically the same player a round
or two later? The elite quarterbacks are five deep so I’m waiting
until the second or third QB is taken before I jump. You don’t
want to start the run, you want to end it. Do yourself a favor
this draft season and wait until the double-digit rounds for a
quarterback or at the very least wait until Newton, Rodgers, and
Luck are drafted before filling the position.
Murray has had a roller coaster career thus far, being labeled
injury prone his first two seasons before having a solid third
year, a monster fourth, and a very disappointing fifth. Now on
his third team in three years, Murray looks to be the main ball-carrier
in an offense that will attempt to stress the run. However, I
don’t think he will actually get the workload and produce enough
to be a top-15 back. On a team that might be playing from behind
a lot due to an awful defense, the Titans are going to run an
“exotic smashmouth” offense for about one quarter every game.
Add that to the fact that they just drafted Derrick
Henry in the second round, and have a QB that will run himself
a handful of times, and the potential for Murray to have a big
workload quickly diminishes.
With well over 1,100 career touches Murray may well be burnt
out already, and if last year is any indication, the quality of
the team around him may have to be higher in order for him to
produce. Murray seems to be the top choice of owners who avoid
the position in the first three rounds but the play I like is
passing on Murray and taking Henry four full rounds later, locking
up the higher upside of a player that could easily match or exceed
Murray’s production.
Fantasy owners should not be investing a fourth round pick on
Edelman, especially in standard leagues. His injury history is
extensive, playing in all 16 games just once in his seven-year
career, and he has already been nicked up this pre-season. We
know Edelman is Tom
Brady’s security blanket, but Brady will miss the first four
games and considering Edelman has missed reps with Jimmy
Garoppolo this off-season, the Patriots top wideout might
get off to a slow start. While Chris
Hogan and rookie Malcolm
Mitchell will mostly work on the outside, tight end Martellus
Bennett is sure to draw more looks over the middle in the
short and intermediate area where Edelman usually thrives. Finally,
Edelman simply cannot be counted on to produce touchdowns, as
he has averaged just three per season over the span of his career
and just five per season since he has been a full time starter.
Considering his lack of upside, his injury history, and increased
competition for targets, Edelman provides horrible value in Round
4. Jeremy Maclin, Golden Tate, Doug Baldwin, Michael Floyd, and
Donte Moncrief are all going after Edelman but each has more upside
and safety in standard leagues.
The Arian Foster saga, as it relates to fantasy football, has
amused me this off-season. Before Foster was signed, he was a
late-round dart throw and sometimes he wasn’t, even drafted
at all even though it was inevitable that he would sign somewhere.
As soon as Miami agreed to the deal, it was like the second coming
of Barry Sanders had arrived! Foster rocketed up the draft boards
and is now being drafted as an RB2. His signing doesn't erase
the fact that Foster is one of the most injury prone players of
the last decade. In his seven-year career Foster has played all
16 games just twice and hasn’t done so since 2012. Now at
age 30, coming off a torn Achilles and with over 1,300 career
touches, odds are Foster is not going to hold up for anything
near a full season. With Jay Ajayi waiting in the wings, a receiving
corps loaded with young talent, and an offense that looks like
it will revolve around the quick passing game, Foster has a few
strikes against him. His previous success and name recognition
is driving his value, but he is more of a late-round flier than
a RB2.
I couldn’t believe my eyes when I saw Gordon’s ADP.
Gordon is currently the first Browns player off the board, despite
being suspended the first four weeks of the season. Not to mention,
he’s one bad move away from being suspended long-term…
again. His fitness is in question, and he hasn’t played
a regular season game since 2014. Is this not crazy to anyone
but me? I get that Gordon had an incredible season in 2013 but
there have been plenty of one-year-wonders that have come and
gone in the NFL with less baggage and downside than Gordon. Much
like Foster, fantasy owners are enamored with Gordon’s past
success and name value, and not with the current reality. Looking
past his suspension, the Browns still have issues at quarterback
and they just drafted a talented receiver in the first round and
have a tight end coming off a career year. Add Duke Johnson to
the pass receiving mix, and you have a lot of hungry mouths to
feed in an offense that very few believe will be anything close
to explosive or dynamic. Gordon (like Foster) is a late-round
flier, not a top 75 pick and not a starting fantasy receiver.
Coming into the league with high expectations, Abdullah’s
rookie year was highlighted by more lows than highs, as he failed
to notch a single game with more than 94 total yards and ended
the year with almost as many fumbles (2) as touchdowns (3). While
Abdullah has a good amount of natural talent, he failed to show
much of it last season, constantly running into his blockers and
failed to turn in enough explosive plays. A natural progression
might be expected in year two but holding Abdullah back is the
offensive system. The Lions ranked second to last in rushing attempts
in 2015 and there is little reason to believe that philosophy
will change much this year.
If Abdullah was a three-down workhorse this might not affect
him, but the backfield is even more crowded than the receiving
options. Theo Riddick (80 receptions last year) returns as the
undisputed passing down back, while Zach Zenner will be the short
yardage/goal-line back. Factoring in the specialty roles and the
Lions pass-happy approach, I don’t see many scenarios where
Abdullah will get more than 10-12 total touches per game. You
might gamble on Abdullah a few times in daily leagues to make
the most of his explosiveness, but in standard leagues there will
be too much inconsistency to make him anything more than bench
fodder.
Parker came into the league as a much hyped prospect with a size-speed
combo that has turned many receivers into fantasy gold. After
suffering a pre-season foot injury Parker only played half the
season, and while he showed flashes of being a solid receiver,
he didn’t exactly jump out as a future stud. This season,
the Dolphins passing game is a bit of a mystery, with a brand
new coach/coordinator (Adam Gase) and some new faces on offense
in general. While some have crowned Parker the automatic No.1
receiver that is far from a certainty and it’s more likely
he will end up third in targets and fantasy production.
First, although the Dolphins will have the volume to produce
multiple fantasy-relevant players, they have not exactly been
efficient or explosive in the Ryan Tannehill era. Tannehill has
some natural talent but the lack of a quality deep ball does not
bode well for Parker’s strengths. Second, Jarvis Landry,
save for an injury, is going to lead this team in targets, there
is no doubt about that. Landry has over 200 total touches in just
two seasons and he fits what Tannehill loves to do perfectly -
throw short/intermediate routes. Behind Landry the Dolphins also
boast Kenny Stills, who has had an excellent pre-season and is
capable of being a big play threat himself.
While Parker remains an intriguing dynasty prospect, the receiving
corps is too muddled, the offense too average, and intangibles
(injury/chemistry/growth) are too unknown to invest anything more
than a late-round pick on him, which of course won’t happen
given his current ADP. I’d much prefer to take a chance
with Marvin Jones, Sterling Shepard, and RB Derrick Henry (to
name a few), so do yourself a favor and pass on Parker this season.