Fantasy Football Today - fantasy football rankings, cheatsheets, and information
A Fantasy Football Community!




 Log In  | Sign Up  |  Contact      






Favorites & Fades


Divisional Round

By: Nick Caron | HC Green | John Fessel | Michael O'Hara
Updated: 1/17/25

Saturday:

HOU @ KC | WAS @ DET


Sunday:

LAR @ PHI | BAL @ BUF


Notes:
- Green highlight indicates plus matchup (top eight)
- Red highlight indicates negative matchup (bottom eight)
- Lines and totals updated Sunday morning

Texans @ Chiefs - (O'Hara)
Line: KC -8.0
Total: 41.8

KC FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.18
KC FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.32
KC FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.25
KC FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.4

No Brainers: WR Nico Collins

Favorites: N/A

On the Fence: WR John Metchie, TE Dalton Schultz, RB Joe Mixon

Following the injury to Tank Dell, the Texans have used a heavy rotation of wide receivers behind Nico Collins. But if anyone is being treated as the WR2 in this offense, it’s John Metchie.

Metchie has consistently run more routes than Xavier Hutchinson and Robert Woods following the injury to Dell. Last week, he showed that target volume can come alongside those routes, drawing eight targets while cracking a 24-percent target share for the first time this season. Given his proven ability to function as the No. 2 pass catcher in Houston, Metchie can be a punt option this week.

Alongside Metchie, it’s been Dalton Schultz who’s seen an increased offensive role in recent weeks. He’s eclipsed a 15-percent target share in three of his last five games. While six targets per game aren’t much in the grand scheme of things, it’s more than viable given the wasteland that is the tight end position in the Divisional Round. Schultz will provide somewhat of a floor thanks to his half-dozen targets, but he is very much reliant on a touchdown to make a significant impact in lineups.

It’s been a tale of two seasons for Joe Mixon. Early in the year, Mixon was eclipsing 100 rushing yards and 20 fantasy points with ease every week. In the last six weeks, it’s been a far tougher task for Mixon to produce RB1 numbers; he’s cleared 11.0 PPR points just twice since Week 12.

Mixon’s intrigue is primarily driven by the fact that he is still the overwhelming 1A in this backfield. In the Wild Card, Mixon played 70 percent of snaps and saw 27 of the 30 backfield opportunities. Unfortunately, this week presents a matchup where Mixon might not be particularly effective with his touches. The Chiefs’ defense ranks top 10 in total rushing defense, yards allowed per carry, and fantasy points allowed to running backs. It wouldn’t be shocking if Chris Jones and company have Mixon boxed like a fish this weekend.

Fade: QB C.J. Stroud

Not much has to be said about C.J. Stroud. He hasn’t scored more than 20 fantasy points in a game since Week 4 against the Jaguars, the league’s worst secondary. Stroud also does not have a game with 250-plus passing yards and multiple passing touchdowns since that Week 4 contest. The Chiefs are a middle-of-the-road matchup for quarterbacks, but it’s not enough to lift Stroud into fantasy relevancy.

HOU FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.10
HOU FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.27
HOU FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.10
HOU FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.19

No Brainers: TE Travis Kelce

Favorites: QB Patrick Mahomes, WR Xavier Worthy

Heading into the Divisional Round, it’s incredibly difficult to evaluate the Kansas City offense. The starters haven’t played since Week 17, on top of the fact that multiple injured players (Isaiah Pacheco and Hollywood Brown) were starting to be incorporated down the stretch.

In the midst of all of this uncertainty, there have been two consistent pieces of this offense in recent weeks. Quarterback Patrick Mahomes has been wheeling and dealing, scoring at least 23.7 fantasy points in each of his last two starts. It’s also helped that the Chiefs have been incredibly pass-heavy in these games with a 9.8-percent pass rate over expectation. A talented Houston secondary could give him some trouble, but it’s hard to bet against a well-rested Mahomes with a healthy weapons arsenal in the playoffs.

Kansas City has used a nasty rotation among its receivers, but Xavier Worthy has been able to rise to the top. He’s ran at least 75 percent of the routes in each of his last four games, drawing nine-plus targets in three of those contests. The consistent volume is what’s so encouraging with Worthy. He’s seeing a variety of looks, not just downfield bombs and designed targets. With the most consistent role of any receiver in this offense, Worthy is the guy to lean on in a murky group of pass catchers.

On the Fence: RB Isiah Pacheco, WR Marquise Brown

As Pacheco has returned from a broken fibula, it’s been a split backfield between him and Kareem Hunt. Neither back has played more than 50 percent of snaps since Pacheco’s return. However, the narrative has been that Pacheco will be truly fired up once the playoffs arrive. While it’s intriguing to play Pacheco in hopes of him receiving a larger workload, there’s no evidence that he’ll be in an expanded role. In fact, Andy Reid said that he plans to deploy both backs in a similar fashion to what we saw late in the regular season. This makes Pacheco an incredibly risky play this week, but there is plenty of upside in hopes that Reid was simply trying to hide his true intentions.

Hollywood Brown is another player who’s been ramping up down the stretch after returning from injury. In his first game back (Week 16), Brown ran a route on 33 percent of dropbacks. That number jumped to 51 percent in Week 17. He’s also been incredibly effective at drawing targets on these routes. His 0.43 targets per route run is an elite mark. The only question is whether his route share will be expanded upon in the Divisional Round. If it continues to sit around 50 percent, he could easily put up a dud against the Texans.

Fade: WR DeAndre Hopkins

At this point, there is no hope that DeAndre Hopkins will assume an expanded role in the Kansas City offense. His route participation has consistently hovered between 45 and 65 percent, never getting higher than 64.3 percent. With Hollywood Brown returning and playing well, the path to more routes is even murkier. At this point, you’re simply relying on a touchdown and an explosive play or two. There are likely better options out there this week.

Prediction: Chiefs 27, Texans 20 ^ Top

Commanders @ Lions - (Caron)
Line: DET -9.5
Total: 55.5

DET FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.6
DET FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.29
DET FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.2
DET FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.31

No Brainers: QB Jayden Daniels

Favorites: WR Terry McLaurin

A 10-target game in the Wild Card round has fantasy managers feeling confident about Terry McLaurin heading into this weekend’s big matchup against the Lions. McLaurin has now finished with at least 17 points in six of his past seven games, further solidifying himself as one of the league’s top weapons this season. He’s clearly Jayden Daniels’ favorite player to target and with the Lions being over a full touchdown favorite, there’s plenty of reason to believe that the Commanders will have to rely more heavily on their passing game than they normally do. Assuming that’s the case, McLaurin makes for an even stronger play as he goes up against a Detroit defense that conceded the second-most fantasy points to opposing wide receivers in the league during the regular season.

On the Fence: TE Zach Ertz

Zach Ertz had a bit of a down week in the Wild Card round as he was held to just two receptions for 23 yards on just four total targets. Those numbers aren’t very inspiring, especially considering that Ertz will be up against a Detroit defense that was quietly elite against opposing tight ends this season, having conceded just three touchdowns to the position on the entire year with only one opposing TE (George Kittle) reaching even 70 yards against them in a single game. Ertz could probably be considered a “Fade” given the matchup and his touchdown-or-bust track record, but the position as a whole is pretty weak heading into the Divisional Round so Ertz could be ranked as high as the TE4 for the week.

Fade: RB Brian Robinson Jr.

Washington’s Brian Robinson started the regular season off extremely hot, but things really trailed off for him down the stretch as he finished with single-digit PPR fantasy points in each of his final three regular season games. That unfortunate stretch continued into the first round of the playoffs, as well, as he carried the ball 10 times for just 16 yards in Washington’s close victory over Tampa Bay. While Robinson did catch a few passes to make up a bit for an otherwise horrendous day on the ground, the concern now has to be that Austin Ekeler is now back in the lineup and there’s a real possibility that this just becomes a 50/50 split backfield. With Ekeler being the more likely player to be utilized in the passing game and a tough matchup on the ground against a Detroit defense that was excellent against the run during the regular season, this is just not a situation that is conducive for fantasy points. Robinson is a player to avoid this week.

WAS FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.28
WAS FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.13
WAS FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.22
WAS FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.20

No Brainers: RB Jahmyr Gibbs

Favorites: WR Amon-Ra St. Brown

The NFC’s top seed will be in action this week as the Lions host the Commanders, and Detroit will be looking to build off of their impressive mugging of the Vikings in Week 18 that allowed them to secure a first-round bye in the playoffs. Wide receiver Amon-Ra St. Brown is always a big part of this offense and that should continue here against Washington - a team that has done a fairly good job against opposing wide receivers overall this season, but who has been exploited by those teams’ WR1 throughout the season. St. Brown is a good bet to see 10 or more targets in this one and he’s practically a lock to deliver double-digit PPR fantasy points along with having one of the higher ceiling potentials of any player.

On the Fence: TE Sam LaPorta

Lions tight end Sam LaPorta failed to deliver on his pre-season fantasy ADP, but that doesn’t mean that fantasy managers should be avoiding him for this playoff run. In fact, LaPorta was consistently good down the stretch during the regular season, delivering six straight double-digit PPR fantasy days to over the final six games, and he scored four touchdowns during that stretch. The cynic might say that LaPorts only saw 10 targets once during that stretch and he’s clearly behind Amon-Ra St. Brown in the target pecking order, but he’s still seeing enough volume to probably be the TE3 or potentially even the TE2 this week. He could reasonably be considered a “Favorite,” but I’ve put him in the “On the Fence” range just because the Commanders defense has been quite overall good this season and only two teams allowed fewer receptions to tight ends during the regular season than Washington did.

Fade: QB Jared Goff

With his two top targets mentioned above as players who are likely must-starts for fantasy managers, it stands to reason that Jared Goff is probably a good bet to deliver solid fantasy numbers this week. If that’s all you’re looking for, then great - go ahead and roll with the Lions quarterback this week. But the unfortunate reality for those starting Goff is that four of the top five quarterbacks in rushing yardage during the regular season will be starting this weekend. While Goff has shown that he has the ability to deliver touchdowns through the air at a rate that can put him in the conversations with these more mobile QBs, he simply does not have the mobility to compete with them on the ground.

If he’s going to finish as a top-four QB this week, Goff is likely going to need to throw at least three touchdown passes. Again, he’s capable of doing this, but it’s also worth considering that he’ll be up against a Washington defense that conceded the fourth-fewest fantasy points to opposing quarterbacks during the regular season. Only three times did they concede three or more passing touchdowns to an opposing quarterback and no one got there against them after Week 10.

Prediction: Lions 30, Commanders 24 ^ Top

Rams @ Eagles - (Fessel)
Line: PHI -6.5
Total: 43.5

PHI FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.30
PHI FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.31
PHI FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.24
PHI FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.28

No Brainers: RB Kyren Williams, WR Puka Nacua

Favorites: N/A

On the Fence: N/A

Fade: QB Matthew Stafford, WR Cooper Kupp, TE Tyler Higbee

Quarterback Matthew Stafford had a pair of touchdown passes and no turnovers in an upset victory over the Vikings in the Wild Card round. Still, Stafford only managed a modest 16.3 fantasy points in the contest. The continued, near complete silence of Cooper Kupp has capped Stafford’s ceiling, which is already limited by a lack of rushing upside. Against an Eagles defense that has returned to 2022 form over the latter half of this season, Stafford can’t be counted on for more than low end QB2 production.

Kupp broke his silence on a gorgeous, Kupp-esque 34-yard reception against the Vikings, but it was his sole catch and target against the league’s most wide receiver-friendly defense. With just 10 total targets over the last four games, and no more than 3 in any of those matchups, it’s become way too risky to look to Kupp to re-emerge in this offense, even as a Flex. The Vikings game was a golden opportunity, especially after being well rested, but the involvement simply was not there.

While Kupp was quiet, teammate Tyler Higbee got off to a good start against the Vikings, before exiting with a chest injury that required a trip to the hospital. Thankfully, by all indications, Higbee appears fine and should be active this Sunday against the Eagles.

Unfortunately, Higbee draws a tougher defense in the Eagles. They finished the 3rd best defense against tight ends, led in no small part by linebackers Zack Baun and Nakobe Dean – who combined to allow no touchdowns in coverage this season, while surrendering under 6 yards per target, per pro-football-reference.com. There are a fair number of solid options at the tight end position this week, and it’s arguably worth turning their way instead of Higbee’s.

LAR FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.11
LAR FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.19
LAR FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.12
LAR FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.7

No Brainers: RB Saquon Barkley

Favorites: QB Jalen Hurts, WR A.J. Brown, WR DeVonta Smith

Since the Eagles Week 5 bye, Jalen Hurts has produced four different 30-point performances. It’s no coincidence that this coincides with when the Eagles defense really started clicking, amplifying the quality starting field position for the offense (6th overall for the season).

Hurts, particularly with this offensive unit, is built to be a finisher, both with his legs and arm. Even in relatively modest passing performances, he’s tended to sure up his floor and often even find a good bit of ceiling by collecting touchdowns. He’s scored more than 14.9 in every game outside of the injury-marred matchup against Washington.

Hurts carries his high floor and ceiling into yet another matchup where the Eagles are sizable favorites. For those looking to go left when everyone else is going right with Josh Allen or Lamar Jackson, Hurts is your guy.

Now, when talking about A.J. Brown, I’m probably supposed to make some joke about him reading books on the sideline, but honestly, it’s quite refreshing to see a go-to receiver being so calm while having a quiet day on the stat sheet.

Sure, Brown buyers won’t have that “squeaky wheel” effect to bank on, but a player like Brown can stand purely on his own talents, especially in an offense that makes big plays and red zone activity the norm. There are only four elite fantasy wide receivers left in the postseason, and A.J is one of them.

Teammate and fellow wide receiver DeVonta Smith might get a chance to flex elite production in another offense, but he’s been a stellar as the Eagles WR2. While Smith saw just 4 targets in the Wild Card round, he was extremely efficient on those targets, reeling in all of them for 55 total yards.

Efficiency is a career staple for Smith, averaging 9.1 yards per target and enjoying a 70% catch rate since entering the league in 2021. He has enjoyed a 6.1% touchdown rate, as well. The post season and tougher competition has done little to slow him down, producing 76.7 Yds/G in six playoff games. Smith, this season’s WR17 in FPts/G (w/ at least multiple starts), is a good WR2 value against L.A.

On the Fence: TE Dallas Goedert

Tight end Dallas Goedert’s triple stiff arm score against Green Bay is a reminder of just how physically gifted and capable of big plays he is. In another offense, not buried behind two stellar receivers, as well as both a quarterback and running back who can run it in with ease anywhere near the goal line, he would likely be a top 5 fantasy tight end.

But this is the universe in which we’re playing fantasy football, and it’s one where Goedert is no more than a 3rd option, and arguably just a 5th option down in the red zone. 3 touchdowns in his last seven games is encouraging, but with a career high of 5 and so much competition for scores, there are several regularly productive tight ends than Goedert remaining. His talent and the matchup with a tight end-friendly Rams defense does keep him in the mix as a mid-tier value starter.

Fade: WR Jahan Dotson

Dotson followed up an 7-94-0 outing in Week 18 with his first Eagles touchdown last week. It was only a couple of years ago where it looked like Dotson might be a major factor in the red zone throughout his career. To this point, that has not panned out. Last week was a bit encouraging, but he still only had 2 targets, and the 11 targets the previous week came while the starters were sitting. He’s buried in this offense and is likely to remain quiet barring injuries to key teammates.

Prediction: Eagles 27, Rams 17 ^ Top

Ravens @ Bills - (Green)
Line: BAL -1.0
Total: 51.5

BUF FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.14
BUF FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.5
BUF FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.14
BUF FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.18

No Brainers: QB Lamar Jackson, RB Derrick Henry

Favorites: TE Mark Andrews

Andrews closed the regular season with touchdowns in each of his last six games and 11 overall, tied for fourth in the NFL. So, why isn’t he a no-brainer? Go back to the previous meeting between these two teams in Week 4 when the talented tight end went without a catch on just one target. He was quiet in the Wild Card round as well, catching two passes for 37 yards. The common thread is both the earlier matchup with Buffalo and last week’s tilt is that Baltimore leaned heavily on the running game -- they had 50 runs and 21 passing attempts against the Steelers, and 34 runs to 19 passes versus the Bills. That’s about as run centric as offenses get in the modern NFL. No doubt, the Ravens would love to replicate that game plan this Sunday as possessing the ball keeps Josh Allen on the sidelines. Despite that, with Zay Flowers (knee) expected to be inactive this week, Andrews should have opportunities to impact the game. He’s a solid TE1 choice, just not a slam dunk.

On the Fence: RB Justice Hill

Even with the Ravens running the ball 50 times last weekend, Hill logged just six carries for 15 yards. He added four receptions for 13 yards along with a touchdown to provide some fringe value. Hill was similarly uninvolved in the ground game against the Bills back in Week 4, turning four carries into 18 yards. He basically was the passing attack, however, easily leading the team in receptions (6) and yards (a season-high 78), and a touchdown. Hill is a safe option for Jackson, and he’s already proven he can have success versus Buffalo. As a flex play, Hill holds some intriguing potential.

Fade: WR Rashod Bateman

While Bateman had just two receptions and 24 yards in Baltimore’s Wild Card triumph over the Steelers, he scored a touchdown -- it was the fifth time in the last seven games that he’s found the end zone. He should once again serve as WR1 this week with Flowers still recovering from a knee injury. Despite that, his upside seems limited. The Ravens used a lot of two-tight end sets against the Steelers, and that could be the path forward in Buffalo as well. In the first meeting, Baltimore’s receivers combined for just four receptions and 43 yards. Unless the Bills push out and force the Ravens to play catch up, expect Andrews, Hill, and Isaiah Likely to be Jackson’s primary targets. That would keep Bateman’s ceiling low.

BAL FPts Allowed vs. QBs: No.8
BAL FPts Allowed vs. RBs: No.26
BAL FPts Allowed vs. WRs: No.3
BAL FPts Allowed vs. TEs: No.14

No Brainers: QB Josh Allen, RB James Cook

Favorites: WR Khalil Shakir

It took a little while for the Bills to get going against the Broncos, but once they did it turned into a rout. It was a balanced attack (272 yards passing, 210 yards rushing), and although Curtis Samuel (3-68-1) led the way in receiving, Shakir was the top target -- he was thrown to a half-dozen times, twice as many as anyone else, catching all six for 61 yards. The third-year pro has grown into Allen’s most trusted option, and he led the team when Buffalo was toppled by the Ravens in Week 4 with four receptions for 62 yards. While Baltimore has improved their pass defense after a horrendous start, it’s still the best way to attack them as they boast the NFL’s top-ranked run defense (they gave up just 29 rushing yards to the Steelers last Saturday). Plug Shakir in as a WR3.

On the Fence: TE Dalton Kincaid

Pegged by some to be a breakout star in his second season, Kincaid took a step back statistically, going from a 73-673-2 line as a rookie to a 44-448-2 this year. Injuries bore some of the blame, but it was disappointing, nonetheless. He played well back in a September showdown with Baltimore, racking up five catches and 47 yards, which was a number he’d top just three times in 2024. He matched that output against Denver last Sunday, posting a 3-47-0 line. Given his middling production, Kincaid is a bit of a risk, but he has the talent to produce, and he’s a potential matchup issue for the Ravens. With the expectation that the Bills will need to lean on Allen’s right arm to advance, Kincaid carries some real upside.

Fade: WR Amari Cooper

Acquired during the season to stabilize an inexperienced receiver corps, Cooper has mostly been a disappointment, at least in terms of numbers. In nine games with Buffalo, the veteran finished with fewer than 20 yards five times. That includes an anemic 2-8-0 performance against Denver last Sunday. While he does have some familiarity with the Ravens from his years in Cleveland (he averaged 3.5 catches and 57 yards per game against them in 2023), his lack of reliable involvement makes him a bad bet for the Divisional Round matchup.

Prediction: Ravens 31, Bills 27 ^ Top