If 2014 was the year in which I was always playing
from behind, 2015 was the year that finally convinced me that
wide receiver - at least at the top - is now the least volatile
position in fantasy football (and probably the one with the most
upside as well).
Do you want to see one of the single-most convincing stats I've
come across to prove how fantasy football has changed? Follow
this
link to the FF Today Stats page, adjust it to PPR scoring
and click on the FPts/G column. At running back, two players are
averaging 20 or more points - one of which hasn't played since
Week 5 (Jamaal Charles). Conversely, six receivers are currently
above that benchmark entering Week 16.
How does that compare to last year? (Thanks for asking.) Four
running backs versus four receivers. How about 2013? Three running
backs versus three receivers (two if you don't include Julio Jones'
five-game injury-shortened season that year).
One "off" year doesn't usually change my thinking,
but I feel like the evidence is compelling and now I'm certain
I know why. As I alluded to in The
New Fantasy Reality, I feel as though most coaches have come
to the conclusion the new Collective Bargaining Agreement doesn't
give them the appropriate amount of time to prepare and has taken
away most of the padded practices (about the only way offensive
linemen can practice their craft outside of playing the actual
game, which obviously affects how well teams are going to run
the ball), they would rather spend their resources on the part
of the game that doesn't always require all 11 players to be on
the same page - the passing game.
There is so little commitment league-wide to the running game
anymore and even less loyalty to running backs because coaches
deem them as replaceable - even though a fair amount of them really
aren't. Combined with how often the few elite runners seem to
go down before the fantasy playoffs anymore and it doesn't make
a ton of sense to hitch your wagon to that kind of horse. (Take
one look at the teams in the championship game of your leagues.
I'm willing to bet about 75 percent are led by Antonio
Brown, Odell
Beckham Jr., Julio
Jones, DeAndre
Hopkins or some combination of one or two top-10 receivers.
Now take a look at the running backs. More than likely, David
Johnson and Tim
Hightower are among the ones getting the job done. This revelation
may be old news in your leagues, but it was rarely ever the case
in the $1K-and-up leagues I'm used to playing in each season -
at least until this year.) Like it or not, it is not our job as
fantasy owners and analysts to make coaches see the error of their
ways, rewrite the CBA or reduce ACL surgery recovery times from
nine months to one but rather to adjust accordingly.
By the time Week 16 rolls around each year, I feel it is most
beneficial to look forward to next year since there isn't really
a ton of advice I can dispense at this point of the season that
is going to alter the course of a fantasy season. As such, I regularly
use the final Blitz column of every year to set the table for
the following season. While the Blitz will take a long vacation
after this week, I will return after a personal bye week –
in which I will watch and cover a lot of college bowl games –
to bring you “Road to the Super Bowl”. After that,
it will only be a short time before I will begin analyzing prospects
for the NFL Draft.
Of course, there will be plenty of time to discuss the next wave
of talent joining the NFL over the next four-plus months. Until
then, I’d like to focus my time and energy on the veteran
players that figure to be on the wish lists of fantasy owners
in 2016. Obviously, much will change between now and the summer
as coaches and coordinators come and go, free agency stirs the
pot and the draft adds playmakers to teams needing one more player
to make everything click. Still, I find it helpful to establish
some sense of how I would rank each position now to get a bit
of a head start on next season. I've expanded my lists from previous
years to reflect the changes I spoke of above.
Above all, have a safe and happy holiday season and good luck
in your championship game(s) this weekend!!!
Rich Get Richer: Cam will get Benjamin
back in 2016.
Analysis: If Newton ends up winning
the NFL MVP, it will be one of the more unlikely stories in recent
memory. He lost his top playmaker (Kelvin Benjamin) before the
season started and his stats (completions, attempts, completion
percentage, rushing attempts and rushing yards) through 14 games
this year amazingly mirror what he did through 14 games last year
- the main differences being 15 more touchdown passes and two
more touchdown runs. Rodgers is probably a near-lock to remain
among the top-five quarterbacks for the next 3-5 years, although
it is concerning the entire Green Bay offense appeared to take
a step back this season. I'm willing to put the blame for that
on two major factors: 1) the absence of Jordy Nelson and 2) the
switch in play-calling duties (until recently) from HC Mike McCarthy
to OC Tom Clements. Brady may want to play until he's 45, but
history says quarterbacks have a difficult time remaining productive
after 38 - the age he's at right now. I'm willing to bet on one
more elite QB1 season simply because he takes good care of himself
and has avoided major injury or surgery (outside of the ACL that
sidelined him for all but one game in 2008).
It's sad that it took until Week 11 for the Seahawks to unleash
Wilson the way I thought they would to begin the season, although
the two biggest factors in his second-half explosion have been
the promotion of C Patrick Lewis and (somewhat due to Lewis' ability
to stabilize the line) the evolution of Wilson as a pocket passer.
The only thing keeping Roethlisberger from being higher on this
list is his lack of durability this year. The way the Steelers'
offense is set up right now, there could be a handful of games
where big Ben throws for five or six touchdowns over the next
couple years if he can to stay healthy all season. Palmer is the
slightly older version of Roethlisberger with the same kind of
embarrassment of riches at receiver and solid pass-catching running
backs.
I find it incredibly difficult to rank Luck so low, but the Colts
are going to have to invest a lot of resources in their offensive
line during the offseason for my ranking of him to change. While
his most recent injury has more to do with his scrambling ability
than the offensive line, the fact the matter is he gets hit more
than just about any quarterback in the league. Assuming Indianapolis
doesn't do enough to protect Luck's long-term health, I'd be willing
to move Dalton in front of him as well. In my mind, he's a younger
fantasy version of Roethlisberger and Palmer with a strong and
deep front five in front of him and a slightly less talented receiving
corps. Brees is ranked relatively low in large part due to the
likelihood HC Sean Payton will not be coaching him next year.
I think the case can be made that if Payton does not return, Brees
could drop into the fringe QB1 territory.
Bortles and Carr are both second-year standouts that have a lot
of things going in their favor moving forward, including two solid
and/or great receivers, a major threat (or potential one in Carr's
case) at tight end and highly versatile running backs that contribute
in the passing game. Rivers hasn't caught much of a break as his
supporting cast has struggled with injuries over the last two
years. Much like Luck, Rivers needs his front office to commit
major resources into fixing the offensive line. Assuming that
happens, Rivers could be a top-five quarterback next year.
Manning seems to walk a fine line between mid-range QB1 and high-end
QB2 most years and the mere fact that he has Odell Beckham Jr.
is probably going to keep him in the conversation for the former.
With that said, it's hard to get too excited about any of his
other weapons (outside of possibly TE Will Tye). The story seems
unlikely to change for Stafford, whose career seems destined to
fall short of what many hoped he was becoming after his breakout
2011 season. Still only 27, Stafford has plenty of time to change
the narrative, but the decline of Calvin Johnson appears to be
starting already and one has to wonder if we haven't already seen
the best from the former No. 1 overall pick. It won't help matters
if he is forced to learn yet another system this offseason. Romo
reminded us of what he is this season - a capable QB1 that is
likely to make his fantasy owners cringe every time he takes a
hit. Thankfully for his long-term outlook, Dallas has been largely
unsuccessful in finding a capable backup, much less another quarterback
that can mimic what he does for the Cowboys' offense.
Analysis: Fantasy owners never had much of a chance to watch
Bell hit his stride this year. When Bell came back from his two-game
suspension, Roethlisberger got hurt. In the same game that Roethlisberger
returned from his knee injury, Bell was lost for the season. Be
that as it may, the Steelers showed more desire to get Bell the
ball more consistently than just about any other team in the league
does with its running back. When we are talking about player of
Bell's considerable talents, that's a big deal. Charles didn't
have near the same early injury-related chaos in Kansas City as
Bell, but his season ended in a similar fashion. Once highly unpredictable
in terms of the consistency of his touches, Charles is one of
the game's few remaining workhorses. It's hard to get to overly
excited about any player that has suffered two ACL injuries in
his career, but few players bring a better mix of consistency
and upside than he does. Gurley's hold on workhorse status for
the Rams is about as good as it gets. A strong case can be made
for him going No. 1 overall in drafts next season, but St. Louis
will need to make huge strides in upgrading his supporting cast
for that to happen. Regardless, no other player in the league
- and perhaps none since a young Adrian Peterson - has a better
mix of talent and guaranteed work in his immediate future that
Gurley.
I was probably a little slower on the Freeman train than I should
have been, but it finally became apparent that he simply runs
with more urgency and desire than Tevin Coleman. Assuming OC Kyle
Shanahan returns for another season and the Falcons infuse more
talent into their offensive line, Freeman should keep a substantial
lead over Coleman for the bulk of the touches coming out of the
Atlanta backfield. A strong case could actually be made for Freeman
being ranked in front of Charles. McCoy doomed most of his owners
in the first half of the season when he tried to rush back from
a preseason hamstring injury, but he has handsomely rewarded the
owners that were able to tread water without him early. Buffalo
showed enough of a commitment getting him 20-plus touches once
he got healthy that his future owners should feel confident landing
him in the middle of the first round next season. Peterson is
one of the most unique physical freaks the NFL will probably ever
see, so he was always going to be a good bet to avoid the dreaded
30-year-old cliff that owners typically concern themselves with
at the running back position. Given last year's suspension, it
made plenty of sense to treat him like he was one year younger
this season and use this coming offseason to reevaluate Peterson
at 31. I'm willing to bet he has one more elite season left in
him, but I believe 2016 is probably the first time owners can
make a solid argument for passing on him until the mid-to-late
portion of the first round.
Considering he enters Week 16 nine yards behind Peterson for
the rushing title, Martin's ranking probably looks a bit low.
As with a number of these rankings, I'm willing to move him up
as the offseason progresses, but there are just too many unknowns
at the moment. Will he return to Tampa Bay? Will Charles Sims
steal more/less work next year? How much of his production this
year was a "contract-year push"? Miller has been criminally
underused for most of his time in Miami and, like Martin, a free
agent after the season. I've chosen to rank him conservatively
here, but his upside is probably as a top-five running back if
he leaves the Dolphins and finds a coach/system that can find
a way to better utilize all of his talents. Ingram's lack of durability
and Payton's uncertain future has the former Heisman Trophy winner
listed just inside the top 10. Ingram stepped up his contributions
in the passing game in a big way in 2015 and it is quite likely
he'll only have Khiry Robinson to share touches with since C.J.
Spiller will probably be released in the offseason.
Johnson's spot in the top 10 will probably be the biggest surprise
of the bunch and will probably feel reactionary to some (given
his three-score outburst in Week 15), but I'm not sure that is
the case. The issues the Cardinals were most concerned with early
in the season - pass-blocking and running inside - don't appear
to be concerns anymore and neither Chris Johnson nor Andre Ellington
possess anything close to the combination of size and speed of
the rookie from Northern Iowa. Rawls get the nod at No. 11 for
now because it seems likely Marshawn Lynch won't not be back at
his cap figure next season. The undrafted rookie free agent is
still a big risk given his off-field red flags in college and
lack of regular contributions in the passing game, but the talent
is hard to deny. Yeldon didn't exactly rock the fantasy world
with his production this year, but did we really expect him to?
Perhaps the most appealing thing about his rookie season was his
consistent workload; as long as that continues, he's going to
be just fine. Defenses will need to start adjusting to the fact
that Jacksonville has an explosive passing game. Obviously, the
more opponents prepare for Allen Robinson, Allen Hurns and Julius
Thomas, the more opportunity Yeldon will have to run against light
boxes.
The next two entries are difficult because they currently play
on the same team and their OC (Adam Gase) could very well be a
head coach next year. Langford is certain to be in Chicago in
2016 and therefore gets the nod over Forte, who is almost certain
to leave via free agency. In the very brief time while Forte was
injured, Langford proved he was capable of being a three-down
back on a team that will focus heavily on ball control and minimizing
turnovers. I don't pretend to know where Forte is going to end
up, but he is another back that seems likely to produce after
age 30 given how often he's been used as a receiver over the course
of his career. Much like Peterson, I wouldn't blame owners if
they chose to get out one year too early on Forte as opposed to
one year too late. Ivory was a tough call over a couple of players
listed below because he is always going to be a bit of risk given
his physical running style and relative lack of contributions
in the passing game. With that said, I could easily see him reaching
10 rushing touchdowns for the first time in his career next year
as the Jets' offense continues to improve.
Analysis: Assuming Brown maintains his current 23.7 point-per-game
average in PPR scoring, his 2015 campaign will go down as the
most dominant one over a full season by a receiver since Randy
Moss in 2007 (24.1). It's almost scary to think what he could
have done this season with a full 16 games with Roethlisberger.
Jones' year has been almost as ridiculous considering he just
ended a five-game scoreless drought last weekend. Had the entire
Atlanta offense not melted down around midseason, we could be
looking at a receiver capable of averaging 25 fantasy points!
Beckham's 14-game totals this year are almost in line with his
12-game totals from last year. Brown and Beckham are probably
the two most impossible receivers to defend in the game, given
today's rules.
By my count, Hopkins has caught passes from nine different quarterbacks
in his two-plus year NFL career. Just imagine what he would be
capable of with a slightly above-average quarterback over a full
season. Robinson drew Demaryius Thomas-like comparisons for his
play during his abbreviated rookie season and has managed to outperform
Thomas in 2015. At the moment, Robinson is more of a big-play
wideout than a complete receiver (at least that's the way Jacksonville
uses him), but his arrow is pointing straight up; the Jags will
almost certainly create more opportunities for him going forward.
Marshall is a tough call here over two of his younger peers, but
he is in an offense led by OC Chan Gailey that will force-feed
him and Eric Decker the ball. With no real threats looming on
the roster to challenge the 10-plus targets they both seem to
see each week, Marshall and Decker seem like a reasonably good
bets to hold their value going forward.
It speaks to the high standard he set over his first three-plus
seasons that Green seems to be a disappointment again this year.
Obviously, the emergence of Tyler Eifert stole much of his thunder
in the red zone in 2015. I'll be very interested to see how two
"down" years affects his fantasy draft stock next summer.
This year, we finally saw the reason I've been a bit skeptical
in regards to Bryant over the past few years - his fantasy value
is tied largely into the health of Romo because the Cowboys haven't
found a quarterback capable of running the offense at a level
anywhere close to their brittle 35-year-old signal-caller. Take
a second to consider that Allen caught 67 of the 89 passes in
his direction this season and that he was on place for nearly
140 receptions when he lost for the season halfway through Week
8. As Antonio Gates continues to age (gracefully), Rivers' reliance
on Allen figures to remain at the same level - if not grow - in
the coming years.
I wish Miami would (or knew how to) use Landry down the field
a bit more often - his 9.5 YPC on 182 career catches is ridiculous
for someone of his ability - but at least the Dolphins have the
good sense to force-feed him the ball in the passing game and
give him a few token carries as a runner. Hopefully, the (likely)
new coaching staff in Miami will make Landry attacking the intermediate
part of the field more of a priority (since throwing the deep
ball may never be a strength for Ryan Tannehill). Durability is
about the only concern owners should have regarding Edelman, who
is a near-lock for 100-plus catches in New England's slot-centric
offense with Brady as his quarterback. Hopefully, I'm loud wrong
about my ranking of Thomas, but I'm afraid we've seen a glimpse
of the near future without a healthy Peyton Manning this year
and it likely means Thomas will be more of a low-end WR1 for the
next year or two. It's not as if he's been a bust in 2015, but
owners tend to start ramping up their expectations after a receiver
delivers three straight seasons of 90-plus catches, 1,400-plus
yards and double-digit touchdowns.
I said in the preseason I had a hard time seeing Cooper reaching
the 80-catch mark and it appears I may end up being right about
that. Nevertheless, the No. 4 overall pick's rookie season has
been a smashing success. If a receiver can set 80 catches, 1,200
yards and 7-8 touchdowns as his baseline in his age-21 season,
I can't wait to see what he does when he "develops"
into a man. Michael Crabtree will put a bit of a cap on his overall
numbers over the next year or two, but Cooper has "superstar"
written all over him. The only reason Jeffery is ranked as low
as he is because he probably hasn't been anywhere close to 100
percent at any point since August. Much like Langford in the running
back section above, Jeffery desperately needs OC Adam Gase to
return or someone of that ilk to take over play-calling duties.
Megatron set such a high bar during his prime that it has become
pretty easy to say he in the decline phase of his career. Knee
(last year) and ankle (this year) injuries have slowed Johnson
down to the point where it is probably safer to draft him as a
WR2 and expect the occasional blow-up game out of him (Thanksgiving
2015, for example).
Speaking of Demaryius Thomas-like disappointments, Cobb's floor
was supposed to be 100 catches, 1,000-plus yards and 8-10 touchdowns
without Jordy Nelson around. Right or wrong, I pin most of the
blame on OC Tom Clements for that part of the Packers' offense
because it was obvious in HC Mike McCarthy's first game as the
play-caller (Week 14) that one of his first orders of business
was to get Cobb the ball early and often. One common complaint
of Green Bay receivers this year was their inability to separate,
something Cobb has rarely ever had any trouble doing. Like many
of the other Saints I've mentioned to this point, Cooks' fantasy
future depends heavily on the return of his coach. It took much
too long for Payton to regularly put his second-year wideout into
positions in which he could succeed. His 2016 fantasy stock is
much more unstable than it appears at the moment and perhaps the
most volatile of any receiver I've discussed to this point. Fitzgerald
is almost certainly going to set a career high in receptions and
is in line to post one of his best yardage seasons, so what gives
with his ranking here? First and foremost, he will turn 33 before
the start of the season. Secondly, one look at his game log this
season reveals he has only scored once since Week 5. Last but
not least, Michael Floyd once again appears ready to challenge
Fitz for the role of Arizona's best fantasy receiver.
I've chosen to rank Nelson conservatively here given the fact
he will be a 31-year-old receiver next season coming off an ACL
injury. While I'm quite certain his return will boost the Packers'
offense as a whole, I have my doubts he will approach his 2014
numbers in his first year back (98 catches, 1,519 yards and 13
touchdowns). A more realistic yet very optimistic expectation
is probably his 2013 season (85-1,314-8), which would make this
ranking about right. Maclin has been able to do what I didn't
think any receiver could - make Alex Smith willing to take a few
more shots downfield. With that said, I highly doubt his 2015
numbers will improve in 2016 despite a full offseason to bond
with Smith. Watkins' rank probably comes as a surprise to some,
but I'm still as high on him as a prospect as I was during the
2014 draft. His detractors will say he plays in a run-oriented
offense and in miserable weather during the most important part
of the fantasy season, but I offer the last four weeks as proof
that he can soon become one of the top 5-10 receivers in the league.
Jameis Winston is being considered as one of the favorites for
NFL Rookie of the Year. What's funny about that is his clear top
receiver (Evans) has seen his production drop from 12 touchdowns
in 15 games last year without him to three scores in 12 games
with him. It's a combination (Winston to Evans) that fantasy owners
should be excited about going forward, but it is bizarre to see
such a drop-off in production when a somewhat-proven talent at
receiver gets an "upgrade" at quarterback. Almost as
much as owners can count on at least one drop from Martavis Bryant
each game, they also seem to be able to rely on about 80-plus
yards and a long touchdown from him just about as often. It happens
with enough consistency that owners can start to dismiss him as
a mere "splash" receiver and treat him more as a high-upside
WR2 with the potential to deliver a handful of WR1 weeks. As with
any receiver that misses a full season, ranking him for the following
season is a tricky endeavor. What makes Benjamin's situation more
complicated is that his quarterback (Newton) is having by far
his best year without him. Does that mean Benjamin will come back
to an offense that believes in spreading it around? Or will things
go back to the way they were in 2014?
Basically, just about everything I said above about Marshall
applies to Decker as well. The reason I have him at No. 25 has
more to do with his reliance on touchdowns for fantasy value and
the fact he lacks the same kind of high ceiling most of the players
in front of him possess. Hilton's value - as we have seen this
year - hinges heavily with the health of Luck. I'll be preaching
caution with all Colts players in 2016 until I see a concentrated
effort to improve the offensive line. Furthermore, Hilton has
clearly been a much better performer in perfect conditions (such
as at home in the domed Lucas Oil Stadium) throughout his career
than anywhere else, meaning he has a bit of a hit-or-miss to him.
Sanders' ranking is a lot like that of teammate Demaryius Thomas.
In Gase and Manning's quick-hitting offense last year (and at
times this season), he has been a great WR2. I'm not sure he will
come anywhere close to approaching that level of consistency with
Brock Osweiler in HC Gary Kubiak's offense - at least not in 2016.
I don't make it a habit to rank receivers in the midst of a 13-touchdown
season this low very often, but there is a very fluky feel about
a player that is two touchdowns shy of matching his four-year
career total entering the season. Why I am willing to bet Wilson's
second-half production is a bit more of a sign of things to come,
I tend to believe the continued emergence of Tyler Lockett will
keep Baldwin in the WR3 discussion (as opposed to a low-end WR1).
The way Indianapolis' season has fallen apart serves as another
indictment on GM Ryan Grigson's approach to last offseason, adding
a high-priced free agent (Andre Johnson) and a first-round pick
(Phillip Dorsett) to a receiver corps that already had Hilton
and Moncrief. Given how much they raved about Moncrief last year,
it looks downright foolish now that Grigson put roadblocks in
front of him and didn't do more to protect his future $25 M/per
year quarterback. With that said, Johnson will probably be one-and-done
in Indy and Moncrief can be utilized in a high-volume outside
role as Luck's top red-zone weapon. Floyd has been ridiculously
productive for nearly 10 weeks now, scoring most of the touchdowns
that were going to Fitzgerald in September. A strong case could
be made for him being ranked 10 spots higher.
Analysis: When healthy, Gronkowski is in near-unstoppable force
and a legitimate first-round pick in fantasy drafts. Enough said.
Olsen is a trickier rank based on how much the offense will likely
changes when Benjamin returns. Yes, Olsen dominated last season
as well with Benjamin around, but this Carolina offense has more
weapons (Ted Ginn, for example) and a player like Devin Funchess
that should be much more involved in his second year. Olsen will
be undoubtedly be affected, but how much? Much like Gronkowski,
injuries may be the only thing that can stop Eifert from being
the latest new challenger to Gronk's top-dog status at the position.
We'll see in the coming years if he deserves such a label, but
I like his chances.
Lost in the continued excellence of Gronkowski and emergence
of Eifert was the rock-solid performance of Walker, who may have
a shot at an even better year next season since Kendall Wright
appears likely to move on from Tennessee. The 31-year-old tight
end already has a pretty good rapport with rookie quarterback
Marcus Mariota and should reap the benefits of playing alongside
Dorial Green-Beckham at some point in 2016. Barnidge is the rare
Cleveland success story - one the Browns didn't waste any time
committing to earlier this month when they signed him to a four-year
deal. Even with questions at quarterback yet again, Barnidge has
proven to be a godsend for a franchise than needs a couple. The
only reason Reed is this low is due to his lack of durability.
I'll be very interested to see how Washington handles its business
in the offseason when Niles Paul is able to return. (For those
of you that don't remember, HC Jay Gruden stated this past offseason
that Paul had moved ahead of Reed on the depth chart because he
was a more complete tight end.)
By most tight ends' standards, Kelce has enjoyed a very productive
year. While he's technically on pace to have a better season than
last year, I'm pretty sure a bump of 3-4 catches and 50-plus yards
isn't what most owners had in mind. It is quite possible that
Kelce ends up being nothing more than a 70-catch, 900-yard, 5-6
touchdown play throughout his career as a Chief simply because
HC Andy Reid's offensive system has almost always relied more
on balance than star power. By the way, I realize those numbers
are pretty good for most tight ends, but I think most of us realize
he could produce more in another offense. It appears that the
only fools for thinking Thomas was going to see a drop-off in
red-zone production were all the people that thought leaving Peyton
Manning for Blake Bortles was a bad thing. With that said, the
artist formerly known as "Orange Julius" hasn't come
close to playing a full season yet. Gates' 16-game projection
based off his nine games this year would be 91 catches, 1,040
yards and seven touchdowns. It seems like he should be put out
to pasture pretty soon, but show me 1-2 other tight ends in the
league capable of that production. Ditto for Watson, who is finally
enjoying the season at age 35 most of us expected him to have
almost 10 years ago with New England. As is with the case with
Gates, there really isn't much reason why Watson can't repeat
this year's production if the Saints' supporting cast remains
relatively unchanged and the defense doesn't improve much.
Doug Orth has written for FF
Today since 2006 and been featured in USA Today’s Fantasy
Football Preview magazine since 2010. He hosted USA Today’s
hour-long, pre-kickoff fantasy football internet chat every Sunday
in 2012-13 and appears as a guest analyst on a number of national
sports radio shows, including Sirius XM’s “Fantasy Drive”.
Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.