Being able to predict opportunity - perhaps the most important variable
in fantasy football - is more than half of the battle when it comes
to being able to construct accurate rankings. Thus, the goal over
the next two weeks: provide thoughts and analysis on some of the
issues that played a factor in the way I distributed the workload
for each team. Unlike past years, I'll be breaking this into four
smaller, more easy-to-digest articles.
Notes: After much consternation, I decided on 15-game
workload projections. Although the industry judges players
and fantasy projections on year-end totals, the fantasy season
ends for the overwhelming majority of owners after Week 16. Furthermore,
it is nearly impossible to project what teams will do (or if they
even need to have certain players suit up) in Week 17 - especially
in a year like 2020.
The bolded numbers near the top of the middle three columns
are the 15-game totals for each team. Players who factored into
the overall pass attempt-carries-targets breakdown but are not
expected to receive a meaningful workload for fantasy purposes
have been excluded in the interest of brevity. The bolded numbers
in the last two columns reflect each team's projected run-pass
ratio. Last year's average plays per game included sacks, while
my projections do not - accounting for some of the gap in the
play averages under each table. Players with a
next to their name have some degree of injury concern.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 62.4 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.6
Since multiple coaching staffs have decided Duke Johnson doesn't
deserve a shot at a lead role despite never having missed a game
and averaging a healthy 4.4 yards per rush for his career, it's
imperative David Johnson stays healthy this year. The alternatives
are former undrafted free-agent Buddy Howell or possibly another
winner of a trade from de facto GM/HC Bill O'Brien. One of the
supposed motivations for the acquisition of David Johnson was
to get the running backs more involved in the passing game under
first-time play-caller Tim Kelly. In the six-season O'Brien era,
the Texans have given their lead back at least 238 carries four
times despite rarely ever having an above-average offensive line
or possessing a high-end talent at running back. David Johnson
has twice hit or surpassed 258 attempts, but he has a total of
230 in his other three pro seasons combined. If there is one positive
for David Johnson besides zero competition for his early-down
role, it might be that Houston is slowly finding long-term solutions
to its offensive line problems.
Watson attempted 67 passes that traveled at least 20 yards in
the air last season - the seventh-highest total in the league.
With all the speed on the perimeter Houston has now, it would
be at least mildly surprising if he doesn't match or exceed Aaron
Rodgers' 88 such attempts last year (second only behind Jameis
Winston's 102). Any increase like that is good for someone like
Fuller, who has yet to average less than 14 yards per target in
his four-year career. The problem is he has given fantasy owners
no reason to believe he will be available often enough to even
partly fill the void left behind by the trade of DeAndre Hopkins.
Fuller has played 11 or fewer games in three straight seasons
and has yet to catch 50 balls in a season or top 700 yards in
any of his four professional seasons. Cooks missed his first two
regular-season games in five years in 2019, ending a four-year
run of at least 65 receptions AND at least 1,082 receiving yards.
Cooks' concussion history is a big deal, but Fuller has proven
time and again he can't be counted on to avoid soft-tissue injuries.
Particularly on a team that can be expected to play in negative
game scripts more often in 2020, it won't be the deep shots that
will be available game after game. It will be the short and intermediate
work, and that's why I'll gladly take Cooks and maybe even Cobb
over Fuller this year.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 65.5 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.8
The Colts compiled the fifth-most rushing attempts in the league
last year. With one of the most accomplished college football
backs of all-time joining the backfield and the defense likely
to take another step forward, Indianapolis should be expected
to run even more than the 471 times it did in 2019. With Rivers
no threat to run, the Colts could very well have more than 450
rushing attempts to split among Taylor, Mack and Hines. It's hard
to imagine Hines will exceed the 52 he had last year when he took
a back seat to Jonathan Williams while Mack was sidelined. That
means roughly 400 carries could be available for Taylor and Mack
behind one of the best offensive lines in the league. The coaches
have repeatedly stated they plan on taking a 1A/1B approach to
Taylor and Mack. Teams tend to self-scout and reassess during
their bye weeks, so perhaps the safest assumption to make is the
Colts will distribute carries fairly evenly between Mack and Taylor
before the Week 7 bye. Not only would this give Taylor a chance
to overcome the lack of an offseason, but it would allow Indianapolis
to comfortably give him about 60 percent of the rushing attempts
down the stretch.
It's easy to understand why fantasy owners are hesitant to put
too much trust into Hilton after consecutive years of lower-body
injuries - the worst of which was last season's calf tear. He's
always been a much better player on the FieldTurf at Lucas Oil
Stadium than on natural grass to boot, making him more of a hit-or-miss
WR2 in fantasy than a low-end WR1. That seems unlikely to change
despite OC Nick Sirianni's insistence Hilton will be the centerpiece
of the team's passing attack because the Colts have other legitimate
weapons at his position for the first time in years. Pittman should
quickly emerge as the same kind of threat in the red zone Eric
Ebron was and gives Rivers the same kind of downfield threat he
had with Mike Williams in recent years. Campbell has been assured
primary residence in the slot and should be able to emerge as
the big-play threat Indianapolis thought it was getting last year
before his hamstring tormented him. It's important to remember
Doyle is not in the same class as Antonio Gates or Hunter Henry
and that Rivers could attempt about 100 fewer passes than the
591 he had last year. In other words, Doyle has upside but keep
expectations at the high-end TE2 level. Targeting him because
"Rivers loves his tight ends" is minimizing the quality
of options the former Charger quarterback has had at the position
throughout his career.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 66.3 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.8
The narratives are out in full force with Fournette. On one hand,
the combination of the Jaguars failing to exercise their fifth-year
option on him and reports of him on the trade block have many
believing Jacksonville will run him into the ground before moving
on in 2021. On the other hand, the arrival of Thompson and the
Jags' apparent willingness to move on from Fournette in what figures
to be a rebuilding year would seem to suggest the team has little
to gain by giving the former No. 4 overall pick 20 carries per
game when it has another back on the roster it likes in Armstead.
There's even a school of thought that has Jacksonville releasing
Fournette before the start of the season. One thing appears for
certain, however: Thompson's presence on the roster figures to
put a hard cap on Fournette's work on passing downs (for as long
as Thompson can stay healthy anyway). One interesting nugget to
keep in mind: 41 of Fournette's 76 catches last season came on
1st-and-10 or 2nd-and-10 (or longer).
Jacksonville quarterbacks attempted 587 passes in 2019. With
the Jaguars expected to field one of the worst defenses and be
among the worst teams in the league, it's hard to see how new
OC Jay Gruden keeps that number under 600 this year. The addition
of Shenault is another shot to Fournette's volume in the passing
game but should be a boon to the offense as a whole. Few receivers
enter the league with his ability to line up virtually anywhere
at multiple positions and even fewer receivers can do that AND
can power through tacklers. Chark emerged as the clear alpha dog
in this receiving corps last season, and Gruden has already assured
the masses he intends to move Chark all over the formation. Expect
his slot snaps (24 percent in 2019) to go up. Fantasy owners should
not forget about Eifert, who played for Gruden as a rookie in
Cincinnati in 2013. Gruden's offenses in Washington were generally
pretty favorable for tight ends; even with Jordan Reed hurt as
often as he was, the position was targeted at least 126 times
every season in his five full years in D.C.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 59.7 2019 Average Plays per Game: 59.3
After witnessing Henry put together one of the more dominant
postseasons by a running back in league history, it's only natural
that people believe the Titans have found their winning formula.
Those people aren't necessarily wrong, but history suggests fantasy
owners wanting to jump on that train now will be getting on too
late. Henry became only the 11th back in NFL history to score
at least 250 PPR points in a season while finishing with fewer
than 20 catches. That's the good news, at least in regards to
how good he is as a runner. The bad news is Earl Campbell is the
only one to ever do it twice in his career. There are two other
key obstacles in Henry's way of another huge year. First and foremost,
RT Jack Conklin bolted for Cleveland in free agency after finishing
as the league's third-best run blocker (per Pro Football Focus).
Whoever wins the battle Dennis Kelly and rookie Isaiah Wilson
for the right to replace him will be a severe downgrade. At least
a small part of Henry's heavy workload down the stretch last year
was a product of Dion Lewis giving the team next to nothing. If
Evans proves to be as explosive as Tennessee hopes, it's conceivable
Henry may finish with closer to 250 carries than 300.
Much like Henry, Brown is due for some regression. Unlike Henry,
there's reason to believe he's in line for a sizable bump in volume.
One thing we know that won't change; he figures to be one of the
best run-after-catch receivers in the league for a while, so a
100-target season for him may end up being comparable to another
receiver getting 120. However, there are reasons to pump the breaks
on him a bit. While Brown started cooking once Tannehill entered
the lineup, it should be noted three of his biggest games took
place with Adam Humphries out due to an ankle injury. With Humphries
only entering Year 2 of his four-year, $36 million contract, it's
possible Titans to find a way to get him more involved. Bill Belichick
suggested Smith could be the best tight end in the league after
the catch before the teams meet in the Divisional Round. While
that sounds like Bill being Bill during the week of the game,
Smith's 8.3 YPC per reception was the best in the league for a
tight end with at least 40 targets. He's due for a sizeable target-share
increase after finishing with only 44 looks a season ago.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 65.2 2019 Average Plays per Game: 68.5
Most fans are well aware of the fact neither Gurley nor Devonta
Freeman had great blocking last season, but to say the Falcons
and Rams had the same pathetic blocking would be untrue. Atlanta
was assigned a 63.9 run-blocking grade by Pro Football Focus (11th
in the NFL), while Los Angeles posted a 53.0 score (26th). LT
Andrew Whitworth was the highest-graded run-blocker on the Rams'
offensive line last year, finishing 66th (minimum 80 percent of
the team's snaps). The news wasn't much better when the threshold
was lowered to 50 and 20 percent of the snaps either. Atlanta
wasn't great itself, but C Alex Mack (19th) and LT Jake Matthews
(44th) were more than respectable and rookie RT Kaleb McGary (69th)
was right behind Whitworth. In other words, while the Falcons
didn't create make Atlanta a runner's paradise, they gave Freeman
much more of a chance to succeed than the Rams gave Gurley. Despite
all this, Gurley was a more productive and, quite frankly, better
runner than Freeman. McGary and fellow 2019 first-rounder RG Chris
Lindstrom, who played only five games due to injury, should be
expected to improve this season entering their second full season.
There is a distinct chance if Gurley's knee holds up - and that
is the biggest question with him moving forward - that he will
give the Falcons a significant upgrade over Freeman.
Jones has usually been a lock for about 150-plus targets and
80-plus catches since 2014. He produces against just about every
defense designed to stop him, so it would be silly to think that's
going to change at age 31. Since 2010, 106 receivers - just over
10 per year - have scored at least 250 PPR fantasy points in a
season. Of that group, all but two had at least 121 targets (and
those two scored 14 and 15 touchdowns). Projected over a 16-game
season, Ridley's average targets in 2019 would have fallen about
five short of the mark and that includes the massive increase
he saw near the end of the season when the Falcons' pass-catchers
were struggling to stay healthy. He has a chance to be a fantasy
WR1, but folks need to understand the odds are against it - especially
if Gurley gives the running game a jolt. Hurst has become a hyped
sleeper and is expected to pick right up where Austin Hooper left
off. It wouldn't be a shock if it happens, but they are also not
the same type of tight end. Hooper's average depth of target in
2019 was 6.5. Hurst's was 8.6 last year in Baltimore. Mark Andrews
(10.6) and Jared Cook (10.3) were at the top of that food chain
in 2019. Given how much Ryan has raved about Hurst's speed and
athleticism this summer, Hurst could move closer to them.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 62.8 2019 Average Plays per Game: 67.3
There seems to be a general misconception in the fantasy industry
that new OC Joe Brady called plays for LSU last year. He did not.
Perhaps it was a matter of semantics, but it is notable nonetheless.
Regardless of whether Brady deserves the amount of credit he is
getting for the Tigers' record-breaking offense, he quickly identified
getting the ball to a mismatch weapon out of the backfield like
Clyde Edwards-Helaire was a good idea. Of course, this bodes well
for McCaffrey, although it would take a fool not to get a player
with his receiving talents matched up on a linebacker as often
as possible. What is less certain is if Brady's two-year apprenticeship
under Sean Payton in New Orleans drove home the importance of
a balanced offense. McCaffrey is coming off a 403-touch season,
and it has to be a priority for Brady and his staff to make sure
that number drops a bit without compromising the offense. As such,
it's possible third-string QB P.J. Walker could take some carries
on zone-read plays while either Davis and/or Bonnafon steal at
least one series per game.
The addition of Bridgewater in free agency and hiring of Brady
pretty much guarantees this offense will try to emulate the Saints'
high-percentage passing attack. That's good news for Moore, who
could be in line for 150 targets in such a high-volume passing
game. Moore wasn't quite as good from a run-after-catch perspective
as he was in his rookie year, but he's still one of the better
RAC receivers around. Samuel's drop rate more than doubled from
2018 to 6.7 percent and his catch rate nosedived to 51.4 percent.
It helps to explain why he was considered a bust by some, but
another possible explanation is that 33.9 percent of his targets
were deemed uncatchable and his average depth of target was 14.6
yards - the same as Kenny Golladay, who had a similar uncatchable
pass rate. Anderson does not project to be a great fit for Bridgewater's
skill set, but the ex-Jet could be if he is used more often in
the short and intermediate passing game than he ever was in New
York. Thomas is due for a big bump from the 30 targets he saw
a year ago. LSU didn't use its tight ends all that much under
Brady's watch last year, however. With that said, it's impossible
to know how much of that was a function of the talent the Tigers
had at receiver and how much of it was by design.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 65.7 2019 Average Plays per Game: 63.2
Kamara has played a total of 45 games over three years in the
NFL. He's logged at least 15 touches in 29 of them (64.4 percent)
and at least 20 touches in 11 (24.4). His usage isn't ideal for
those of us who want and/or expect volume every week, but it's
a beautiful thing for fantasy owners in that 33.5 percent of his
729 career regular-season touches have come via the passing game,
which further reduces the number of times he gets beat up between
the tackles. In other words, last year's injury-plagued season
figures to be much more the exception than the rule. Murray's
180 touches look very good for a complementary back, but fantasy
owners must understand 65 of his 146 carries (44.5 percent) and
15 of his 34 receptions (44.1) came in the three games Kamara
either missed (Weeks 7-8) or was being rested for the most part
(Week 17). In New Orleans' other 13 games, Murray averaged 6.2
carries and 1.5 catches. He is a high-upside handcuff in the sense
he can be an RB1 if Kamara must miss time again, but his standalone
value was questionable at best in 2019 and doesn't figure to change
significantly in 2020.
Since targets started getting tracked in 1992, Thomas is only
the 14th player to amass at least 185 in a season. Only one of
them (Cris Carter) was able to increase his targets the next year.
The average drop-off - even if we figure in Carter's bump from
188 targets in 1994 to 197 in 1995 - was 27.8 percent the following
year. At the very least, this means fantasy owners should expect
Thomas to finish with roughly 134 targets in 2020. The drop may
not be as bad as history suggests it could be given his age and
the offense he plays in, but 2019 was a bit of a perfect storm
for him in that Kamara got hurt and the absence of a quality second
receiver. Kamara's track record tells us he is unlikely to have
another rough season, while Sanders is the closest thing New Orleans
has had to a viable threat opposite Thomas since his rookie year
in 2016 (Brandin Cooks). Cook attracted 65 targets in 14 games
last year. Contrary to popular belief, only nine took place in
the red zone. However, there were two key reasons he paid off
nicely in fantasy after a slow start: he scored on every red zone
catch he made and his average depth of target of 10.3 yards ranked
second at the position.
2020 Projected Average Plays per Game: 63.1 2019 Average Plays per Game: 67.9
The Jones-Vaughn debate has become almost comical this offseason.
The next time Vaughn steps on the field with a Bucs helmet will
be the first time he has done so. With the kind of head start
he is going to have over Vaughn in several areas (including knowledge
of the playbook and actual physical reps), the biggest concern
for Jones this season will be the propensity HC Bruce Arians showed
for pulling him in favor of Peyton Barber last season despite
there being clear evidence - statistical and otherwise - that
Jones was the better back. Jones was one of the youngest players
in the league when he entered the NFL in 2018 and - if we are
to believe his trainer - hasn’t been instructed on some
of the finer points of football very well. McCoy's arrival is
interesting, but I'm not sure it does much more than muddy the
competition for the likely James White/Kevin Faulk-type role in
this offense. It should not be a shock if he ends up competing
with Dare Ogunbowale for a roster spot or if both get cut in the
event Raymond Calais looks sharp and/or Vaughn or Jones prove
they are up to the challenge in pass pro.
Evans missed three games due to injury with Jameis Winston and
still easily turned in a 1,000-yard season, making him 6-for-6
in doing so. "But Doug … Brady doesn't have the arm
to throw deep anymore." OK. Evans is more than a vertical
receiver and Brady threw 60 passes that traveled at least 20 yards
in the air last season (completing 25). As a point of reference,
Kyler Murray was 25-for-61 on such throws. If fantasy owners want
to cite Evans' lack of consistency last year, his four single-digit
fantasy games in 2019 are the same number he had in 2017 and 2018.
There seems to be a lot of love for Godwin and rightfully so,
but there will almost certainly be more 12 personnel (one running
back, two tight ends) than last season (23 percent), so fantasy
owners relying on 11 personnel (which the Bucs played on 64 percent
of their snaps) to get Godwin in the slot as often as he was in
2019 could be disappointed. Gronkowski hasn't played more than
13 games since 2015 and sat out last season. That either means
he has given his body time to heal or he's rusty. Regardless,
I'm not sure I want to bet on the former when there are at least
two better options in this passing game on just about every play.
Give me Howard at the end of deeper drafts and I'll take my chances
on the narrative that Brady loves his tight ends outweighing the
one that says Arians and OC Byron Leftwich don't.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006 and been featured in USA TODAY's Fantasy Football Preview magazine since 2010. He is also a high-stakes player who often appears as a guest analyst on a number of national sports radio shows, such as Sirius XM's "Fantasy Drive." Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.