One of the older fantasy football adages is more opportunity tends
to lead to more success. That logic applies just as much - if not
more so - inside the 20 than it does outside of it. Since touchdowns
are the lifeblood of fantasy football and since the majority of
them are scored closer to the goal line, it only makes sense to
take into account what players are getting those chances and how
successful they are with them.
Red zone analysis helps owners get a sense of what teams are
doing in prime scoring territory, but looking at what teams do
solely inside the 20 doesn't provide the total picture. And it
makes sense why: just like in basketball where the field-goal
percentage goes down as the shot get progressively longer, the
percentage of teams scoring a touchdown on any given play go down
the further away a team is from the goal line. In keeping up with
the basketball metaphor, fantasy owners aren't concerned with
the first few passes that led to the shot; we want successful
conversions. The point to be made here is a lot more touchdowns
are scored inside the 5 and inside the 10 than between the 11
and 20.
Here is a key for the abbreviations you will see below:
TD – Rushing Touchdown Tm % – Percent of team's carries
inside specified area
Qualified RB Averages (RBs/WRs/QBs
with at least four RZ carries) Inside the 20: 20.1 percent conversion rate Inside the 10: 33.1 percent completion rate Inside the 5: 47.2 percent completion rate
Note: The focus on
the next two pages will be inside the 5 and a bit inside the 10,
as the majority of TD runs occur within those ranges.
In 2015, Devonta Freeman led the league with 47 red zone attempts,
DeAngelo Williams paced the field with 30 carries inside the 10
and Williams and Chris Ivory each had a league-best 18 runs inside
the 5. LeGarrette Blount (68, 42 and 24) kind of blew them right
out of the water last year, didn't he? With the Patriots expected
to be better offensively this year, this obviously bodes well
for Mike Gillislee. Perhaps not coincidentally, Gillislee was
6-for-6 on scoring touchdowns on carries inside the 5.
While slightly less efficient overall in all three ranges last
year, Freeman saw almost exactly the same amount of work at each
level. Will new OC Steve Sarkisian fall in line with former play-caller
Kyle Shanahan in that regard? It bears mentioning while Tevin
Coleman was less efficient than Freeman inside the 20 and inside
the 10, he was 3-for-3 on opportunities inside the 5. (Freeman
was 5-for-16.)
So, you think Le'Veon
Bell and Ezekiel
Elliott maxed out their upside? Well, maybe not. While David
Johnson was the only runner to rival Blount at the 20, 10
and 5, Bell and Elliott comparatively did not see a lot of work.
Elliott (11) tallied only half as many carries inside the 5 as
Johnson (22), while Bell saw less than half of Elliott's relative
meager workload. Bell's usage is particularly striking, as Rob
Kelley, Jay
Ajayi, Jordan
Howard and Matt
Forte - each of whom started roughly the same number of games
- saw as much (if not more) work in all three ranges than the
Steelers' stud back.
Fans who want to find fault with the way Tennessee used DeMarco Murray and Derrick Henry last year can use these numbers to make
their case. The Titans seemed to favor Henry more inside the red
zone as the season went on, presumably to keep Murray from hurting
his injured toe any further. Although few would quibble with how
efficient Murray was inside the 20, 10 and 5, Henry was better
at each level.
Not a big fan of Frank Gore losing red zone work to Robert Turbin?
Tough. The "Turbinator" was as good - if not better
- than Henry (that's right, Derrick Henry) at every level. To
be kind, Gore was awful (13.8 percent conversion rate inside the
20, 21.1 inside the 10 and 20 percent inside the 5).
The narrative that Lamar
Miller had a disappointing first season in Houston has been
overplayed so much at this point that it has become tiresome.
He ran for over 1,000 yards in 14 games playing hurt for most
of the season with a quarterback who did not scare defenses and
running behind a below-average line. (LT Duane Brown and C Greg
Mancz, who filled in for 2016 second-round pick Nick Martin after
he was lost for the season in training camp with a high ankle
sprain, were the only Texans' linemen who graded out halfway well
as run-blockers per PFF.) Miller is healthy and should get the
rest he needs with D'Onta
Foreman backing him up, Brock
Osweiler is gone and Martin is back. Perhaps most amazingly,
Miller (62.5 percent) was on par with Elliott (63.6) and slightly
better than Bell (60) in terms of converting inside the 5. In
case you are wondering if Miller's conversion rate inside the
5 last year was a fluke, it was 57.1 in 2015 with Miami.
Jeremy Hill may still be considered the odds-on favorite for
goal line work. However, his 40-percent conversion rate inside
the 5 was not only below the league average last year, but also
significantly lower than his 56.3-percent mark in 2015. Behind
a less proven offensive line this season, one has to wonder if
he'll even hold on to the short-yardage/goal line role in Cincinnati
all season with Joe Mixon around if he cannot improve that number.
For all those folks expecting Adrian Peterson to swoop right
in and take all the goal line work, maybe not so fast. While it
is true Mark Ingram did not fare well at any level in the red
zone last year (13.9-percent conversion rate inside the 20, 20
percent inside the 10 and 28.6 inside the 5), AP didn't exactly
set the world on fire in his last full season in Minnesota two
years ago (15.5, 26.9, 25). In case you were wondering, all those
numbers were fairly steep drop-offs from his previous full season
in 2013. Yes, quality of offensive line makes a big difference,
and he will have Football Outsiders' top unit in terms of adjusted
line yards paving the way for him this year.
Following the selection of Christian McCaffrey, the general consensus
seems to be Jonathan Stewart will serve as the rookie's backup
and/or be relegated in some way to change-of-pace/goal line/short-yardage
work. Folks, I'm as big of a fan of McCaffrey as any fantasy analyst,
but the Panthers didn’t extend the 30-year-old Stewart's
contract in March only to cut down his role a month later by drafting
McCaffrey. Regarding only his red zone prowess, Stewart managed
above-average efficiency inside the 20 (22.5), 10 (45) and 5 (56.3)
despite running behind what was generally recognized as one of
the worst offensive lines in the league last year. The Panthers
loved their "Double Trouble" days with Stewart and DeAngelo Williams - in the rare instance both players stayed healthy -
and McCaffrey's selection was a move toward an upgraded version
of that, albeit with more emphasis on getting the ball out of
Cam Newton's hands quickly and keeping him healthy.
Melvin
Gordon was actually a bit more efficient converting inside
the 10 (37) and 5 (53) than Blount and right on track with David
Johnson (39.3, 54.6). While it wouldn't be overly surprising
to see the third-year back share more of the work with Branden
Oliver and perhaps Andre
Williams in between the 20s this year (Gordon accepted 213
of the 234 carries San Diego handed out to running backs from
Week 3-13 after Danny
Woodhead was lost for the season in Week 2 and before Gordon
got hurt early in Week 14), there's plenty of reason to believe
Gordon will match his attempts in all three ranges and be more
successful at doing so. If there is one running back I believe
can crack the "Big Three" of Johnson, Bell and Elliott this year,
it is Gordon.
While plenty of owners remember Jay Ajayi didn't take over the
full-time job in Miami until Week 5, he still was able to rush
for eight touchdowns. Given that production, it may come as a
surprise how uninvolved he was inside the 20, relatively speaking.
Somehow, despite handling 242 of the Dolphins' 298 carries from
Week 5 on, Ajayi received only 56.4 percent of the team's carries
for the year inside the 20, 53.6 inside the 10 and 43.8 inside
the 5. The last number is the most surprising, if only because
he scored on 71.4 percent of those attempts. With a talented supporting
cast going into its second year together under HC Adam Gase and
the starting job no longer in question, it's not hard to see Ajayi
was significantly more TD upside in 2017.
For everyone who believes Ty Montgomery needs to be removed at
the goal line given his receiver background, keep reading. It
is notable he was well above league-average inside the 20 (25
percent), 10 (50) and 5 (60). It bears mentioning he could've
easily benefited from small sample size in this case, as his 12
red zone carries tied him with his quarterback (Rodgers) for the
team lead. With that said, it seems ironic at the very least the
Packers' first running back choice was Jamaal Williams, who just
happens to do two or three things really well that seem to be
knocks/unknowns on/for Montgomery (pass-blocking, ball security
and power running). It's almost as if Green Bay already knows
it wants Montgomery leading a committee and Williams to handle
the goal line/short yardage role as well as serve as the four-minute
back.
Doug Orth has written for FF
Today since 2006 and been featured in USA Today’s Fantasy
Football Preview magazine since 2010. He hosted USA Today’s
hour-long, pre-kickoff fantasy football internet chat every Sunday
in 2012-13 and appears as a guest analyst on a number of national
sports radio shows, including Sirius XM’s “Fantasy Drive”.
Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.