The preseason isn’t going to change the way you envision value
in the first 3-5 rounds of a redraft league. With many top players
sitting preseason out this year, it’s a truer adage than ever.
That said, what we are learning in August affects targets later
in your draft and how the value of players is shifting beyond
those first few rounds. Don’t think much can be gleaned
from what took place over the weekend in what is now a three-game
preseason? Think again. Here’s what we observed...
1. The Second Act for Zach Wilson Was Better Than the
First
The Packers didn’t play many of their defensive regulars, so this
isn’t about Zach
Wilson being able to dissect a truly elite NFL defense. That
isn’t likely to come anytime soon. What was apparent this past
weekend is that Wilson can make throws and exhibit poise both
in and out of the pocket. Fantasy managers have viewed Jets’ players
as essentially irrelevant for a number of years and I don’t think
that mindset is being challenged. But, it is being challenged…
by me at least. The most significant loss due to injury this preseason
for any NFL team happened with New York last week when DE Carl
Lawson ruptured his Achilles meaning he is lost for the season.
Lawson’s absence will make the Jets defense more vulnerable despite
having a coach that actually knows something about that side of
the ball. My point? Wilson looked on Saturday like a guy who can
grow into the position and even make some tough throws. The Jets’
inability to stop opponents is going to force him to have to try
to win games from behind…probably every week. The good news for
Wilson and for the Jets is that they may have finally found a
true WR1…
2. …And Corey Davis Looks Like He’s Being Undervalued
It’s called the power of perception. A WR like Michael
Gallup in Dallas is being drafted by and large ahead of Corey
Davis in spite of the former being the third option in his
team’s passing attack while the latter is the team’s projected
primary target. We target players in fantasy football who come
from teams that score points… and win games - things the Jets
haven’t done for quite some time. But, anybody who watched Davis
play on Saturday can see that not being taken until after Dallas’
WR3 would be pure folly. Wilson was dependent on Davis. He looked
for him on underneath routes. He looked for him down the field.
4 catches and 70 yards later, Davis took the last three quarters
off, but not until he looked the part of what we call in fantasy
football a target monster. People seem to have forgotten Davis
was a top-5 overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft and he helped carry
the Titans last season when A.J.
Brown got off to a slow start. Draft Davis over Gallup. In
fact, draft him over 10-15 guys that are currently ahead of him
in current “expert rankings”. Barring a significant injury, you’ll
be thanking us for the tip as early as late September.
3. Ja’Marr May Have a Ways to Go… and Other
Bengal Concerns
Most football fans realize that Ja’Marr
Chase opted out of his 2020 college football season with LSU.
That reality didn’t scare off many teams in late April when it
was draft time. The Bengals hoped that the chemistry between Joe
Burrow and Chase enjoyed in 2019 would carry over to NFL stardom
sooner than later. Reports out of Cincinnati, however, had been
suggesting that Chase’s return to action wasn’t going as smoothly
as likely he and his team had hoped. That rumor appeared to grow
some legs after this weekend with Chase dropping not one, not
two, but all three balls thrown his way in preseason action vs.
Washington. The light may come on for Chase all at once, but until
it does, look for a steady dose of Tyler
Boyd and Tee
Higgins to begin the season. As for Chase’s partner in “chemistry”,
Burrow hasn’t played in the preseason yet as he continues his
recovery from a season-ending injury in 2020. Reports have suggested
that he is uncomfortable in camp during live action. Maybe that
will work itself out, but for now, don’t overpay for Chase (consider
him just outside the top 30 WRs in a redraft) and look to Burrow
as a high-upside backup, not a starter you can count on just yet.
4. The Patriots Offense Continues to Look Sharp
I know, I know…New England played the Eagles on Thursday night
and the Eagles resemble a rudder-less ship right now, but that
doesn’t change what I saw watching the game. Cam
Newton and Mac
Jones combined to complete 75% of their passes to 12 different
receivers. I saw the running backs come together to run for 210
total yards with rookie Rhamondre
Stevenson backing up his solid debut with another decisive
collection of carries that included 60+ yards and 2 TDs. And,
I saw Jakobi
Meyers consistently get separation from defenders such that
he averaged nearly 20 yards a catch and scored a TD. All in all,
the Patriots appear to be on the same page this year, which is
a far cry from what much of 2020 looked like. The talent of Stevenson
is making Damien
Harris a riskier pick, but an injury to N’Keal Harry vs. Philly
has Meyers looking like a good candidate for a top-25 WR who was
only lightly heralded prior to the start of the preseason. This
team is re-forming their offensive identity and while it’s hard
to predict individual successes, team success is looking like
a certainty.
5. Pat Freiermuth Looks Like a Red-Zone Stud
On Saturday evening, Eric
Ebron dropped the first pass thrown to him, blinked and then
witnessed rookie TE Pat
Freiermuth haul in two touchdown catches on plays he looked
born to make. People say all the time that preseason doesn’t matter
and yes, you can overvalue some things that happen, but make no
mistake about this: Ben
Roethlisberger took note of those two plays and his trust
this morning in Friermuth is different than it was this time last
week. Friermuth is a confident player and with Vance
McDonald now retired, the TE job in Pittsburgh was ripe for
the taking with only the productive, but also inconsistent Ebron
holding down the fort. Has Friermuth already surpassed Ebron in
fantasy value based on what we saw on Saturday? The answer is:
Yes. Yes, he has. Tight end is a very difficult position for a
rookie to learn and I don’t think Friermuth is going to be a yardage
monster right off the bat. But, 7-9 TDs this season seems about
right and that alone makes him worthy of a TE2 role on your fantasy
team.
6. Justin Fields Produces Both Good and Bad
It’s amazing how different a player can look when they play against
a team that actually has an effective defensive scheme. Enter
Justin Fields,
Week 2, and this time around, Fields looked more like a rookie,
completing less than 50% of his passes while clearly feeling the
heat from a Buffalo defense that is designed to make quarterbacks
feel uncomfortable. All that said, there was some good news coming
out of the game. In limited game action, Fields ran for 46 yards
on 4 carries, demonstrating that his propensity to get you points
on the ground in Week 1 of the preseason was no fluke. The QBs
that have really separated themselves, value-wise, in recent seasons
all have that additional component to their games. When Fields
starts his first game this season (and it’s a when, not an if),
he should immediately be seen as a borderline QB1. That still
leaves him in the QB 14-18 range in redrafts for now, but he’s
becoming a popular QB2 pick and justifiably so. But, expect some
rough outings against better defenses as he makes the jump to
NFL starter.
7. 13 Snaps Ain’t Much to Go On, But it’s a Big Deal just
the Same
In the preseason, sometimes the bigger story is not how well
someone played in game action, but whether or not they played
at all. Teams don’t put players into game action during
the preseason unless they’ve grown comfortable with their
health status and as such, those mere appearances are significant.
The reference here is to Amari Cooper who played this weekend
for Dallas and even touched the ball once on a reverse. One of
the most fascinating debates of the summer has been who to draft
first - Cooper or teammate CeeDee Lamb. It’s a difficult
decision, but at least it’s now a decision you can make
without Cooper’s health being a primary factor in the decision.
It comes down to which guy you think will be more productive.
Next up for the Cowboys is getting Dak Prescott back on the field,
which is another story for another day.
8. Bridgewater Strikes Back…But Jerry Jeudy Strikes Best
It is fascinating how some teams basically sit their regular season
starters for the duration of the preseason and some really let
them play. One factor that seems to be legit is that when a QB
battle is taking place, everybody plays…at least a good chunk
of the first half. In Denver’s case, we’ve seen them execute actual
regular season plays in order to get a good look at both Drew
Lock and Teddy
Bridgewater. Lock appears to have the upper hand, but Teddy
was very solid this weekend, completing 9-of-11 passes for 105
yards and a TD. The fact that both QBs have played well this summer
bodes well for Denver, but it bodes best for a potential break-out
of WR Jerry Jeudy
in his sophomore season. Reports out of camp for the past three
weeks have noted that Jeudy has been nearly impossible to cover
and he has now averaged nearly 25 yards per catch in the first
two preseason games. Quarterback play indeed seems to be the only
thing standing between him and a serious uptick in production…and
for now, QB play continues to be good.
9. Seeds of Doubt are Shrinking in Miami
Much like the Broncos, the Dolphins are employing more comprehensive
plays this preseason and involving all healthy participants who
are going to be in the starting lineup Week 1. The reason Miami
has taken this approach is simple: They are still trying to learn
what they have in Tua Tagovailoa given this is more like his rookie
season than his second. Miami was concerned last season that Tua
was not throwing downfield enough, but may be learning that’s
not really who he’s designed to be. He peppered the Falcons’
defense on Saturday with short, accurate throws to underneath
receivers and running backs and engineered multiple touchdown
drives in the process. There is still quite a bit of evidence
suggesting that Tua’s fantasy value is capped by his style
of play such that he’s nothing more than a solid QB2 this
season. That said, the Dolphins have looked crisp in the preseason
on the offensive side of the ball and should only get better as
they get their field-stretching WRs back. One disclaimer: Saturday’s
output did come at the expense of the one of the league’s
most porous defenses in Atlanta. After all, Jacoby Brissett followed
Tua and was 9 for 9 with a TD throw.
10. The 49ers Seem to Be Liking Lance-A Lot
Whereas Matt Nagy has stated from day one that Chicago will be
trotting out Andy Dalton at QB on September 12th, Kyle Shanahan
appears to be making no such promises after another solid outing
on Sunday night from rookie, Trey Lance. Conventional wisdom is
that Garoppolo gives the team the best chance to win right off
the bat, but it’s hard to overlook what Lance brings to
the table skill-wise. One thing is for sure: Lance is worth drafting
not only in dynasty formats (obviously), but redrafts as well.
Much like Fields, when he is allowed to start a full game, he
represents borderline QB1 value and simply makes for a better
late-round draft pick than say, Daniel Jones or Derek Carr at
this point in time. It will be interesting to see how this ultimately
plays out in the weeks ahead.
Next week, we’ll take one last look at the Preseason with
an examination of what takes place in Week 3 - Until then...