Personnel has a large say in what areas of the field quarterbacks
throw the ball. However, being able to identify how often they
throw into a certain range over a two-year period should give
us an idea of what players - be it running backs, receivers and
tight ends - stand to benefit the most.
Over the next two weeks, I will examine and analyze recent historical
data as it relates to where quarterbacks tend to throw and what
it means for the pass-catchers attached to them for the 2023 season.
Key:
BLOS - Behind the line of scrimmage
Short - 0-9 yards
Medium - 10-19 yards
Deep - 20+ yards
Depth of
Quarterback Throws (2021 and 2022 seasons)
Players
Tm
Year
G
BLOS %
Short %
Med %
Deep %
BLOS +
Sh%
BLOS +
Sh +
Med%
Med +
Deep%
Kyler Murray
ARI
2021
15
22.3
36.9
18.8
14.8
59.2
78.0
33.6
Kyler Murray
ARI
2022
11
18.7
44.1
17.2
11.5
62.8
80.0
28.7
Matt Ryan
ATL
2021
17
13.9
48.8
21.6
9.1
62.7
84.3
30.7
Marcus Mariota
ATL
2022
13
14.3
38.0
26.3
16.0
52.3
78.6
42.3
Desmond Ridder
ATL
2022
4
19.1
40.0
26.1
8.7
59.1
85.2
34.8
Lamar Jackson
BAL
2021
12
9.9
48.4
19.1
14.1
58.3
77.4
33.2
Lamar Jackson
BAL
2022
12
14.4
42.6
20.2
14.4
57.0
77.2
34.6
Josh Allen
BUF
2021
19
14.1
43.2
22.3
12.3
57.3
79.6
34.6
Josh Allen
BUF
2022
18
11.3
42.9
21.8
16.0
54.2
76.0
37.8
Sam Darnold
CAR
2021
12
16.0
44.3
19.7
9.9
60.3
80.0
29.6
Justin Fields
CHI
2021
12
8.1
47.0
24.1
15.9
55.1
79.2
40.0
Justin Fields
CHI
2022
15
18.9
36.2
18.9
16.0
55.1
74.0
34.9
Andy Dalton
CHI
2021
8
15.7
45.3
24.2
6.8
61.0
85.2
31.0
Joe Burrow
CIN
2021
20
12.7
51.5
17.2
12.1
64.2
81.4
29.3
Joe Burrow
CIN
2022
19
16.1
45.2
22.1
9.0
61.3
83.4
31.1
Baker Mayfield
CLE
2021
14
13.2
43.8
22.0
13.2
57.0
79.0
35.2
Jacoby Brissett
CLE
2022
12
11.4
45.3
21.1
14.1
56.7
77.8
35.2
Deshaun Watson
CLE
2022
6
12.4
44.7
22.4
7.6
57.1
79.5
30.0
Dak Prescott
DAL
2021
17
14.4
47.4
20.5
12.2
61.8
82.3
32.7
Dak Prescott
DAL
2022
14
12.9
48.5
23.1
10.8
61.4
84.5
33.9
Russell Wilson
DEN
2022
15
15.9
41.3
15.9
16.1
57.2
73.1
32.0
Teddy Bridgewater
DEN
2021
14
12.7
50.5
16.7
12.2
63.2
79.9
28.9
Jared Goff
DET
2022
17
14.5
47.4
19.3
9.4
61.9
81.2
28.7
Jared Goff
DET
2021
14
15.8
50.8
16.6
9.1
66.6
83.2
25.7
Aaron Rodgers
GB
2021
17
17.3
45.4
17.1
13.0
62.7
79.8
30.1
Aaron Rodgers
GB
2022
17
20.7
40.4
15.9
15.5
61.1
77.0
31.4
Jordan Love
GB
2021
4
14.5
48.4
21.0
12.9
62.9
83.9
33.9
Jordan Love
GB
2022
4
14.3
47.6
28.6
4.8
61.9
90.5
33.4
Davis Mills
HOU
2021
13
17.5
47.2
17.5
10.7
64.7
82.2
28.2
Davis Mills
HOU
2022
15
16.1
42.8
19.8
12.9
58.9
78.7
32.7
Matt Ryan
IND
2022
12
15.8
47.3
22.8
4.3
63.1
85.9
27.1
Carson Wentz
IND
2021
17
14.7
46.5
19.8
11.4
61.2
81.0
31.2
Trevor Lawrence
JAC
2022
19
17.9
43.0
20.6
11.6
60.9
81.5
32.2
Trevor Lawrence
JAC
2021
17
14.3
46.3
19.9
10.3
60.6
80.5
30.2
Patrick Mahomes
KC
2021
20
21.0
41.8
18.2
9.7
62.8
81.0
27.9
Patrick Mahomes
KC
2022
20
18.1
43.2
21.0
9.4
61.3
82.3
30.4
Baker Mayfield
LA
2022
12
20.0
41.2
20.3
9.6
61.2
81.5
29.9
Justin Herbert
LAC
2021
17
12.2
51.2
19.9
9.5
63.4
83.3
29.4
Justin Herbert
LAC
2022
18
18.0
45.6
17.1
9.8
63.6
80.7
26.9
Matthew Stafford
LAR
2021
21
14.3
46.2
23.6
11.6
60.5
84.1
35.2
Matthew Stafford
LAR
2022
9
20.1
48.2
17.8
8.9
68.3
86.1
26.7
Derek Carr
LV
2021
18
15.6
44.6
20.7
11.9
60.2
80.9
32.6
Derek Carr
LV
2022
15
11.6
44.6
20.3
14.1
56.2
76.5
34.4
Tua Tagovailoa
MIA
2022
13
10.5
38.3
31.5
13.8
48.8
80.3
45.3
Tua Tagovailoa
MIA
2021
13
14.4
48.7
25.3
7.5
63.1
88.4
32.8
Jacoby Brissett
MIA
2021
9
13.3
52.0
17.8
8.9
65.3
83.1
26.7
Kirk Cousins
MIN
2021
16
15.9
42.4
19.6
12.7
58.3
77.9
32.3
Kirk Cousins
MIN
2022
18
13.9
44.9
22.6
9.7
58.8
81.4
32.3
Mac Jones
NE
2022
14
19.7
42.8
15.6
15.2
62.5
78.1
30.8
Mac Jones
NE
2021
18
14.7
47.2
20.8
11.3
61.9
82.7
32.1
Andy Dalton
NO
2022
14
10.1
50.0
22.2
10.1
60.1
82.3
32.3
Daniel Jones
NYG
2022
18
16.3
49.6
19.5
4.9
65.9
85.4
24.4
Daniel Jones
NYG
2021
11
13.6
50.4
22.7
6.6
64.0
86.7
29.3
Zach Wilson
NYJ
2021
13
14.9
44.4
20.6
11.2
59.3
79.9
31.8
Zach Wilson
NYJ
2022
9
14.9
37.6
21.1
13.6
52.5
73.6
34.7
Jalen Hurts
PHI
2022
18
15.4
46.4
16.6
13.0
61.8
78.4
29.6
Jalen Hurts
PHI
2021
16
16.4
36.4
21.5
15.8
52.8
74.3
37.3
Kenny Pickett
PIT
2022
13
12.6
49.1
18.8
12.1
61.7
80.5
30.9
Ben Roethlisberger
PIT
2021
17
16.5
51.6
17.4
10.9
68.1
85.5
28.3
Geno Smith
SEA
2022
18
13.8
46.1
21.9
11.2
59.9
81.8
33.1
Russell Wilson
SEA
2021
14
17.0
42.8
15.0
18.8
59.8
74.8
33.8
Brock Purdy
SF
2022
10
15.9
43.8
19.7
11.6
59.7
79.4
31.3
Trey Lance
SF
2021
5
12.7
32.4
25.4
18.3
45.1
70.5
43.7
Jimmy Garoppolo
SF
2021
18
14.8
46.6
24.3
7.6
61.4
85.7
31.9
Trey Lance
SF
2022
2
25.8
32.3
22.6
9.7
58.1
80.7
32.3
Jimmy Garoppolo
SF
2022
11
17.9
47.6
19.2
9.1
65.5
84.7
28.3
Tom Brady
TB
2021
19
17.7
43.2
22.8
10.9
60.9
83.7
33.7
Tom Brady
TB
2022
18
16.9
48.8
18.1
9.1
65.7
83.8
27.2
Ryan Tannehill
TEN
2022
12
11.7
52.3
19.1
10.2
64.0
83.1
29.3
Ryan Tannehill
TEN
2021
18
15.5
45.6
22.5
9.9
61.1
83.6
32.4
Sam Howell
WAS
2022
1
5.3
68.4
5.3
10.5
73.7
79.0
15.8
Carson Wentz
WAS
2022
8
17.4
49.6
13.4
12.3
67.0
80.4
25.7
Taylor Heinicke
WAS
2022
9
14.7
39.8
23.6
11.2
54.5
78.1
34.8
Taylor Heinicke
WAS
2021
16
18.6
42.1
19.6
13.6
60.7
80.3
33.2
Averages
15.5%
45.3%
20.2%
11.4%
60.8%
81.0%
31.6%
Note: The cutoff for the quarterbacks on this list was 200 pass
attempts in a season. Several others - such as Desmond Ridder and
Sam Howell - were included to provide perspective on their tendencies,
albeit with very limited sample sizes. The averages at the bottom
of the table are the averages for the 74 entries.
Our journey begins with an injured quarterback (ACL) that may
not play much this year on a team that turned over its coaching
staff and will embrace more of a conventional run-based offense
under first-year OC Drew Petzing. He is almost certain to emulate
parts of Kevin Stefanski's offensive philosophy after serving
on the Browns' staff since Stefanski took over the top job in
Cleveland. It should not come as a surprise that Murray posted
two of the top 10 marks in percentage of BLOS throws in 2021 and
20222 since those passes are usually a hallmark of the Air Raid
offense that former HC Kliff Kingsbury ran in Arizona.
Four games is not a large sample to draw many conclusions, but
it is interesting that Ridder and Marcus Mariota threw short and
medium at virtually the same rate but flip-flopped in terms of
how often they threw behind the line of scrimmage and deep. Mariota's
16 percent deep attempt rate is one of the highest in this two-year
sample, while Ridder's 8.7 is one of the lowest. Contrast both
of these players with HC Arthur Smith's first season in charge
when Matt Ryan threw behind the line of scrimmage a Mariota-like
13.9 percent of the time and deep on a Ridder-like 8.7 percent
of his throws.
The major differences in Jackson's 2021 and 2022 seasons were
a five-percent uptick in his throws behind the line of scrimmage
(9.9 to 14.4) and a subsequent six-percent downturn in short throws
(48.4 to 42.6). Baltimore is almost certain to open things up
more under OC Todd Monken - especially with the additions of Odell
Beckham Jr. and Zay Flowers and the return of Rashod Bateman -
so we probably have to rely on the resumes of the new faces to
determine what part of the field Jackson will attack the most.
While the aforementioned three receivers and TE Mark Andrews can
all stretch the field, it seems unlikely Jackson will attempt
as many deep passes as he did BLOS throws again this year (47
apiece).
The primary difference in Allen's 2021 and 2022 seasons was a
transition from former OC Brian Daboll to new OC Ken Dorsey. Allen's
BLOS pass attempts dipped by 2.8 percent, but his deep throws
picked up by 3.7 percent. He should be a solid bet to throw at
least 22 percent of his passes in the 10-19 yard range and 43
percent of his attempts in the 0-9 yard range again in 2023. Not
only is that where Stefon Diggs does most of his work, but it
should be where rookie TE Dalton Kincaid - the favorite to be
the primary slot option - lives as well.
There are plenty of narratives floating out in cyberspace about
Fields' accuracy woes, but one could easily make the argument
he has yet to play with a receiver in the pros as good as the
ones he had at Ohio State. That will change this season with D.J.
Moore. As such, expect Chicago to take advantage of Moore's run-after-catch
ability on short and medium throws while dropping a few points
from his BLOS and deep marks. Josh Allen and Jalen Hurts are recent
examples of seemingly inaccurate passers who became a lot more
accurate in the same year they added a star receiver. Expect Fields
to follow suit.
Contrary to popular belief, Burrow attempted throws of 20 yards
or more down the field at one of the lowest rates in the league
last year (nine percent), which was a 3.1 percent drop from 2021.
He ramped up his BLOS passes by almost the same percentage (3.4).
The same kind of phenomenon happened at the short and medium levels,
as the former jumped by 4.9 percent and the latter fell by 6.3
percent. As it specifically relates to the Bengals, my working
theory as of now is that defenses played significantly more shell
coverages designed to keep Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins from
beating them deep, which resulted in a lot more throws in the
10-19 yard range.
It serves little purpose to read much into Watson's six-game
sample last season, other than offering it up as an interesting
sidebar to the quarterback he was during his final days as a Texan.
In 2020, Watson's BLOS-Short-Medium-Deep splits were 11.9-43.8-26.7-12.3.
In 2019, they were 11.5-51.4-17.3-14.7. (During his suspension-shortened
2022 season, those marks were 12.4-44.7-22.4-7.6.) All of this
is to say that Watson strayed from the deep throws last year and
focused more on medium passes, which was probably the product
of having two players in Amari Cooper and David Njoku who tend
to do their best work in the 10-19 yard range. Having another
year to work with Donovan Peoples-Jones and adding more speed
(Marquise Goodwin, Elijah Moore) should see Watson return to more
of the deep-ball tendencies he exhibited in Houston.
Prescott's distribution has been remarkably similar over the
last three seasons, so it remains to be seen how much of an impact
- if any - that the transition from former OC Kellen Moore to
HC Mike McCarthy (and new OC Brian Schottenheimer, to a lesser
extent) will have on it. The addition of Brandin Cooks and Michael
Gallup's expected return to 100 percent health figure to play
a bigger role than the change of offensive leadership, although
McCarthy historically has leaned on the conservative side. Nevertheless,
the departure of Dalton Schultz and the addition of Cooks should
push Prescott's short-range attempts down and his medium and deep
shots up.
Outside of his sheer volume of pass attempts (400 in 2021 and
483 in 2022), very little changed for Wilson in terms of where
he threw the ball in his last year in Seattle versus his first
year in Denver. The question then becomes one of personnel (are
DK Metcalf and Tyler Lockett that much better than Jerry Jeudy
and Courtland Sutton?), creativity (was Nathaniel Hackett that
bad?) and decline (Wilson's on-target percentage was 73.3 percent
- the second straight season that mark has dropped by three percent).
The addition of Marvin Mims and the return of Tim Patrick point
to Wilson's deep-ball rate going up to pre-2020 levels (at least
16 percent).
Goff has only twice surpassed a 10-percent deep passing rate
- but not in any year since 2018. For the most part, his two years
in Detroit have been remarkably similar, except for the small
flip-flop in his short and medium attempts. That is to be expected
given how important Amon-Ra St. Brown has been to the offense.
What remains to be seen is how much a healthy Jameson Williams
affects that. While Williams will obviously do some work on BLOS
and short targets, he was drafted with medium and deep targets
in mind. Unfortunately, the Lions (and fantasy managers) will
have to wait through Williams' six-game suspension before finding
out what impact he can have on this offense.
The former first-round pick has attempted a mere 83 passes in
three NFL seasons, so drawing many - if any - conclusions about
how deep he is throwing the ball would be foolish. Perhaps it
is worth some consideration in comparing and contrasting his mark
to Aaron Rodgers', albeit over a much larger sample size. Love
did not throw behind the line of scrimmage much with his opportunities
over the last two seasons (six percent less than Rodgers in 2022)
but threw a significantly higher percentage of his passes in the
0-9 yard range. A similar dichotomy played out in the medium and
deep ranges, as Love targeted 10-19 yard throws at a much higher
rate than Rodgers, who went deep much more often than his protégé.
Lawrence essentially turned just over three percent of his pass
attempts in the 0-9 yard range for more throws behind the line
of scrimmage. That comes as a minor surprise considering Urban
Meyer - he of the spread offense - was calling plays for most
of 2021. In terms of his actual efficiency, one reason why Lawrence
performed so much better in 2022 was that his short completion
rate jumped from 71.7 percent to 77.1. It is also worth noting
that Lawrence tied Russell Wilson for third in most 20-plus yard
throws, which could have been as much of a product of the Jaguars
adding Christian Kirk as it was a show of faith in the quarterback's
abilities. For what it is worth, his deep completion rates in
both years (30.6 in 2021, 33.3 in 2022) have been among the worst
of the 74 entries on the board.
The 2022 season saw Mahomes attempt fewer BLOS throws (from 21
percent to 18.1) and attack the medium area of the field much
more often (18.2 to 21). His short throws rose a modest 1.4 percent.
The increase in short and medium throws checks out considering
how much he relies on Travis Kelce. Interestingly, his deep ball
rate dropped a mere three-tenths of a percent despite the departure
of Tyreek Hill. One of the many things that helps Mahomes separate
himself from the competition is his deep completion rate. In each
of the last two years, he has connected on at least 44 percent
of his 20-plus yard throws. Kirk Cousins is the only other quarterback
in the table above who can make the same claim.
Perhaps it had to do with the number of games missed by Keenan
Allen and Mike Williams, but Herbert's reliance on BLOS throws
last year (read: Austin Ekeler) cannot be explained away in the
same way that Stafford's was - namely a revolving door on the
offensive line. Perhaps former OC Joe Lombardi felt his hands
were tied, but 2022 was not the first time one of Lombardi's offenses
was overly conservative. Under new OC Kellen Moore, expect a return
to Herbert's rookie season in 2020 during which he attempted passes
of at least 20 yards on 11.3 percent of his throws. With his current
supporting cast, Herbert could easily post a medium plus deep
passing rate of over 30 percent for the first time in his career.
Most of the biggest gaps in the depth of throws from year to
year that we have seen in quarterbacks to this point have been
around three percent. That brings us to Stafford, who threw one
of every five balls behind the line of scrimmage (20.1) in 2022
after averaging one every 7.1 throws in 2021. The combination
of the offensive line falling apart and Cooper Kupp being Stafford's
only quick-throw option undoubtedly played a role in this development.
The increase in BLOS throws came at the cost of his medium throws,
which dipped from 23.6 percent to 17.8. Predictably, his deep
throws took a big hit as well, dropping from a respectable 11.6
percent in 2021 to 8.9, which is one of the lower percentages
in the table above. His medium throws took a bigger nosedive,
going from 23.6 percent to 17.8.
Garoppolo's reputation precedes itself: he gets hurt a lot and
does not throw downfield very often. Unlike most other quarterbacks,
however, it is hard to blame him for throwing behind the line
of scrimmage or short on 65.5 percent of his throws - as was the
case in 11 games last year - when he had Christian McCaffrey and
Deebo Samuel at his disposal. What is mildly surprising about
his 2022 breakdown is that 9.1 percent of his throws traveled
20-plus yards, which should help ease the minds of Davante Adams'
fantasy managers a bit. It is far from an ideal number, but it
also seems reasonable that HC Josh McDaniels will push that number
over 10 for the first time since 2018 - the year Garoppolo was
traded from the Patriots - who had McDaniels running the offense
at the time - to the 49ers.
While it is probably not a surprise that a quarterback attached
to Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle threw deep on 13.8 percent of
his throws last season, there was a time not so long ago that
Tagovailoa's ability to do just that was in question. However,
there is a more startling number to discuss. The former Alabama
standout completed 54.5 percent of those throws, which is by far
the highest mark over the last two seasons. When his medium-range
throws are included, Tagovailoa attempted passes of at least 10
yards 45.3 percent of the time last season and completed 61.8
percent of those attempts.
Year 1 of the Kevin O'Connell experience saw Cousins throw the
ball deep less than 10 percent of the time for the first time
in nearly 10 years (when he was a backup in Washington behind
Robert Griffin III in 2013). There are a multitude of reasons
why that could be the case, but the three of the most likely explanations
are that Justin Jefferson works the short and medium part of the
field, Minnesota lacks a true field-stretcher after K.J. Osborn
and Cousins will turn 35 in August. Still, fantasy managers should
want to see their quarterbacks top the 30 percent mark when they
add their quarterback's medium and deep throws together because
that is where the big plays typically happen. Another thing that
makes it a good idea is Cousins' proficiency on deep (45 percent
completion rate in each of the last two seasons) and medium (63
percent combined over the last two years) throws.
During his rookie year, it was a common refrain to hear that
Jones might be the best quarterback in his draft class. Last season,
there were whispers of him eventually losing his job to Bailey
Zappe. This can happen when a team decides to make a longtime
defensive coordinator its offensive coordinator. In short, we
can probably dismiss most of what we saw from this offense in
2022. Perhaps the most interesting nugget as it relates to the
topic du jour is how Jones ramped up his BLOS (from 14.7 in 2021
to 19.7 in 2022) and deep throws (11.3 to 15.2) and dialed down
the short (47.2 to 42.8) and medium (20.8 to 15.6) attempts. This
means that former OC Matt Patricia believed his offense was best
suited to pick up yards after the catch - largely with Rhamondre
Stevenson (good) - and go for broke with DeVante Parker while
focusing less on Jakobi Meyers and Hunter Henry (not so good).
One of the reasons we can feel optimistic about Jimmy Garoppolo
throwing downfield a bit more often in 2023 - due to the presence
of Davante Adams - is because Carr did the same thing. Interestingly,
Carr's short and medium throws occurred at about the same rate
in 2022 as they did in 2021, while the percentage dip on BLOS
throws was accounted for on deeper attempts. This makes a difference
because Carr's new offense is expected to be similar to the one
he just left - albeit with a better supporting cast. That, and
Chris Olave proved to be a very good deep-ball receiver as a rookie.
Throw in the reported development of speedster Rashid Shaheed's
game and Carr could beat last season's deep-ball percentage of
14.1.
It is too early to make any declarative statements about passing
game tendencies after one year with HC Brian Daboll, if only because
the Giants didn't have a weapon like Stefon Diggs in 2022 (and
still don't). However, one look at how infrequently Jones threw
the ball 20 or more yards down the field in 2022 (4.9 percent)
is a pretty strong indication we aren't about to see the second
coming of Josh Allen. (For anyone out there hoping for such a
thing.) As evidenced by their offseason moves (such as Parris
Campbell this spring), New York is likely expecting Jones to continue
limiting mistakes and let his receivers do work after the catch.
Jones threw medium or deep a meager 24.4 percent of the time in
2022. While adding Darren Waller should drive that number a bit,
it is highly unlikely to move much past 27, which would still
be one of the lowest marks if included in the table above.
The 2021 season is probably a better barometer of what Rodgers
might do in New York than 2022. Not only was his "new"
offensive coordinator (Nathaniel Hackett) with him in Green Bay
but so was Davante Adams. It appears Adams' role will now fall
into the capable hands of Garrett Wilson. At any rate, Rodgers
distributed the ball beautifully to all four areas of the field
in 2021, sending at least 13 percent of his throws to each one.
(He was over 15 percent to each area in 2022, but the absence
of Adams obviously played a role in him taking a step back from
his MVP form, as did one of every five attempts going to a target
behind the line of scrimmage.) Supporting cast should not be a
problem for him this year, as Wilson can win at every level, Lazard
can win in contested-catch situations and Mecole Hardman can do
work on BLOS targets (as can a healthy Breece Hall).
The addition of A.J. Brown opened the offense up in a big way,
but it was not because Hurts threw the ball deep more often (2.8
percent drop from 2021). His medium throws even declined by 4.9
percent. What changed the most besides his modest increase of
efficiency to all areas of the field was a 10-percent increase
in his attempts in the 0-9 yard range. A large part of that can
probably be explained by the sizable increase in run-pass option
pass attempts (122 in 2022 after 95 in 2021), which tend to lead
to throws in the short area of the field. Considering how often
Hurts throws behind the line of scrimmage (15-plus percent in
each of the last two years), D'Andre Swift and Kenny Gainwell
could see more usage than most expect in 2023.
Pickett was the victim of his inexperience and a poor offensive
line last year, not to mention some curious offensive philosophy
by Matt Canada. Things began taking a turn for the better near
the end of the season, but this offense figures to remain a conservative
unit for the foreseeable future. Thus, it would not be surprising
if Pickett's distribution remains roughly the same in 2023, with
perhaps a slight dip in deep passes and a slight bump in medium
attempts. To a large degree, the personnel dictates it after George
Pickens. Diontae Johnson, Pat Freiermuth, Allen Robinson and Darnell
Washington will not be asked to stretch the field very often.
It was clear early on last season that Smith throws a great deep
ball (47.1 completion rate on deep throws and 52.9 accuracy rate
on them - both very good marks). Surprisingly, he did not go deep
nearly as often as one might expect. His 11.2-percent deep passing
rate was just a shade higher than the average of the quarterbacks
in the table above but a far cry from the 18.8-percent figure
Russell Wilson posted with Seattle in 2021. Where Smith made up
the difference was in the short passing game (85.7 percent completion
rate) and by throwing in the 0-9 yard range (3.3 percent more
than Wilson in 2021) and 10-19 yard range (plus-6.9 percent) more
often.
In terms of where they threw the ball in 2022, the biggest differences
between Purdy and Jimmy Garoppolo were that Purdy averaged about
four fewer passes per game, pushed the ball down the field about
once a game more than Garoppolo and was ridiculously accurate
on throws of 10-19 yards (80.4 percent). While Christian McCaffrey
and Deebo Samuel do some of their fine work there, Brandon Aiyuk
and George Kittle do more work than their aforementioned teammates
on medium throws. Since all of Purdy's starts came after the McCaffrey
trade and San Francisco's supporting cast remains roughly the
same, it seems reasonable to believe about the only thing that
will change about Purdy's distribution is that he will probably
focus more often on medium throws. (That assumes he fully recovers
from his elbow injury on time and keeps the starting job.)
It is probably not a great idea to read too much into Mayfield's
time with the Rams or Panthers last year. Not only did he arrive
midway through the season in Los Angeles (and thus had limited
knowledge of the playbook with the Rams), but he also had little
to work with in both spots. Interestingly enough, Mayfield's previous
two seasons with Cleveland (2020 and 2021) were near carbon copies
of each other, as his BLOS and deep throws were within one percentage
point of each other both times. He also attempted passes in the
10-19 yard range 23 percent of the time. It is worth noting that
he has completed deep passes at a significantly higher rate than
the average of the quarterbacks listed above. In 2020, he completed
exactly half of those throws. In 2021, it was 40 percent. He was
at 50 percent again in Carolina last year and 43.8 during his
time with the Rams. In short, Mike Evans' biggest fans have reason
to be hopeful.
Simply put, it appears much of Tannehill's drop-off last year
was a product of throwing short more often (52.3 percent in 2021,
45.6 in 2022) and being much less accurate with those attempts
(82.6 percent versus 75.3). Otherwise, he was a more accurate
medium and deep thrower than he was in 2021. That last statement
is an interesting one considering it came after the trade of A.J.
Brown. Furthermore, the Titans opted for BLOS throws less often
(15.5 percent in 2021, 11.7 in 2022) with a much less refined
route-runner with considerable run-after-catch skills (Treylon
Burks) than it did the previous season. All of which probably
makes it a good idea the Titans moved on from former OC Todd Downing
and are rolling with new OC Tim Kelly, who fared better than he
probably should have as the Texans' play-caller for part of 2020
and all of 2021.
Limited data - his first (and only) NFL action came in Week 18
last season.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and has appeared as a guest analyst on several national sports radio shows and podcasts, including Sirius XM's Fantasy Drive, FantasyPros and RealTime Fantasy Sports. He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.