Being able to predict opportunity - perhaps the most important variable
in fantasy football - is more than half of the battle when it comes
to being able to construct accurate rankings. Thus, the goal over
the next two weeks: provide thoughts and analysis on some of the
issues that played a factor in the way I distributed the workload
for each team. Unlike past years, I'll be breaking this into four
smaller, more easy-to-digest articles.
Notes: After much consternation, I decided on 15-game
workload projections. Although the industry judges players
and fantasy projections on year-end totals, the fantasy season
ends for the overwhelming majority of owners after Week 16. Furthermore,
it is nearly impossible to project what teams will do (or if they
even need to have certain players suit up) in Week 17 - especially
in a year like 2020.
The bolded numbers near the top of the middle three columns
are the 15-game totals for each team. Players who factored into
the overall pass attempt-carries-targets breakdown but are not
expected to receive a meaningful workload for fantasy purposes
have been excluded in the interest of brevity. The bolded numbers
in the last two columns reflect each team's projected run-pass
ratio. Last year's average plays per game included sacks, while
my projections do not - accounting for some of the gap in the
play averages under each table. Players with a
next to their name have some degree of injury concern.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 63.1 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.6
It appears as if OC Brian Daboll has found his sweet spot with
Allen, who averaged 6.4 carries one year after averaging 7.1 as
a rookie. Of his 109 carries in 2019, 19.3 percent happened inside
the red zone. In 2018, the percentage was 21.3. He has rushed
exactly 11 times inside the 10 and five times inside the 5 each
year. With the addition of Moss, it's hard to see any of those
marks being repeated. However, the big question for Buffalo isn't
as much goal-line work - Moss and Allen figure to handle the overwhelming
majority of it - but whether the "Frank Gore role" the
third-round pick has been ticketed for means the Bills prefer
Singletary in the same complementary role he played in the first
half of last season. Or did they like what they saw in the second
half enough to commit 15 touches per week to Singletary and put
Moss in more of a relief role? My prediction: as dynamic as Singletary
is, the Bills will quickly learn Moss is a tone-setter. It would
not be surprising if the workload is split in such a way that
Moss is the better play in non-PPR formats and Singletary is the
slightly better option in PPR leagues. Whatever the gap is between
the two players in fantasy this year, expect it to be slim.
Diggs is known as one of the better route-runners in the league
but proved he was one of the NFL's best deep threats as well last
season. It's unclear at this time what part of his game the Bills
want to feature in 2020, but it seems reasonable after Allen led
the league in uncatchable passes (27 percent) and went 4-for-37
on deep targets not thrown in Brown's direction that Buffalo might
want to lean a bit more on the short and intermediate game. It's
hard to imagine this passing offense changing all that much in
volume even with the addition of Diggs, meaning Brown and Beasley
will almost certainly lose about 20 percent of last year's targets
(115 and 106, respectively). Knox will also struggle to see enough
of an increase in targets to break out, especially if he comes
anywhere close to repeating last year's drop percentage of 17.9.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 61.5 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.9
Miami will almost certainly be a better running team than it
was in 2019 because it will be hard to be any worse. From cycling
through Kalen Ballage to Mark Walton and Patrick Laird after deciding
they didn't always like Kenyan Drake's practice habits, the Dolphins
managed to set the stage for a 37-year-old quarterback to lead
the team in rushing. If nothing else, Howard provides stability
to a backfield that desperately needs it; he is a back who gets
a bit more than what is blocked and generally stays healthy (last
year was the first time in four pro seasons he didn’t play
at least 15 games). He provides almost nothing as a receiver,
however, making him something of a polar opposite of Breida, who
is a big play waiting to happen and has shown himself to be a
good option in the passing game in limited action but always seems
to be playing hurt. Their profiles would seem to suggest that
while Breida may get "hot" and earn more carries than
Howard on occasion, Howard should be a solid bet to get around
15 carries in at least 12 games.
There has been relatively little discussion about Chan Gailey
taking over for Chad O'Shea and plenty of assumptions made that
the offense will do the same things as last year. It's worth noting
that from Weeks 10-17, Gesicki logged 223 snaps in the slot -
the fourth-highest total in the league regardless of position
over that span. If that kind of usage continues under Gailey,
then it's probably not going to matter if Williams' return from
an ACL surgery is seamless. Parker's four-year, $40 million contract
extension in late December was a pretty clear indication the Dolphins
feel he is the lead guy. While that doesn't necessarily mean Williams
can't eventually emerge as a 1B to Parker's 1A, it does suggest
Miami sees Parker more like a receiver whose second-half pace
had him finishing with an 88-1,604-10 line as opposed to the 56-800-8
trajectory he was on before Williams' injury. And most of this
conjecture seems to have already embraced Williams' return to
form as a given. With virtually no offseason, a new play-caller
and a player entering his second season coming off a serious knee
injury, it could be October or November before we see the Williams
we remember.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 66.5 2019 Average Plays per Game: 68.4
Tom Brady may be gone, but the same architects for one of the
most frustrating running-back-by-committee attacks each year still
reside in Foxboro. The major difference this year, however, is
how many of the roughly 400 carries that usually get distributed
among four or five New England running backs will be taken by
Newton. Complicating matters even further is the uncertain status
of where Michel is at physically after offseason foot surgery.
Does Williams take the job with a strong start if Michel isn't
quite ready for Week 1? How much does Burkhead factor into the
plans? Michel's fantasy owners likely still have nightmares about
the difference in his production last year with Burkhead available
versus when he wasn't. And how does White fit into the plans now?
It seems unlikely Newton will lean on him as much as Brady did.
White has yet to run more than 87 times in a season, so even the
slightest hit to his work in the passing game (95 targets in 2019)
will hurt.
It would be silly to write off any receiver coming off a 100-catch
season, but how much longer can the Patriots continue to ask 34-year-old
Edelman to work the middle of the field before he breaks down?
Last season was only the second time since 2014 that he was able
to play a full slate of games. It's also worth noting that no
wide receiver topped 73 catches with Newton as the primary starter
in Carolina since Steve Smith hauled in 79 in Newton's rookie
year. Harry's inability to separate from man coverage could very
well be a long-term concern, but there is some history of Newton
being able to work with such receivers (Kelvin Benjamin). Can
the kind of trust that needs to get built for a contested-catch
receiver like that get built over the course of training camp?
Sanu reportedly hired a full-time coach to live with him this
offseason as he tries to become more than a "safe" receiver
with little big-play ability. Regardless of how much Harry and
Sanu step up, Edelman and White are likely very good bets to combine
for 200-plus targets again, and the Patriots have to hope they
can both hold up.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 56.8 2019 Average Plays per Game: 59.8
HC Adam Gase has a reputation for consistently running one of
the league's most plodding offenses year after year, but Football
Outsiders charted the Jets running a play once every 30.6 seconds
in "neutral"
situations last year - good for 16th in the league. At least last
season, the ability to maintain a drive was a much bigger problem
than how quickly the offense snapped the ball. Gore was not added
just to be a sounding board or show a young team how to work hard.
Whether he or Perine ends up working one series for every two
Bell does is a question that needs to be answered, but the odds
of Bell averaging 20.7 touches again (311 in 15 games last year)
are long. With that said, he shouldn't need that kind of workload
to amass 1,250 total yards and four total TDs again. The Jets
should be able to field a competent offensive line after overhauling
it in the offseason, while the additions of Mims and Perriman
should stretch the field a bit more and open up a few more running
lanes when Bell gets to the second level.
Darnold didn't have much of a chance last year, coming down with
mononucleosis after Week 1 and playing virtually the entire season
without Herndon. Crowder was the one constant in this offense
when Darnold was healthy - something that should be expected to
continue in 2020 given how heavily Gase's offenses have relied
on slot receivers. Gase famously called Herndon "a unicorn"
shortly after his hire last winter because of his belief in the
young tight end's ability to play all three downs. The Athletic's
Connor Hughes has reported throughout the offseason that the Jets
can't wait to unleash Herndon, and I feel confident in saying
I probably don't have him projected for enough targets if he plays
16 games this year. For as good of a prospect as Mims is, the
lack of offseason work probably ended whatever hopes he had of
overtaking Perriman as the team's top perimeter receiver before
December. Perriman has accounted for himself nicely late in the
last two seasons. While Mims' route tree is not as limited as
some seem to believe, he may end being more of a red zone threat
than a do-everything alpha as a rookie.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 65.1 2019 Average Plays per Game: 66.8
The retirement of C Travis Frederick and departure of TE Jason
Witten sting a bit from the perspective of the quality of run-blocking
Elliott will get in 2020, but it's worth noting Dallas ranked
second in Football Outsiders' adjusted line yards metric (4.91),
so they can probably absorb the hit there better than most. A
slightly bigger concern may be Pollard, who is obviously not a
threat to Elliott's status as a starter. However, he is someone
who has proven to be good enough that the Cowboys may want to
rethink how much they want to subject Elliott to 300-plus carries.
Zeke already has three on his resume, so another such season would
make him one of only 19 running backs in NFL history to have four.
Fantasy owners also can't overlook the fact he has been extremely
durable through four straight high-usage seasons; even though
he is only 25 years of age, there is bound to be a year in the
near future when this Maserati needs to spend some time in the
repair shop. Another thing to consider: Elliott's rushing yards
per game have declined every year.
It's impossible to know to what degree Cooper was limited by
knee and ankle injuries last season, but Gallup averaged more
targets than he did. While there's no question Cooper is one of
the league's premier receiving talents, his home/road splits -
in 2019 and throughout his career - are perplexing and have led
to more inconsistency than an alpha receiver should have. Gallup's
three-score Week 17 put a nice bow on his breakout second season,
but it also accounted for half of his touchdowns for the year.
On the plus side, Gallup lined up almost exclusively as the team's
"X" receiver - the position that most of the league's
top receivers play - in his second year, which should say just
how much the Cowboys think of him. Randall Cobb lined up in the
slot on 91.9 percent of his snaps in 2019 (Cooper was at 14.2
and Gallup was at 13.5), so any doubts about Lamb being the primary
slot option can probably be dismissed. It shouldn't be surprising
if this year's trio comes pretty close to copying last year's
119-113-83 target distribution to Cooper, Gallup and Cobb, respectively.
How the Cowboys redistribute last year's 126 tight end targets
(83 of which went to Witten) will have a huge bearing on whether
Cooper and/or Gallup leap into superstardom and/or Jarwin becomes
a low-end TE1.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 60.2 2019 Average Plays per Game: 64.2
It's unclear at the moment if the Giants are in a better position
to handle an injury to Barkley this season or if new OC Jason
Garrett is an upgrade over former HC Pat Shurmur as a play-caller.
However, they now have little excuse when it comes to providing
Barkley a running lane. A left side of projected starting LT Andrew
Thomas and LG Will Hernandez should emerge as one of the league's
better run-blocking duos in short order. RG Kevin Zeitler graded
out as the 13th-best run-blocking guard in the league last year
on what was mostly a poor line, suggesting he can improve on that
finish in his second year with New York. One of bigger mysteries
with the Giants this year is just how much Garrett has changed
as a play-caller since he last called plays in 2012. One thing
does seem certain, however: his Dallas teams never seemed to have
a problem feeding their top back. From DeMarco Murray to Darren
McFadden to Ezekiel Elliott, the Cowboys' top back handled at
least 270 touches every year over his last seven seasons in Dallas.
Barkley, Tate, Shepard, Slayton and Engram were never able to
take the field at the same time in 2019, so we don't know much
more about this passing game than we did at the same time a season
ago. Nevertheless, the two most consistent fantasy players of
the receiving group for fantasy purposes last year were Engram
and Tate. Most fantasy owners know the book on Engram: a target
monster who performs at an elite level when healthy but not a
player we can count on to last an entire season. Tate got the
nod over Shepard as the primary slot option, playing inside over
85 percent of the time he was on the field. Tate rewarded that
decision by posting 80 yards and/or one touchdown in eight of
the 11 games he played. Slayton took the fantasy world by storm
with a trio of two-touchdown games as a rookie, but each of the
efforts came against three of the worst secondaries in the league.
There's more to his game than just being the vertical threat he
was drafted to be, but he figures to be a boom-or-bust option
in fantasy for as long as Engram and Tate are healthy and/or able.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 67.2 2019 Average Plays per Game: 69.0
There's a general perception that HC Doug Pederson prefers a committee
backfield approach. After all, Sanders' 179 carries were the most
by any running back during his time in Philly. Perception is often
not reality and that appears to be the case here. In 2016, Ryan
Mathews was a 29-year-old back that had the misfortune of having
one of the greatest pass-catching backs in NFL history on the
same roster in Darren Sproles. Pederson was just starting to ramp
up Mathews' workload late in that season before a neck injury
ended his season (and ultimately his career). LeGarrette Blount
was well on pace for 200-plus rushing attempts in 2017 before
Jay Ajayi became available via trade, and it wasn't long after
his arrival from the Dolphins that the "Jaytrain" was
getting a steady 15 carries per week. Ajayi was expected to be
featured early and often in 2018, but he tore his ACL in Week
5. A couple of months later, Josh Adams emerged with a pair of
20-carry games before Sproles eventually returned from an injury.
Jordan Howard quickly emerged as the leader of the pack in 2019
and was also well on his way to 200-plus carries before a shoulder
injury put him on the shelf. Pass on Sanders in fantasy this year
if you feel as if Philadelphia running backs are snake-bitten,
but don't do it because "Pederson likes committees."
What Wentz did amid a rash of injuries at receiver last year
was nothing short of incredible. The bad news is Jackson and Goodwin
haven't come close to finishing a season in a while and Jeffery
could begin this year on the PUP list. The good news is Philadelphia
attacked the position early and often in the draft and focused
on speed with all three of those picks, meaning another extended
absence from Jackson shouldn't cripple the offense like it did
last year. Another piece of good news? Few - if any - teams rely
on the receiver position less than the Eagles, who have seen the
team target share at the position hold steady in the high-40s
over the last two years. Some of that is due to the injuries Philadelphia
has suffered at receiver, but some it is because the Eagles have
one of the best tight end rooms in the league. For as good as
Goedert already is and how good he will likely become, last year's
finish has led to the perception he is on the verge of a TE1 season.
It's easy to forget that while the Eagles love using two tight
ends, much of Goedert's production came with Ertz limping to the
finish line and Greg Ward serving as the No. 1 receiver. It's
at least one year too soon to fade Ertz. Tight ends tend to age
relatively well and it has been well-documented how strong Ertz's
connection is with Wentz.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 60.0 2019 Average Plays per Game: 55.3
Before the arrival of Christian McCaffrey, HC Ron Rivera endorsed
the two-back approach with his teams in Carolina. That may be
the only bit of clarity we will have entering the season at running
back in Washington. Nothing should be considered off the table,
including Peterson getting released before the opener or sharing
carries with Guice. McKissic may be asked to assume the old Chris
Thompson role or may not make the final roster. Same with Bryce
Love. Speaking of McCaffrey, Rivera famously compared Gibson's
skill set to that of the All-Pro. For good measure, Washington
also signed Peyton Barber to provide more competition. About the
only thing I feel confident in saying is that Guice and Gibson
will make the team and have roles. Guice should lead an early-down
committee at the very least, while Gibson's role could range anywhere
from Cordarrelle Patterson to Guice's complement. The bigger problem
for fantasy owners: this mess might be worth sorting through if
it was the Saints, but we're talking about a team that averaged
16.6 points and 55.3 plays last season. Even with the talent the
team added in the offseason, the offense needs to make huge strides
just to get to average.
Rivera must have left his heart in Carolina even after taking
the Washington job, as he compared another one of his former pupils
(D.J. Moore) to a member of his current team (McLaurin). There
are some parallels with that comparison, however, and it would
not be a stretch to see the Ohio State product make the same kind
of second-year leap Moore did. Unlike Moore, McLaurin won't have
the benefit of a player like McCaffrey to occupy the defense's
attention. That's not meant to diminish Sims, who established
himself as a trusted target for Haskins late in the season out
of the slot. Especially after Kelvin Harmon tore his ACL this
summer, Sims should enter camp with a sizeable edge over the competition
to be McLaurin's sidekick. Gandy-Golden figures to be thrust into
a major role as a result of Harmon's injury and has freakish size
(6-4, 223), but his tape suggests he is more of a contested-catch
option and less of the deep threat he was at Liberty. The team
also seems genuinely excited about Thomas emerging as the starter
at tight end. While he has improved statistically every year since
making the conversion from quarterback, he is another player where
it feels like the team is trying to speak his ability to be a
solid pro into existence.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and been featured in USA TODAY's Fantasy Football Preview magazine since 2010. He is also a high-stakes player who often appears as a guest analyst on a number of national sports radio shows, such as Sirius XM's "Fantasy Drive." Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.